Stephen Colbert

Can”Vote Sanity” stop the madness?

The Rally to Restore Sanity may not identify the candidates driving America crazy -- but there are others who will

  • more
    • All Share Services

CanJon Stewart

The secrecy surrounding the “Rally to Restore Sanity (or Fear)” leaves everything to the imagination until noon Saturday. Or almost everything besides the touted performances of John Legend and the Roots, Mavis Staples and Jeff Tweedy, and Sheryl Crow — none of whom would be likely to headline a Glenn Beck or Tea Party rally. Hosts Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert can be expected to tweak Democrats as well as Republicans and to downplay their own political leanings. But if the satirists play true to the title of their event, what will they tell the hundreds of thousands trekking to Washington and the many thousands more watching the livecast? If the nation’s sanity needs to be restored, will they hint who might be most responsible for driving America over the edge? 

Neither Stewart nor Colbert is likely to exacerbate the risk they have taken by addressing such touchy questions directly. But some Democrats believe the “crazy” label will stick to Republican candidates, especially those associated with the Tea Party movement — and that sanity versus its opposite may well be the most effective meme to sway independent and undecided voters during the final days of the campaign.

Over the past several days, a group of progressive activists — including Erica Payne, Billy Wimsatt, Trevor FitzGibbon and Heather Hurlburt — has put together a hasty but creative effort to promote “Vote Sanity” as the closing argument against the Republicans. On VoteSanity.com, author and entrepreneur Wimsatt has adopted the colors and graphics of the rally logo, urging everyone going to Washington or attending one of the hundreds of satellite rallies around the country to bring “Vote Sanity” signs. (If that is too subtle, the site links directly to MoveOn.org.)

At VoteSanity.org, a site put up by the Agenda Project, there is an amusing video titled “Welcome to Crazytown” that reviews the kookiest antics of the Tea Party crowd, with the help of cartoon figures and a cuckoo clock, plus a helpful list of “ten signs someone is a complete wack-a-doodle,” with linked references to Sharron Angle, Carl Paladino, Glenn Beck and Nazi SS reenactor Rich Iott, among others. 

All of this may seem either desperate or whimsical, but “Vote Sanity” is based on more than simply ripping off Comedy Central. Behind the slogan is survey research conducted recently by Drew Westen, the Emory University psychologist and author of “The Political Brain,” who found swing voters strongly receptive to a one-line message: “We need leaders who hear the voice of the people, not people who just hear voices.” Whether those undecided voters actually know which candidates have displayed signs of derangement is another matter. 

But that is where Stewart and Colbert could provide important guidance — if they are sufficiently daring to “kid on the square” (as Al Franken would say) about where the anticipated GOP blowout might land us. Nobody should expect a partisan speech from these comic artists, but both can easily caricature the pretensions to fiscal responsibility, outdated nostrums, conspiracy mongering, shrill prejudice and nutso extremism that one party has exploited during this campaign.

Isn’t that what they do every night? And they wouldn’t even have to say “Republican.” 

Joe Conason blogs in Salon several times a week and writes a weekly column for the New York Observer. His latest book is "It Can Happen Here: Authoritarian Peril in the Age of Bush."

Steny Hoyer: Colbert an ‘embarrassment’

Leading Democrat goes on Fox News, pans Stephen Colbert's appearance at the House Judiciary Committee

  • more
    • All Share Services

The House’s No. 2 Democratic leader says comedian Stephen Colbert’s (kohl-BEHR’s) testimony last week on immigration was “inappropriate” and “an embarrassment.”

Colbert was invited to appear before the House Judiciary Committee by Democratic Rep. Zoe Lofgren of California. But other Democrats weren’t happy about her decision.

The committee chairman, Rep. John Conyers, D-Mich., asked Colbert to leave the room at the beginning of the hearing because Colbert has no expertise in farm labor issues or immigration policy.

House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer of Maryland tells “Fox News Sunday” he thought the episode was more of an embarrassment to Colbert than to the House. But, he added, “I think it was inappropriate” that he testified.

Stephen Colbert testifies before Congress, to the dismay of some Democrats

The satirical pundit argues for the legalization of undocumented farmworkers

  • more
    • All Share Services

Stephen Colbert testifies before Congress, to the dismay of some DemocratsComedian Stephen Colbert, host of the Colbert Report, testifies on Capitol Hill in Washington, Friday, Sept. 24, 2010, before the House Immigration, Citizenship, Refugees, Border Security and International Law subcommittee hearing on Protecting America's Harvest. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)(Credit: AP)

Faced with the inescapable fact that he is one of the two most effective mouthpieces for the progressive political agenda in the nation, comedian Stephen Colbert testified before the House Immigration and Agriculture subcommittee today in support of the legalization of undocumented agriculture workers.

It was weird. John Conyers initially asked Colbert to leave, but hearing chair Zoe Lofgren allowed him to stay. Colbert’s prepared testimony was funny, but fell flat before an audience of self-serious old legislators. “Apparently, even the invisible hand doesn’t want to pick beans.”

His comedic argument: Legalizing farmworkers would lead to less exploitation, making their jobs more attractive to Americans.

His opening statement:

Some good lines: “After all, it was the ancient Israelites who built the first food pyramid.” And Colbert’s great-grandfather didn’t come to America to see this country “overrun by immigrants — he did it because he killed a man back in Ireland.”

Some Democrats, being idiots, decried Colbert’s attempts to bring attention to the issue they were trying to bring attention to. Steve Cohen, who is usually pretty cool: “I don’t think he should be here. It commercializes the committee.” Rep. Cohen, what it does is get everyone on the Internet talking about your committee hearing, that would’ve otherwise been ignored. Colbert’s presence makes his young, liberal viewers interested in the subject of immigration reform. You guys theoretically want young, liberal people to care about what you’re doing, right?

Colbert is still taking questions, and answering with zingers, in character. It’s all sort of awkward and weird, but anyone who’d accuse Colbert of making a mockery of the issue has probably never watched a subcommittee hearing before.

And now Steve King is accusing Colbert of … something. Unpacking corn, instead of packing corn. King is starting an argument with a comedian about corn. He seriously attempted a gotcha moment, with Stephen Colbert, about a bit on his comedy program, which King watched on the YouTube. Which proves my point about who, exactly, makes mockeries of these things.

(Then Rep. Judy Chu noted that asking celebrities to testify before Congress has a long and storied history, with Republicans having once called on Elmo.)

Update: Colbert finally got serious, when asked by Chu why he cares about immigration. Colbert said he cares about people “with the least power.” He quoted the Bible, as he often does: “Whatsoever you do to the least of my brothers … these seem like the least of our brothers.” And, simply: “Migrant workers suffer and have no rights.” I think his willingness to break character like that proves the seriousness of his purpose. Now the committee is adjourned.

Continue Reading Close
Alex Pareene

Alex Pareene writes about politics for Salon and is the author of "The Rude Guide to Mitt." Email him at apareene@salon.com and follow him on Twitter @pareene

Wednesday link dump: I am a patriot

The cabbie-slasher's drunken rants, the worst Politico headline of the month, and the rich getting richer

  • more
    • All Share Services

Alex Pareene

Alex Pareene writes about politics for Salon and is the author of "The Rude Guide to Mitt." Email him at apareene@salon.com and follow him on Twitter @pareene

Page 7 of 7 in Stephen Colbert