Updated: Today
Topic:

Apple

The problems with iTunes Plus

Apple offers higher-quality, DRM-free music. What's the catch?

iTunesLast week Apple launched iTunes Plus, which allows users to purchase DRM-free tracks, meaning songs can be copied to your heart's content, uploaded onto multiple iPods, made to dance a jig, whatever. Additionally, iTunes Plus downloads come encoded at a bit rate of 256 kbps as opposed to the standard 128 kbps, resulting in improved sound quality. Pretty good, right?

Not so much. The problem isn't that iTunes Plus is more expensive ($1.29 per track as opposed to the standard 99 cents), but any track you purchase in the new format is instantly watermarked with your username and e-mail address. Over on the Wired Web site, intellectual property attorney Fred von Lohmann explained the ramifications: "There's absolutely no reason [personal information] had to be embedded, unencrypted and in the clear," he said. "Some of the privacy problems, in light of this, is that anyone who steals an iPod that includes purchased iTunes music will now have the name and e-mail address of its rightful owner."

Maybe the possibility of your iPod being stolen, the thief putting your music on a file-sharing site and then finding you've been sued by the RIAA for illegal file-sharing because your name was attached to a digital file doesn't bother you. Fair enough. But try to handle this bit of buzz kill: The sound quality upgrade offered by iTunes Plus is barely noticeable. Don't just take the experts' word for it, though, take mine too. I conducted my own listening test -- comparing the 128kbps and 256kbps versions of Jethro Tull's "Witch's Promise." Playing these songs more than 20 times back-to-back revealed a difference so minimal it might have been imagined.

Is access to DRM-free files and (maybe, possibly) better sound quality worth the privacy issue and added cost? I'm leaning toward no. But if you've had a chance to fiddle around with iTunes Plus, drop Audiofile a line and let us know what you think.

-- David Marchese

Apple Inc. in the news

Loading...

Recommended Reads

The world in the iPod
The microchip that runs Apple's popular music player is made in India, Taiwan, China and Silicon Valley. Is this an example of how globalization works to everyone's benefit -- or a sign that the world economy is about to roll over America?
By Andrew Leonard, Salon

iLove it or iHate it
Is Apple's new blue bombshell a hit or a dud?
By Janelle Brown and Scott Rosenberg, Salon

An end to the Apple turnover
Steve Jobs accepts the inevitable -- and embraces the CEO title.
By Lydia Lee, Salon

Steve Jobs' iTunes dance
Now the Apple CEO says he would gladly sell songs without digital restrictions, if the record companies let him. That's hardly a brave defiance, and besides, I don't believe him.
By Cory Doctorow, Salon

Apple's iTunes sells 5 billion songs, but you don't own them
Why DRM means your music isn't really yours.
By Farhad Manjoo, Salon

Steve Jobs’ 2009 letter to the community about his health.
Terse and obfuscatory, this thing is Jobs all over.

Apple's obsession with secrecy grows stronger
Apple’s decision to limit communication with the media, shareholders and the public is at odds with the approach of other companies, which are embracing online outlets like blogs and Twitter.
By Brad Stone and Ashlee Vance, The New York Times

The Untold Story: How the iPhone blew Up the wireless industry
This 4.8-ounce sliver of glass and aluminum is an explosive device that has forever changed the mobile-phone business.
By Fred Vogelstein, Wired

A list of Steve Jobs' best quotes
An example: "The cure for Apple is not cost-cutting. The cure for Apple is to innovate its way out of its current predicament."
By Owen Linzmayer, Wired

The Secret Diary of Steve Jobs
Fake Steve Jobs tells all in this hilarious and often informative act of fraudulent auto-blography.

Currently in Salon