Baseball
The pro-Derek Jeter backlash
It starts here. Just because he's overhyped and overpraised doesn't mean he's not an all-time great.
Let’s do a little mailbag about Derek Jeter. Not to pick on letter-writer mboehm for his/her response to “Historic Yankee futility,” but he/she represents what I think is a pretty common view in a certain crowd, which is to say contrarians. That is, my crowd.
But I’m here to start a backlash. A backlash against the Jeter backlash, which is a backlash against the Jeter hype. So it’s an anti-anti-hype backlash backlash. Jeter. Backlash. Or something. Anyway, take it away, mboehm:
mboehm Jeter is a very good player (and a likely Hall of Famer) but to use the term “any player so great” is going too far.
Well that was kind of part of a joke, that part. To bring those of you who didn’t click the link up to speed, I’d wondered if any player as great as Jeter had ever won so few championships. The joke there, see, is that Jeter’s won a lot of championships.
But I’ll stand behind the part about Jeter being great.
You’ve been surprisingly duped by the New York-Boston centric ESPN that dominates the way we think about sports.
So here’s the part where I argue that it isn’t me that’s been duped by the … what you said. It was you, Charlie. You’ve reacted to the years of Jeter hype by underrating Jeter. Just because he’s been praised beyond the limits of ridiculousness doesn’t mean he’s not great.
If he’d spent his entire career in, just to name a place, Seattle, my hunch is you’d be railing against the New York-Boston ESPN cabal that would have kept this all-time titan from getting his due, while a merely good shortstop such as Orlando Cabrera of the Yankees — he ended up in New York as a result of the ripple effect of the alternate universe that put Jeter in Seattle, follow? — is treated like a deity.
You should be writing a column about Ichiro Suzuki, who has achieved 200 hits for all eight of his seasons in MLB, matched by only one other player in MLB history.
Thanks for the tip!
Jeter is maybe a slightly above average career fielder.
I think he’s below average, actually.
He’s a singles hitter.
Really. But I should be writing about Ichiro. Let’s go to the blockquote:
Career slugging percentage
Jeter .458
Ichiro .431Percentage of hits that are singles
Jeter 73
Ichiro 82Plate appearances per extra-base hit
Jeter 13.5
Ichiro 17.8On-base percentage
Jeter .387
Ichiro .377
Ichiro, the guy you want me to write about instead of Jeter because Jeter’s just a singles hitter, is a singles hitter. He gets more hits, but fewer extra-base hits, than Jeter, and he also makes more outs. Ichiro’s also a superb base-stealer, while Jeter’s only very good.
Ichiro’s a very good fielder, though he’s only spent a little time at a premium position. Jeter is below average, but at a premium position. That can’t be discounted. Jeter has been adequate at shortstop while hitting like a third baseman or corner outfielder. That’s huge, and it blows a guy like Omar Vizquel — great fielder, useless hitter, and mentioned by you in a part of the letter I didn’t quote — out of the water.
Jeter is a slam-dunk Hall of Famer. Not quite inner-circle, but solidly qualified, not at all borderline, and he’s probably got five years to add to his counting totals. He’s easily a top 15 shortstop all-time, maybe top 10.
The pro-Jeter backlash starts here.
King Kaufman is a senior writer for Salon. You can e-mail him at king at salon dot com. Facebook / Twitter / Tumblr More King Kaufman.
Guillen’s pro-Castro candor
The Miami Marlins' manager is lucky to get a suspension. Not so long ago, he might have received a car bomb.
A contrite Miami Marlins manager Ozzie Guillen gestures at a news conference on Tuesday. (Credit: AP/Lynne Sladky) There’s not much reason to doubt that baseball manager Ozzie Guillen admires Fidel Castro. He said so five years ago in an interview with Men’s Journal. When asked to name the toughest man he knew, Guillen replied, “Fidel Castro. He’s a bull—- dictator and everybody’s against him, and he still survives, has power. Still has a country behind him. Everywhere he goes, they roll out the red carpet. I don’t admire his philosophy; I admire him.’’
Continue Reading Close
Jefferson Morley is a staff writer for Salon in Washington and author of the forthcoming book, Snow-Storm in August: Washington City, Francis Scott Key, and the Forgotten Race Riot of 1835 (Nan Talese/Doubleday). More Jefferson Morley.
The year of the baseball book
From a treatise on Yankee hating to a "people's history," a number of great books covered the national pastime
A simple and unsettling calculation reveals to me that this year marks the 40th anniversary of my coming to New England and setting up shop as a Red Sox fan. How innocent I was in that distant day: how little I understood the faces etched with pain, the haunted eyes, the lips that writhed in uttering “Yankees.” It did not take long to become afflicted by the same symptoms and, in my time here, certain Yankee-related events have been so traumatic that they are best designated by numerals alone: 1978 and 2003. The ALCS of 2004 (when the Red Sox came from a 0-3 game deficit to vanquish the evil ones) changed the region’s mental landscape — as, of course, did the subsequent World Championship(s). Since then, Yankee hating has become more of a pleasant pastime than a crippling mental and spiritual disorder.
Continue Reading CloseThe Marlins’ bizarre new look
The team's revamped logo involves a whimsical rainbow swoosh. The effect is anything but intimidating
So far the biggest story to come out of baseball’s early off-season isn’t some splashy free agent signing or the abrupt retirement of St. Louis Cardinals manager Tony LaRussa, but that of the logo and uniform redesign of the Florida Marlins. The new look was officially announced on Friday, and if you haven’t seen them already, you might not believe your eyes. In fact, when some of the images of the new logo were leaked there was such shock and disbelief by the baseball world, most people assumed it was a farce, calling the look everything from “Hawaiian Shaved Ice” to “Push-up Pop” to “Rainbow Bright.”
Continue Reading CloseExonerating Bill Buckner
25 years after the Red Sox infielder's infamous World Series error, we look at what really happened that October
(Credit: AP) Bill Buckner’s error in the 1986 World Series – 25 years ago today, a day of infamy for Red Sox fans — is one of the two most famous plays in World Series history. (Willie Mays’ catch in the 1954 fall classic is the other.)
Like Mays’ over-the-shoulder catch, Buckner’s booboo is entrenched in American folklore. Jimmy Fallon’s Red Sox fanatic in “Fever Pitch,” distraught over breaking up with his girlfriend, watches Buckner’s play over and over on his VCR. During congressional hearings in 2008, U.S. Rep. John Yarmuth, D-Ky., called former Treasury Secretary John Snow, then-SEC chief Christopher Cox and former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan “three Bill Buckners.” On “Curb Your Enthusiasm” this season, Larry David loses a softball game when a ball rolls between his legs; his coach screams, “You Buckner-ed me!”
Continue Reading CloseAllen Barra's next book is "Mickey and Willie -- The Parallel Lives of Baseball's Golden Age," from Crown. More Allen Barra.
What baseball tells us about racism
Most home-plate umpires are white -- and they seem to be hurting the careers of minority pitchers
Despite recent odes to “post-racial” sensibilities, persistent racial wage and unemployment gaps show that prejudice is alive and well in America. Nonetheless, that truism is often angrily denied or willfully ignored in our society, in part, because prejudice is so much more difficult to recognize on a day-to-day basis. As opposed to the Jim Crow era of white hoods and lynch mobs, 21st century American bigotry is now more often an unseen crime of the subtle and the reflexive — and the crime scene tends to be the shadowy nuances of hiring decisions, performance evaluations and plausible deniability.
Continue Reading Close
David Sirota is a best-selling author of the new book "Back to Our Future: How the 1980s Explain the World We Live In Now." He hosts the morning show on AM760 in Colorado. E-mail him at ds@davidsirota.com, follow him on Twitter @davidsirota or visit his website at www.davidsirota.com. More David Sirota.
Page 1 of 81 in Baseball





