David Paterson

This week in crazy: Governor David Paterson

The New York leader says anti-cabbie violence is the inevitable result of not listening to him

  • more
    • All Share Services

This week in crazy: Governor David Paterson

I don’t think accidental New York Governor David Paterson is stupid, but he frequently demonstrates shockingly poor judgment. And he’s a terrible communicator (except, oddly, on sports talk radio). But this week, his muddled attempts to be a peacemaker in the hysterical mosque controversy finally became flat-out nuts.

It started two weeks ago, when Paterson joined the chorus of people declaring that the Park51 Islamic community center proposed for lower Manhattan be moved. He even said the state would help them find and buy a new location, further away from the World Trade Center site (not necessarily out of “sensitivity,” but more in order to make the angry people shut up — a noble, completely misguided goal). The only problem with this plan is that it made no sense and was probably unconstitutional.

Then Paterson said he was going to meet with the Park51 organizers, in order to convince them to support his weird and bad plan. This wasn’t really true. (Although Paterson did meet with Archbishop Timothy Dolan, who really has nothing to do with anything.) Still, Paterson insisted that everyone was on board, and at this point he was citing Rudy Giuliani, which is a probable sign that he’s just losing it.

Also losing it, in a more serious sense, was Michael Enright, a film student, fixated on the Afghanistan war, who, in an apparent racist, drunken rage, viciously slashed a Muslim cab driver in Manhattan on Tuesday night. Was the crime related to a general uptick in anti-Muslim sentiment, across the nation, localized in New York? It’s impossible to tell. But Paterson thought this statement was appropriate:

“The potential for this kind of violence is one of the reasons why I have called publicly for a respectful and unifying conversation about the Park51 project. I continue to offer my assistance for an open dialogue that I believe will help to bring New Yorkers together.

The implication is that Muslims have it coming — that they can expect more slashings, as long as they refuse to meet with Paterson to plan a different way forward. (Paterson then attempted to educate Americans on different kinds of Muslims.)

I think David Paterson means well. But he’s sounding completely nuts.

Continue Reading Close
Alex Pareene

Alex Pareene writes about politics for Salon and is the author of "The Rude Guide to Mitt." Email him at apareene@salon.com and follow him on Twitter @pareene

Who will attend Charlie Rangel’s sold-out birthday party?

The embattled congressman promises speeches tonight from Andrew Cuomo and Chuck Schumer (but they won't confirm)

  • more
    • All Share Services

Who will attend Charlie Rangel's sold-out birthday party?Andrew Cuomo, Charlie Rangel and Chuck Schumer

Are you going to Representative Charlie Rangel’s birthday gala tonight? More importantly, are prominent New York Democrats?

Rangel’s birthday party is always a well-attended party, but most years the longtime congressman is not facing multiple ethics charges. Rangel’s campaign sent out a memo claiming that Senator Chuck Schumer and would-be Governor Andrew Cuomo will both be speaking at the gala at the Plaza Hotel. But neither Cuomo nor Schumer have confirmed their attendence.

It actually sounds like a pretty kick-ass party:

Rep. Joe Crowley is to introduce the “master of ceremonies” Gov. David Paterson, who briefly wavered about sticking to his agreement to participate, but apparently is back on board. Other speakers include: Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver, Mayor Bloomberg, Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, and NYC Council Speaker Christine Quinn.

Paterson is, according to this memo, to acknowledge the presence of former NYC Mayor David Dinkins and his father, ex-state Secretary of State Basil Paterson. And then Rangel speaks. Dionne Warwick will take the stage after the congressman, and then do a “Happy Birthday” duet with Chuck Jackson.

Attendees supposedly also include Representatives Jerry Nadler, Anthony Weiner, Yvette Clark, Jose Serrano, Greg Meeks, and Chaka Fattah.

You want to be at this party, right? Unfortunately, public tickets are sold out. But keep checking CharlieRangel.org to see if more are made available!

Continue Reading Close
Alex Pareene

Alex Pareene writes about politics for Salon and is the author of "The Rude Guide to Mitt." Email him at apareene@salon.com and follow him on Twitter @pareene

Law prof: Paterson mosque plan may be unconstitutional

Governor's plan to provide state land to defuse the "ground zero mosque" fight could violate establishment clause

  • more
    • All Share Services

Law prof: Paterson mosque plan may be unconstitutionalNew York Gov. David Paterson listens to a speaker during a legislative leaders budget meeting at the Capitol in Albany, N.Y., on Wednesday, June 16, 2010. Paterson has given lawmakers a June 28 deadline to complete the state budget, which was due on April 1. (AP Photo/Mike Groll)(Credit: Mike Groll)

A plan floated today by New York Gov. David Paterson to provide state property at an alternative site to the organizers of the “ground zero mosque” could violate the constitutional prohibition against the establishment of religion, two legal experts tell Salon.

Paterson said today that he does not have a problem with the plan to build an Islamic center called Cordoba House near ground zero, but because of the outcry against it he made this offer: “if the sponsors were looking for property anywhere at a distance that would be such that it would accommodate a better feeling among the people who are frustrated, I would look into trying to provide them with the state property they would need.”

But, said Boston University School of Law professor Jay Wexler, if Paterson is proposing donating state land for a mosque or selling the land at a discount, the plan could be successfully challenged in court. “They’re really giving government aid to religion — the aid is the break betwen fair market value and whatever they’re selling it for. That’s almost like they’re giving a bunch of money to mosque,” said Wexler, author of a book on church-state legal battles.

In an interview with Salon, Paterson spokesman Morgan Hook acknowledged there are potential constitutional issues. “There are church and state issues here. Obviously there are very large concerns about how involved the state can be. We’re looking into that,” Hook said.

Hook emphasized that the governor was aiming to alleviate tensions by “offering to mediate a conversation between the planners and those who are against the project.” He said the governor’s office has not identified a plot that it has in mind and that in any case the governor was not proposing donating state land for free.

But Paterson’s comments raised the hackles of advocates of separation of church and state.

Barry Lynn, executive director of  Americans United for Separation of Church and State, told Salon there is case law barring use of government funds to house an entity that, like Cordoba House, is going to be used even in part for religious purposes.

“I think the governor should really back off this idea,” said Lynn. “When a private group wants to build a center that contains a mosque on their own private property they have a right to do that.”

Even a plan to sell state land at fair market value to the mosque organizers could be vulnerable to challenge.

“You start saying well the bidding is open and closed with this one group, that would raise problems,” said Lynn. “You cannot cut special deals with religious groups without raising constituional red flags.”

Wexler, the law professor, said that in the case of a sale, the state would probably argue “they’re taking an action that does not have a purpose to promote religion. The purpose is to avoid offense, or to diffuse this whole thing.”

Of course, we may never find out — no one has taken up Paterson on his idea yet.

Continue Reading Close
Justin Elliott

Justin Elliott is a reporter for ProPublica. You can follow him on Twitter @ElliottJustin

Paterson says he made initial leak to media

The New York governor claims he revealed to the media his conversation with Sherr-una Booker

  • more
    • All Share Services

New York Gov. David Paterson says he was the first to reveal to the media a conversation he had with the woman at the center of a domestic violence scandal involving a top aide.

Paterson told WOR Radio on Thursday that he was the first to say he had a conversation with Sherr-una Booker. She is a former girlfriend of David Johnson, an aide now on leave from the executive office.

Booker later failed to show for a hearing in the case against Johnson, resulting in its dismissal. Paterson says he didn’t urge her to drop the complaint.

Paterson didn’t say which media outlet he spoke with.

The New York Times first reported on the abuse report and the conversation. It posted a story on its Web site Thursday disputing Paterson’s comments.

Common Cause calls on Paterson to quit

The accountability organization that formerly supported the New York governor now wants him to go

  • more
    • All Share Services

A group that promotes accountability in government and had supported New York Gov. David Paterson is now calling for his resignation.

Common Cause Executive Director Susan Lerner said Friday that Paterson is unable to fully focus on the state’s fiscal crisis because he’s ensnared in two scandals that threaten his job.

Lerner says that Paterson deserves due process but that the state budget and deficit require full attention.

Attorney General Andrew Cuomo is investigating whether Paterson illegally contacted a woman who had accused a top aide of domestic violence. The state’s ethics commission has charged Paterson with violating a gift ban.

A Paterson spokesman says the governor is working on budget issues despite the scandals. He met with legislative leaders this week.

NY Gov. Paterson’s spokesman quits amid scandal

Communication director is the third major person in the governor's administration to resign since the scandal broke

  • more
    • All Share Services

The top spokesman for New York Gov. David Paterson is resigning and says he can’t in good conscience continue to serve.

Communications director Peter Kauffmann is the third key person to flee Gov. David Paterson’s scandal-marred administration in two weeks.

Kauffmann says he cannot continue in the administration plagued by the scandals that threaten the jobs of Paterson and those he directed.

His testimony and e-mails were critical in a state charge that Paterson illegally obtained World Series tickets and lied about it.

Paterson is also being investigated over contact with a woman who had accused a top aide of domestic violence.

THIS IS A BREAKING NEWS UPDATE. Check back soon for further information. AP’s earlier story is below.

ALBANY, N.Y. (AP) — A senior state Democrat tells The Associated Press that black party leaders in Gov. David Paterson’s New York City neighborhood hope to craft a “message calling for the governor to resign.”

The Democrat briefed on the meeting planned for Thursday night spoke on the condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the issue.

Black leaders at the meeting in Harlem could play a large role in the fate of New York’s first black governor.

A black Democratic adviser who also spoke on condition of anonymity says the Rev. Al Sharpton is expected to say he’s rethinking his support for Paterson.

Paterson is being investigated over contact with a woman who had accused a top aide of domestic violence. He also faces ethics charges over free New York Yankees tickets.

Paterson says he is innocent and won’t quit. His office didn’t respond to requests for comment.

Continue Reading Close

Page 1 of 6 in David Paterson