Broadsheet

Shocker! "Boy crisis" in education is overblown!

Don't you just love it when a long-term, large-scale study debunks a myth that has been promulgated by the media? Me too! That's why I was happy to see an article in today's Washington Post about a new study that seems to largely refute the so-called boy crisis in education.

"Using data compiled from the National Assessment of Educational Progress, a federally funded accounting of student achievement since 1971, the Washington-based think tank Education Sector found that, over the past three decades, boys' test scores are mostly up, more boys are going to college and more are getting bachelor's degrees," the Post reports.

Repeat after me. Despite what you've read in Newsweek and jillions of other publications, test scores are up, more boys are going to college and more boys are getting bachelor's degrees. Sounds like a crisis to me! The studies' authors conclude that the hysteria about boys and education has been fomented by "inadequate research, sloppy analysis and discomfort with the fact that although the average boy is doing better, the average girl has gotten ahead of him." Yes folks, it seems that the media decided that if girls were doing better, then boys must be in big, big trouble.

The report doesn't just fault the media for fanning the flames of controversy, however. It also calls out conservatives who blamed the crisis on feminists who they claimed focused on female students at the expense of males and liberals who say schools are "forcing all children into a teacher-led pedagogical box that is particularly ill-suited to boys' interests and learning styles."

But before we all breathe a sigh of relief and chalk up the "boy crisis" to an irresponsible media and various ideologues, it's important to note that the news in the report wasn't all good. Boys from low-income homes, particularly those who are black and Hispanic, are in crisis -- they test far below white boys. But "the predominant issues for them are race and class, not gender," wrote Education Sector senior policy analyst Sara Mead in the report. The Post also quotes some skeptics who don't think the gender gap in education has been overblown entirely. One educational consultant notes that there is still a huge disparity in writing skills between girls and boys, among other worrisome trends.

Still, let's agree to retire the phrase "boy crisis." For accuracy's sake.

News flash: Masculinity is about more than sex
A study suggests that stereotypes about men's view of masculinity are wrong.
Quote of the day
Sen. Barbara Boxer on Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin.
What's that smell?
Scented candles for men will bring the fragrance of urinal cakes into your home at last.
Should Obama have picked Hillary?
Did the GOP just co-opt the Democrats' chance at making history? Sarah Palin, a conservative, antiabortion, pro-NRA Republican may just be the first woman in the White House.

Recent Posts

Quote of the day
Sen. Barbara Boxer on Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin.
What's that smell?
Scented candles for men will bring the fragrance of urinal cakes into your home at last.
Should Obama have picked Hillary?
Did the GOP just co-opt the Democrats' chance at making history? Sarah Palin, a conservative, antiabortion, pro-NRA Republican may just be the first woman in the White House.

Full Archive

RSS Feed

Posts by date

August 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31

Tips or Comments?

E-mail us at broadsheet@salon.com.