Farhad Manjoo
Does Flickr = Censr? Yahoo might be to blame
The photo-sharing site blocks users in Germany and several Asian countries from looking at "restricted" pictures.
Flickr won’t let people in Singapore, Germany, Hong Kong or South Korea look at photos of breasts, butts, backs, as well as Nazi symbols or other images deemed offensive in those countries. In the past few days, Flickr instituted a new “SafeSearch” policy that prohibits users in these places from turning off content filters. Why the company did it isn’t clear; Stewart Butterfield, Flickr’s co-founder, posted a couple messages on Flickr’s boards that strongly hinted that the plan goes against Flickr’s own wishes, and was instead pushed by Yahoo, Flickr’s parent company. The explanation hasn’t satisfied the Flickr faithful, who’ve been flooding the photo site with many quite creative examples of protest art.
Many blame the Flickr blockages on Yahoo’s policy of satisfying censorship authorities in the countries in which it operates. In 2000, Yahoo was sanctioned by a French court for violating laws prohibiting the sale of Nazi memorabilia; now Yahoo, Google and other Web firms censor their sites in accordance with the Chinese government. Singapore, Hong Kong and South Korea have laws blocking various kinds of speech; Germany, meanwhile, strictly prohibits Nazi imagery, and courts there have ruled that they have the power to block non-German Web sites that display banned content.
In one of his posts, Butterfield explained that including Germany in the new filtering scheme was a tough call. “The decision came down to the wire, but we decided to include Germany,” he wrote. “We’re still hoping that that was the right decision. It definitely was not a decision that was made lightly and there is no intention to annoy, frustrate or inconvenience Flickr members in Germany.”
The problem is not only that Flickr is now censoring images, it’s that it’s doing so quite indiscriminately. Every Flickr image can be tagged by users as falling into one of three “safety” categories — safe, “moderate,” or “restricted.”
But a Singaporean’s idea of “restricted” might very well be a German’s idea of a fun way to spend the afternoon. Nazi symbols are blocked in Germany, but nudes — well, nobody there has a thing against naked people! As a Flickr user named Remmy quite eloquently puts it:
The point is: I want to see the nudes! I want my nudes to be accessible to the ones who like to see them. Plain simple, this is my right. I know of no German law that would prohibit me from seeing any kind of nudity (of course except anything with children involved, this is out of question). Hell, I can see tits and asses and even an almost explicit presentation of sexual intercourse on public TV after 6 p.m.! There is no law that would prohibit this. And there is absolutely no need for Flickr to block all properly flagged “moderate” and “restricted” photos for users in Germany.
Butterfield responded to the storm with a rather cryptic message, one that suggested the decision was out of his hands:
Unfortunately I can’t give a more detailed update yet or any concrete good news, but please don’t take our silence to mean that nothing is happening. We are doing our best to make the situation better as quickly as possible. I’m sure it doesn’t make a lot of sense from the outside, and we would prefer to be able to share all the context — believe me, this is extremely uncomfortable and we’d *strongly* prefer not to be in this position — but we don’t have a choice at this time.
Again, we will post more as soon as we can — in the meantime, all we can do is apologize.
The one winner in this story is Thomas Hawk, the CEO of Zooomr, the upstart Flickr competitor whose slogan is “No limit photo sharing.” Earlier this week, Yahoo’s shareholders rejected a resolution to adopt an anti-censorship policy at the company. On Wednesday, Hawk announced that he would adopt the same policy at Zooomr.
On Wednesday, Hawk was busy on Flickr’s message boards, posting a few messages criticizing the company for its stance. And how did Flickr respond to Hawk’s comments? According to him, the staff deleted his messages.
[Flickr protest picture from jesuspark.]
The thinking man’s action hero
Using paper clips, chewing gum, chocolate and down-home ingenuity, MacGyver always saved the day. Let's bring him back -- and give him a girl!
It isn’t necessary to explain how, in the pilot episode of “MacGyver,” our mulleted, Midwestern hero gets himself trapped inside a top-secret research bunker overflowing with sulfuric acid. Suffice it to say, he needs to find a way out, and probably soon (because government agents are fixing to fire a missile at the bunker to prevent the acid from spilling into a nearby aquifer). Plus, he has to save the people he has found inside (among them a gun-wielding climate scientist who wants destroy the bunker in an effort to set back research into an ozone-layer-ruining weapon of mass destruction). Fortunately, MacGyver has a few chocolate bars, a scrap of sodium metal, a cold capsule, a pair of binoculars and cigarettes.
Continue Reading CloseGoodbye to Machinist
Yo, I'm out.

Today much of the tech world is sad that the iPhone 3G’s launch is going so miserably. But I’m sad that it’s my last day at Salon.
I’ve accepted a job at Slate, where, starting next week, I’ll be writing a twice-weekly technology column. Machinist will go on a break for a week, after which a guest blogger will bring you the latest tech dish.
Continue Reading Close“True Enough” at Google, and in San Francisco
A YouTubey presentation of my book.
As I mentioned in the comments yesterday, I’m getting ready to depart this space; I’ll have a fuller explanation tomorrow, sometime before or after I get in line to buy the new iPhone.
In the meantime, I thought I’d add a note about one of the more fun events related to my book’s release — the opportunity I had, in May, to speak at Google’s headquarters in Mountain View.
Continue Reading CloseThe iPhone 3G reviews are in: It’s pretty good
But battery life suffers, and the GPS isn't as great as you hoped.
Walt Mossberg (WSJ), David Pogue (NYT) and Edward Baig (USA Today) have been using the new iPhone 3G for a couple of weeks now, and today they all dish on their experiences.
Continue Reading CloseScary! YouTube ordered to hand your viewing history to Viacom
But there's a silver lining to one of the most bone-headed legal decisions in recent times.
Update: This post has been updated with comments from Viacom.
In the fall of 1987, a freelance reporter named Michael Dolan learned that judge Robert Bork kept an account at Potomac Video, a D.C. rental shop. This was at the height of the contentious and ultimately failed Senate confirmation hearings for Bork’s nomination to the Supreme Court — so naturally, Dolan thought there was a story here, and he went to work on getting a peek at Bork’s video rental history.
Continue Reading ClosePage 1 of 143 in Farhad Manjoo
