Michelle Goldberg
The last great liberal hero
To those who knew him, Sen. Paul Wellstone personified the highest ideals of the American left.
Sen. Paul Wellstone was one of the last links between the American left and the Democratic Party. Old-school progressives may feel increasingly alienated from government and the people who are supposed to represent them there, but Wellstone proved that there can still be a place for them, that the liberal dream of uniting steelworkers and small farmers with urban intellectuals is still alive, however elusive it sometimes seems. “He was the one voice inside the Democratic Party that made it possible to argue that there was still hope within the Democratic Party,” says Rabbi Michael Lerner, who worked with Wellstone in support of the Israel peace movement.
“He was sort of like the ideal progressive coalition all in one,” says David Moberg, a senior editor at In These Times who has known Wellstone for years and has written about him often. “He inspired passion among labor unions and an equivalent passion among environmentalists. Minority groups felt passionate about him, women voted overwhelmingly for him.” And he got under the skin of his opponents — the first George Bush, annoyed at the freshman senator’s incessant questioning at a reception for new members of Congress, asked one of his aides: “Who is this chickenshit?”
When Wellstone ran successfully for the U.S. Senate against Republican incumbent Rudy Boschwitz in 1990, his opponent had five times as much money as Wellstone did. A political science professor at Carleton College in Northfield, Minn., and longtime activist on behalf of small farmers, he was the very antithesis of a professional politician — the kind of underdog candidate that usually only wins in the movies. “He won because he organized in an old-fashioned way, having a disproportionately large ground operation, direct contact with people, lots of get-out-the-vote,” says Moberg. “He brought a great deal of passion into his speaking. His kind of politics involved mobilizing average citizens to get out and believe in doing political work.”
It’s no surprise, then, that he came off as naive. “I was always surprised that he could get elected in the first place,” says John Judis, co-author of “The Emerging Democratic Majority.” “He didn’t have a conventional politician’s personality. He was so feisty, so hot, in an era of people who want to be cool. He’s too short also — he was about 5-foot-5, even shorter than me. He lacked all the usual attributes you associate with being senatorial. He seemed totally inappropriate for the late 20th and early 21st century.”
Which is, of course, why people loved him — he hearkened back to an earlier generation of fiery populists. Roy Grow, an old friend and former colleague in Carleton’s political science department, says Wellstone was a great admirer of Saul Alinsky, a legendary Chicago radical and community organizer who in the 1940s united Catholic leaders, labor unions, youth groups and mutually antagonistic ethnic groups to fight unfair labor practices. “[Wellstone] saw in Minnesota an energy in politics that normal politicians had not tapped, ” says Grow. “He knew the energy in small towns, on farms, in labor organizations — his whole campaign was based on tapping into that energy.”
Grow recalls the Minnesota farm crisis during the early 1980s, when “all across the upper Midwest there was foreclosure after foreclosure, people being thrown off farms they’d owned for generations. All over the state there were little groups of farmers protesting outside the banks, buying each other’s equipment when it went up for auction, refusing to leave their land — and Paul was always there with them.”
Until he left the classroom for the Senate, he brought that same populist passion to his teaching. “He drew energy from people, not from adulation, but from tapping into their feelings and their needs,” Grow says. “He wasn’t a traditional kind of teacher. He would take a group of students to a union hall, take them to a picket line and make them feel the anguish on that picket line.”
Astonishingly, politics didn’t seem to change him. “When he was talking about running for president in 2002, I heard him at a small open house,” recalls Todd Gitlin, a historian of the antiwar movement and professor at Columbia University in New York. He was so downspoken, to coin a word. Almost shambling. He was so informal and unprepossessing as to immediately mark him off as a man of his political generation, a person who’d come to politics not out of some stupendous sense of his own self-worth or need to compensate for some inner breakage, but out of conviction.
“I only met him that one time, but I can’t think of another public figure whose death affects me so personally, ” Gitlin continues. “He was the personification of that hope or prayer that a link between the left and Democratic Party could actually be out there in the real world, doing the work of a real politician.”
Indeed, as a politician, he didn’t sell out the progressives who brought him to power, remaining the most liberal member of the Senate, and in many ways its conscience. “He was a true brother and a true friend, someone who cared profoundly about the powerless, the disabled and working people in general,” says Leo Gerard, president of United Steelworkers of America. “I went to his office one time with some steelworkers who were going to lose their jobs. He was lying on the floor with his feet up on a chair, because he had a very bad back. He jumped up and hugged them like he never had any pain. How do you put a value on a friend like that?”
One of Wellstone’s last votes was against president Bush’s Iraq resolution, a decision many thought would hurt him in a tight race with Republican challenger Norm Coleman, the former mayor of St. Paul. In the end it didn’t — after the vote, his campaign got a boost. “The initial fear when Paul voted against it was that it would hurt his campaign, but the initial polling came up just the opposite,” said another resolution opponent, Sen. Dick Durbin, D-Ill., in an interview just hours before Wellstone’s death. “It reaffirmed who Paul Wellstone [was] and what he’s willing to do and risk — the fact that he [was] prepared to stand up to the president even with election around the corner.”
It wasn’t his only brave move on foreign policy — he remained close to Peace Now, the Israeli opposition group, despite the enormous political danger of criticizing Israeli policy. “He was the one senator who was willing to identify with the Israeli peace movement,”‘ says Lerner. “When Tikkun did a conference to support the Israeli peace movement in Jerusalem in 1991, right after he was elected, he came against the advice of many of the leaders of the Democratic Party in his area.
“His accomplishment was to be a voice of hope in a period of despair, to be someone who showed that it was possible to be principled and progressive and visionary, and still win.”
How abortion changed the world
From a sketchy underground doctor to the American fight against communism, a look at the unlikely forces that helped spread global family planning.
In the 1950s, before he became notorious, Harvey Karman was a psychology student at UCLA, attending on the GI bill. Writing a paper on the emotional impact of abortion led him into the abortion underground, where he helped a number of desperate coeds find ways to terminate their pregnancies. “It seemed like every guy who got a girlfriend pregnant, everyone who had remotely heard about me, said, ‘This guy knows about abortion,’” he told Ms. magazine in 1975. Often he’d help young women make their way to Mexico to end their pregnancies. Some of them came through the procedures fine, but some came home sick or injured, and Karman would take them to the school’s medical center for treatment. Frustrated with this system, he eventually started performing abortions himself.
Continue Reading CloseThe holy blitz rolls on
The Christian right is a "deeply anti-democratic movement" that gains force by exploiting Americans' fears, argues Chris Hedges. Salon talks with the former New York Times reporter about his fearless new book, "American Fascists."
Longtime war correspondent Chris Hedges, the former New York Times bureau chief in the Middle East and the Balkans, knows a lot about the savagery that people are capable of, especially when they’re besotted with dreams of religious or national redemption. In his acclaimed 2002 book, “War Is a Force That Gives Us Meaning,” he wrote: “I have been in ambushes on desolate stretches of Central American roads, shot at in the marshes of Southern Iraq, imprisoned in the Sudan, beaten by Saudi military police, deported from Libya and Iran, captured and held for a week by Iraqi Republican Guard during the Shiite rebellion following the Gulf War, strafed by Russian Mig-21s in Bosnia, fired upon by Serb snipers, and shelled for days in Sarajevo with deafening rounds of heavy artillery that threw out thousands of deadly bits of iron fragments.” Hedges was part of the New York Times team of reporters that won a 2002 Pulitzer Prize for explanatory reporting about global terrorism.
Continue Reading CloseDestination: Turkey
This endlessly fascinating, sometimes heartbreaking puzzle of a country that's fraught with religious and political conflict is brilliantly captured in the novels of Orhan Pamuk and Elif Shafak.
My husband knew better than to get me a diamond ring when he proposed. What I really wanted was what I always want — plane tickets somewhere far away from wherever I happen to be. Rather than spend any money on a wedding, we decided to blow our rather paltry savings seeing the world. Right after eloping to city hall, we spent six weeks in Greece and Turkey. Then we came home, put all our stuff in storage, tied up the loose ends of our lives and bought one-way tickets to Saigon, commencing a yearlong jaunt through Asia. We’ve been to other countries since then, mostly in the Middle East and Europe. When I look at maps of the earth, I’m awed by all the places I haven’t been, but I’m lucky enough to be fairly well-traveled. Last year, when I staggered over the finish line of a book deadline, exhausted and brain-fried, my husband and I decided to take another trip. We wanted to go somewhere foreign but familiar enough to be relaxing. I thought for a moment about where, in all the world, I’d most like to be. I didn’t have to think long. Turkey.
Continue Reading CloseAbortion under siege in Mississippi
Preaching that abortion is as evil as Islam, Nazism and homosexuality, dozens of activists have descended on Jackson, determined to shut down the state's last abortion clinic.
Flip Benham was going to burn a Koran at Mississippi’s state Capitol on July 18 but he couldn’t get a fire permit. The blaze was to be the culmination of an antiabortion rally that Benham, director of Operation Save America, billed as an “ecclesiastical court.” His attack on Islam might seem like a non sequitur, but to Benham, it made perfect sense. “Islam is the same thing as abortion and homosexuality,” he said. “It’s the black-colored glove covering the same fist, which is the fist of the devil.” Benham had T-shirts made up, black with white lettering, proclaiming, “Homosexuality Is Sin! Islam Is a Lie! Abortion Is Murder! Some Issues Are Just Black and White!”
Continue Reading Close“Any attack on Iran will be good for the government”
Nobel laureate and human rights activist Shirin Ebadi discusses the plight of women in Iran, Bush's similarity to Ahmadinejad and why direct negotiations are the only solution.
Shirin Ebadi’s new book, “Iran Awakening: A Memoir of Revolution and Hope,” opens with a chilling scene that underlines just how hazardous her human rights activism has been. In the fall of 2000, Ebadi, one of Iran’s leading reformist lawyers, represented Parastou Forouhar, whose parents, dissident intellectuals, were butchered by government assassins. Their killings, part of a string of murders of regime critics carried out by the Ministry of Intelligence in the late ’90s, were perpetrated with particular sadism — the aging couple were stabbed repeatedly and then hacked to pieces.
Continue Reading ClosePage 1 of 52 in Michelle Goldberg