Michelle Goldberg
We shall overcome … liberals
At a black church in Philadelphia, Martin Luther King Jr.'s niece joined Jerry Falwell and Rick Santorum to denounce critics of Samuel Alito.
A time traveler from the civil rights era would have been flabbergasted at Justice Sunday III last night. The third of the Family Research Council’s nationally televised rallies to proclaim God’s support for Bush’s judicial nominees was held at Greater Exodus Baptist Church, an African-American congregation in downtown Philadelphia, and it roared with full-throated gospel and foot-stomping enthusiasm. Martin Luther King Jr. was invoked over and over — his niece, Alveda King, a frequent presence at religious right confabs, summoned the memory of Rosa Parks and sang a yearning version of “We Shall Overcome.”
But what Alveda King and the other participants at Justice Sunday ached to overcome wasn’t discrimination or poverty or disenfranchisement. Rather, they spoke of overcoming decades of progressive jurisprudence — the very jurisprudence that provided legal support to the civil rights movement. They spoke of overcoming opposition to Bush’s Supreme Court nominee Samuel Alito, a man who has demonstrated hostility to past Supreme Court decisions protecting voting rights, and who belonged to Concerned Alumni of Princeton, a group that sought to limit the number of women and minorities at the university. (“A student population of approximately 40 percent women and minorities will largely vitiate the alumni body of the future,” said one of its brochures.)
Greater Exodus Baptist Church is pastored by the Rev. Herb Lusk, a charismatic former tailback for the Philadelphia Eagles and one of Bush’s staunchest backers among black clergymen. Lusk, who endorsed Bush from his church via video at the 2000 Republican National Convention, has been awarded more than $1 million in grants under the president’s faith-based initiative. In Lusk’s view, the central divide in American life is not racial or economic but religious. Decrying “discrimination against people of God,” he bellowed: “My brothers and sisters, I will not go down without a fight!” The largely black audience jumped to their feet, cheering and clapping. “Be careful how you fool with the church!” Lusk thundered. “Don’t fool with the church because the church has buried many critics. All the critics we have not buried, we’re making funeral arrangements for!”
Laughter resounded in the high-ceilinged, baby-blue room. Behind Lusk, several throne-like white chairs, upholstered in dark red, were arranged in a circle. Perched in them were Justice Sunday III’s featured speakers — Sen. Rick Santorum, James Dobson, Jerry Falwell, Bishop Wellington Boone (a leader in the Promise Keepers) and Alveda King. They were flanked by two flags — the stars and stripes on one side, and the Christian flag, white with a red cross on a blue field, on the other. The event was simulcast to viewers all over the country watching at churches and at home on Christian television.
The entire evening had a surreal, upside-down quality, as if history had been caught in a whirlpool and come back all jumbled. Appearing via video, David Barton, a theocratic revisionist historian, invoked the words of Thomas Jefferson to argue that the founders intended for religion and government to be intertwined. (“I tremble for my country when I reflect that God is just,” he quoted, not bothering to mention that Jefferson was talking about the sin of slavery, not secularism.) A cast of white conservatives, several with past links to racist groups, presented themselves as heirs to the preachers who led the fight against segregation. The moral authority of the black church was invoked against the judges who have most fervently defended civil rights.
This was particularly audacious given that racial issues could play at least as large a role as abortion in the battle over Alito’s confirmation. In a 1985 application to become deputy assistant attorney general in the Reagan administration, Alito wrote, “In college, I developed a deep interest in constitutional law, motivated in large part by disagreement with Warren Court decisions, particularly in the areas of criminal procedure, the Establishment Clause, and reapportionment.”
The Warren court’s reapportionment cases determined that voters must have equal representation; prior to them, there were vast differences in the population of legislative districts, often resulting in the dilution of black voting power. Delaware Sen. Joseph Biden has said he’d consider filibustering over Alito’s views on reapportionment.
Alito’s interpretation of civil rights law is also controversial — as the Washington Post wrote in an editorial, “In several prominent cases, Judge Alito has displayed a more skeptical attitude than have his colleagues toward claims of race and gender discrimination and has tended to embrace narrow readings of important federal anti-discrimination laws.”
Nevertheless, Justice Sunday III speakers presented a potential Alito confirmation as an unparalleled triumph for both black and white believers. “What we have worked on for 30 years is coming to culmination, consummation right now,” said Jerry Falwell. “We were able to hold off Michael Moore, most of Hollywood, most of the national media, George Soros, and the Kennedys and other crowds who fought so fiercely against the reelection of George Bush. And now, now we’re looking at what we really started on 30 years ago — a reconstruction of a court system gone awry.”
Today, conservatives excoriate the Supreme Court for banning school-sponsored Bible reading and prayer. But the high court first earned right-wing ire by declaring segregation unconstitutional in 1954′s Brown v. Board of Education. Responding to Brown, conservatives then fulminated about “judicial tyranny” and launched campaigns to have Warren impeached. Southern white religious leaders denounced the civil rights movement; in 1958, Falwell delivered a sermon titled “Segregation and Integration: Which?” He argued that the latter would lead to the destruction of the white race.
And yet there was Falwell at the pulpit of a predominantly black church, speaking of Supreme Court reconstruction as the common project of Christians of all races. With only a few hundred people in the packed house, Greater Exodus Baptist Church is smaller and more modest than the sprawling suburban megachurches that hosted the previous two Justice Sundays, but it served as a grander backdrop, imbuing the proceedings with a soulful authenticity meant to negate criticisms of Judge Sam Alito’s civil rights record.
Never mind that host Tony Perkins, head of the Family Research Council and Justice Sunday III’s host, once paid Ku Klux Klan Grand Wizard David Duke $82,500 for his mailing list. Or that, in the early 1990s, David Barton spoke to at least two major Christian Identity gatherings — Christian Identity being a white supremacist sect that believes blacks to be “mud people” and Jews the spawn of Satan. (Today, Barton is vice president of the Texas Republican Party and one of the most important purveyors of the revisionist notion that America was founded as a Christian nation, only to be subverted by God-hating secularists peddling the false doctrine of church-state separation. He was featured in several video segments at Justice Sunday III, and Falwell referenced his arguments.)
It’s a little surprising that Santorum would place himself in such company. Facing a difficult reelection campaign, he’s recently made efforts to distance himself from some parts of the religious right; once a major supporter of intelligent design, Santorum has since said it shouldn’t be taught in science classes and has resigned from the advisory board of the Thomas More Law Center, the conservative Catholic legal group that represented the anti-evolution school board in Dover, Pa.
But at Justice Sunday III, Santorum was in full culture-warrior mode. “Extreme liberal judges,” he said, are “destroying traditional morality, creating a new moral code, and prohibiting any dissent.” He continued, “The only way to restore this republic our founders envisioned is to elevate honorable jurists like Samuel Alito.”
Santorum warned that Democrats would try to thwart this noble goal by dragging the Alito hearings “into the gutter, so they can continue their far-left judicial activism on the Supreme Court.” Will you, he implored the audience, stand by and watch the destruction of the Constitution? “If your answer is no, then join me and make sure the answer is yes on Judge Samuel Alito.” In other words, to question Alito’s commitment to civil liberties is to acquiesce in the destruction of liberty. To examine his record on civil rights is to invite tyranny.
As the event ended, 50 or 60 clergymen, black and white, came to the front of the room and joined hands in prayer. “May not secularization or unbelief prevail against your word,” one said. Perkins looked approvingly at the assemblage. “Black Americans, white Americans,” he said. “Christians, standing together.”
How abortion changed the world
From a sketchy underground doctor to the American fight against communism, a look at the unlikely forces that helped spread global family planning.
In the 1950s, before he became notorious, Harvey Karman was a psychology student at UCLA, attending on the GI bill. Writing a paper on the emotional impact of abortion led him into the abortion underground, where he helped a number of desperate coeds find ways to terminate their pregnancies. “It seemed like every guy who got a girlfriend pregnant, everyone who had remotely heard about me, said, ‘This guy knows about abortion,’” he told Ms. magazine in 1975. Often he’d help young women make their way to Mexico to end their pregnancies. Some of them came through the procedures fine, but some came home sick or injured, and Karman would take them to the school’s medical center for treatment. Frustrated with this system, he eventually started performing abortions himself.
Continue Reading CloseThe holy blitz rolls on
The Christian right is a "deeply anti-democratic movement" that gains force by exploiting Americans' fears, argues Chris Hedges. Salon talks with the former New York Times reporter about his fearless new book, "American Fascists."
Longtime war correspondent Chris Hedges, the former New York Times bureau chief in the Middle East and the Balkans, knows a lot about the savagery that people are capable of, especially when they’re besotted with dreams of religious or national redemption. In his acclaimed 2002 book, “War Is a Force That Gives Us Meaning,” he wrote: “I have been in ambushes on desolate stretches of Central American roads, shot at in the marshes of Southern Iraq, imprisoned in the Sudan, beaten by Saudi military police, deported from Libya and Iran, captured and held for a week by Iraqi Republican Guard during the Shiite rebellion following the Gulf War, strafed by Russian Mig-21s in Bosnia, fired upon by Serb snipers, and shelled for days in Sarajevo with deafening rounds of heavy artillery that threw out thousands of deadly bits of iron fragments.” Hedges was part of the New York Times team of reporters that won a 2002 Pulitzer Prize for explanatory reporting about global terrorism.
Continue Reading CloseDestination: Turkey
This endlessly fascinating, sometimes heartbreaking puzzle of a country that's fraught with religious and political conflict is brilliantly captured in the novels of Orhan Pamuk and Elif Shafak.
My husband knew better than to get me a diamond ring when he proposed. What I really wanted was what I always want — plane tickets somewhere far away from wherever I happen to be. Rather than spend any money on a wedding, we decided to blow our rather paltry savings seeing the world. Right after eloping to city hall, we spent six weeks in Greece and Turkey. Then we came home, put all our stuff in storage, tied up the loose ends of our lives and bought one-way tickets to Saigon, commencing a yearlong jaunt through Asia. We’ve been to other countries since then, mostly in the Middle East and Europe. When I look at maps of the earth, I’m awed by all the places I haven’t been, but I’m lucky enough to be fairly well-traveled. Last year, when I staggered over the finish line of a book deadline, exhausted and brain-fried, my husband and I decided to take another trip. We wanted to go somewhere foreign but familiar enough to be relaxing. I thought for a moment about where, in all the world, I’d most like to be. I didn’t have to think long. Turkey.
Continue Reading CloseAbortion under siege in Mississippi
Preaching that abortion is as evil as Islam, Nazism and homosexuality, dozens of activists have descended on Jackson, determined to shut down the state's last abortion clinic.
Flip Benham was going to burn a Koran at Mississippi’s state Capitol on July 18 but he couldn’t get a fire permit. The blaze was to be the culmination of an antiabortion rally that Benham, director of Operation Save America, billed as an “ecclesiastical court.” His attack on Islam might seem like a non sequitur, but to Benham, it made perfect sense. “Islam is the same thing as abortion and homosexuality,” he said. “It’s the black-colored glove covering the same fist, which is the fist of the devil.” Benham had T-shirts made up, black with white lettering, proclaiming, “Homosexuality Is Sin! Islam Is a Lie! Abortion Is Murder! Some Issues Are Just Black and White!”
Continue Reading Close“Any attack on Iran will be good for the government”
Nobel laureate and human rights activist Shirin Ebadi discusses the plight of women in Iran, Bush's similarity to Ahmadinejad and why direct negotiations are the only solution.
Shirin Ebadi’s new book, “Iran Awakening: A Memoir of Revolution and Hope,” opens with a chilling scene that underlines just how hazardous her human rights activism has been. In the fall of 2000, Ebadi, one of Iran’s leading reformist lawyers, represented Parastou Forouhar, whose parents, dissident intellectuals, were butchered by government assassins. Their killings, part of a string of murders of regime critics carried out by the Ministry of Intelligence in the late ’90s, were perpetrated with particular sadism — the aging couple were stabbed repeatedly and then hacked to pieces.
Continue Reading ClosePage 1 of 52 in Michelle Goldberg