“The Judge and the Historian”

Denouncing a miscarriage of justice, a historian compares Italy's courts to the Inquisition's.

Topics: Books,

Judges and historians, Carlo Ginzburg argues, have a good deal in common. Both have the weighty responsibility of examining the written record and drawing from it conclusions about what happened in the past. Yet judges bear the greater burden. Historians’ mistakes can be corrected by later historians building on their predecessors’ work; but when judges err by falling prey to logical fallacies and thus reconstruct the past incorrectly, innocent people go to prison, and the very concept of justice is corrupted.

Ginzburg, himself a historian who has specialized in the Inquisition and who teaches at UCLA, wrote “The Judge and the Historian” to call the world’s attention to what he sees as precisely such a gross miscarriage of justice in his native Italy. In 1988, a full 16 years after a Milan police superintendent was mowed down in broad daylight by two shots from a revolver, an informer came forward, confessed to a role in the crime and implicated three leaders of the far-left group Lotta Continua. The men he fingered were convicted, and after seven rounds of trials and appeals over nine years (a convoluted sequence not unusual in contemporary Italy), the convictions were upheld; the men remain in prison.

This was no ordinary murder. From the late 1960s through the early 1980s, Italy was a nation in chaos, torn by the terrorism of the Red Brigades, haunted by assorted conspiracies and conspiracy theories and plagued by a plethora of anarchist, neo-fascist and other noisy fringe movements. And Luigi Calabresi, the murdered officer, was no ordinary policeman. He was widely believed on the left to have murdered, under official auspices, Giuseppe Pinelli, an anarchist wrongly suspected by the police of detonating a terrorist bomb in 1969. (Pinelli’s death became the topic of Dario Fo’s satirical drama “Accidental Death of an Anarchist.”)

You Might Also Like

Ginzburg regards the convictions in the Calabresi case as the 20th century equivalent of the witchcraft and heresy convictions under the Inquisition. The contemporary Italian courts, he says, cared just as little for the evidence as the 16th and 17th century Catholic ones: Suspects could affirm their crimes, deny all or remain silent, and all these possible responses were regarded as evidence of their guilt. The Calabresi judges ended up believing the informer, Leonardo Marino, despite the dozens of problems Ginzburg cites with his story, any one of which, he says, should have created more than the shadow of a doubt and led to acquittal.

Ginzburg confesses his own bias up front: He has been a close friend of Adriano Sofri, one of the convicted Lotta Continua activists, for more than 30 years and “is certain that this accusation is groundless.” He scores several solid points against Marino, asking why the informer came forward when he did and strongly hinting that the authorities egged Marino on to help put a notorious murder to rest after a 16-year impasse.

But for a polemic intended as a Zola-like “J’accuse,” much of the argumentation is curiously bloodless. “The Judge and the Historian” reads not at all like a true-crime tale and not much like a work of history. It’s closer to a literary deconstruction of the trial record, probing for inconsistencies of tone and language as much as for errors of fact. “Anyone who is accustomed by profession to read and interpret texts can hardly fail to think that these phrases reek of pretentious diction,” Ginzburg scoffs at the explanation Marino gives for having spoken to the police. “Pretentious diction”? That’s not a crime. And in a criminal case it isn’t even good evidence.

Jonathan Groner is an editor at Legal Times in Washington.

More Related Stories

Featured Slide Shows

  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on Facebook
  • 1 of 11
  • Close
  • Fullscreen
  • Thumbnails
    Martyna Blaszczyk/National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest

    National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest Entries

    Slide 1

    Pond de l'Archeveche - hundreds thousands of padlocks locked to a bridge by random couples, as a symbol of their eternal love. After another iconic Pont des Arts bridge was cleared of the padlocks in 2010 (as a safety measure), people started to place their love symbols on this one. Today both of the bridges are full of love locks again.

    Anders Andersson/National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest

    National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest Entries

    Slide 2

    A bird's view of tulip fields near Voorhout in the Netherlands, photographed with a drone in April 2015.

    Aashit Desai/National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest

    National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest Entries

    Slide 3

    Angalamman Festival is celebrated every year in a small town called Kaveripattinam in Tamil Nadu. Devotees, numbering in tens of thousands, converge in this town the day after Maha Shivratri to worship the deity Angalamman, meaning 'The Guardian God'. During the festival some of the worshippers paint their faces that personifies Goddess Kali. Other indulge in the ritual of piercing iron rods throughout their cheeks.

    Allan Gichigi/National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest

    National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest Entries

    Slide 4

    Kit Mikai is a natural rock formation about 40m high found in Western Kenya. She goes up the rocks regularly to meditate. Kit Mikai, Kenya

    Chris Ludlow/National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest

    National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest Entries

    Slide 5

    On a weekend trip to buffalo from Toronto we made a pit stop at Niagara Falls on the Canadian side. I took this shot with my nexus 5 smartphone. I was randomly shooting the falls themselves from different viewpoints when I happened to get a pretty lucky and interesting shot of this lone seagull on patrol over the falls. I didn't even realize I had captured it in the shot until I went back through the photos a few days later

    Jassen T./National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest

    National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest Entries

    Slide 6

    Incredibly beautiful and extremely remote. Koehn Lake, Mojave Desert, California. Aerial Image.

    Howard Singleton/National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest

    National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest Entries

    Slide 7

    Lucky timing! The oxpecker was originally sitting on hippo's head. I could see the hippo was going into a huge yawn (threat display?) and the oxpecker had to vacate it's perch. When I snapped the pic, the oxpecker appeared on the verge of being inhaled and was perfectly positioned between the massive gaping jaws of the hippo. The oxpecker also appears to be screeching in terror and back-pedaling to avoid being a snack!

    Abrar Mohsin/National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest

    National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest Entries

    Slide 8

    The Yetis of Nepal - The Aghoris as they are called are marked by colorful body paint and clothes

    Madeline Crowley/National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest

    National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest Entries

    Slide 9

    Taken from a zodiac raft on a painfully cold, rainy day

    Ian Bird/National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest

    National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest Entries

    Slide 10

    This wave is situated right near the CBD of Sydney. Some describe it as the most dangerous wave in Australia, due to it breaking on barnacle covered rocks only a few feet deep and only ten metres from the cliff face. If you fall off you could find yourself in a life and death situation. This photo was taken 300 feet directly above the wave from a helicopter, just as the surfer is pulling into the lip of the barrel.

  • Recent Slide Shows

Comments

0 Comments

Comment Preview

Your name will appear as username ( settings | log out )

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href=""> <b> <em> <strong> <i> <blockquote>