Broadsheet

Where are all the female conductors?

A female winner of a BBC conducting competition highlights the lack of women on the podium.

Last week, comic Sue Perkins was declared the winner of the BBC's "Maestro" reality show, in which famous amateurs competed for the chance to conduct the BBC concert orchestra for a day. Though the competition bore a closer resemblance to "Dancing With the Stars" than actual hiring practices in the classical music world, Perkins' win did highlight an issue with the latter: Despite women's advances in other artistic disciplines, female conductors are still incredibly rare. A year ago, Marin Alsop became the first female music director of a major U.S. orchestra, and Ewa Strusinska became the first female assistant conductor in the U.K. earlier this year. Meanwhile, "all of the principal conductors of the London, Royal and BBC Philharmonic orchestras are men and there is a distinct lack of female baton-wielding super stars."

Everyone interviewed for the BBC article, including Alsop herself, seems to want to put a positive spin on things: Yes, the sexism has been awful in the past, but things are improving! It's just taking a while! Cultural commentator Norman Lebrecht points out that "25 years ago there were no female presenters on the news either," and Natalia Luis-Bassa, principal conductor of the Huddersfield Philharmonic Orchestra, speculates that "in 10 to 15 years things will even out." Given that most conductors don't hit their stride until late middle age, it is understandable that few women have reached their full potential on the podium yet. Only 30-odd years ago, New York Philharmonic manager Helen Thompson was saying things like, "Women can't conduct Brahms, and Mahler is men's music." Still, it's likely to take more than a couple of token appointments and a female reality-show winner to effect real change. As Lebrecht notes, sexism in the industry "is a function of society and not of music."

Feminism in the news

Loading...

Currently in Salon

  • The Democrats' lust to win at any cost stripped abortion from the healthcare bill. Can pro-choicers put it back?
  • Why the hopeless story of a ghetto teen is just the kind of movie black people need right now
  • The fall of the Berlin Wall, 9/11 and the collapse of Lehman Brothers: Each ushered in a new American era
  • Don Draper and the denizens of Sterling Cooper take drastic measures in the face of a brave new world
  • Inside the elaborate, disturbing and downright riveting world of child-beauty pageants
  • This just in from the Institute for the Advancement of Conservative Science: History began on 1/20/09!
  • The untold story of Johnny Cash, protest singer and Native American activist, and his feud with the music industry
  • A memoirist searches for the truth about a fatal shooting in 1960s Phoenix
  • My partner says he's just not attracted to me "right now"
  • The aftermath of Wall Street's meltdown reminds me of the aftermath of the Berlin Wall's fall. Not in a good way