| ||||||
|
Arts & Entertainment Books Comics Health & Body Media Mothers Who Think News People Politics2000  Technology- Free Software Project Travel & Food  Columnists
- - - - - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - - - - - View From the Top - - - - - - - - - - - - Also Today For a full list of today's Salon Technology stories, go to the
Technology home page. - - - - - - - - - - - - Search Salon - - - - - - - - - - - - Salon Columnists - - - - - - - - - - - - Recently in Salon Technology Silicon Follies Silicon Follies Complete archives for Technology - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - |
The Web can't make racists | page 1, 2
Optimists -- I'm among them -- aren't so quick to assume that people's brains will roll over and play dead at first contact with the poisonous content of hate sites. Conveniently, you can read the entire text of what is still, after a century and a half, the most persuasive and valuable study of these issues -- John Stuart Mill's "On Liberty" -- on the Web. In Mill's argument for the free play of ideas, the best way for society to arrive at the truth is to have its dogmas and beliefs "vigorously and earnestly contested"; good ideas will survive and be sharpened, while bad ones won't make the cut. Mill would have welcomed the way the Web exposes racist propaganda, giving the rest of us a chance to see it for what it is and respond to it. Sure enough, the Web now hosts an impressive array of sites that are dedicated to countering racism and exposing hate sites -- from the Anti-Defamation League to HateWatch to the Southern Poverty Law Center. These sites are professional, well-organized and full of valuable information: The SPLC offers 'Ten Ways to Fight Hate"; the ADL offers a useful review of the law surrounding hate speech online. If good speech drives out bad, then this is the good speech about this subject on the Web. Scott Rosenberg's column appears once a week in Technology Nothing you read on these sites, of course, does anything to make what you'll find on sites like the World Church of the Creator's any more palatable: It's easy to get paranoid about such material even if you're not delusional. But it's important to keep them in perspective: When news reports talk about how "thousands" of hate sites now reach "millions" of people on the Web, you need to keep in mind that there are not thousands of Nazi Yahoos out there. These sites range from a number of ambitious operations to a large number of barren home pages on free services. And their "millions" of visitors are, in virtually every case, potential. You and I can visit these sites, but we don't -- not, at least, until they hit the headlines. The most substantial fear about racists on the Net is that they will use the network's power to find and organize like-minded people in some clandestine way. But the more clandestine their online activities are, the less useful they'll be for rounding up new recruits. This is the paradox that undercuts our most awful fears about hate-mongering online: If the racists don't go public, they can't grow their ranks, but if they do go public, they incite more opposition than support. As the quote that serves as epigraph to the HateWatch Web site puts it, "How it infuriates a bigot when he is forced to drag out his dark convictions." The Web actually promotes that "dragging out." Of course, there will be individual cases in which a hate site message finds a receptive hearing. In the end, though, I don't believe that the Web has much to do with them: The stuff on these sites is typically so loony that you couldn't be enticed by it unless you were predisposed in some way to accept it. In other words: The Web didn't make anyone do it. It doesn't turn people into racists. People who fall for hate sites were already open to hate, whether it appeared on a computer screen, in a leaflet or on a library shelf. If we knew exactly why, we might have a key to finally uprooting these pernicious ideas from our society. But the reasons, alas, are probably as varied as the individuals.
- - - - - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - - - - - Search Salon | |||||
 |
 |
 |
 |
|||
