War Room

Wrong on 9/11? It's not just ABC

When the subject is a TV miniseries best known for getting its facts wrong, you'd think a reviewer would be careful to get hers right.

But as Think Progress reports, the New York Times' Alessandra Stanley's Clinton-is-more-to-blame-than-Bush review of ABC's "The Path to 9/11" includes an invented conclusion of the 9/11 Commission. Stanley writes: "The Sept. 11 commission concluded that the [Monica Lewinsky] sex scandal distracted the Clinton administration from the terrorist threat." What the 9/11 Commission actually said: While Clinton's aides were obviously aware of his problems, he "told them to ignore them ... All his aides testified to us that they based their advice solely on national security considerations. We have found no reason to question their statements."

It's actually worse than that. After Clinton ordered missile strikes on Osama bin Laden's training camps in 1998, he suffered "Wag the Dog" criticism from Republicans who claimed he was just trying to change the subject. "The failure of the strikes, the 'Wag the Dog' slur, the intense partisanship of the period, and the nature of the al Shifa evidence likely had a cumulative effect on future decisions about the use of force against bin Laden," the commission wrote. Translation: While the 9/11 Commission found no reason to believe that the Lewinsky scandal caused Clinton's aides to color their advice to him on terrorism, the Republicans' criticism of the steps Clinton did take against bin Laden may have made it harder for him to take more. To be fair to Stanley, she does acknowledge in her New York Times review that "the right-wing groups who drove for impeachment must look back at their partisan obsession with shame, like widows sickened by the memory of spats about dirty dishes and gambling debts."

Although Stanley's largely positive review won't help matters, the Daouian triangle that has come together against ABC's truth-challenged miniseries is starting to have some effect. Faced with critical stories in the Washington Post and elsewhere, a storm from the liberal blogs and setting-the-record straight letters from Clinton's lawyer, Senate Democrats, Media Matters for America and tens of thousands of Think Progress readers, ABC says it's making changes to the program. Meanwhile, Scholastic Inc. has abandoned the "classroom companion guides" it produced for the miniseries, pushing instead materials that stress, among other things, the questions students should raise about such productions.

Former Bush cabinet member as Obama's running mate?
Politico reports that a Republican who served in George W. Bush's cabinet during his first term has been mentioned by Barack Obama's search team as a potential running mate.
GOP candidates may skip convention
Most of the Republicans in the hottest Senate races say they aren't going to St. Paul to celebrate John McCain (and send off George W. Bush).
Rove map shows Obama beating McCain
A series of Electoral College maps produced by the company run by the man once known as "Bush's Brain" has Barack Obama narrowly winning the presidency.
The John Edwards "love child" story
Yes, the original report comes from the National Enquirer, but new information lends additional credibility to its article.

Current Salon Politics Stories

’08 Update

07:20 EDT, July 26, 2008
A tale of two campaigns Obama had a magical week, McCain had a bad one, but the polls remain remarkably close.
Joan Walsh
65
20:22 EDT, July 25, 2008
Former Bush cabinet member as Obama's running mate? Politico reports that a Republican who served in George W. Bush's cabinet during his first term has been mentioned by Barack Obama's search team as a potential running mate.
War Room
25
16:10 EDT, July 25, 2008
Rove map shows Obama beating McCain A series of Electoral College maps produced by the company run by the man once known as "Bush's Brain" has Barack Obama narrowly winning the presidency.
War Room
15
14:57 EDT, July 25, 2008
The John Edwards "love child" story Yes, the original report comes from the National Enquirer, but new information lends additional credibility to its article.
War Room
60
12:24 EDT, July 25, 2008
McCain memo is riddled with inaccuracies McCain's campaign claims to have debunked "three prevailing myths about Obama's foreign policy," but it's the McCain camp that isn't connected to reality.
War Room
23

Salon Politics Blogs

Recent Posts

GOP candidates may skip convention
Most of the Republicans in the hottest Senate races say they aren't going to St. Paul to celebrate John McCain (and send off George W. Bush).
Rove map shows Obama beating McCain
A series of Electoral College maps produced by the company run by the man once known as "Bush's Brain" has Barack Obama narrowly winning the presidency.
The John Edwards "love child" story
Yes, the original report comes from the National Enquirer, but new information lends additional credibility to its article.
Previous Posts…

War Room RSS Feed

Posts by date

July 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031

About War Room

War Room is written and edited by Alex Koppelman, with contributions from Salon reporters around the country.

Daily Newsletter

Get Salon in your mailbox!