Editor: Mark Schone
Updated: Today
Topic:

Iraq War

Losing ground on Iraq?

How a Senate withdrawal measure went from 52-47 to 47-47.

In July, the U.S. Senate voted 52-47 to take up consideration of a measure that would have required the president to begin withdrawing troops from Iraq within 120 days. While 52 votes constituted a majority, they weren't enough to meet the 60-vote requirement for a cloture motion that would have cut off debate and moved the measure toward an up-or-down vote.

So Democrats tried to get a substantially similar measure going again this morning. The result this time: 47-47.

How is it possible that Democrats actually lost ground?

Here's how.

Democrats Barbara Boxer and Dick Durbin and independent Bernie Sanders, all of whom voted for the measure in July, didn't vote today. That takes support down from 52 votes to 49 votes.

Democrat Tim Johnson, who didn't vote in July, voted yes today. That takes support back up to 50 votes.

Democrat Harry Reid, who voted no in July, voted yes today. That takes support up to 51 votes.

Democrats Chris Dodd, Ben Nelson and Mark Pryor and Republican Susan Collins, all of whom voted yes in July, voted no today. And with that, the 52-47 vote found its way back down to 47-47.

Dodd explained his vote by saying that he'll vote yes only on measures that would "fully fund the complete redeployment of our troops out of Iraq." We haven't heard explanations from Nelson, Pryor or Collins yet, but somehow we're doubting that they're quite so unequivocal.

Iraq war in the news

Loading...

Recommended Reads

The Gamble: General David Petraeus and the American Military Adventure in Iraq, 2006-2008
The author of "Fiasco" uses hundreds of hours of exclusive interviews with top officers in Iraq and extraordinary on-the-ground reportage to document the inside story of the Iraq War since late 2005.
By Thomas E. Ricks

Small Wars Journal
A journal dedicated to the study of such subjects as counterinsurgency, foreign internal defense, support and stability operations, peacemaking, and peacekeeping. Founded by ex-Marines.

Afghanistan is worse than you think
We all knew that the situation in Afghanistan has been rapidly becoming worse. But few people know just how steep the downward spiral has been.
By Alex Koppelman, Salon

Currently in Salon