salon.com

     Powered by Yahoo!

Site Presented By

  • Home
  • Excerpt
  • Author events
  • Reviews & Comments
  • Contact
  • Buy the book
  • Blog
  • |
  • Log in
Font S / S+ / S++
Wednesday May 2, 2007 16:51 EST

The Kennedy legacy vs. the Bush legacy

The two most noxious myths these days about the presidency of John Fitzgerald Kennedy are: 1) JFK was a distracted playboy who accomplished nothing significant in his brief 1,000 days in office, and 2) He was a militant Cold Warrior who was willing to risk nuclear war to keep our Communist foes in their place. Saber-rattling neocons and chest-thumping Democrats are particularly fond of this bellicose image of Kennedy. But my new book, "Brothers" -- which I call a "hidden history of the Kennedy years" -- proposes a very different version of JFK's brief reign.

I portray a president who heroically kept the country out of war -- against relentless pressure from hard-liners in the Pentagon, CIA and his own White House, who were determined to militarily engage the enemy in Berlin, Laos, Vietnam and especially Cuba. Kennedy knew that any such military confrontation could quickly escalate into a nuclear war with the Soviet Union. And he realized that a full-scale invasion of Cuba or Vietnam could become hopelessly bogged down, turning into a bloody and endless occupation.

In fact, even the CIA's own analysts predicted such a nightmarish scenario if Kennedy listened to his intelligence officials and military commanders and invaded Cuba. A National Intelligence Estimate produced in April 1962 predicted that while U.S. military forces would quickly sweep aside Castro's army and take Havana, American soldiers would soon come under fire from the remnants of Fidel's military, as they melted into the countryside and became nettlesome insurgents. U.S. forces would respond to the inevitable terrorist attacks with their own excessive violence, turning the Cuban people increasingly against the U.S. occupation. Meanwhile, America's image would suffer badly around the world as a result of our blundering, unilateral military action. Sound familiar?

The only reason Cuba didn't become the Iraq of its day was that Kennedy was too wise to be snookered by hard-liners into this trap. He had already been misled early in his administration by the CIA, which convinced him that its ragtag army of Cuban exiles could defeat Castro at the Bay of Pigs. JFK vowed that he would never again listen to these so-called national security experts, and following the fiasco, he even threatened to "shatter the CIA into a thousand pieces and scatter it to the winds." The president didn't go that far, but he did fire the CIA's top two officials -- including legendary spymaster Allen Dulles, who was stunned by Kennedy's presumption that the democratically elected president of the United States should run the country's foreign policy, instead of Washington's shadowy national security elite.

Imagine having a president who was not only farsighted enough to recognize the dangers of imperial folly, but who had the fortitude to stand up to the frothing war lobby that seems to call for blood -- others' blood, never their own -- in every administration. "He kept the peace." That's what John F. Kennedy often said he wanted as his epitaph. And it should be. "I think [Kennedy's] view was that the primary responsibility of the president is to keep the nation out of war if at all possible," Robert McNamara, JFK's defense secretary, has commented. McNamara himself would go down in history with a very different legacy. But Kennedy kept true to his peaceful vision until his own violent death.

-- David Talbot
Print Email Digg it Del.icio.us
Permalink
Read comments (5)

Currently in David Talbot's blog

It's about Time
The media reevaluates JFK
The CIA reveals its family jewels
But the agency is still up to its old tricks -- including spreading lies about the Kennedys
Chris Matthews gets it wrong -- again
From the Kennedy assassination to the Clinton impeachment to the Bush war, the Washington media elite has been consistently boneheaded
For more information
If you're looking for sane and intelligent online oases to explore the JFK case, check out these two sites
Bugliosi vs. "Brothers"
The attorney's massive new tome gets Bobby Kennedy wrong
People's choice
Vox populi is music to my ears

Authors

David Talbot

Hailed as a "pioneer of online journalism" by the New York Times, David Talbot is the founder and former editor in chief of Salon. He has worked as a senior editor for Mother Jones magazine and as a features editor for the San Francisco Examiner. Talbot has written for the New Yorker, Rolling Stone and other publications. He lives with his family in San Francisco.

A note from the author: "I was a 16-year-old campaign volunteer for Robert Kennedy the night he was shot down in Los Angeles. It struck me then that his murder, following those of his brother and Martin Luther King Jr., had irreparably wounded America. And this feeling has never left me in all the years that have followed. For me, aggressively pursuing the hidden history of the Kennedy years was an attempt to find out where my country had lost its way, and perhaps to restore the hope and faith that I myself had lost as a young American growing up in the 1960s."

  • In Salon: The exclusive story of Robert F. Kennedy's secret search for the truth about John F. Kennedy's assassination
    By David Talbot
  • Book excerpt

Article Finder

  • Search: All articles
  • By Topic: Salon Directory
  • By Date: All articles

Daily Newsletter

Salon in your mailbox!

  • Salon
  • About Salon
  • Contact & Help
  • Corrections
  • Advertise in Salon
  • Salon Personals
  • Salon Jobs
  • Salon Mobile
  • Salon Newsletter
  • RSS Feeds
  • Salon Premium:
  • Premium log in
  • What is Salon Premium?
  • A & E
  • Books
  • Comics
  • Community: Table Talk & The WELL
  • Life
  • News & Politics
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Tech & Business
  • Letters
  • Investor Relations
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service

Copyright ©2009 Salon Media Group, Inc. Reproduction of material from any Salon pages without written permission is strictly prohibited. SALON® is registered in the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office as a trademark of Salon Media Group Inc.