War Room

A cut-and-paste job in Iraq

On July 13, as on just about every day in Iraq, a car bomb exploded near Baghdad, killing several Iraqi children. A statement put out by the 3rd Infantry Division's press office described how an anonymous Iraqi man said he felt about the attack: "The terrorists are attacking the infrastructure, the children and all of Iraq," the man was quoted as saying. "They are enemies of humanity without religion or any sort of ethics. They have attacked my community today and I will now take the fight to the terrorists."

Then, a little more than a week later, on July 24, a car bomb exploded at a police station in Baghdad, killing more than 25 Iraqis. Again, the 3rd Infantry Division's press office put out a statement condemning the attack. And again, an anonymous Iraqi man had harsh words for the attackers: "The terrorists are attacking the infrastructure, the [Iraqi police] and all of Iraq. They are enemies of humanity without religion or any sort of ethics. They have attacked my community today and I will now take the fight to the terrorists."

Who is this angry, eloquent, very consistent Iraqi man? As it happens, he's a fiction. When reporters who'd been given the second statement pointed out the similarities to the military, the 3rd Infantry Division removed the quote from the press release, explaining that it had made an "administrative error." It promised to investigate the matter.

Of course, accidents happen, but considering that the two quotes are similar but not identical -- one notes that the victims are children, and the other says they're police -- it's difficult to see how such an error might have occurred entirely innocently. And forgive us if we note, too, the propaganda value of the quote: an Iraqi man angrily responding to yet another devastating car bomb by vowing to "take the fight to the terrorists" -- just like George W. Bush says we should do! -- sure looks designed to ease the public's flagging confidence in the mission.

But let's give the military the benefit of the doubt. Let's say this was an innocent slip-up -- that there was an Iraqi man who said what the military says he said on July 13, and that somebody somehow sneaked his quote into the July 24 press release without meaning to. Such a scenario clears the military of outright lying, but doesn't it also tell us something worse -- that bombs in Iraq have become so routine, so normal, that responding to them has become, for the military, just a matter of cutting-and-pasting together a press release composed of strong words of condemnation? Either way, the thing's unsettling.

McCain: "facts of global warming demand our urgent attention"
In a speech, the presumptive Republican nominee laid out his views on global warming and the environment, prompting criticism from left and right.
More superdelegates for Obama
Democratic superdelegates continue a steady march to Barack Obama; it's now widely estimated that he leads Hillary Clinton in superdelegate endorsements.
McAuliffe: "We are in through June 3"
Terry McAuliffe, Hillary Clinton's campaign chairman, tells MSNBC Clinton will keep running at least until the last primary of the season.
Missouri may take voter I.D. laws a step further
The state's lawmakers may support a measure that would be even more restrictive than the Indiana I.D. law upheld by the Supreme Court.

Current Salon Politics Stories

’08 Update

19:39 EDT, May 12, 2008
McCain: "facts of global warming demand our urgent attention" In a speech, the presumptive Republican nominee laid out his views on global warming and the environment, prompting criticism from left and right.
War Room
19
18:40 EDT, May 12, 2008
More superdelegates for Obama Democratic superdelegates continue a steady march to Barack Obama; it's now widely estimated that he leads Hillary Clinton in superdelegate endorsements.
War Room
39
17:31 EDT, May 12, 2008
McAuliffe: "We are in through June 3" Terry McAuliffe, Hillary Clinton's campaign chairman, tells MSNBC Clinton will keep running at least until the last primary of the season.
War Room
22
16:07 EDT, May 12, 2008
Missouri may take voter I.D. laws a step further The state's lawmakers may support a measure that would be even more restrictive than the Indiana I.D. law upheld by the Supreme Court.
War Room
30
14:58 EDT, May 12, 2008
Bob Barr to run for president The former congressman, who left the GOP in 2006, will try to win the Libertarian Party's nomination at a convention later this month.
War Room
21

Salon Politics Blogs

Recent Posts

More superdelegates for Obama
Democratic superdelegates continue a steady march to Barack Obama; it's now widely estimated that he leads Hillary Clinton in superdelegate endorsements.
McAuliffe: "We are in through June 3"
Terry McAuliffe, Hillary Clinton's campaign chairman, tells MSNBC Clinton will keep running at least until the last primary of the season.
Missouri may take voter I.D. laws a step further
The state's lawmakers may support a measure that would be even more restrictive than the Indiana I.D. law upheld by the Supreme Court.
Previous Posts…

War Room RSS Feed

Posts by date

May 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

About War Room

War Room is written and edited by Alex Koppelman, with contributions from Salon reporters around the country.

Daily Newsletter

Get Salon in your mailbox!