War of words
The Chinese get what sounds like an apology, and President Bush gets a resolution that silences the right -- for now.
By Daryl Lindsey, Alicia Montgomery and Jake TapperTopics: China, George W. Bush, News
In the end, the resolution of the spy plane standoff hinged on semantics — the use of language that would politically appease both Americans and Chinese, and keep from bruising either a sensitive superpower with a new president, or a rising Asian nation long attuned to slights to its pride and dignity.
U.S. Ambassador to China Joseph Prueher sent a letter Tuesday night to Chinese Foreign Minister Tang Jiaxuan expressing “sincere regret” over the loss of a Chinese pilot and stating that the U.S. is “very sorry” for entering Chinese airspace and making an emergency landing on Hainan Island “without verbal clearance.” The missive also asked Beijing to “please convey to the Chinese people and to the family of pilot Wang Wei that we are very sorry for their loss.” Beijing leaders responded positively to the letter, which provided it with a way out of an increasingly messy diplomatic crisis with the country that holds the linchpin to China’s plans for economic growth.
Though the letter stopped short of a full apology, which the U.S. did not want to give, it did indicate that the U.S. was “very sorry” for the death of Wang and the emergency landing, using the term baoqian. That’s more casual than “zhengshi daoqian,” the equivalent of a formal apology, which Chinese President Jiang Zemin had sought, but baoqian implies enough U.S. responsibility for the incident to satisfy hardliners, linguistic experts say.
“The key phrase in English, ‘very sorry for entering China’s airspace,’ leaves just barely ambiguous the question of fault, but the Chinese baoqian is not similarly ambiguous,” says Princeton Professor of Chinese Perry Link, who edited “The Tiananmen Papers” earlier this year. “Both governments can run with their respective spins, but in language the Chinese side has done somewhat better.”
According to prominent Chinese literary translator Zhu Hong, who is also a professor of Chinese Literature at Boston University, although baoqian is not the most formal for of apology in the Chinese language, it is the second most serious form of expressing regret or articulating feeling apologetic. Zhu says that in the context of the diplomatic crisis with China, use of baoqian in the ambassador’s letter would imply enough U.S. responsibility to be an acceptable form of apology, and allow Chinese leaders to sway public opinion and hardliners.
In a statement issued Wednesday, Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Chen Ci said: “Since the U.S. government has already said ‘very sorry’ to the Chinese people, the Chinese government has, out of humanitarian considerations, decided to allow the 24 people from the U.S. spy plane to leave after completion of the necessary procedures.” But Chen also added that “this is not the conclusion of the case.”
Though the matter of recovering the spy plane remains unresolved, the letter effectively ended the diplomatic impasse between the two countries, and within hours, a chartered Continental Airlines 737 was en route from Guam to pick up the detainees.
The resolution came none too soon for President Bush, who was facing an uprising on his right over his comparative caution in dealing with the stalemate. The chorus of conservative critics gained in volume over the last several days, with Rep. Henry Hyde, former presidential candidate Gary Bauer and a growing number of rightist pundits charging that Bush was too soft in what Hyde and others alleged was a “hostage” situation — a term the Bush administration pointedly refused to use. Hard-liners began calling for sanctions against China, including yanking the U.S. ambassador, cutting trade ties and blocking China’s entry into the World Trade Organization or its bid to host the Olympics.
But on Wednesday key Republicans praised the resolution of the crisis. “Everybody knows we were very limited in our options,” says Sen. Chuck Hagel, R-Neb., a member of both the Senate Committee on Foreign Relations and its Subcommittee on East Asian and Pacific Affairs. “I think it [the letter] is fine. Obviously, we’ve got some diplomatic doubletalk in there, but that’s to be expected in this business. Overall, it’s probably as good as we could have gotten here, at least in regards to the short term.
“The Chinese were holding a lot of the cards — the cards being 24 of our crew members,” Hagel continued. “In the end, were we going to exacerbate an already delicate problem here by hardening lines on both sides? Driving both sides further and further apart? With an endgame that would be more and more unattractive?
“Let’s be honest here, the Chinese had us over a barrel on this thing. I was just talking to a constituent, and he said that we should have been tougher, and I asked him, ‘Where do you want to start? With tactical nuclear missiles? Bombarding Hainan island with the Seventh Fleet?’”
The abrupt turnabout on China was striking considering that only a day earlier, Bush had to defend himself to the American public and conservatives during a press conference. “Diplomacy sometimes takes a little longer than people would like,” Bush told reporters.
For days, the Chinese had been demanding an “apology” from the U.S. for its role in the accident. Over the weekend, both Bush and Secretary of State Colin Powell expressed regret and sorrow for the apparent death of Chinese fighter pilot Wang Wei, but refused to apologize for the incident. In fact, it had strong reasons not to — Pentagon sources revealed Tuesday that just before the crash, the Chinese jet had come within three feet of striking the American surveillance plane.
The Chinese have been engaging in the practice of tailgating American planes with increasing frequency during the past several months. The accident occurred over waters that are observed by most countries of the world as international waters, and if the Chinese jets hadn’t been intercepting the American craft, the accident wouldn’t have happened. So there was little for the Bush administration to do but express regret that the accident occurred or that lives were lost.
While polls showed Americans supported the president’s handling of the crisis, there were also signs that public resentment against China had begun to build. Wednesday the New York Times reported Wednesday that Kmart had been inundated with thousands of calls from consumers asking the company to boycott products made in China because of the standoff. “Our customers are telling us to quit doing business in China — that they’re not going to buy things made there anymore, ” Kmart vice president Dale Apley was quoted as saying in the Times.
Once the immediate crisis was resolved, some conservatives praised Bush’s stance, with the benefit of hindsight. Arthur Waldron, director of Asian studies at the American Enterprise Institute, says the most important turning point in the stalemate was not Bush’s offer of regret, but his refusal to offer more than that. “If they [China] had been getting concessions, they would have kept holding on to [the crewmembers]. When Americans were getting mad, Asian countries weren’t lining up behind them [the Chinese], and they felt that their chance at the Olympics might be threatened, they just didn’t want those hostages anymore. They took Bush’s statement, dropped some modifiers and subordinate clauses, and spun it their way.”
Nonetheless, this won’t be Bush’s last dispute with the Chinese. Several crucial outstanding matters still remain unresolved in our diplomatic relations, including the recent detention of American academics in China and the pending sale of arms by the U.S. to Taiwan.
“I’m more worried by the Chinese arrests of American scholars than I was about this,” offers AEI’s Waldron. “The plane and the detention of the crew, that was an accident. These arrests are a considered policy, targeting people who had not been previously targeted. Those detentions had been pushed out of the headlines, but I think that they are going to bubble back to the surface now.”
Sen. Chuck Hagel believes the spy plane incident hurt U.S.-Chinese relations in the long term.
“I do believe the Chinese have mishandled this, and they will suffer some consequences in the Congress as result of that, in five specific areas: trade, the Taiwanese arms package, an arms embargo and Olympic resolution, and both cultural and military-to-military exchanges.
“We’re not through with this. When Congress reconvenes after recess, you’re going to see resolutions, press conferences, etc. Especially if the Chinese continue to play games with the matter of our getting the plane back — which I suspect they will. You’ll see a rather significant deterioration of our relationship with the Chinese over the next few weeks. And the longer they play games with that plane, the worse they’re going to make it.”
Daryl Lindsey is associate editor of Salon News and an Arthur Burns fellow. He currently lives in Berlin and writes for Salon and Die Welt. More Daryl Lindsey.
Alicia Montgomery is an associate editor in Salon's Washington bureau. More Alicia Montgomery.
Jake Tapper is the senior White House correspondent for ABC News. More Jake Tapper.
Related Stories
More Related Stories
-
Glenn Beck: CNN interview with atheist tornado survivor was a setup!
-
Incoming BBC news director on journalism gender gap: "We can do better"
-
Illegal construction, shoddy materials at fault in Bangladesh factory disaster
-
Ahead of Obama's speech, U.S. acknowledges four American drone killings
-
Must-see morning clip: Bill O'Reilly visits "The Daily Show"
-
Lawsuit alleges anti-gay hiring practices at ExxonMobil
-
Boy Scouts poised to vote, still greatly divided on gay youth
-
House supporters of KXL received $56m from fossil fuel industry
-
80-year-old becomes oldest to climb Mount Everest
-
Before FBI shooting man implicated self, Tsarnaev in triple murder
-
Paul McCartney backs Pussy Riot
-
UK emergency committee convenes after attack
-
Brave scout leader tried to reason with London attackers
-
If Alex Pareene were a cable news executive...
-
El Salvador court delays ruling on abortion case while woman's life hangs in the balance
-
UK officials: Radical Islam behind London attack
-
Pa. governor "can't find" any Latinos to work in his administration
-
London machete attack could be linked to terrorism
-
Conservative group blames military sexual assault on "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" repeal
-
Lois Lerner, IRS disaster
-
Donald Rumsfeld worried that marriage equality will lead to polygamy
Featured Slide Shows
The week in 10 pics
close X- Share on Twitter
- Share on Facebook
- Thumbnails
- Fullscreen
- 1 of 11
- Previous
- Next
-
Lisa Montgomery embraces her nephew Thursday after a tornado tore apart her home in Cleburne, Texas. The twister killed six people and destroyed entire swaths of the North Texas town.
Credit: AP/LM Otero -
Jack McMahon, the defense attorney for abortion doctor Kermit Gosnell, speaks outside the Criminal Justice Center in Philadelphia Tuesday. His client was convicted of killing three babies in his clinic, and will serve multiple life sentences.
Credit: AP/Matt Rourke -
A photo taken Monday captures Vice President Joe Biden's response to a Milwaukee second-grader's innovative proposal to end America's epidemic of gun violence. This guy!
Credit: AP/Jenny Aicher -
Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky., flanked by a grouper-eyed Michele Bachmann, addresses the IRS' admission that it targeted Tea Party groups in advance of the 2012 election. In an op-ed for CNN Thursday, the Kentucky senator slammed the president for his faux outrage.
Credit: AP/Molly Riley -
Ousted IRS chief Steven Miller is sworn in on Capitol Hill Friday. Miller testified before the House Ways and Means Committee on the extra scrutiny the agency gave conservative groups applying for tax-exempt status.
Credit: AP/J. Scott Applewhite -
Attorney General Eric Holder pauses as he testifies on Capitol Hill before the House Judiciary Committee Wednesday. Holder is under fire, among other things, for the Justice Department's gathering of phone records at the Associated Press.
Credit: AP/Carolyn Kaster -
O.J. Simpson sits during an evidentiary hearing at Clark County District Court in Las Vegas, Nev., Thursday. Simpson, who is currently serving a nine-to-33-year sentence in state prison for armed robbery and kidnapping, is using a writ of habeas corpus to seek a new trial.
Credit: AP/Las Vegas Review-Journal/Jeff Scheid -
Major Tom to ground control: On Sunday astronaut Chris Hadfield recorded the first music video from space, a cover of David Bowie's "Space Oddity."
Credit: AP/NASA/Chris Hadfield -
When it rains it pours. President Barack Obama speaks during a news conference Thursday with Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, inexplicably inspiring an #umbrellagate Twitter meme.
Credit: AP/Jacquelyn Martin -
A smoke plume rises high above a road block at the intersection of County A and Ross Road east of Solon Springs, Wis., Tuesday. No injuries were reported, but the the wildfire caused evacuations across northwestern Wisconsin.
Credit: AP/The Duluth News-Tribune/Clint Austin -
Recent Slide Shows
- Share on Twitter
- Share on Facebook
- Thumbnails
- Fullscreen
- 1 of 11
- Previous
- Next
Related Videos
Most Read
-
Oklahoma senator: Tornado aid "totally different" from Sandy aid
Jillian Rayfield
-
Tornado survivor to Wolf Blitzer: Sorry, I'm an atheist. I don't have to thank the Lord
Mary Elizabeth Williams
-
9-year-old slams Rahm over Chicago schools
Natasha Lennard
-
Inhofe and Coburn: Red state hypocrites
Joan Walsh
-
Facebook's hate speech problem
Mary Elizabeth Williams
-
Experts: Fox News spying scandal a game-changer
Natasha Lennard
-
Brad Pitt keeps breaking his silence on how boring marriage to Jennifer Aniston was
Daniel D'Addario
-
Revenge, ego and the corruption of Wikipedia
Andrew Leonard
-
Did a Salon excerpt ruin Penn Jillette's chance to win "Celebrity Apprentice"?
Daniel D'Addario
-
You are less beautiful than you think
Ozgun Atasoy, Scientific American
Popular on Reddit
links from salon.com

200 points201 points202 points | 66 comments

45 points46 points47 points | 1 comment
From Around the Web
Presented by Scribol
- British mom filmed confronting killers of soldier in London explains brave act
- Chatter: Machete terrorist attack in London
- Tax haven no longer? Luxembourg resists change to lax regulations
- America: What's more harmful, pot use or incarceration?
- UPDATES: More details of British soldier's killers emerge, as riots break out in London
- Can activists shame Abercrombie & Fitch into reforming?
- How Apple's tricky accounting could spark global tax reform
- What happens when two ancient galaxies smash into each other?
- How a Ghost Army of American artists helped defeat Hitler
- London's gruesome attack and the rising threat of lone-wolf terrorism



Comments
0 Comments