Farhad Manjoo
Does Blockbuster edit its movies?
Also: Is it really so bad that Netflix won't let you take your ratings with you?
Let’s tackle this first: Blockbuster does not “edit” movies it rents out in its stores or on its online service, contrary to what many readers say in response to my piece praising Blockbuster’s DVD-by-mail service. Doing so would be illegal, of course — copyright law prohibits Blockbuster from doing anything to the movies without authorization from studios.
OK, well then does Blockbuster ask the studios for watered-down versions of films? The Internet abounds with stories about this, but Tami Cannizzaro, a spokeswoman for Blockbuster, says it’s simply not true. “We have heard that for years,” she told me this afternoon. “We don’t get special versions nor do we ask the studios to make special versions. If we get a movie, it’s the studio version.” If any of you believe you can prove Cannizzaro wrong, please e-mail me.
It is true that Blockbuster does not carry movies that the Motion Picture Association of America has rated NC-17; this is a long-standing Blockbuster policy, Cannizzaro says. Blockbuster does carry some unrated films, but only those that the company has determined would not have received an NC-17 rating had the MPAA rated them. Thus even though they weren’t rated, you won’t find John Cameron Mitchell’s “Shortbus,” Michael Winterbottom’s “9 Songs,” nor, of course, Kirby Dick’s “This Film Is Not Yet Rated” at Blockbuster.
Netflix, meanwhile, does carry both NC-17 and unrated movies. If this is important to you — it is to me — choose Netflix.
A number of readers took issue with my demand that Netflix make subscribers’ information portable. I wrote that I’ve spent hours entering ratings and compiling a queue at Netflix, and I expect to be able to move that data easily — that is, electronically — to Blockbuster, my home computer, or anywhere else I please. After all, it’s my data.
Several readers said this position is ludicrous. Here’s how Harvey put it: “Since when has any service online ever let you do something like that? Can you take your ratings from Amazon and load them up on the Barnes and Noble site? No frigging way! Why would competing sites want to create this sort of interoperability between them? In what universe is Farhad Manjoo living?”
Well, Harvey, I’m living in a universe in which Flickr, the popular photo service, has decided to allow its users to easily move pictures to Flickr’s direct competitors because, in the words of Flickr founder Stewart Butterfield, the policy fosters “user freedom.” Would anyone quibble with this? The photos you put up at Flickr are obviously your photos; Flickr says so in its user agreement. So clearly you should be able to move them to another service if you want to, right?
Or say you’ve been writing a blog at Six Apart’s subscription blog service TypePad, but now you decide you want to move it over to competitor WordPress. Would it be OK for TypePad to refuse? Hey, they might say, why should we make it easy for you to take your years’ worth of blog posts if you’re going to leave our service anyway? You wouldn’t stand for this, would you? And, consequently, TypePad provides an export function. Any work you put in TypePad isn’t stuck there forever.
Why should Netflix be any different? Movie ratings are personal data. Netflix is profiting from them; the company uses my hundreds of ratings to help other people choose movies. I don’t mind that they do. But if they want me to keep entering ratings, why is it too much to ask that they don’t hold the ratings exclusively forever?
Finally, some of you seem to resent Blockbuster more for its past than its present; it’s charged you so many late fees and subjected you to such awful in-store service you’d never consider trying it now. I hear that; it’s a free market, take your dollars wherever your heart feels at home.
What I don’t get is the suggestion in many letters that Blockbuster should never have entered the market in the first place. Whether you use it or not, I can’t see how Blockbuster’s move isn’t unquestionably good for everyone. Would Netflix have lowered its price and moved so quickly to streamed movies had it not faced competition from Blockbuster? Maybe. But I’m sure the rivalry is keeping the people at Netflix quicker on their toes, and that’s a good thing.
The thinking man’s action hero
Using paper clips, chewing gum, chocolate and down-home ingenuity, MacGyver always saved the day. Let's bring him back -- and give him a girl!
It isn’t necessary to explain how, in the pilot episode of “MacGyver,” our mulleted, Midwestern hero gets himself trapped inside a top-secret research bunker overflowing with sulfuric acid. Suffice it to say, he needs to find a way out, and probably soon (because government agents are fixing to fire a missile at the bunker to prevent the acid from spilling into a nearby aquifer). Plus, he has to save the people he has found inside (among them a gun-wielding climate scientist who wants destroy the bunker in an effort to set back research into an ozone-layer-ruining weapon of mass destruction). Fortunately, MacGyver has a few chocolate bars, a scrap of sodium metal, a cold capsule, a pair of binoculars and cigarettes.
Continue Reading CloseGoodbye to Machinist
Yo, I'm out.

Today much of the tech world is sad that the iPhone 3G’s launch is going so miserably. But I’m sad that it’s my last day at Salon.
I’ve accepted a job at Slate, where, starting next week, I’ll be writing a twice-weekly technology column. Machinist will go on a break for a week, after which a guest blogger will bring you the latest tech dish.
Continue Reading Close“True Enough” at Google, and in San Francisco
A YouTubey presentation of my book.
As I mentioned in the comments yesterday, I’m getting ready to depart this space; I’ll have a fuller explanation tomorrow, sometime before or after I get in line to buy the new iPhone.
In the meantime, I thought I’d add a note about one of the more fun events related to my book’s release — the opportunity I had, in May, to speak at Google’s headquarters in Mountain View.
Continue Reading CloseThe iPhone 3G reviews are in: It’s pretty good
But battery life suffers, and the GPS isn't as great as you hoped.
Walt Mossberg (WSJ), David Pogue (NYT) and Edward Baig (USA Today) have been using the new iPhone 3G for a couple of weeks now, and today they all dish on their experiences.
Continue Reading CloseScary! YouTube ordered to hand your viewing history to Viacom
But there's a silver lining to one of the most bone-headed legal decisions in recent times.
Update: This post has been updated with comments from Viacom.
In the fall of 1987, a freelance reporter named Michael Dolan learned that judge Robert Bork kept an account at Potomac Video, a D.C. rental shop. This was at the height of the contentious and ultimately failed Senate confirmation hearings for Bork’s nomination to the Supreme Court — so naturally, Dolan thought there was a story here, and he went to work on getting a peek at Bork’s video rental history.
Continue Reading ClosePage 1 of 143 in Farhad Manjoo
