War Room

Alito: A man with a plan to roll back Roe?

As the Supreme Court hears oral arguments today in cases that could chip away at abortion rights, a memorandum just released by the National Archives seems to underscore court nominee Samuel Alito's interest in rolling back the protections of Roe v. Wade.

Writing as a lawyer in the Solicitor General's Office in 1985, Alito said that "no one seriously believes that the [Supreme Court] is about to overrule Roe v. Wade." But in recent court actions, Alito said he saw a "positive sign" that a majority of the justices might be willing to "cut back" Roe's protections. "What can be made of this opportunity to advance the goals of bringing about the eventual overruling of Roe v. Wade and, in the meantime, of mitigating its effects?" he asked.

His answer: The Solicitor General's Office should file an amicus brief in then-pending cases in which "we should make clear that we disagree with Roe v. Wade and would welcome the opportunity to brief the issue of whether, and if so to what extent, that decision should be overruled." Then, Alito said, the Solicitor General's Office should argue to the court, "without great formal discussion of levels of scrutiny or degrees of state interest," that some of the state efforts to limit abortion rights that had been struck down in the name of Roe were in fact "eminently legitimate and reasonable."

Alito wrote optimistically about "an opportunity to nudge the court ... to provide greater recognition of the states' interest in protecting the unborn throughout pregnancy, or to dispel in part the mystical faith in the attending physician that supports Roe and the subsequent cases."

Alito concluded: "I find this approach preferable to a frontal assault on Roe v. Wade. It has most of the advantages of a brief devoted to the overruling of Roe v. Wade: it makes our position clear, does not even tacitly concede Roe's legitimacy, and signals that we regard the question as live and open."

The strategy Alito articulated in 1985 is, of course, awfully similar to the one antiabortion advocates are now pursuing in cases like those before the Supreme Court today. Roe itself isn't on the chopping block just yet, but by pushing back against state regulations -- a parental notification law was at issue in one of the cases today -- antiabortion groups hope they can undercut Roe so thoroughly that it ultimately means nothing even if it's never reversed.

In 1985, at least, Alito seemed to see things exactly the same way. Maybe he's different now -- even judicial nominees can change, the president's protestations notwithstanding -- but at the very least the 1985 memo suggests that senators should think twice when they hear Alito talking about "settled law" and "respect for precedent" when his confirmation hearings begin next year.

Sarah Palin's pastor problem
Move over Jeremiah Wright
McCain knocks Obama as "celebrity" again
But Paris Hilton doesn't make an appearance in this new ad.
More dirt on Palin on the way?
The National Enquirer is reporting that Sarah Palin had an affair with her husband's business partner, who reportedly just tried to have his divorce records sealed.
Woodward: Don't credit surge for Iraq turnaround
In his new book, the investigative journalist credits covert ops with reducing violence in Iraq.

Current Salon Politics Stories

Salon Politics Blogs

  • Mean Old Party

    From Fred Thompson to Sarah Palin, snarling Rudy Giuliani to smiling Lindsey Graham, Republicans bared their fangs this week to hide their unpopular agenda. And it might work.

  • Will the GOP's negativity produce a backlash?

    Democrats like to tell themselves that Americans dislike the character attacks in which the GOP specializes. But that comforting thought is untrue.

Recent Posts

McCain knocks Obama as "celebrity" again
But Paris Hilton doesn't make an appearance in this new ad.
More dirt on Palin on the way?
The National Enquirer is reporting that Sarah Palin had an affair with her husband's business partner, who reportedly just tried to have his divorce records sealed.
Woodward: Don't credit surge for Iraq turnaround
In his new book, the investigative journalist credits covert ops with reducing violence in Iraq.
Previous Posts…

War Room RSS Feed

Posts by date

September 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
282930

About War Room

War Room is written and edited by Alex Koppelman, with contributions from Salon reporters around the country.

Daily Newsletter

Get Salon in your mailbox!