Editor: Mark Schone
Updated: Today
Topic:

Barack Obama

What the White House knew about Souter

Justice David Souter's upcoming departure wasn't entirely a secret in Washington. The administration had already started planning for a Supreme Court vacancy before the news broke.

WASHINGTON -- The White House press secretary, Robert Gibbs, was going through one of those silly charades on Friday afternoon that the capital sometimes seems to specialize in. The world had learned hours before that Justice David Souter would be stepping down from the Supreme Court, but apparently Souter hadn't gotten around to formally notifying President Barack Obama -- or his aides -- of his intentions.

So even as the administration began to put together a system to choose Souter's replacement and get that person confirmed by the Senate, Gibbs spent the first half of his midafternoon news briefing pretending there was nothing to talk about and refusing to give anything but the very broadest answers to questions about a Supreme Court nomination. "Is it weird that you haven't heard from Justice Souter?" a reporter asked Gibbs. "No," he answered, "it's weird that I'm talking about this not having heard from him."

Just a few minutes later, the games came to an end. "Hey," Obama said, strolling into the briefing room to the surprise of just about everyone in it, reporters and aides alike. "I'm sorry, but Gibbs is screwing this thing up," Obama said, teasing his press secretary. "There's a job to do, you got to do it yourself." Souter had just sent the White House a letter announcing his plans to step down and spoken to Obama on the phone; the president decided to break the news in person, interrupting Gibbs in the process.

"The process of selecting someone to replace Justice Souter is among my most serious responsibilities as president," Obama said. "So I will seek somebody with a sharp and independent mind and a record of excellence and integrity. I will seek someone who understands that justice isn't about some abstract legal theory or footnote in a casebook; it is also about how our laws affect the daily realities of people's lives." Pointedly, he said he wanted Souter's replacement to be sworn in "in time for him or her" to join the court when it starts its new session on the first Monday in October.

That was about all the White House would say officially about the news. But behind the scenes, aides had long ago started planning how to fill a vacant spot on the Supreme Court -- which, considering that Souter, at 69, is younger than five of his nine colleagues, was probably smart. Soon after the election, an administration official said, Obama's transition team set up a working group on judicial nominations, which picked out potential candidates for U.S. Court of Appeals and Supreme Court spots. Obama met with them several times in December, suggesting the names of people he might want to consider. (Officials wouldn't say whose names were brought up.) Senior White House aides met Thursday -- before the Souter news broke -- to talk about setting up a strategy for selecting and winning confirmation for a Supreme Court nominee.

The administration official, who requested anonymity to speak more freely about the judicial nomination process, said the timing of that meeting was a coincidence (if that's true, whoever planned it might want to buy a lottery ticket soon). But Souter had already given a few key players around Washington an idea that he might not stay on the court for long. A Senate source told Salon that about a month ago, Souter met with Sen. Patrick Leahy, D-Vt., who chairs the Judiciary Committee, telling Leahy he might retire. (ABC's George Stephanopoulos reported that Souter gave Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid a tip as well.) Leahy spoke to Obama Friday morning, before the White House had officially acknowledged that there would be a vacancy, and the two of them had also discussed judicial nominations during last year's campaign and after the election.

Obama has already nominated three judges for different circuit courts, acting more quickly, the administration official said, than the Clinton or the Bush administration did in sending judicial picks to the Senate. None of the three have been confirmed yet, though. Ironically, Arlen Specter's switch from Republican to Democrat -- which should make it easier for Obama's picks to make it through the Senate, by putting Democrats close to 60 votes -- may slow things down even more.

That's because Specter had been the top Republican on the Judiciary Committee, which will have the first crack at questioning, and voting on, whomever Obama chooses. But picking his replacement won't be so easy for the GOP. The next in line, Orrin Hatch of Utah, is barred by internal rules from becoming the ranking member because he chaired the committee recently. After him comes Chuck Grassley of Iowa, who can't take over the top GOP spot on Judiciary because he's already the highest-ranking Republican on the Finance Committee. Jon Kyl of Arizona can't take the job either, because he's the Senate's deputy GOP leader. Which means Alabama's Jeff Sessions, a conservative who sometimes looks and sounds like an angry Southern leprechaun, might take over the job. Hatch could step up if the GOP caucus gives him a waiver. A leadership aide said Republicans would probably vote on the committee spot early next week.

Obama promised Friday that he would reach out to whoever takes over, to get advice before seeking the Senate's consent to a nomination. Vice President Joe Biden, who ran confirmation hearings for several Supreme Court justices when he chaired the Senate Judiciary Committee, may play a major role in helping Obama and his aides figure out how to get the nominee through the panel (though a senior administration official told Salon that reports that Biden would run the process were overblown).

First, though, the administration has to come up with a nominee. It's only May 1, but time sometimes flies in Washington. That first Monday in October could be here before Obama and his aides know it.

Barack Obama in the news

Loading...

Recommended Reads

BOOKS

Dreams from My Father: A Story of Race and Inheritance
Obama's first book, a memoir focused on personal issues of race, identity, and community.
By Barack Obama

The Audacity of Hope: Thoughts on Reclaiming the American Dream
Obama's second book, in which he shares his personal views on faith and values and offers a vision of the future that involves restoring a government that has fallen out of touch with the people.
By Barack Obama

10 reasons there's a bright future for journalism
An optimistic take on what's coming, both for news outlets and news consumers.
By Mark Glaser, Salon

Obama: From Promise to Power
In this compelling book, a Chicago Tribune reporter draws on interviews with Obama, his family, friends, and rivals, as well as his own extensive coverage since Obama's days in the Illinois Senate, to offer a nuanced look at a man of idealism and ambition intent on making history.
By David Mendell

SPEECHES

July 28, 2004: Obama's first national prime-time speech
In this speech, Barack Obama urges America to remember its unity, pledging that "out of this long political darkness a brighter day will come."

August 28, 2008: Obama's acceptance of the Democratic Party's presidential nomination
In this speech, Obama lays into John McCain, describing him as "anything but independent."

November 5th, 2008: Obama's victory speech
In this speech, Obama tells his ecstatic supporters, and the entire nation, that "change has come to America."

January 20, 2009: Obama's inaugural address
The new president calls upon the nation to face its challenges head on, with determination, strength and a commitment to ensuring the delivery of freedom to future generations.

SALON STORIES

How would Barack Obama handle foreign policy?
The presidential contender on dealing with Iran, fighting AIDS in Africa and restoring America's standing in the world.
By Walter Shapiro, Salon

Chicago is Barack Obama's kind of town
The city has a unique history of launching the careers of powerful black politicians -- which is part of the reason Obama moved there.
By Edward McClelland, Salon

American revolutionary
In his acceptance speech, Barack Obama stood up for Democratic values, took the fight to McCain -- and proved that the United States is still capable of reinventing itself.
By Walter Shapiro, Salon

Barack Obama's epic win
The culmination of a brilliant campaign, Obama's unequivocal defeat of John McCain marks a political and generational transformation.
By Walter Shapiro, Salon

Barack Obama, honeymoon killer?
The Clintonites in his Cabinet, forgiveness for Lieberman, the creeping signs of centrism -- progressives aren't ready to panic, yet.
By Mike Madden, Salon

"A new era of responsibility"
Mixing straight talk about dire times with lofty rhetoric about hope and determination, Obama repudiates Bush and vows to get to work.
By Mike Madden, Salon

OTHER STORIES

The Conciliator
Where is Barack Obama coming from?
By Larissa MacFarquhar, The New Yorker

Time's "Person of the Year" coverage of Obama
A strangely fascinating database of Obama-formation, including everything from "6 Degrees of Obama" to a collection of Obama-themed art from Flickr.
Time

The presidency of Barack Obama
This New York Times megapage is the last word on Barack Obama, including everything from his personal biography to his current political stance on detainees and Africa.
The New York Times

Currently in Salon