Salon Newsreal | What we really can't forgive Clinton for: He got caught

T A B L E+T A L K
Is there a best way to die? Discuss how you'd like to shuffle off this mortal coil in the Science and Health area of Table Talk

D A I L Y+Q U O T E
Put some clothes on!

R E C E N T L Y
Field of pills
By Tom McNichol
Have steroids, will homer
(09/03/98)
America rides out the shock waves
By Jonathan Broder
Yale finance expert David DeRosa predicts that Wall Street will withstand the globe's economic convulsions
(09/02/98)
Who lost Russia?
By Jonathan Broder
As Moscow teeters on the brink, Russian experts blame years of bad American advice
(09/01/98)
Clinton's dog days
By Charlie Varon
The New York Times gives Buddy a bone
(09/01/98)
Days of rage (cont.)
By Stephen Talbot
The filmmaker fires back at David Horowitz over his PBS documentary "1968."
(09/01/98)
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Browse the
Newsreal Archives
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

spacer

What we really can't forgive
Clinton for: He got caught

THE CLOCK IS TICKING ON HOW LONG WE CAN HANDLE THE COGNITIVE DISSONANCE BETWEEN HIS BEHAVIOR AND OUR GRANDIOSE EXPECTATIONS OF THE PRESIDENCY.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BY FRED BRANFMAN
If President Clinton ends up having to resign -- which is what I expect -- it will not be because he is an immoral or evil person, but because the American public is still not prepared, psychologically, to accept that our president is a mere mortal.
One probable, and ironic, legacy of Clinton will be that future presidents will be granted more latitude in personal sexual behavior, just as politicians can today get divorced or admit having smoked marijuana. This development will be welcome -- it's long past time for us to cease projecting our subconscious needs for a larger-than-life leader onto the fallible human beings our democratic process propels into the office of president. But for the moment, the cognitive dissonance between our little-discussed expectations of the presidency and Clinton's behavior may well lead to an Al Gore presidency within the next year. If so, the proximate cause will be Democratic leaders asking the president to step down in the face of larger-than-expected congressional losses and/or a weakening economy. But the real causes will go far deeper.
Did you ever have a nightmare where you were humiliated before everyone you knew, a nightmare in which everyone was either disgusted by or laughing at you? And do you remember how horrible you felt when you awakened? Now imagine poor Bill Clinton. He is in the middle of a living nightmare of humiliation beyond anything most of us can imagine. He is embarrassed not just before his family, friends, co-workers and everyone he knows, but the entire world -- and the entire world for all time to come, to boot. And, unlike the rest of us, he can't wake up. He will inhabit this nightmare all the rest of his days.
"Poor Bill Clinton." It is this dimension of Monicagate that is unique in the history of the presidency. We have had scoundrels, rogues, liars and people who committed great violence in the job before. But never have we had so hapless a president. "The Emperor With No Clothes" was supposed to be a fairy tale, not the literal description of a president whose private parts have actually become a subject of public discussion.
From this perspective, Clinton's mistake is not that he had sex in the Oval Office or lied. It is something far more serious: He got caught. Presidents can be forgiven anything so long as they seem powerful enough to protect us. But a president who is so weak or foolish as to get caught is something that our psyches are just not prepared for.
It is amazing how little public discussion there has been about the role the presidency plays in our psyches and lives, which is the real issue underlying the Clinton scandal. It is true, as many have suggested, that CEOs, college professors and military officers could lose their jobs for denying and then having to admit having adulterous sex with someone young enough to be their child. But for no one other than a president could this become a national obsession, dominate the media for months on end and threaten to paralyze both the executive and legislative branches of government.
Let us begin with the basics: A president is different from every other American, all 250 million of them. This has partly to do with power: The president is the only person we entrust with the authority to use nuclear weapons. That is, we voluntarily grant the president, and only the president, the right to kill us and all life on earth.
N E X T+P A G E+| The psychic power of the presidency

T A B L E+T A L K Is there a best way to die? Discuss how you'd like to shuffle off this mortal coil in the Science and Health area of Table Talk D A I L Y+Q U O T E Put some clothes on! R E C E N T L Y Field of pills By Tom McNichol Have steroids, will homer (09/03/98) America rides out the shock waves By Jonathan Broder Yale finance expert David DeRosa predicts that Wall Street will withstand the globe's economic convulsions (09/02/98) Who lost Russia? By Jonathan Broder As Moscow teeters on the brink, Russian experts blame years of bad American advice (09/01/98) Clinton's dog days By Charlie Varon The New York Times gives Buddy a bone (09/01/98) Days of rage (cont.) By Stephen Talbot The filmmaker fires back at David Horowitz over his PBS documentary "1968." (09/01/98) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Browse the Newsreal Archives - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
		What we really can't forgive Clinton for: He got caught THE CLOCK IS TICKING ON HOW LONG WE CAN HANDLE THE COGNITIVE DISSONANCE BETWEEN HIS BEHAVIOR AND OUR GRANDIOSE EXPECTATIONS OF THE PRESIDENCY. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - BY FRED BRANFMAN If President Clinton ends up having to resign -- which is what I expect -- it will not be because he is an immoral or evil person, but because the American public is still not prepared, psychologically, to accept that our president is a mere mortal. One probable, and ironic, legacy of Clinton will be that future presidents will be granted more latitude in personal sexual behavior, just as politicians can today get divorced or admit having smoked marijuana. This development will be welcome -- it's long past time for us to cease projecting our subconscious needs for a larger-than-life leader onto the fallible human beings our democratic process propels into the office of president. But for the moment, the cognitive dissonance between our little-discussed expectations of the presidency and Clinton's behavior may well lead to an Al Gore presidency within the next year. If so, the proximate cause will be Democratic leaders asking the president to step down in the face of larger-than-expected congressional losses and/or a weakening economy. But the real causes will go far deeper. Did you ever have a nightmare where you were humiliated before everyone you knew, a nightmare in which everyone was either disgusted by or laughing at you? And do you remember how horrible you felt when you awakened? Now imagine poor Bill Clinton. He is in the middle of a living nightmare of humiliation beyond anything most of us can imagine. He is embarrassed not just before his family, friends, co-workers and everyone he knows, but the entire world -- and the entire world for all time to come, to boot. And, unlike the rest of us, he can't wake up. He will inhabit this nightmare all the rest of his days. "Poor Bill Clinton." It is this dimension of Monicagate that is unique in the history of the presidency. We have had scoundrels, rogues, liars and people who committed great violence in the job before. But never have we had so hapless a president. "The Emperor With No Clothes" was supposed to be a fairy tale, not the literal description of a president whose private parts have actually become a subject of public discussion. From this perspective, Clinton's mistake is not that he had sex in the Oval Office or lied. It is something far more serious: He got caught. Presidents can be forgiven anything so long as they seem powerful enough to protect us. But a president who is so weak or foolish as to get caught is something that our psyches are just not prepared for. It is amazing how little public discussion there has been about the role the presidency plays in our psyches and lives, which is the real issue underlying the Clinton scandal. It is true, as many have suggested, that CEOs, college professors and military officers could lose their jobs for denying and then having to admit having adulterous sex with someone young enough to be their child. But for no one other than a president could this become a national obsession, dominate the media for months on end and threaten to paralyze both the executive and legislative branches of government. Let us begin with the basics: A president is different from every other American, all 250 million of them. This has partly to do with power: The president is the only person we entrust with the authority to use nuclear weapons. That is, we voluntarily grant the president, and only the president, the right to kill us and all life on earth. N E X T+P A G E+\| The psychic power of the presidency