Broadsheet

Did you just call me a zygote?

A few months ago, when I wrote about a proposed ballot initiative in Colorado that would define a fertilized egg as a person, I was hoping that I'd been fooled by an Onion headline.

But alas, it's true. Proposed Amendment 48 (PDF), which will indeed be on the ballot in November, is described as an amendment to change the definition of the term "person" to "include any human being from the moment of fertilization as 'person' is used in those provisions of the Colorado constitution relating to inalienable rights, equality of justice, and due process of law."

Yikes. I usually try to see both sides of things -- and while I do understand how people could consider abortion murder (even if I don't agree with them), I've got to say, this one crosses the line. I already enunciated a lot of my objections in my previous post, but this editorial by Gail Schoettler in the Denver Post lays down a few more.

What about cancer treatments, Schoettler asks, which can kill a fetus -- could a woman on chemotherapy be considered a murderer? Or how about birth control or in vitro fertilization (which can waste fertilized eggs)? Stem cell research? Could a fetus have property rights?

"The proposal says a handful of cells is just as important as the woman whose egg might have been fertilized," Schoettler writes. "Is it just as important as a mom with three kids to take care of? Should it be given the same rights as a woman who has dedicated her life to teaching or medicine or community service?"

I like to think that women who don't have three kids and haven't devoted their lives to community service still have at least the same importance as their unborn children, but I suppose that's a small point to quibble with. The bottom line -- which is laid out thoughtfully and convincingly in this article (PDF) -- is that Amendment 48 is creepy as hell. I hope that Colorado's citizens have the sense not to pass it.

Posted in: Catherine Price, Reproductive rights

Shacking up, not settling down
Horrors! Young couples are moving in together without plans for marriage
Slipped through the cracks
Roundup: Is porn ditching narrative? Plus romance novels, eating placenta and more
Pope tries to school Obama on abortion
The two meet for the first time in Vatican City and get straight to business
A slap in the face to fat girls
Beth Ditto may be a hip plus-size icon, but her new clothing line feels like an insulting throwback to a 1985 Kmart

Recent Posts

Slipped through the cracks
Roundup: Is porn ditching narrative? Plus romance novels, eating placenta and more
Pope tries to school Obama on abortion
The two meet for the first time in Vatican City and get straight to business
A slap in the face to fat girls
Beth Ditto may be a hip plus-size icon, but her new clothing line feels like an insulting throwback to a 1985 Kmart

Full Archive

RSS Feed

Posts by date

July 2009
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031

Tips or Comments?

E-mail us at broadsheet@salon.com.