| Find out more | Log in | ||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Have yourself a merry little Festivus | 1, 2 Still, that's no excuse for the embarrassing performance of many of the women who do make it into the hot seat. Unlike the gutsier male players, women play the game too cautiously, blowing their lifelines on answers they think they know but, oh gee, they're not 110 percent sure they know. Or they crap out on the baby questions because they've been living in a cave for their whole frickin' lives! Take the contestant who had to use a lifeline on the $200 question "Buddy, can you spare a (blank)?" And then she stared at the $300 question ("Where would you find a tome?") for hours -- until she answered "hardware store." There's no excuse for that, no excuse at all. We just suck.
David E. Kelley's school daze. Having created "Ally McBeal," a show about a workplace that's basically an extension of high school, Kelley must have felt uniquely qualified to do a series that was actually set in a high school. But what's suitable for "Ally," a surreal, comic fantasia of adults acting on impulse, is staggeringly inappropriate for "Boston Public," a surreal, comic fantasia of teenagers acting on impulse and the teachers who hate them for it. "Boston Public" is high school from the perspective of a staff under siege. The kids are portrayed as thugs, Lolitas or packs of wild animals. The adults grouse about not being able to take disciplinary action because the students have "rights." Comic relief is chiefly provided by buffoonish teachers Milton Buttle (Joey Slotnick) and Harvey Lipschultz (Fyvush Finkel) -- their names say it all. To deflect potential criticism from teachers unions for portraying public school educators as hapless burnouts, Kelley gives us decent, no-nonsense principal Steven Harper (Chi McBride) and idealistic, caring history teacher Lauren Davis (Jessalyn Gilsig), and has them poignantly commiserate with each other about how undervalued they are by society. But Kelley isn't fooling anybody. "Boston Public" has something to offend everyone who ever went to public high school (hmm, I wonder if Kelley did?) or taught public high school. First of all, someone should remind Kelley that Boston doesn't really need the old wounds of forced busing reopened by having bow-tied octogenarian Lipschultz deride black students as "de-segs." Someone should also remind Kelley that a teacher who brings a gun to class and fires three rounds to scare the students into behaving, as teacher Harry Senate (Nicky Katt) did in the pilot episode (a scene that fell flat as both satire and commentary), would be arrested faster than you can say "Columbine." But perhaps I'm nitpicking. The bigger issue is that "Boston Public" paints the worst possible picture of public education. It's a mean-spirited, humiliating show; its glib, sensationalistic moments negate the impact of the "inspiring" bones Kelley throws to teachers. "The monster we battle every day is disrespect," Lauren observed in one episode, and how Kelley had the chutzpah to even write that line is beyond me. Raining on my parade. NBC's broadcast of the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade was not a parade. Where I come from, a parade consists of people marching. There was no actual marching during NBC's coverage. There was no footage of legs moving up and down or trombone slides going in and out. I'm sure there was some real parading going on in New York -- otherwise, how would all those bands and floats and balloons have gotten from 77th Street to Seventh Avenue? During the hour and a half that I watched NBC's taped West Coast coverage, I saw a lot of scenes from Broadway musicals (note to self: must avoid "Seussical" at all cost), a lot of teen-pop idols and country singers lip-syncing songs and Al Roker doing sideline interviews with NBC stars. But I could discern only the faintest glimpse of forward motion behind Katie Couric and Matt Lauer in the broadcast booth, and only the underbellies of the balloons whenever Roker was kind enough to move his enormous head out of the way. This was a depressing comedown from the Thanksgiving parade telecasts of my childhood, in which the cameras stayed on the marchers and off the faces of the TV hosts. But there you have it -- another holiday ruined by corporate greed and commercialism. Long live Festivus! Listen up, readers: Mister Rogers is not dead. He was not a CIA killing machine during the Korean War. He does not have military tattoos up and down his arms that he hides by wearing cardigan sweaters. Those are all urban legends, just like the ones about the rat in the bucket of Kentucky Fried Chicken and the poodle in the microwave. So, for cryin' out loud, please stop sending me e-mails asking me if this crap is true! To recap: Mister Rogers. Alive. Not dead. Now, who's up for some feats of strength? salon.com - - - - - - - - - - - -
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Now playing: Read all the recent movie reviews by Salon's critics | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Arts & Entertainment | Books | Comics | Mothers Who Think | News
People | Politics | Sex | Tech & Business and The Free Software Project
Letters | Columnists | Salon Plus | Salon Shop
Reproduction of material from any Salon pages without written permission is strictly prohibited
Copyright 2005 Salon.com