Navigation Salon Salon Books email print
Arts & Entertainment
.Books
Comics
Health & Body
Media
Mothers Who Think
News
People
Politics2000
Technology
- Free Software Project
Travel & Food
_______
Columnists

 

Current
Wire Stories

Click here to read the latest stories from the wires.

- - - - - - - - - - - -

- - - - - - - - - - - -

Also Today

For a full list of today's Salon Books stories, go to the Books home page.

- - - - - - - - - - - -

Search Salon


  
Advanced Search  |  Help

- - - - - - - - - - - -

Recently in Salon Books

Reviews
"Sleeping With Extra-Terrestrials" by Wendy Kaminer
American boobs will believe practically anything. But is this news?

By Andrew O'Hehir
[11/17/99]

Ivory Tower
On closer reading
At the fifth annual conference of the Association of Literary Scholars and Critics, the old guard looks for the the Young Turks to take up their bookish battle cry.

By Boris Kachka
[11/17/99]


I wrote a novel in three days
A guy, his best pal and a bottle of tequila. It was a recipe for literary greatness.

By Dave Fox
[11/16/99]

Interview
Love in a cage
Irish novelist Ronan Bennett talks about his years in a British prison and the difficulty of combining romance with politics.

By David Bowman
[11/16/99]

Reviews
"Breakfast With Scot" by Michael Downing
In a smart, funny and affecting novel, two gay men inherit an 11-year-old boy and blanch when he turns out to be a budding queen.

By Greg Bottoms
[11/16/99]

Complete archives for Books

- - - - - - - - - - - -

- - - - - - - - - - - -




Poetry nation? | page 1, 2

There are the requisite celebrity picks, but only two of them -- Laurie Anderson and the real Patch Adams, who chose poems by George Herbert and Walt Whitman, respectively. It's much to Pinsky and Dietz's credit that they steered clear of politicians and other big names. There is also a smattering of children, and their entries and explanations prove to be among the most charming and affecting in the book. After all, how could an anthology like this be complete without "Casey at the Bat," accompanied by this word of wisdom from an 11-year-old boy in Atlanta: "I play in Little League and I see this happen all the time." Or this comment, from an 11-year-old girl, about Shakespeare's "Shall I Compare Thee to a Summer's Day": "I could see a handsome young man reciting this poem to his true love, hoping that she would fall in love with him or go out on a date."

A cheering number of people with titles like "farmer" and "cashier" and "homemaker" do appear, people who have no obvious reason to be all that interested in poetry. There's even a handyman from North Carolina who loves the Prologue to "The Canterbury Tales" (though there's perhaps some explanation in the fact that he's also a "Zen teacher," which he describes as an extension of his career in "fixing things").



Americans' Favorite Poems

Edited by Robert Pinsky and Maggie Dietz

W.W. Norton & Company, 288 pages
Poetry

Buy this book at B&N.com


But in the midst of all the carefully assembled populism, there is a telling moment. It comes in an entry by a construction worker in Boston, who sent in a selection from Walt Whitman's "Song of Myself" with this account: "In 1994 I began attending the University of Massachusetts as an English major. This was looked upon by many of my coworkers as nothing less than ridiculous. I guess a ditchdigger who reads Shakespeare is still just a ditchdigger."

Which raises an interesting question: While it's inspiring and true that there are working-class people out there going back to school and learning to love poetry (the Boston construction worker goes on to say how poetry has helped him and fueled his self-esteem), how strong is the tide that pulls against them? I can't help feeling that for every person like this guy, or, for that matter, for every white-collar guy who is equally driven to discover poetry in his off-hours, there are at least 50 others who think they're absolutely nuts -- who look blank when poetry is mentioned and dismiss the whole enterprise by saying "I don't understand poetry."

As much as I'd like to believe that we're in some kind of poetry renaissance in the U.S. of A., I have a hard time doing it. Sales of poetry books haven't increased. The NEA grants money to poets only every other year now, instead of every year. Despite all the M.F.A.s, solid teaching jobs are scarce, and publishing houses, which have to worry about costs more than ever, aren't rushing to build up their poetry lists. If people are reading Merrill on the subway -- which they very well may be doing -- they're probably not going out to buy his collected works and sitting down with it after dinner.

In an odd way, Pinsky seems to know the limits of his endeavor. As he comments on what he calls the "double nature" of poetry, the way it's an intimate art comprised of the most public of all mediums, language, he says that "in a different country -- say, one where great national poets were shared as part of patriotic feeling, or where there was social prestige in knowing lines by heart -- this duality of poetic feeling might be less poignantly distinct." Yes -- in a different country. But in this one it often seems to receive a lot of fanfare with little substance to back it up.

Then again, maybe that's precisely what separates poetry from other genres -- its mysterious, persistent existence in an ever-modernizing world. Who knows how many poetry-loving people out there didn't even write in to the Favorite Poem Project because they wanted to keep their secret to themselves?

In his poem "The Great Poet Returns," Mark Strand writes, "Tell me, you people out there, what is poetry anyway?/Can anyone die without even a little?" Whether or not the Favorite Poem Project proves it, somehow I still believe, still have to believe, that the answer is no.
salon.com | Nov. 17, 1999

 

- - - - - - - - - - - -

About the writer
Melanie Rehak is a poet and critic.

Table Talk
Read poets society Who, what and why do you read?

Sound off
Send us a Letter to the Editor

Send e-mail to Melanie Rehak

- - - - - - - - - - - -

Print this story  Get a printer-friendly version

Email this story  E-mail a friend about this article

Backflip This Story  Backflip this article to find it again

- - - - - - - - - - - -

Search Salon


  
Advanced Search  |  Help

 

Salon | Search | Archives | Contact Us | Table Talk | Ad Info

Arts & Entertainment | Books | Comics | Life | News | People
Politics | Sex | Tech & Business | Audio
The Free Software Project | The Movie Page
Letters | Columnists | Salon Plus

Copyright © 2000 Salon.com All rights reserved.