Pennsylvania
Philly fights school plan
A state-appointed commission recently announced a plan to privatize most of the Philadelphia school system
On a weekday evening, at a renovated West Philadelphia church, a wide array of community members discussed the state-appointed School Reform Commission’s (SRC) recently-announced plan to privatize most of the Philadelphia School District — labeled by SRC head Thomas Knudsen as “decentralization.”
The meeting came on May 8th, just two weeks after the SRC announced their radical proposal. A woman in her mid-thirties, voice quivering slightly, admitted: “We knew that what happened in Wisconsin last year would happen here too. This is going to be a huge fight.”
The agenda of this meeting of public school teachers, students, labor organizers and seasoned activists (including members of Occupy Philadelphia) included crafting a response to what some here see as the “Shock Doctrine” being applied to Philadelphia public education. Residents have received an ultimatum from the city: accept property tax hikes – which Mayor Michael Nutter says would raise upwards of $92 million, but would disproportionately affect low income residents — or let schools close.
“In a way, politicians and business interests co-opted the idea of decentralization,” said one activist. “It should be about giving power to communities to determine what they need.”
Not in the way the SRC and others have framed it, however.
Ron Whitehorne, a former teacher and Philadelphia Federation of Teachers (PFT) member, says that there is no confidence in the SRC’s plan among many school union members.
The SRC’s plan, in essence, is to “decentralize” the school district and allow for-profit interests to turn public schools into charters.
“There is no proof that privatization is better,” adds Amanda, a Students for a Democratic Society organizer [who asked that her last name not be used]. “All the articles which have come out on this issue since this plan was announced point out this fact.”
She has a point – public officials themselves have said recently that charter schools do not always produce better results compared to public schools, although there are charters which do perform well. High performance Charters are definitely in the minority, however.
“I’m deeply concerned that corporations want to turn our schools into cash cows,” said Cynthia Murray Holmes, a South Philadelphia elementary school teacher. “They’ve succeeded so far in pitting their model against public schools – which is not what charter schools were created for. And I don’t think putting our children’s education in the hands of for-profit interests is wise.”
She adds that charters were supposed to be testing grounds, in essence, to come up with new ideas to improve public education. The concept was never intended to be used as a tool to privatize entire school districts, and certainly not to the extreme that officials are steering towards. Many here feel that the political leadership are taking privatization as an easy – and by no means correct – solution to the education funding crisis. They point to ending tax abatements given to corporations, for instance, as something that could stave off this privatization effort.
It is apparent that city officials who support a draconian privatization plan, as well as their wealthy benefactors, created such a small window for public reaction on purpose. And according to many assembled at the church, the power players’ disdain for democracy is topped off with Mayor Nutter’s request to the people of Philadelphia: “Grow up and deal with it.”
“The resonant theme here,” says Whitehorne to the assembled crowd, “is democracy. The citizens have no real say in this. This [SRC] was not elected, and that’s unacceptable.”
And judging by these concerned people, they think this plan is unacceptable too.
Romney’s useless allies
Once supposed to be crucial 2012 assets, swing-state governors like Tom Corbett are looking more like liabilities
Tom Corbett (Credit: AP/Gene J. Puskar) In 2010, the governor’s mansion in four key Rust Belt swing states — Pennsylvania, Ohio, Wisconsin and Michigan — flipped from Democratic to Republican control. This was supposed to be a boon to whomever became the 2012 Republican nominee. “Republican control of the majority of 2012 swing states is a major roadblock to the President’s reelection,” Haley Barbour crowed at the time. But increasingly, these erstwhile allies are turning into greater liabilities than assets.
Continue Reading CloseDaniel Denvir is a staff writer at Philadelphia City Paper and a contributing writer for Salon. You can follow him at Twitter @DanielDenvir. More Daniel Denvir.
Fire in central Pennsylvania farmhouse kills 7 children
Fast-moving blaze claims lives of kids while mother milked cows, father napped in truck down the road
This image from video provided by WHP TV shows the charred remains of a Blain, Pennsylvania farm house where seven children died after the house caught fire Tuesday night. Seven children, including a 7-month-old girl, perished in a fast-moving fire in a home on a Pennsylvania dairy farm while their mother milked cows and their father dozed in a milk truck down the road, police said Wednesday.
No cause or origin of the fire had been determined by early Wednesday morning, but the children’s grandfather, Noah Sauder, told The Associated Press the blaze may have started in the kitchen, where the family used a propane heater. Fire marshals were investigating.
Public records indicate the parents are Theodore and Janelle Clouse. A neighbor described the family as hard-working.
Continue Reading Close1 killed in Pa. natural gas explosion; 5 missing
Authorities are still trying to determine cause of blast that consumed row of houses in flames
A man gets some rest inside the Agri-Plex at the Allentown Fairgrounds after being evacuated from her building when an explosion rocked the intersection of 13th and Allen Streets in Allentown, Pa., early Thursday Feb. 10, 2011. Fire Chief Robert Scheirer said the cause of the explosion was unknown but natural gas from a ruptured underground line was feeding the fire. He said eight houses were destroyed and about 500 people evacuated, including elderly residents of a high rise. Several buildings are involved and at least two people are still unaccounted for. (AP Photo/Rich Schultz)(Credit: AP) A natural gas explosion in eastern Pennsylvania killed at least one person, leveled two houses, spawned fires that burned for more than seven hours and prompted the evacuation of hundreds of people. At least five others were unaccounted for Thursday.
The victim lived in two-story row house in a downtown residential neighborhood that blew up about 10:45 p.m. Wednesday, police Chief Roger MacClean said. A couple in their 70s lived in the home, but the condition of the body prevented positive identification, fire Chief Robert Scheirer said.
Continue Reading CloseThe gas industry attacks an Oscar nominee
In a self-destructive P.R. move, lobbyists urge Oscar to shun the scruffy activist documentary "Gasland"
A still from "Gasland" Josh Fox’s Oscar-nominated film “Gasland” definitely isn’t the first prominent documentary to spark a vigorous counterattack from the corporate interests it seeks to expose. Michael Moore’s movies, from “Bowling for Columbine” onward, have provoked extended debates about their accuracy and fairness, and Davis Guggenheim’s Oscar-winning climate-change documentary, “An Inconvenient Truth,” was widely picked apart for possible exaggerations, generalizations and misstatements of scientific fact. Joe Berlinger’s film “Crude,” about oil industry practices in Ecuador, became the focus of a lawsuit by Chevron Corp. that threatens to strip issue-oriented documentarians of their First Amendment protection.
Continue Reading CloseProsecution rests in immigrant beating trial
Three former Pa. police officers face charges of obstructing an FBI investigation into the death of Luis Ramirez
(from left) Chief Matthew Nestor, Lt. William Moyer and Officer Jason Hayes. Federal prosecutors have rested their case against three former Pennsylvania police officers charged with orchestrating a cover-up of the beating death of an illegal immigrant.
Former Shenandoah police chief Matthew Nestor and two subordinates, William Moyer and Jason Hayes, are charged with obstructing an FBI investigation into the July 2008 attack on 25-year-old Luis Ramirez. Prosecutors allege that the officers helped a group of white high school football players concoct a cover story.
An FBI agent testified Thursday that Moyer lied about what a witness said during the investigation. Moyer had told the agent, Adam B. Aichele, that Edward Ney saw a Mexican chasing a group of kids with a gun. A taped 911 call from Ney proves he did not make that statement and it was fabricated by Moyer.
Continue Reading ClosePage 1 of 10 in Pennsylvania