'08 Roadies

Iowa Democratic debate offers little punch, ends in split decision

Here are the unplugged, off-the-top of my head reactions, typed in a frantic hurry in a press room as the cameras and microphones are being set up for the fandango of post-debate spin: This was a don't-rock-the-boat debate. There were no dramatic clashes, few memorable moments, much candidate boilerplate and a marzipan overload of paeans to Iowa. In short, you did not miss too much if you opted for the George Mitchell press conference about the steroid All-Scar team.

But since there has to be a verdict, here goes. The winner for consistently staying on message and making his appeals to the Iowa voters in a smiling fashion: John Edwards. The winner for the best strategic laugh: Hillary Clinton. (Her guffaw was in response to a question to Barack Obama about how could he be the candidate of change if he was depending so heavily on foreign-policy veterans of the Clinton administration). The winner for surpassing expectations with his best debate performance to date: Bill Richardson. The winner as the candidate who may have benefited the most from the placid tenor of the debate: Barack Obama.

Now back to the real business of journalism -- chatting with my press-room colleagues to decide what it all meant.

About '08 Roadies

'08 Roadies is a periodic diary of campaign dispatches by Washington bureau chief Walter Shapiro, who is covering his eighth presidential race, and Mike Madden, Salon's Washington correspondent.

Current Salon Politics Stories

’08 Update

23:04 EDT, Sept. 7, 2008
Palin watch Day 8 and counting, and still no interviews.
Joan Walsh
55
07:52 EDT, Sept. 6, 2008
Mean Old Party From Fred Thompson to Sarah Palin, snarling Rudy Giuliani to smiling Lindsey Graham, Republicans bared their fangs this week to hide their unpopular agenda. And it might work.
Joan Walsh
284
18:47 EDT, Sept. 5, 2008
Sarah Palin's pastor problem Move over Jeremiah Wright
War Room
54
17:22 EDT, Sept. 5, 2008
McCain knocks Obama as "celebrity" again But Paris Hilton doesn't make an appearance in this new ad.
War Room
32
15:47 EDT, Sept. 5, 2008
Woodward: Don't credit surge for Iraq turnaround In his new book, the investigative journalist credits covert ops with reducing violence in Iraq.
War Room
30

Salon Politics Blogs

Recent Posts

Mike Huckabee gets serious in a big way
The former Arkansas governor has finally found the idea maven -- Jim Pinkerton -- to add heft to his just-folks shtick.
The ghost of primaries past
A Myrtle Beach debate shows Ronald Reagan is still the patron saint of South Carolina Republican politics.
Live blogging the GOP debate
American flag pins have become the last refuge of desperate candidates.

'08 Roadies RSS Feed

Posts by date

January 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031

Daily Newsletter

Get Salon in your mailbox!