Park51

Presenting The Baitys

Our awards for the most egregiously race-baiting campaign ads of the year

  • more
    • All Share Services

Presenting The Baitys

Are you scared of gang-banging Mexican illegals? Islamic sleeper cell jihadists? Chinese people? Then this was the election cycle for you! From the primaries through the week before election day, America’s been blanketed with race-baiting political campaign ads from insufficiently guarded border to shining sea. Today’s the day when those countless hours spent by soulless political consultants poring over stock images of young Latino men looking for the shot that screams “about to kidnap your daughter” pays off. (Election day, historically, is also that day.) We’re proud to present the first annual Salon Baity Awards for Excellence in the Field of Race-baiting.

(There will be no live ceremony, so we ask you to please just imagine that the winners in each category were introduced by an oddly mismatched couple of celebrities, like Katherine Heigl and Pau Gasol.)

Best Attempt at Convincing People That Mexican Immigrants Are Drug-running Cartel Assassins

First up, California gubernatorial candidate Meg Whitman wins an honorary Baity for putting the border fence in her ads, then lying about it, then running a Spanish-language ad claiming that she’s against the Arizona immigration law.

Our next Baity winner is one-time victim of a race-baiting whisper campaign John McCain. Senator McCain once honorably refused to support the flying of the Confederate flag. Then, ten years ago, he folded on that issue for reasons of political expediency, so I’m not sure why everyone is being such a baby about him folding on everything else he ever pretended to believe in. This ad is shameless primarily because John McCain was once a major supporter of comprehensive immigration reform (a.k.a. “shamnesty”) — but once he ended up in a primary campaign against a more conservative challenger, McCain decided remaining in the Senate was more important than standing up for the rights of immigrants. So: Complete the danged fence!

Next up: Nevada’s Sharron Angle, who just may defeat Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, despite the fact that basically everyone acknowledges that she’s crazy. Angle shot out to an early lead with her “Thanks, Pal” ad explaining how much Harry Reid loves Mexicans, who are scary.

The original ad was scrubbed from YouTube after a copyright complaint by a Reuters photographer, but you can see it at the beginning of this clip from The Young Turks. You’ll note that happy, white college graduates are compared to young Latino men in backwards baseball caps. Reid wants to give the Mexican ones in-state college tuition, which is for some reason horrible, because we must never allow immigrants to go to college.

Angle quickly released another incredibly similar ad without the offending stock shot:

And another:

This ad — titled “At Your Expense” — explains that Reid “sides with Mexico” when it comes to immigration. (Mexico doesn’t want all those horrible Mexicans in it!)

While it looks like Angle is running away with the category, Louisiana’s David Vitter — incumbent Senator from a state that does not border on Mexico — has some anti-Hispanic fearmongering of his own to dish out. Vitter’s “Welcome Prize” is practically an insane piece of art, with its own Lynchian dream-logic.

Apparently Vitter’s opponent, Democrat Charlie Melancon, hires welcoming committees — with fireworks and brass bands! — to meet illegal immigrants at well-marked holes in the chain-link fence that protects us from Mexico (which, again, Louisiana does not share a border with).

But this, friends, was not the end of it.

Sharron Angle’s latest and greatest ad — our overall Baity winner in this category –squeezes more anti-Latino imagery and immigration fear-mongering into 30 seconds than you ever thought possible:

The professional announcer can barely keep up with the hateful script!

(This is the ad that made Joy Behar resort to name-calling, which was news, for some reason.)

Best Scaremongering About the “Ground Zero Mosque” by a Performer From Nowhere Near New York City

The fact that an Imam intends to build an Islamic community center in lower Manhattan became national news this summer, because Republicans are scared of Muslims. Our own Justin Elliott already rounded up the best anti-”Ground Zero Mosque” ads of the year to date. Who can forget this classic from a North Carolina candidate?

There’s this weird one from Ohio Republican Josh Mandel, which suggest that his Christian opponent attends a mosque:

The American Future Fund attacked Iowa Democrat Bruce Braley for considering the Cordoba House project to be a Manhattan-area zoning issue instead of a fundamental assault on our values:

Best Attempt to Make Everyone Afraid of New York City’s Hundreds of Thousands of Muslim Residents by a Local Politician

While a national Republcan group gained attention for trying and failing to air a brutal anti-Muslim ad featuring footage of 9/11 in New York TV markets, this category belongs to Buffalo-area developer and America’s angriest gubernatorial candidate Carl Paladino. Paladino won an upset primary victory over longtime loser Rick Lazio thanks in part to being even more against the mosque project than his anti-mosque opponent. Paladino promised to blatantly violate the constitution and use the power of the government to block the construction of a religious building, because of The Terror:

Congratulations on your Baity, Carl! Go celebrate with your many Muslim friends.

Best Ad Intended to Make People Resent Asians, For Some Reason

A Chamber of Commerce-linked group called “Americans for Job Security” aired this ad, featuring Indian people thanking Blanche Lincoln primary challenger Bill Halter for sending them all of America’s jobs.

This commercial from Spike Maynard, challenging Nick Rahall in West Virginia, explains that Representative Rahall is made in China, like our horrible bluejeans. There is also some really classy “Asian” music.

Nick Rahall wants to give your toy-making job to a Chinese person, who will give your children lead poisoning.

Rahall is also the victim of ads worthy of Baitys in the all-purpose anti-Arab category.

Rahall’s opponents want you to know that he’s Lebanese. Which means he loves Hamas! And he wants to “mobilize” Arab Americans!

Terrifying!

Craziest All-Around Race-baiting

I’m not sure why anyone thought this would work, but an anti-Harry Reid group sponsored a Spanish-language ad instructing Hispanic voters to stay home, because Democrats didn’t tackle immigration this year:

The ad, of course, was produced by a Republican who opposes Democratic proposals for immigration reform.

The message of these ads from a GOP congressional primary loser in Florida — featuring a literal “towelhead” — is that people with dark complexions are probably trying to blow up airplanes.

Then there was Tim James, the Alabama gubernatorial candidate who was sick and tired of people not constantly speaking English everywhere in his state at all times.

Finally, fringe Missouri candidate Glenn Miller receives a special Baity for Old-Timey Racism, for his Kansas City radio ads urging white people to “take our country back” from the Jews, and not, as today’s Republicans generally put it, the Muslim Socialists.

Willie Horton Lifetime Achievement Award for Exceptional Race-baiting

Former Roger Ailes aide Larry McCarthy was the man behind 1998′s “Willie Horton” ad, the harrowing tale of how Michael Dukakis allowed a black murderer to get out of jail for a weekend of rape and murder. (A sign of McCarthy’s brilliance: Horton went by “William.” No one called him “Willie” until McCarthy decided it sounded blacker.) That brilliant piece of fear-mongering about a furlough program started under a Republican governor helped George H. W. Bush win the presidency. The lifetime achievement award is named in Horton’s honor, but presented to the ad that most embodies the spirit of Larry McCarthy.

And, look at that, McCarthy is this year’s winner! McCarthy is the man behind that anti-Mosque ad attacking a random Iowa Democrat! The ad was one of the most shameless of the entire anti-Mosque campaign, cheerfully lying about Imam Abdul Rauf and assigning collective blame for 9/11 to the world’s billion Muslims.

But McCarthy wasn’t done. This month, McCarthy produced an ad for “Citizens Against Government Waste” designed solely to make Americans resent smug Chinese people, who will own us in 20 years if Barack Obama continues spending government money on infrastructure projects.

The “Chinese Professor” ad is a brilliant return to form for the horrible mastermind behind the original race-baiting campaign ad. We hope Larry McCarthy’s Baity helps fill the hole where his soul is supposed to be.

Congratulations to all our Baity winners! But they better not get too comfortable — 2012 is just around the corner, and I have a feeling that it will be filled with grotesque images of the darkest recesses of the resentful White American psyche.

Alex Pareene

Alex Pareene writes about politics for Salon and is the author of "The Rude Guide to Mitt." Email him at apareene@salon.com and follow him on Twitter @pareene

Christine O’Donnell advertises endorsement from bigot blogger Pamela Geller

The Delaware Senate candidate welcomes the support of an anti-Muslim writer who flirts with fascism

  • more
    • All Share Services

Christine O'Donnell advertises endorsement from bigot blogger Pamela GellerChristine O'Donnell and Pamela Geller

[Updated] Below, a screenshot of Delaware’s Republican nominee for U.S. Senate Christine O’Donnell’s “endorsements” page. We’ve got Mitt Romney, Jim DeMint, the NRA, Sarah Palin, the Tea Parties — oh, and look at that: Down near the bottom (right above longtime socialite and fervent supporter of the Afghanistan Mujahideen Joanne Herring) is “Atlas Shrugs” blogger Pamela Geller.

Pamela Geller, the main instigator in this summer’s anti-mosque frenzy, is a bigoted conspiracy theorist. She’s a liar and probably slightly insane. She regularly compares Muslims to Nazis. Geller’s called Barack Obama’s birth certificate a forgery, and Obama a Muslim. She published a lengthy “investigation” on her site in 2008 claiming that Obama’s father was actually Malcolm X. And Charles Johnson recently documented her many ties to far-right neo-fascist movements in Europe. Johnson has examples of Geller defending white supremacists and even genocidal war criminals.

She’s not the sort of person whose endorsement you want to advertise.

Update: Shortly after Salon pointed this out, O’Donnell removed the endorsement from her website — which upset Geller so much that she withdrew it.

Continue Reading Close
Alex Pareene

Alex Pareene writes about politics for Salon and is the author of "The Rude Guide to Mitt." Email him at apareene@salon.com and follow him on Twitter @pareene

Joy Behar and Whoopi Goldberg fail with Bill O’Reilly

I wish they'd beaten the Fox bully with the truth, rather than walking off their own set

  • more
    • All Share Services

Joy Behar and Whoopi Goldberg fail with Bill O'ReillyWhoopi Goldberg and Joy Behar

After watching the story explode on Twitter and Facebook, I was really looking forward to seeing Bill O’Reilly get owned by Joy Behar and Whoopi Goldberg on “The View” Thursday morning. I despise O’Reilly and his hour of bullying, “The O’Reilly Factor,” while “The View” is my favorite talkfest on television. Besides, having lived to talk about my own showdown with O’Reilly – where he ordered me to “Stop talking!” and told me I have blood on my hands – I know what it’s like to want to stalk off the set. I expected to think Behar and Goldberg humiliated O’Reilly by refusing to share their set with him, and I wanted to see that. I admit it, when it comes to O’Reilly, I can be a little bit petty and ungracious.

But sadly, I didn’t see that on “The View.” I saw O’Reilly flacking his latest vanity book project, “Pinheads and Patriots,” with his typical fact-lite, faux-macho “common sense,” about why building the Park51 Islamic Center near Ground Zero is “inappropriate” (what a schoolmarmish Bill-O word) – and why President Obama “separated himself from the voters” by affirming the site owners’ right to build there. It started off OK: Goldberg refuted O’Reilly’s argument by pointing to the 70 Muslim families who lost loved ones on 9/11 (The New York Times counted 60 Muslim 9/11 victims). When O’Reilly insisted that 70 percent of Americans don’t want to see the Islamic Center built on the site, Behar asked him where he got his numbers. (In fact, a CBS News poll found that 71 percent of those asked thought the choice of site was “inappropriate.”) Goldberg continued to ask O’Reilly, why, public opinion aside, Muslims shouldn’t be allowed to worship where they want, given their constitutional right to do so, and O’Reilly lost it, declaring, “Because Muslims killed us on 9/11!” Of course, that’s a lie: Islamic terrorists killed Americans, including Muslims, on 9/11, and I expected Behar and Goldberg to refute it. Goldberg started to, saying “What bullshit!” insisting “terrorists” were to blame for 9/11, and asking O’Reilly what religion was Oklahoma City bomber Timothy McVeigh (he was raised Irish Catholic, like me and O’Reilly).

But then Behar got up and said, “I don’t want to sit here, I’m outraged,” walked away, and Goldberg followed her, leaving an irritated Barbara Walters and conservative Elizabeth Hasselback to try to refute O’Reilly’s point. (Hasselback managed to blame Obama, insisting that because he retired the term “War on Terror,” now Americans have to say Muslims, not terrorists, killed us on 9/11. Got it?) O’Reilly wound up offering the standard weasel’s apology: “If anyone felt I was demeaning all Muslims, I apologize.”

It was disappointing to see Behar and Goldberg leave the stage. It’s not that they weren’t provoked; O’Reilly condescended to Behar, in particular. When she objected to O’Reilly’s opposition to the center, declaring “This is America,” the Fox bully told her, “Hold it, hold it, listen to me, because you’ll learn.” (I might have understood Behar walking off at that moment more than I did later.) And I’m not defending O’Reilly here; God knows he’s treated many liberal guests with contempt, belittling them, even cutting their mics. Maybe there was a behind the scenes conflict over hosting O’Reilly on “The View” to begin with, and he came on the show over Behar and Goldberg’s objection. But once he was on the set, they should have taken him down verbally, not walked away.

There was so much Behar and Goldberg could have said. They might have reminded O’Reilly that his own ancestors faced the same kind of bigotry Muslims do today, when they first tried to build churches in New York. I made this point in August, recalling the way the Know-Nothing party rioted and rampaged against Catholicism, burning down Catholic churches, schools and convents, from Massachusetts to Kentucky. Only last week, the New York Times told the story of Father Kevin Madigan, pastor of St. Peter’s Catholic Church in Manhattan, who realized while researching his church’s history that it had tragic parallels with the plight of the Park51 center. In the case of St. Peter’s, Protestants who thought Catholics (especially the Irish) were idol-worshipping heathens loyal to a foreign despot, the Pope, protested the building of the first Catholic church in what was then the heart of Manhattan. The Catholics caved, and built their church outside city limits. But Protestants still objected. On Christmas Eve 1806, they surrounded the church to protest that holiday of “popish superstition” (yes, America, we brought you Christmas! And a Jew, Irving Berlin, wrote some of your favorite Christmas songs!) A riot erupted, dozens were injured and a policeman was killed. The admirable Father Madigan has been telling that story in letters to his parishioners and in sermons, but modern day Know Nothings like Bill O’Reilly apparently gotten the message.

Here’s the Times story, and here’s a wonderful essay about St. Peter’s and the Park 51 Center by Father Tom Joyce from the Web site U.S. Catholics. It sickens me to see guys like O’Reilly (and my MSNBC debate partner Pat Buchanan) claim they speak for Irish American little guys, when they’re wealthy pundits who have become mouthpieces for corporate America. I wish he’d been confronted with his own religious bigotry more effectively.

There were so many ways to own Bill O’Reilly in that debate. I wish Behar and Goldberg had hit him with passionate counter-argument, not mute outrage. I thought I’d be thrilled to see them rebuke O’Reilly by walking off. Instead I was sad to see them stop talking, since as I learned personally, that’s what O’Reilly wants all liberal women to do.

 

Continue Reading Close
Joan Walsh

Joan Walsh is Salon's editor at large.

Uncle Sam wants you to stop being afraid t-shirt

By popular demand, a completely unauthorized opportunity to wear your patriotism

  • more
    • All Share Services

Many readers expressed interest in obtaining a T-shirt or poster featuring the Uncle Sam Wants You To Stop Being Afraid of Other Americans message highlighted here in HTWW on Wednesday.

One reader, Larry Peck, founder of TeesWithTude.com, went ahead and made it happen. The image isn’t exactly identical to the original, and, I hasten to note, it is completely unauthorized (I still haven’t heard a word from anyone claiming to have created the mini-masterpiece), but I thought I would pass the link along anyway.

I Want You to stop being AFRAID.

Andrew Leonard

Andrew Leonard is a staff writer at Salon. On Twitter, @koxinga21.

How to be a true (non-mosque fearing) American

A call to patriotism we can all get behind: Uncle Sam doesn't like scaredy-cats

  • more
    • All Share Services

How to be a true (non-mosque fearing) American

I do not know who created the brilliant Uncle Sam poster that illustrates this blog post, but I sure would like to find out. The person who originally shared it on Facebook told me he “found it online,” but doesn’t remember where. I googled madly but could pick up no trail. And that’s too bad, because whoever put it together deserves some viral recognition. Or T-shirt revenue. Or something.

Uncle Sam wants YOU to stop being afraid of other Americans, of other religions, of other classes, of other nations, of speaking out. You’re Americans first. Act like it.

This message gets to the heart of something very important. The conservative right likes to wrap itself in the flag and paint opposition to its values as un-patriotic and un-American. But tolerance is also an American value. And what is more craven than the fear that the American way of life will be undermined by the exercise of such a value — by our welcoming of difference, our openness to that which threatens us?

The forces of conservative reaction are afraid of gays in the military, of Muslims in downtown Manhattan, of presidents with funny names, of other languages, other cultural practices — heck, they’re even afraid of Halloween. That’s a puny, red, white and yellow understanding of what it means to be American. It’s embarrassing.

UPDATE: An unauthorized t-shirt version is now available!

Continue Reading Close
Andrew Leonard

Andrew Leonard is a staff writer at Salon. On Twitter, @koxinga21.

The most baldly anti-Muslim ad of the year

A Republican House candidate in the rural South makes the planned Islamic community center in N.Y. a top issue

  • more
    • All Share Services

The most baldly anti-Muslim ad of the year

If you thought the wave of anti-Muslim bigotry sweeping the country was over, check out this new TV spot by Republican North Carolina congressional hopeful Renee Ellmers

In the ad, Ellmers and a narrator refer interchangeably to “the Muslims,” “the terrorists” and the organizers of Park51 in New York as if they are one and the same:

NARRATOR: After the Muslims conquered Jerusalem, and Cordoba, and Constantinople, they built victory mosques. And, now, they want to build a mosque by ground zero. Where does Bob Etheridge stand? He won’t say. Won’t speak out. Won’t take a stand.

ELLMERS: The terrorists haven’t won. And we should tell them in plain English, ‘No, there will never be a mosque at ground zero.’

Ellmers is taking on Rep. Bob Etheridge, D-N.C., in North Carolina’s rural 2nd District, where Etheridge has a good shot at holding on to his seat.

But what is even more illuminating of the current moment than the ad itself is Etheridge’s response. Via Jeremy Jacobs at the Hotline:

Update, 10:50 a.m.: A spokesman for Etheridge says the congressman has never supported building the mosque near Ground Zero.

Continue Reading Close
Justin Elliott

Justin Elliott is a reporter for ProPublica. You can follow him on Twitter @ElliottJustin

Page 2 of 22 in Park51