Broadsheet

Face transplants — just for the ladies?

A couple of weeks ago, a French woman’s face transplant sparked all kinds of controversy over the safety, ethics and implications of the procedure. Thursday’s New York Times joined the debate with some public-opinion reporting from, of all places, a Manhattan nail salon, where two female customers argued over whether it would be OK to buy Angelina Jolie’s face and have it grafted to your own. Gack.

Granted, the issues involved are interesting: What does wearing a dead person’s face mean for your identity? Would it be unbearably sad for the family of the deceased if they encountered his or her face on another person in Barnes & Noble? Is it better if face transplants are performed only in medically necessary cirumstances, like on burn victims or on people with birth defects, or should people be able to have elective transplant surgery for cosmetic reasons?

But also, New York Times, why is this a women’s issue? Why interview the ladies at the nail salon and not the muscleheads at the gym, too? Why compare getting a face transplant to “buying a $1,000 Gucci bag”?

Sure, women get more elective plastic surgery than men. But times are changing; men get nose jobs and and hair plugs and calf implants. If physique-focused mags like Men’s Health are still in business, there must be men out there who are willing to pay for the privilege of being told their abs need work.

But maybe I’m being ridiculous. Readers, join the controversy! First off, if it were possible to get a face transplant for purely cosmetic purposes, would that be a decent use of a donated cadaver?

And, if the process became widely available, do you think any dudes would sign up?

Can a girl sexually abuse herself?
A 15-year-old faces child porn charges after distributing naked self-portraits.
Hillary Duff doesn’t think you’re totally gay
In a new PSA, the pop tart schools a few teen girls on the poison of that ubiquitous slang, “It’s so gay.”
Which Gossip Girl is most like Obama?
Glossy magazines for teen girls are slipping in politics along with the lip gloss.
Saving hookers with high fashion?
A Dutch town has decided to help prostitutes off the streets, one makeover at a time.

Recent Posts

Hillary Duff doesn’t think you’re totally gay
In a new PSA, the pop tart schools a few teen girls on the poison of that ubiquitous slang, “It’s so gay.”
Which Gossip Girl is most like Obama?
Glossy magazines for teen girls are slipping in politics along with the lip gloss.
Saving hookers with high fashion?
A Dutch town has decided to help prostitutes off the streets, one makeover at a time.

Full Archive

RSS Feed

Posts by date

October 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031

Tips or Comments?

E-mail us at broadsheet@salon.com.