Race
Prodigal daughter
A golden girl from Birmingham's elite takes a cold, hard look at her hometown's ugly past -- and her own father's role in it.
To grow up in Birmingham, Ala., in the 1960s — as I did, and as did Diane McWhorter, author of “Carry Me Home: Birmingham, Alabama, The Climactic Battle of the Civil Rights Movement” — was to be asked to believe in a scenario of white working-class life that was midway between “Leave It To Beaver” and “The Andy Griffith Show.” You got along not by coming to terms with the momentous events going on downtown, but by learning to pretend they weren’t happening (or at best that they were the product of outside agitators). Or by simply getting out.
McWhorter spent the first part of her life in privileged denial, and most of the second, it appears, in catching up. Wisely, she never tries to place her own story at the center of her book; she simply places all her personal cards face-up so the reader may better judge her perspective.
McWhorter grew up “on the wrong side of the revolution,” a white girl, the daughter of Ivy League-educated parents who lived across the hill from the city itself in Mountain Brook, one of the country’s wealthiest suburbs. She was roughly the same age as the four little girls who were killed in the 1963 bombing of the 16th Street Baptist Church, an event which meant less to her at the time than the cancellation of her school’s production of “The Music Man.”
In subsequent years McWhorter would be haunted by the killings and, increasingly, by the knowledge of her own father’s involvement with the Ku Klux Klan. Finally, her desire to dig up the truth could not be assuaged by anything less than a thorough and complete knowledge of the politics, economics and personalities that led to the most important social events of 20th century America. For there is no hyperbole in her book’s subtitle; the struggle for civil rights was nothing less than a battle, and Birmingham was no less a defeat for white supremacy than Stalingrad was for the Nazis.
Though it wasn’t apparent to those of us who grew up there, Birmingham was far from a typical city of the Deep South. The big difference was industry: Birmingham really didn’t begin to rise until well after the Civil War, and the spur to growth was steel. Though the steel industry has long since given way to the service economy, the town still contains vast yards of warehouses and refineries (if you recall the strike scenes from the 1984 Mel Gibson film “The River,” which was filmed right near the downtown area, then you know what much of it looks like).
McWhorter revives an unfashionable explanation — class antagonism — in tracing the roots of the battle for Birmingham: the local steel powers, or “Big Mules,” pooled their efforts to keep the thousands and thousands of “millbillies” from organizing. Almost before the race conflict began, the town saw violence and intimidation against union organizers and ambitious communists, who nearly succeeded in gaining a foothold in the ranks of Birmingham labor. The Big Mules, like Mafia dons, had stooges and fixers to carry out their acts of terrorism and intimidation so they need have no direct connection with the violence.
The most famous fixer was a former baseball announcer and “cornball” radio comic named Eugene “Bull” Connor, who rose to the position of city commissioner and proved adept at orchestrating violence when, as McWhorter puts it, “the have-nots threatened to organize along racial lines.” The Big Mules never gave specific orders; there was no need to, as they merely had to “delegate political intermediaries to oversee strategic racial violence.”
Meanwhile, at the other end of the social spectrum were tough, battle-hardened veterans of the labor and civil rights struggles, best typified by Fred Lee Shuttlesworth, the hero (if you must pick just one) of “Carry Me Home,” rather than Martin Luther King Jr. Indeed, King does not come off at his best in McWhorter’s account, if only because her emphasis on the local, relatively unknown heroes serves to diminish the perception, held by many white liberals, of King as Messiah of the Alabama movement.
“From the relative safety of Atlanta,” McWhorter writes, “King had watched the trials of his Birmingham colleague Fred Lee Shuttlesworth, the proud creature of a city he said had “a heart as hard as the steel it manufactures and as black as the coal it mines.” Shuttlesworth’s “ramrod carriage, arrogantly tilted head, and harsh intelligence, contained in the package of an unpolished, rabble-rousing Baptist preacher, contrasted with the Reverend Dr. King’s intellectual Hamlet image, as the pampered product of black bourgeoisie.”
Shuttlesworth, whose “appalling courage” (he had been threatened, bombed and whipped with chains) earned him the title “The Wild Man From Birmingham,” was an utter realist. While publicly adhering to King’s nonviolent approach, he knew, as did the Irish rebels of 1916, that the goal could not be won without violence. The difference was that Shuttlesworth knew his people would have to endure most of the violence without hope of winning any direct reprisal.
“Bull” Connor proved to be an unwitting pawn, albeit a brutal one, of Shuttlesworth and the movement. Or, as Wyatt Tee Walker, executive director of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, put it, “I prayed that he’d keep trying to stop us … Birmingham would been lost if Bull had let us go down to the city hall and pray.” By turning on the fire hoses and bringing out the dogs, “Bull” Connor helped galvanize a people, not just in Birmingham, but through national television, around the world.
It would be misleading to call “Carry Me Home” a difficult read. It is in fact a very difficult read, rich and complex and at times maddeningly detailed. I have seen at least two critics comment that at times they had difficulty “seeing the forest for the trees”.
Well, that’s because the trees are so big and the forest so wide. It would have been neater if this fabulous cast of characters had all lived simpler lives, or if the battle for civil rights had not been so hard, but there you are. One might suggest that the reason this story has never been told before is precisely because no writer has been so willing to give as much of herself as was needed to tell the story. It’s tough enough to devote more than a decade to researching a book like this, but to have to ask your father at the end of it if he bore any responsibility for the murder of four little girls is courage above and beyond the call.
Allen Barra's next book is "Mickey and Willie -- The Parallel Lives of Baseball's Golden Age," from Crown. More Allen Barra.
Stop-and-frisk, eviscerated
A U.S. district judge exposes the NYPD's harassment strategy as racist, unconstitutional
(Credit: Reuters/Carlo Allegri)
This month, a federal judge in New York dealt a blow to “stop-and-frisk,” a policy that resulted in 685,000 recorded police stops in 2011. Eighty-five percent of those stopped were African American and Latino, mostly youths.
The future of whiteness
Both Republican and Democratic racial politics are doomed. How culture shifts will reshape American ideas on race
The Census Bureau has announced that a majority of new-born infants in the U.S. now belong to categories other than what the U.S. federal government calls “non-Hispanic white.”
While so-called “non-Hispanic whites” still account for 49.6 percent of American newborns, immigration has expanded the Hispanic and Asian categories, while the African-American or black share of the U.S. population has remained roughly constant. Whether they celebrate or dread it, progressive champions of the “rainbow coalition” and white conservative nativists at least agree on one fact: In the future, whites in the U.S. will be a minority.
Continue Reading CloseMichael Lind’s new book, "Land of Promise: An Economic History of the United States", will be published in April and can be pre-ordered at Amazon.com. More Michael Lind.
“The Intouchables”: Racial comedy, French style
"The Intouchables" is the biggest foreign-language film of all time. Some critics say it's also racist
A still from "The Intouchables" Here’s a startling news item: “The Intouchables,” a lively if largely predictable Parisian comedy about a wealthy quadriplegic and his ne’er-do-well immigrant caretaker, has become the biggest international success in the history of French cinema. Indeed, according to some sources — and these things are notoriously difficult to measure on a global and historical scale — “The Intouchables” is now the biggest non-Anglophone film of all time, with a worldwide gross approaching $300 million.
Continue Reading CloseCan you identify?
Science shows that the only way around some readers' prejudices is to trick them
(Credit: Shutterstock/Salon) The news of recent research documenting how readers identify with the main characters in stories has mostly been taken as confirmation of the value of literary role models. Lisa Libby, an assistant professor at Ohio State University and co-author of a study published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, explained that subjects who read a short story in which the protagonist overcomes obstacles in order to vote were more likely to vote themselves several days later.
The suggestibility of readers isn’t news. Johann Wolfgang von Goethe’s novel of a sensitive young man destroyed by unrequited love, “The Sorrows of Young Werther,” inspired a rash of suicides by would-be Werthers in the late 1700s. Jack Kerouac has launched a thousand road trips. Still, this is part of science’s job: Running empirical tests on common knowledge — if for no other reason than because common knowledge (and common sense) is often wrong.
Continue Reading Close
Laura Miller is a senior writer for Salon. She is the author of "The Magician's Book: A Skeptic's Adventures in Narnia" and has a Web site, magiciansbook.com. More Laura Miller.
Whitewashing, a history
From "Tiffany's" to "Khan," we look at Hollywood's illustrious tradition of casting white actors in non-white roles SLIDE SHOW
All I have to say is that whitewashing has been going on since as long as Hollywood has existed — it’s a tradition — and rather than non-white people complaining about it, they should embrace it. It will make going to the movies so much easier and more fun. But there are just a few things you need to understand.
First, stop watching movies as ethnic people and start watching them as white people. There’s nothing that white people like more than seeing other white people in movies and on television. When you go to the movies with your ethnic “judgment” eyes, you miss my point. Watch as a white person, and suddenly your outrage turns to understanding and laughter.
Continue Reading CloseAasif Mandvi is an actor and writer who appears as a correspondent on "The Daily Show with Jon Stewart." He also co wrote and stars in the film "Today's Special" and will be appearing this summer in the films "Premium Rush" and "Ruby Sparks." More Aasif Mandvi.
Page 1 of 78 in Race