State of the Union
From the Pundits: Obama’s corporate pep talk
Met with high approval ratings, Obama's SOTU -- particularly the please-all tone -- left some commentators uneasy
President Barack Obama delivers the State of the Union address on Capitol Hill in Washington, Tuesday, Jan. 25, 2011. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci)(Credit: AP) The takeaway quote from Obama’s speech sounds like a slogan: “Win the future.”
Apple’s seminal “Think different” campaign — which some say restored the company’s reputation — comes to mind, for some reason. But the association is apt according to the pundits’ reaction to the speech. First of all, the American people really liked the speech. According to a CBS News poll the approval rating on Obama’s second State of the Union clocked in at a cool 91%. (It’s worth pointing out that only 500 people made up the group polled.) The reactions from analysts, journalists, and talking heads varied somewhat, however. Here’s a sampling of the more insightful ones:
MSNBC’s Rachel Maddow calls Obama’s speech a “prayer to the free market” that sounded like “more of a CEO-style pep talk than a football rally style pep talk.” Watch:
Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy
Salon’s Andrew Leonard identifies the (glaring) missing word in the speech:
The unemployment rate in the United States is 9.4 percent. But if you went to President Barack Obama’s State of the Union address on Tuesday night looking for a job, you came away empty. The president did not even mention the word “unemployment.” The stock market “has come roaring back,” he told America, and “corporate profits are up.” But aside from one reference to “the shuttered windows of once booming factories, and the vacant storefronts of once busy Main Streets,” Obama devoted precious little time to the current plight of Americans who might be facing foreclosure or the expiration of their unemployment benefits. Instead he told us that the “worst of the recession is over” and “that we had broken the back of the recession.”
The New York Times Paul Krugman feels a bit “meh.”
Considering the rumors a few weeks ago, which suggested a cave on Social Security, this wasn’t too bad. Obama said that we’re going to do something about Social Security, but unclear what. And in general he at least somewhat stood his ground against the right. In fact, the best thing about the speech was exactly what most of the commentariat is going to condemn: Obama did not surrender to the fiscal austerity now now now types.
Overall, however, I have no idea what the vision here was. We care about the future! But we don’t want to spend!
Meh.
Slate’s John Dickerson dwells more on the corporate-speak:
“Win the future.” That was President Obama’s slogan for his State of the Union address, in which he used the phrase (or a variant) 11 times. Not only is Obama courting American business, he’s using tag lines from corporate marketing. But as the president spoke, the line sounded more like the title of a self-help seminar, with Obama in the role of Tony Robbins.
The Huffington Post’s Howard Fineman calls the whole affair “Love Train in the House!”
The president almost made John Boehner cry by praising him as a working class hero. That was to be expected. But in his tour-de-force of good fellowship Tuesday night, Barack Obama went further.
For an hour or so, he shrewdly (and in his own interest) ended the anger of our politics, even though he had been a full-throated participant in some of its mayhem minutes in the last two years.
Instead, when he was done delivering his feel-good, oh-so-sensible and sotto voce State of the Union address, I expected the sound system in the House to begin blasting the O’Jays’ classic–and to see the members dancing in a conga line in the aisles, Coors Light in hand.
The New Yorker’s Steve Coll, briefly:
This really is a much more mainstream American speech than his last one, which was very New Deal-ish. He supposedly read Lou Cannon’s Reagan biography over the holidays.
Think Progress’s Matthew Yglesias points out another omission of a divisive topic:
I thought it was a good speech; an example of trying to govern from the White House…
The tragedy we can see unfolding, though, is the way the president shied away from even mentioning the idea that climate change is a problem. That reflects political reality, but it also reflects the greatest failure of Barack Obama’s term in office.
More reactions to come as they roll in. In the meantime, check out the New York Times’ crazy real-time fact-checked fully interactive explosion of multimedia video coverage (complete with all kinds of things to click on!). Or you can watch the address and read the full text here on Salon.
Adam Clark Estes blogs the news for Salon. Email him at ace@salon.com and follow him on Twitter @adamclarkestes More Adam Clark Estes.
State of the Union 2011 liveblog
Our continuously updated analysis of America's new Sputnik moment
U.S. President Barack Obama during his first State of the Union address on Capitol Hill in Washington The state of the War Room is psyched for an investment in our future-winning Sputnik moment. The White House has a really cool website up where you can see who’s in the first lady’s box and the full text of the speech has already been posted. (Back in the dark, pre-internet days, only reporters would know what the President was going to say an hour before he said, and the rest of America didn’t get to share in their cynical boredom with the whole enterprise.) We’ll be updating this post until God Blesses America.
Continue Reading Close
Alex Pareene writes about politics for Salon and is the author of "The Rude Guide to Mitt." Email him at apareene@salon.com and follow him on Twitter @pareene More Alex Pareene.
The 5 best State of the Union drinking games
We're not saying you should get drunk watching tonight's speech, but if you want to ...
Many Americans will listen intently tonight to what President Obama has to say about the economy, Tucson, the Middle East and other pressing topics. Others will take the opportunity to drink alcohol. If you happen to be in the latter camp, we’ve compiled this handy guide to the five State of the Union drinking games we think will provide the best bang for your buck on this historic night.
Marc Melzer and Howard Deutsh’s game on drinkinggame.us:
This is the most basic of the drinking games we found, and therefore the most plausible. Think of it as your safe bet (in terms of the rules themselves applying to the speech, not in terms of health. If you actually play by all of these rules, you will die). There are simple shot commands for the Obama and/or 2011 general climate safe buzzwords (“hope,” “change,” “progress,” “civility”), shots for mentioning key Arab nations, and key domestic issues (“education,” “jobs”).
Justin Spees is an editorial fellow at Salon. More Justin Spees.
State of the Union liveblog tonight!
Check back at 8 for thrilling live coverage of the most important speech of the year
Tea Party Supreme Court Justices Antonin Scalia, Clarence Thomas, and Samuel Alito are expected to skip to night’s State of the Union address — David Koch’s invited them to watch the Clippers-Mavericks game projected on a massive screen at Lincoln Center’s 2,500-seat David H. Koch Theater instead, I think, unless I just made that up — but I will be here to liveblog the entire unpredictable and thrilling event. So come on back to the War Room at 8 PM eastern for up-to-the-minute standing ovation counts and close readings of the body language of the members of Congress silly enough to agree to sit next to people from the other party. I assume the full text of Obama’s remarks will leak online soon enough, too, so we can focus on the really important stuff, like Joe Biden’s facial expressions.
Alex Pareene writes about politics for Salon and is the author of "The Rude Guide to Mitt." Email him at apareene@salon.com and follow him on Twitter @pareene More Alex Pareene.
Obama State of the Union: Spending, but restraint
In his speech tonight, the president will announce a five-year freeze on discretionary spending
FILE - In this Dec. 6, 2010, file photo President Barack Obama, visiting Forsyth Technical Community College in Winston-Salem, N.C., speaks about the key to boosting American competitiveness, that it rests in the nation's willingness to invest in a more educated workforce, a deeper commitment to research and technology, and improvements in infrastructure, from roads and airports to high-speed internet. Under pressure to boost the economy the same message will likely be at the center of his State of the Union address Tuesday, Jan. 25. (AP Photo/Chuck Burton, File)(Credit: AP) Eager to show some budget toughness, President Barack Obama will use his State of the Union address to call for a five-year freeze on all discretionary government spending outside of national security, the White House said Tuesday.
The move is almost identical to the freeze Obama called for in his address to the nation last year at this time — his current proposal would cover five years, not three years — and ultimately it may have little effect. Congress decides the budget on its own terms, and Obama has even less sway than he did in his first two years on the job now that Republicans have taken control of the House.
Continue Reading CloseThe troops are not all right: how leaders are overlooking our soliders
Obama won't tell just how American soldiers are doing in his State of the Union tonight, and it's a shame
U.S. Army Pfc. Ryan Walsh, attached to Delta Company, 1st Battalion, 28th Infantry Regiment, 4th Infantry Brigade Combat Team, 1st Infantry Division, works security on the roof of the police station in the Hatamyia region of Balad, Iraq, Oct. 31, 2009. Soldiers from Delta Company visit the station regularly to build and continue relationships with local leaders. (U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 1st Class Steven King/Released)(Credit: Mc1 Steven King) Obama will touch on Tucson and the economy in his SOTU tonight, and he’ll reassure us that we are beating terrorism. He will talk about Iraq and Afghanistan, particularly the latter, affirming our success in driving back the Taliban and that we are on track to begin troop withdrawal in July, as planned.
Continue Reading CloseMichelle Fitzsimmons is an editorial fellow at Salon.com. More Michelle Fitzsimmons.
Page 2 of 15 in State of the Union