Broadsheet

Losing her religion

Here's a weird one: About three years ago, a Continental Airlines flight attendant named Sharon Brown accused Victoria Osteen, wife and co-pastor of uber-preacher Joel Osteen, of assault. The incident, for which the Federal Aviation Administration has already fined Osteen $3,000, took place prior to a flight from Houston to Vail, Colo. Apparently, the scuffle was over a stain on Osteen's first-class seat and involved some boob-elbowing (ouch!).

Televangelist Joel Osteen's wife sued for anxiety, hemorrhoids and shaken faith.

Now, I like a good televangelist takedown as much as the next girl, but what actually interests me about the ensuing lawsuit are the claims Brown is making. The suit alleges that the run-in with Osteen caused Brown anxiety, hemorrhoids ... and loss of faith. Personally, I was lost at hemorrhoids. I understand they can be stress-related, but is there any way to prove that an encounter with an irate passenger caused a flight attendant to develop a literal pain in the ass?

More important, is it fair to charge Osteen with affecting Brown's faith? I'm not a religious person by any stretch of the imagination, but it seems to me that it should take more than a bum experience with the wife of a preacherman to shake a true believer. It can be disillusioning, I'm sure, to learn that an admired clergy member isn't above airplane fisticuffs, but come on. If Victoria Osteen's bad behavior drives you to a crisis of faith, you were probably heading for one sooner or later.

The legal implications of the Osteen case worry me a bit, too. We all know that you can sue someone for "emotional damages," but can we expect to see "loss of faith" cited in future suits? A law student friend assured me the "loss of faith" angle wouldn't stick unless accompanied by a nasty tort like assault, but still -- is it ever legitimate to hold someone else liable for your own religious doubts? And who's to say that loss of faith is necessarily a bad thing, anyway?

Posted in: Role models

News flash: Masculinity is about more than sex
A study suggests that stereotypes about men's view of masculinity are wrong.
Quote of the day
Sen. Barbara Boxer on Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin.
What's that smell?
Scented candles for men will bring the fragrance of urinal cakes into your home at last.
Should Obama have picked Hillary?
Did the GOP just co-opt the Democrats' chance at making history? Sarah Palin, a conservative, antiabortion, pro-NRA Republican may just be the first woman in the White House.

Recent Posts

Quote of the day
Sen. Barbara Boxer on Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin.
What's that smell?
Scented candles for men will bring the fragrance of urinal cakes into your home at last.
Should Obama have picked Hillary?
Did the GOP just co-opt the Democrats' chance at making history? Sarah Palin, a conservative, antiabortion, pro-NRA Republican may just be the first woman in the White House.

Full Archive

RSS Feed

Posts by date

August 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31

Tips or Comments?

E-mail us at broadsheet@salon.com.