Broadsheet

The question of self-defense in domestic violence

Here's a question: If your husband domestically abuses you, should you be pardoned for killing him? That was the issue at hand on Monday when Gov. Ernie Fletcher granted "clemency, pardons or early parole reviews" to 21 women in Kentucky who were convicted of killing or trying to kill men who they say abused them, according to Louisville's Courier-Journal."

The women's main argument wasn't that they were innocent but, rather, that the legal system didn't take into account the situations that led to their crimes -- situations that ranged, according to the article, from a vague "string of abuses and neglect allegations" by one of the women's fathers to an ex-husband who allegedly had a 20-year history of hitting his wife in the face with a baseball bat, stabbing her with a knife, beating her kids and choking her till she passed out -- and who raped her a week before she ended up shooting and killing him.

That sounds horrible -- as do the crimes committed by the victims themselves, one of whom threw gasoline on her abusive husband and lighted him on fire, killing him. But I think the real question to deal with is what we can do to prevent such situations from occurring in the first place. It's hard to assert that someone who has been raped, stabbed and beaten doesn't have a legitimate reason to want to escape from her or his abuser. But what does it say about the recourses available to victims of domestic abuse that these women felt that they had no choice but to kill their abusers?

With that in mind, here a few links to organizations that are trying to help stop the cycle of violence and abuse before it ends in murder or manslaughter. Feel free to add other suggestions in your comments:

AARDVARC: An Abuse, Rape and Domestic Violence Aid and Resource Collection.

Domestic Violence Notepad: A collection of Internet resources for the victims of domestic violence. (Warning -- several of the links no longer work.)

dmoz.org: An open directory project with resources for victims of domestic violence.

Posted in: Catherine Price

News flash: Masculinity is about more than sex
A study suggests that stereotypes about men's view of masculinity are wrong.
Quote of the day
Sen. Barbara Boxer on Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin.
What's that smell?
Scented candles for men will bring the fragrance of urinal cakes into your home at last.
Should Obama have picked Hillary?
Did the GOP just co-opt the Democrats' chance at making history? Sarah Palin, a conservative, antiabortion, pro-NRA Republican may just be the first woman in the White House.

Recent Posts

Quote of the day
Sen. Barbara Boxer on Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin.
What's that smell?
Scented candles for men will bring the fragrance of urinal cakes into your home at last.
Should Obama have picked Hillary?
Did the GOP just co-opt the Democrats' chance at making history? Sarah Palin, a conservative, antiabortion, pro-NRA Republican may just be the first woman in the White House.

Full Archive

RSS Feed

Posts by date

August 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31

Tips or Comments?

E-mail us at broadsheet@salon.com.