Editor: Mark Schone
Updated: Today
Topic:

2008 Elections

Congress hobbled on gag rule

Lacking the votes to override a Bush veto, lawmakers gut bill that could have weakened the deadly "Mexico City policy."

Amie Newman at RH Reality Check has the latest on the fate of the global gag rule -- and it doesn't look good. For women, that is. The gag rule (also known more delicately as the "Mexico City policy"), for which we have Ronald Reagan to thank, allows U.S. aid to international family planning agencies only if they restrict their services and abide by "free speech limits that would never hold up under the United States Constitution." Not only can they not provide smashmortion; they can't even discuss it. As Planned Parenthood explains it: "Overseas family planning agencies thus have to choose between accepting U.S. money, which is often their main source of support, or offering their clients comprehensive -- and potentially life-saving -- reproductive health services and information." Expert witnesses at a recent hearing before the House Committee on Foreign Affairs -- the first hearing of its kind in a decade -- pulled no punches about the consequences of the policy: "Women are dying because the U.S. Global Gag Rule is preventing them from getting the reproductive health care and supplies they desperately need to prevent unwanted pregnancies." According to this article in Sunday's Washington Post, which will have you tearing your hair out in fistfuls and then curling up into a ball to weep, children are also born with a death sentence -- or at least the very real prospect of becoming orphans -- to HIV-infected mothers who lost access to birth control when local clinics lost funding. (Said clinics didn't even provide abortions, which, as if things weren't crappy enough, are illegal in Kenya. But other subsidiaries of their London-based parent organization do, in other countries. That's good enough for the gag rule!)

Anyway. The above-mentioned hearing had raised hopes; Dems had shoehorned language into an omnibus spending bill that would invalidate or weaken the policy, or at least provide for a "contraception exemption." But when it came time over the weekend to veto-proof the bill, poof! The language was outta there. The bill passed Monday in the House, leaving the gag rule intact. The Senate is expected to follow suit.

On the upside, Newman notes, the bill nullified (for a year, anyway) the mandate that at least one-third of U.S. HIV prevention funds be used solely for abstinence-only programs. It also increases HIV prevention and family planning funds, though they're still not considered sufficient.

Sen. Hillary Clinton has vowed to, like the Clinton before her, repeal the gag rule as soon as she gets the opportunity. Let's hope she and the other candidates keep talking about what too many family planning clinics can't.

2008 Elections in the news

Loading...

Currently in Salon

  • The Stupak-Pitts amendment is a devastating setback for women's rights. Are we ready to fight yet?
  • So the former Miss USA contestant has one. Big whoop. Remember when those videos used to actually mean something?
  • Why the hopeless story of a ghetto teen is just the kind of movie black people need right now
  • The fall of the Berlin Wall, 9/11 and the collapse of Lehman Brothers: Each ushered in a new American era
  • Rammstein's album is being censored for depicting violence against women. It's also the No. 2 record in Europe
  • This just in from the Institute for the Advancement of Conservative Science: History began on 1/20/09!
  • Ever since we moved in, we've been at each other. What happened?
  • The Democrats' lust to win at any cost stripped abortion from the healthcare bill. Can pro-choicers put it back?
  • Don Draper and the denizens of Sterling Cooper take drastic measures in the face of a brave new world
  • Inside the elaborate, disturbing and downright riveting world of child-beauty pageants