Broadsheet

Court sends abortion law back for repairs

Enjoy this while it lasts: The Supreme Court has ruled that abortion laws must protect women's health and safety.

At least that's the way that abortion advocates are gamely trying to spin today's fuzzy ruling. Wednesday, in a unanimous decision penned by, sigh, Sandra Day O'Connor, the court said that (as the New York Times put it) "lower courts were wrong to declare a New Hampshire abortion law unconstitutional in its entirety" and that they should instead "look for a less drastic way to repair the statute's flaws." The case in question is Ayotte v. Planned Parenthood, and at issue -- among other things -- is the lack of a health exception to a parental notification requirement.

By sending the law back for repairs, the court avoided revisiting or affirming precedent. (Yeah, best to wait 'til O'Connor's out of the picture.)

The court's action is -- in part -- a victory for the Bush administration, who had argued on behalf of New Hampshire's attorney general that, as the court ultimately decided, the lack of a health exception doesn't mean you have to throw the unborn out with the bathwater.

But abortion-rights advocates do see a significant silver lining in the court's decision. In a joint Planned Parenthood/ACLU press release, Jennifer Dalven, deputy director of the ACLU's Reproductive Freedom Project and the attorney who argued the case, said, "Today's decision tells politicians that they cannot jeopardize women's health when they pass abortion laws."

News flash: Masculinity is about more than sex
A study suggests that stereotypes about men's view of masculinity are wrong.
Quote of the day
Sen. Barbara Boxer on Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin.
What's that smell?
Scented candles for men will bring the fragrance of urinal cakes into your home at last.
Should Obama have picked Hillary?
Did the GOP just co-opt the Democrats' chance at making history? Sarah Palin, a conservative, antiabortion, pro-NRA Republican may just be the first woman in the White House.

Recent Posts

Quote of the day
Sen. Barbara Boxer on Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin.
What's that smell?
Scented candles for men will bring the fragrance of urinal cakes into your home at last.
Should Obama have picked Hillary?
Did the GOP just co-opt the Democrats' chance at making history? Sarah Palin, a conservative, antiabortion, pro-NRA Republican may just be the first woman in the White House.

Full Archive

RSS Feed

Posts by date

August 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31

Tips or Comments?

E-mail us at broadsheet@salon.com.