Harvard
Occupy Harvard gets the old college jeer
In the school of the 1 percent, griping greets the movement
Occupy Harvard, near a statue of the university's founder, John Harvard. (Credit: AP/Steven Senne) CAMBRIDGE, Mass. — It’s the height of recruiting season at Harvard College, and the big draws are, as always, the banks, the hedge funds and the consultants. A quick look at the Office of Career Services’ recruiting event schedule is revealing. This past week, there were internship open houses for the top-tier consulting firms McKinsey and Bain, the private equity powerhouse Blackstone, and banks from JPMorgan to Barclay’s to Citigroup. This week Bridgewater, the world’s largest hedge fund, Morgan Stanley and Bain Capital — the private equity firm Mitt Romney founded — are coming to Cambridge.
So when 800 students and sympathizers – demanding fair treatment for Harvard workers, divestment from corporations that abuse workers’ rights, and other actions to reduce the university’s contribution to economic inequality — erected tents in Harvard Yard on Wednesday night and began the Occupy Harvard movement (the media working group of which, in the interest of full disclosure, I am a participant), they didn’t enter the most hospitable environment.
And sure enough, student reaction toward the protesters was swift and negative. I Saw You Harvard, the university’s widely used missed-connection page that also functions as a forum for general griping, was overwhelmed with students complaining about the occupation.
The posts were filled with accusations of hypocrisy (“I saw you … OccupyHarvard protesters, camping out in your matching expensive tents, funded by the very institution that you fight against”), defensiveness about Harvard as an institution (“I saw you Harvard protesters … forgetting there are greater evils than a University with an incredible financial aid program”) and, of course, profanity (“OccupyMyAs*hole sounds more fun,” “Occupy Harvard needs to Occupy DEEZ NUTS!!!!!!”).
But more than anything else, students were bothered by the university’s decision to restrict access to Harvard Yard to those with student IDs, a decision most undergraduates blamed on the occupiers (who, for the record, have repeatedly called on Harvard to open up the yard).
It’s worth noting that in the history of Harvard protests, such a lockdown of the yard is very rare. The only precedent is the 1969 Vietnam protests, in which a group of 30 students, later swelling to 500, took over University Hall, expelling administrators, and picking up and carrying out associate dean Archie Epps when he wouldn’t leave voluntarily. (Epps, campus legend has it, bellowed, “Unhand me, motherfuckers!” as he was being whisked away.) Then, Harvard locked down the yard, and called in state and local police to force the occupiers out.
But subsequent protests have not resulted in a similar response. The 2001 living wage campaign saw nearly 50 students occupy Massachusetts Hall, which houses the offices of Harvard’s president, for three weeks, with almost a hundred sympathizers staying in tents in the yard each night. It was a far larger protest than Occupy Harvard is, drawing the support of 400 faculty members and four U.S. senators, and throughout all of it, the yard remained open.
And yet, with only 30 tents pitched, Harvard still insists on regulating access to the yard two days after the protests started. The move, which followed a long period on Wednesday night in which no one was allowed in or out of the yard, was undoubtedly designed to turn students against the protesters by making students stop to show identification on their way to class.
And it worked. David Wang, a senior, tweeted, “Occupy ‘Occupy Harvard’: Because 1% of students shouldn’t be allowed to make 99% wait in line to go through and out of the yard. #justleave,” an “I Saw You Harvard” poster complained, “Your ‘movement’ is restricting my movement and keeping me from getting to class and to my job.”
Other students gripe about the occupiers’ slogan, “We want a university for the 99%.” The mantra echoes that of other Occupy movements, but many a Harvard undergraduate has taken great exception to the idea that they might occupy a place of privilege within American society.
As confounding as this likely is to outsiders, some inside Harvard insist that the university’s generous financial aid package means that it represents a wide cross section of American society and that, by opposing Harvard and especially by criticizing its endowment, occupiers are taking aim at nothing less than the American dream.
Michael Cotter, a sophomore and a friend of mine, took to the Crimson, the school’s newspaper, to defend the university on just these grounds, writing, “Considering Harvard’s ever-increasing financial aid packages … it seems somewhat farcical to suggest that Harvard doesn’t want increased socioeconomic diversity.”
Harvard, indeed, has a lot of money, and a lot of that money goes toward financial aid. But that’s only half the story. The college admissions office brags that 70 percent of Harvard students receive financial aid – but that means 30 percent do not. And given that families making well into the hundreds of thousands of dollars a year can still receive financial aid, that means that over a quarter of students are from families in the very highest reaches of the U.S. income distribution.
Harvard, then, does not function mainly to afford economic mobility to poor students, but to entrench the position of students who were rich when they got here.
Other students, however, have abandoned all pretense of representing the masses. Students in Wigglesworth, one of the freshman dorms, grabbed a bullhorn and chanted, “We are the 1 percent,” “flip me some burgers,” and “fuck you, lazy assholes,” as student Daniel Backman reported in the Harvard Political Review. The sentiment continued last night as I went to sleep at around 2 a.m. in a tent in the yard. A gang of drunk “bros” wandered by the occupiers chanting, “We are the 1 percent,” with a few “Joe Pa-ter-no” chants in honor of the disgraced Penn State football coach thrown in for additional offense.
Some grad students in the tent next to mine shouted back, “Fuck you, you 1 percent motherfuckers!” One of the chanters responded, “Why are you in teepees? We all know you have iPhones.” A grad student yelled back, “I don’t have a smartphone! Fuck you, I grade your papers.” The bro moved on. His sparring partner may grade his papers, but he’s the one in the 1 percent. He knows who wins in the long run.
Dylan Matthews is a senior at Harvard College and a researcher at the Washington Post. Follow him on Twitter @dylanmatt More Dylan Matthews.
Future attack lines from Mitt Romney, self-loathing Harvard elitist
The former Massachusetts governor sure hates those Ivy League career politicians, like himself
Mitt Romney constantly attacks Harvard, because Harvard is where girly intellectual egghead elitists go to college, while Real Men are plowing tractors or whatever one does on farms, until it is time to Go Fight in the War.
This week, Romney gave a foreign policy speech to some veterans, and he really gave Harvard what-for:
Continue Reading CloseChastising those who may believe that if the United States recedes, so, too, will its enemies, Romney bashed what is often seen as a liberal bastion.
“That may be what they think in that Harvard faculty lounge, but it’s not what they know on the battlefield!” he told the vets.
Alex Pareene writes about politics for Salon and is the author of "The Rude Guide to Mitt." Email him at apareene@salon.com and follow him on Twitter @pareene More Alex Pareene.
Amy Poehler’s Harvard graduation speech
The comedian and actress wants you to remember one thing: Everything you see in movies is real
Amy Poehler at Harvard's commencement, quoting "Good Will Hunting." After writing a piece on funny movie quotes to use at college commencements, I was called by an official-sounding person on the telephone and asked what qualities make for a good graduation speaker. I guess because I can recite dialogue from “Good Will Hunting” and “Spider-Man,” I am now an expert on these things.
But I did point to Harvard’s Class Day Committee as having a good track record for picking great speakers. Between Ali G. , Conan O’Brien and Will Ferrell, this Ivy League knows how to keep young adults in their seats and not fidgeting. Graduating students want to witness a living legend, yes, but they also want to be entertained. Too often schools pick someone important or famous without considering whether or not they will be able to translate their years of wisdom and experience into something graduates will absorb. With the assumption that actions speak louder than words, graduation committees often forget that when it comes to speeches, it’s actually the other way around.
Continue Reading CloseDrew Grant is a staff writer for Salon. Follow her on Twitter at @videodrew. More Drew Grant.
I was the Harvard harlot
When I started a sex blog at 19, it electrified the Ivy League -- and taught me how to fear other people's judgment
A photo of the author in her Harvard years, left, and now Professionally speaking, I’m what some people call a “sexpert” (and probably what your granny might call a “harlot”). By the ripe age of 20, I’d already written an explicit sex blog, moonlighted as a dating columnist, and had college classmates trade naked photos of me like baseball cards. Since I’ve graduated, I’ve made a living speaking about and reporting on sex. So when Marie Claire approached me (along with four other women) about a story on my sexual history and number of partners last fall, it seemed like the perfect opportunity to talk about double standards. There was only one glaring problem: It brought me back to a person I tried mightily not to be anymore, and the “fearless” sexual provocateur they were hoping to interview was now terrified what others might think.
Continue Reading CloseLena Chen is a blogger, writer and speaker on sex, gender and feminism. She blogs daily at TheChicktionary.com. More Lena Chen.
Donald Trump’s personal experience with questionable Ivy League admittance standards
The prospective candidate accuses the president of being unqualified for the Ivy Leagues -- like his son-in-law was
President Obama, Jared Kushner, Donald Trump Donald Trump added a blatantly race-baiting component to his already racially charged campaign against Barack Obama’s Americanness this week when he claimed — based on things he’s “heard” — that Obama was a “terrible student” who got into Columbia and then Harvard based solely on affirmative action:
Continue Reading Close“How does a bad student go to Columbia and then to Harvard? I’m thinking about it, I’m certainly looking into it. Let him show his records,” he said, without providing backup for his claim.
Trump added, “I have friends who have smart sons with great marks, great boards, great everything and they can’t get into Harvard.”
Alex Pareene writes about politics for Salon and is the author of "The Rude Guide to Mitt." Email him at apareene@salon.com and follow him on Twitter @pareene More Alex Pareene.
Harvard to allow ROTC back on campus
After 41 years in defiant protest against military policies the nation's oldest university will help train soldiers
Memorial Church in Harvard Yard The Reserve Officer Training Corps’ four-decade exile from Harvard University campus ends Friday with an agreement that was spurred by a congressional vote allowing gays to serve openly in the military.
Harvard President Drew Gilpin Faust and Navy Secretary Ray Mabus are scheduled to sign an agreement Friday that will establish the Naval ROTC’s formal presence on campus for the first time since the Vietnam War era, the university announced Thursday.
ROTC first exited amid anti-war sentiment, and the school lately kept it off campus and stopped funding the program because of the policy that prevented gays from serving openly. But Faust said she had worked toward ROTC’s return after Congress repealed the so-called “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy in December.
Continue Reading ClosePage 1 of 13 in Harvard