War Room

Facts are stupid things, again

Campaign finance records show that while Jack Abramoff's associates and Indian tribes he represented gave money to both Democrats and Republicans, Abramoff himself made contributions solely to Republican candidates and campaign committees.

How hard is this to understand?

For some members of the mainstream media, it's apparently so complicated that they can't possibly be expected to get it right. After the much-discussed dust-up over Deborah Howell's false characterization, you'd think that the message would be starting to sink in: Abramoff himself didn't give anything to Democrats. But there was Katie Couric this morning, diving into the hole just as Howell tries to dig out.

Think Progress has the video, but here's the short version. In an interview with Howard Dean, Couric proclaimed that Democrats "took money from Mr. Abramoff." When Dean said that wasn't so, Couric began to lecture him: "Let me just tell you ... According to the Center for Responsive Politics, Abramoff and his associates gave $3 million to Republicans and $1.5 million to Democrats, including Sen. Minority Leader Harry Reid."

It's that tricky little "and" that gets them every time. Abramoff didn't give money to Democrats. Abramoff's associates did. So saying that "Abramoff and his associates" gave money to Democrats is like saying that "Germany and Japan bombed Pearl Harbor." It's half right, which is another way of saying that it's half wrong.

Dean tried to push back, but Couric said that NBC would have to dig a little deeper to get at the truth. "Well," she said, "well obviously have to look into that and clarify that for our viewers at a later date." You do that, Katie. We'll be waiting.

New McCain ad touts "Original Mavericks"
With the addition of Sarah Palin to his ticket, John McCain is repositioning himself yet again; this time, he's trying to return to his roots.
Poll: McCain over Obama, 54-44
A new survey shows John McCain got a big boost from his party's convention -- will it last?
Sarah Palin's pastor problem
Move over Jeremiah Wright
McCain knocks Obama as "celebrity" again
But Paris Hilton doesn't make an appearance in this new ad.

Current Salon Politics Stories

Salon Politics Blogs

Recent Posts

Poll: McCain over Obama, 54-44
A new survey shows John McCain got a big boost from his party's convention -- will it last?
Sarah Palin's pastor problem
Move over Jeremiah Wright
McCain knocks Obama as "celebrity" again
But Paris Hilton doesn't make an appearance in this new ad.
Previous Posts…

War Room RSS Feed

Posts by date

September 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
282930

About War Room

War Room is written and edited by Alex Koppelman, with contributions from Salon reporters around the country.

Daily Newsletter

Get Salon in your mailbox!