Marilyn Monroe

Attention starlets: Please stop channeling Marilyn Monroe

As a new Marilyn biopic arrives, Lady Gaga, Lindsay Lohan and more keep mimicking Monroe's moves. Enough already

  • more
    • All Share Services

Attention starlets: Please stop channeling Marilyn MonroeThe painting "Marilyn Monroe" by the artist Alexander Timofeev (Credit: AP)

Just in case you thought the news that occasional morgue worker, temporary L.A. jail resident, and all-around train wreck Lindsay Lohan posing for Playboy wasn’t agonizingly predictable enough, the magazine has announced that the photos will be a “classic tribute inspired by the original Tom Kelley nude pictorial of Marilyn Monroe.” Oh, please, make it stop.

Of all the dead idols that we keep digging up, Marilyn Monroe crushes all competition. Sorry, Elvis. Sorry, James Dean. There’s only so much to be done with sparkly jumpsuits and nice black pullovers. But Marilyn? She’s almost inexhaustible. Note: almost.

Nearly 50 years after the former Norma Jeane Baker’s death, the Marilyn homage has become the most clichéd thing possible for a starlet and a photographer. Which Marilyn do you want? Britney’s youthful, boop-a-doop Marilyn, shilling for Pepsi? Jennifer Lopez’s whacked out, poured into her dress, “Happy Birthday” Marilyn, serenading George Lopez? Steely blond Rihanna for Vogue? Scarlett Johansson’s tousled, Joe DiMaggio-era Dolce and Gabbana Marilyn? Kate Upton’s zombie twist on “Seven Year Itch” Marilyn? Nicole Kidman’s fragile “Some Like It Hot” incarnation? Kim Kardashian’s “tooling around with Arthur Miller” period Monroe? Last month, even Lady Gaga put her own spin on the star, wearing a flesh-colored outfit as she performed for Mis-ter Pres-i-dent Bill Clinton. At least Michelle Williams’ reincarnation of Marilyn comes with a full new movie attached, possibly even written by a human who didn’t just stop the concept at the words “Marilyn” and “Monroe.”

Then there are the Marilyn Hall of Famers. Let’s give a special shout-out, then, to Gwen Stefani, Christina Aguilera, Paris Hilton, every Guess jeans ad campaign, and all-time-champion Madonna, who have again and again throughout their careers proven a fierce determination to ride Marilyn Monroe’s image all the way to their own graves. Well done, folks. Even Monroe herself got tired of playing Marilyn Monroe after just 36 years. Would that she’d had your collective stamina in this onslaught of Monroe-verload.

But the one woman currently most hell-bent on filling the icon’s Chanel No. 5 has to be Lindsay Lohan. In 2008, she re-created Bert Stern’s legendary nude “last sitting” with Monroe for New York magazine, in a spread shot by Stern himself. “It was very similar, déjà vu you might say,” Stern said of the experience. “Like revisiting an old street.” And what’s more interesting than walking down an old street? Oh, that’s right — everything.

Now, both Playboy and Lohan are going down another old street, this time with Tom Kelley’s notorious 1949 pinup images of the very young and very naked starlet. It’s nothing if not proof that Playboy and Lohan combined have not enough spark or creativity to do something that isn’t itself derivative of an idea even Anna Nicole Smith already covered before she shuffled off this mortal coil.

In a statement, a rep for the dentally challenged actress said Monday that “The pictorial is absolutely fantastic and very tasteful.” Hefner himself has assured readers hungry to feast upon the spectacle of a troubled star posing as a troubled and dead star that “Oh yes,” Lohan goes full monty for the pictures. But he adds that the whole thing is “classy. Very classy.” At this point, the Playboy/Lohan definition of “very classy” seems to be “anything shy of a vagina cam.”

Would the Monroe myth be so indelible if she’d settled down and had a family? If she’d grown old and died like a mere mortal woman? Or is the fascination because she stayed forever youthful, forever vulnerable, forever a big hot mess? Disaster has its allure, for sure. But the constant dredging up of Marilyn stopped being sexy and interesting a long time ago. And though fulfilling morbid curiosity while providing sad spank fodder may be the only career option left for Lohan — assuming she’s not really into that gig down at the morgue — it’s time she and her platinum-tressed, baby-voiced ilk took a goddamn hike. Because at this point, the Marilyn thing isn’t like some some cute musical number from “Gentlemen Prefer Blondes.” Instead it’s like an episode of “American Horror Story” — a freaky alternative reality, one in which a long deceased beauty just keeps clawing her way back into willing new bodies, again and again and again – and boring her victims to death.

Mary Elizabeth Williams

Mary Elizabeth Williams is a staff writer for Salon and the author of "Gimme Shelter: My Three Years Searching for the American Dream." Follow her on Twitter: @embeedub.

Are short-haired women less attractive?

Michelle Williams says only gay men and her girlfriends like her pixie cut. Why is long hair still sexy's standard?

  • more
    • All Share Services

Are short-haired women less attractive?Michelle Williams (Credit: AP/Peter Kramer)

It seems impossible — how could Marilyn Monroe be undesirable? Yet in a new interview with Elle, Michelle Williams, who plays the doomed blond bombshell in “My Week With Marilyn,” admits that her real-life look has never won her too many fans. Speaking about her trademark short-cropped hair, Williams says that “I’ve really grown into it — I feel like myself with short hair. And it’s been a really long time since I had long hair, five years.” But Williams admits that her daughter, Matilda, “would love … her mum to grow out the cropped hair, though that’s unlikely to happen any time soon.” The only people who like it, she says, are gay men and my girlfriends. “Straight men across the board are not into this hair!” Well, one man was — in a reference to her ex-fiance, Heath Ledger, who died in 2008, she says, “I cut it for the one straight man who has ever liked short hair and I wear it in memorial of somebody who really loved it.”

Why do so many people – from 6-year-old girls to nearly every straight man on the planet – have a thing for long hair? True, the flowing mane has always had a powerful allure – Shakespeare wrote of his lady’s hair as “threads of beaten gold” and wavy-haired ladies milk that pre-Raphaelite thing to this day. But the iconic, much-imitated Dorothy Hamill and Princess Diana cuts trend only briefly, before giving way again to Paris Hilton and Tyra Banks-level super weaves.  Gone are the days when you could even have a token Cynthia Nixon short-haired chick on your television ensemble — now it’s all Sofia Vergara and Whitney Cummings. The closest thing to a short-haired TV star is Judge Judy.

And just as surely as contemporary females are expected to have zero hair anywhere on their bodies, they’re considered unusual if they aren’t rocking a Taylor Swift-like follicular cascade. Behold the current Maxim 100 — not a short-haired image in the bunch, even of Maxim-designated hotties and sometime-pixies Rihanna, Emma Watson and Natalie Portman. Clearly, flowing locks are a source of power. That’s why it’s such a shock when actresses like Williams lop off their hair – and why they’re often in a hurry to get it back. Julia Roberts shaved for “Hook” 20 years ago, and has been all trademark waves ever since. Demi Moore famously went shorn for “Ghost” and “G.I. Jane,” then quickly returned to waist-length tresses. Perhaps most notably, Gwyneth Paltrow’s moment of shortness in “Sliding Doors” was a blip in a career spent behind a princess blond mane.

In many quarters, a woman cutting her hair is still seen as a woman committing an act of rebellion. She’s a troublemaking Sinead O’Connor ripping up the pope’s picture, a defiantly post-”Harry Potter” Emma Watson, a brazenly weird Amber Rose. She can be as traffic-stopping stunning as Winona Ryder in her Gen-X heyday, as hot as Halle Berry emerging from the surf in a James Bond movie, or as fierce as Keira Knightley kicking ass in “Domino” — and there’s still an implied “I’m just sticking it to the man” subtext to her do.

Sometimes, short hair is the beer gut for ladies. Among a certain segment of my mother’s and grandmother’s generations, a short cut was an admission that you were middle-aged and no longer interested in making the effort. But for plenty of women, hair is just a canvas upon which to creatively express themselves. For them, short hair isn’t an admission of defeat – it’s an expression of a style that doesn’t have to fit into the Anne Hathaway mold. The notion that our hair has to conform to rigid parameters is as ludicrous as the idea that our bodies do. Because, really, what’s sexier than a woman who, like Williams, says she feels comfortable with herself? And if the little girls and straight men don’t quite get it, it’s a good thing that the woman gorgeous enough to embody Marilyn Monroe, the goddess whose own platinum tresses frequently never grazed her shoulders, does.

Continue Reading Close
Mary Elizabeth Williams

Mary Elizabeth Williams is a staff writer for Salon and the author of "Gimme Shelter: My Three Years Searching for the American Dream." Follow her on Twitter: @embeedub.