Coen Brothers
“Intolerable Cruelty”
George Clooney and Catherine Zeta-Jones square off deliciously, but this '30s-style battle of the sexes from the Coen brothers never catches fire.
“Intolerable Cruelty” has a solid farce structure, a bunch of ripe second bananas, and two sinfully attractive stars ready to raise comic hell. So why is a movie with so many genuine laughs and so many good bits only fitfully amusing?
The short answer is that the Coen brothers seem to be incapable of trusting their material. In “Intolerable Cruelty” they’ve begun with a script by Robert Ramsey and Matthew Stone (which the Coens also worked on) that has just about everything you’d want in a farce: a juicy premise, escalating complications, eccentric supporting characters, good lines and a taste for the absurd (there’s no reason that a Vegas wedding chapel should have a Scottish theme other than that’s just the kind of lunacy you’d expect in screwball comedy).
But they can’t resist “tweaking” it, and while their usual cartoonish air is considerably toned down here, even the slight emphases that they bring to shots or sequences can be fatal to comic timing. At times, in “Intolerable Cruelty,” they are the equivalent of actors who think that the way to do comedy is to act funny. But in good screwball farce, the lunacy arises from the situations and the characters and the best thing a director can do is to stay out of the way of both. For much of “Intolerable Cruelty,” the camera seems to be in the wrong place. Actors are stranded in long shots when the camera needs to be on them to give the comic moments shape and punch, or the camera is positioned low so that they seem to be looming over us.
The Coens’ cartoon style worked beautifully in “O Brother, Where Art Thou?” The movie felt like a Mad magazine scrambling of the iconography and popular culture of the Depression. It made sense to turn the Depression into a shared comic tall tale — so many of the memories that Americans have had handed down by relatives who lived through the Depression do seem like tall tales at this remove. The movie was both a celebration of and a joke about Americans’ innate inability to get on with things.
The setting for “Intolerable Cruelty” is contemporary, though the spirit of the film derives from ’30s screwball comedies. The movie takes place in Beverly Hills mansions and law offices and restaurants, and in plush Vegas hotel suites. But the Coens and cinematographer Roger Pratt can’t simply present the swanky settings for our delectation. They start with wide-angled views of these rooms, as if they were doing a parody of Architectural Digest. The actors often seem to be standing in front of cutouts instead of inhabiting the world on screen.
It’s too bad that the timing and emphasis are so off here, because the tone feels right. “Intolerable Cruelty” is a battle-of-the-sexes farce with George Clooney as Miles Massey (a name that seems both drippy and crisp, like a foulard primped to droop perfectly out of a breast pocket), a divorce lawyer for whom winning has become so routine that he’s in a state of ineradicable boredom. Catherine Zeta-Jones is Marilyn Rexroth, the gold digger whose eternal enmity he earns after screwing her out of her cheating husband’s money. Natch, they fall for each other. But love here has less to do with rapture than with hunger. This is courtship as safari.
“Intolerable Cruelty” is more cynical than bright (a ’30s comedy would have swathed the comic daggers in satin), and as a comedy about the boredom of marriage it’s nowhere near as consistently witty as Laura Kipnis’ recently published polemic “Against Love” (somebody get her to consult on a script). But it’s not the repellent cynicism that has characterized some of the Coens’ work.
Though the Coens are still far from sympathetic to their characters, “Intolerable Cruelty” seems more motivated by amusement than bile. They enjoy the eccentrics they’ve put on screen. The gags that fizzle never linger too long because somebody comes along to tickle you — like the whippet-thin Billy Bob Thornton, who plays an aw-shucks Texas oil billionaire whose blood seems to be made of equal parts honey and barbecue sauce, or Jonathan Hadary as a foofy hotel concierge. I’ve seen Hadary on stage but never knew he had this amount of craziness in him. He plays the role as if the foreigners whom Erik Rhodes always played in the Astaire-Rogers musicals had been melded with the persnickety petty officials that were the specialty of Franklin Pangborn.
As a private detective who works for Clooney, Cedric the Entertainer gets the broadest and least funny material. He deserves a lot more than holding a video camera on cheating spouses while repeating, “I’m ‘onna nail yo’ ass!” But Edward Herrmann, as Zeta-Jones’ cheating hubby, may possibly be having the most fun of his career. Herrmann has long been called on to be no more than a reliably dull actor of the Hal Holbrook school. The pity of that is that he can be amazing, as he was playing a preacher soliciting the murder of abortion doctors on an episode of “Law & Order,” or as he was last year in his improbably touching performance as William Randolph Hearst in “The Cat’s Meow.” Here, Herrmann uses his big-man’s frame to play a blithely horny idiot and the look of surprise he gets on his face is like a kid who earns an A for playing hooky. And Geoffrey Rush makes a great entrance as a hipster producer in a scene that forever finishes off that gassy Simon and Garfunkel “classic” “The Boxer.”
George Clooney trusts the Coens a bit too much for his own good. He melds himself into their cartoon style when you wish he had just been left to play it straight and suave. What gets him through is that he’s more game for silliness than any leading man around right now. But it’s Zeta-Jones who walks away with the movie and who is most resistant to the Coens’ shenanigans. The woman has aplomb that is simply flabbergasting.
Zeta-Jones looks as if she were made to make men suffer. When she walks through a room you expect the males to turn into the Big Bad Wolf from the Tex Avery cartoon “Little Hot Riding Hood” and start clocking themselves on the head with mallets. You feel that if you took her temperature at any point, it would read absolute zero. Zeta-Jones never raises her voice or gets steamed up; after a while, she begins to seem like the person involved with “Intolerable Cruelty” who has figured out the style it needs. She knows when to leave well enough alone.
Charles Taylor is a columnist for the Newark Star-Ledger. More Charles Taylor.
The Fix
Jessica Lange wows 'em at college, James Gandolfini sings with Kate Winslet, and Egypt looks for its own Pamela Anderson. Plus: Is Bill Gates cheap?
Everyone and his brother and sister did the commencement speech thing this weekend and politics was definitely in the air. Former prez Bill Clinton blasted prez George Bush‘s opposition to affirmative action in a speech at Tougaloo College in Mississippi, V.P. Dick Cheney told University of Missouri graduates to “look for the unexpected opportunities” in life, and Sen. Rick Santorum spoke to seven-eighths of the graduating class of St. Joseph’s University (the rest walked out on him) about loving one another, even when we disagree (we assume no mention of man-dog love was made). (Washington Post)
Continue Reading CloseKaren Croft is the editor of Salon Sex. More Karen Croft.
“O Brother, Where Art Thou?”
Dogpatch rapture! The new film from the Coen brothers turns the Depression into a crackpot American fairy tale.
If Mad magazine had attempted to do “Let Us Now Praise Famous Men” the result might be “O Brother, Where Art Thou?” The Coen brothers’ new movie is a monkeyshines ramble through the iconography of the Depression South. It invokes the images familiar from the photographs of Walker Evans and Dorothea Lange — shanty shacks, ragamuffin children, big-bellied bosses in summer suits — as well as books and movies of the era, like “The Grapes of Wrath” and “I Am a Fugitive From a Chain Gang” and the musicals of Busby Berkeley.
Continue Reading CloseCharles Taylor is a columnist for the Newark Star-Ledger. More Charles Taylor.
Noir way out
Jonathan Lethem reviews 'Hit Me,' directed by Steve Shainberg and starring Elias Koteas, Laure Marsac and William H. Macy.
For filmgoers with a keen eye for writer’s credits, Steve Shainberg’s neo-noir “Hit Me” offers an intriguing two-for-one: noir legend Jim Thompson’s novel “A Swell-Looking Babe” adapted for the screen by Denis Johnson, author of “Fiskadoro,” “Jesus’ Son” and many other haunting, enigmatic volumes of fiction and poetry. The lead actor, setting and premise of “Hit Me” are promising as well: Elias Koteas (“The Adjuster,” “Exotica,” “Crash”) plays Sonny, a desperate, scuffling night bellhop in the ominous and claustrophobic Stillwell Hotel, where a sequence of seemingly random bad turns draws him into the sucker role in a violent robbery scheme.
Continue Reading CloseJonathan Lethem's most recent novel is "Motherless Brooklyn." More Jonathan Lethem.
Sharps and Flats: Soundtrack from “The Big Lebowski”
I‘ve only seen the trailer for “The Big Lebowski,” but I’m convinced the Coen brothers’ new film isn’t half as good as the soundtrack that accompanies it. Based on 60 seconds of evidence, the movie is an uneasy blend of “Fargo” and “Kingpin” — a dark, high-concept comedy about “murder, greed and bowling.” Steve Buscemi and John Turturro offer indie-film cred, but the movie’s real stars are John Goodman and Jeff Bridges, who’s tricked out as a shaggy drifter named Dude (almost as improbable as the stammering lover he played in “The Mirror Has Two Faces”). My preview review of “The Big Lebowski”: not a bad movie, just a self-conscious attempt to prove that big box-office expectations haven’t tamed the Coens completely.
Continue Reading CloseKeith Moerer is a regular contributor to Salon. More Keith Moerer.
Page 5 of 5 in Coen Brothers