Allison Hoover Bartlett

Bad fortune

When the nanny foretold disaster, my son gave me a lesson in blind faith.

  • more
    • All Share Services

Bad fortune

The scene creeps in again, dog-eared.

Julian is almost a year and a half old. The furniture is pulled away from the southern corner of the living room, where his babysitter, Liu Yen, practices Chi Gung each day. When I come home, Julian is lying in her lap. She holds his hand with the pink palm up.

“How was he today?” I ask, tossing my bags and kicking off shoes at the same time.

“Oh, OK,” she says, looking at her slippered feet.

She is still mad about our conversation yesterday. That must be it. I had told her for the last time that Julian must not go in any cars without his car seat. It’s not only dangerous, I told her, it’s illegal. I had tried to make my ultimatum less personal, less my own neurotic mothering. Liu Yen didn’t like being told to do anything. It’s why she married a younger man, a taboo in her culture. It’s why she took part in the demonstrations in Tiananmen Square. It’s why she left China.

“Is anything the matter?” I ask.

Liu Yen speaks softly, but her eyes are direct, sure in their gaze to the floor, then to me. She holds Julian’s fat little starfish hands that never stop grasping at things.

“I have thought many times to leave here,” she says.

She had been a chemist in Beijing, an apprentice to a scientist researching traditional Chinese medicine. She is precise, intelligent, spiritual. I was drawn to these qualities and to her warmth, her laugh, the way she lifted Julian from my arms the first day she met us and distracted him from a cry by taking him to the window. “See baby? See the bird. Ah yah.” He was transfixed.

Now Liu Yen opens Julian’s hand and strokes his palm.

“You are lucky I have stayed so long. It is too much responsibility.” She says “responsibility” slowly, getting every syllable right.

“You see,” she says, looking down into his palm, “his lifeline is broken. It stops here.”

She looks at me. I don’t understand.

“Whenever that happens,” she says, “there will be a terrible accident. I knew a girl who fell out of a third-floor window, and another, worse …”

I think I am smiling.

“But he will not die.” She lifts his hand. “You see?”

I am nodding.

“The line continues over here. But there will be an accident. That is why I can’t ever take my eyes off him. I sit by the cradle when he sleeps.”

When Liu Yen left for the day, I moved Julian from my hip to my heart and held him with both arms.

In the midst of this sort of trauma, the kind that breaks your faith, not your bones, things happen in slow motion. Fear brings astounding clarity to detail. Vision narrows to prevent sensory overload. When I was 15, a friend told me she was pregnant. She told me how they told her at Planned Parenthood. They said to her, “The test was positive,” and she was thinking, “positive, that means good. I’m not pregnant.” Then they said to her, “That means you are pregnant.” She remembers those words and the dent in the silver coffee pot with the black handle that sat on a small table across from her.

I remember flickers of that afternoon with Liu Yen: Julian’s hand in hers, the sofa with its pattern of bronze squares stamped on brown cotton. Between us there is something. I imagine that she has tossed me a stone, and I can’t catch it. It’s a rock that in traversing the arc between us grows bigger and heavier. I start taking steps backwards, sensing the weight of it coming toward me, trying to figure out how I’m going to hold it when it lands.

Six months later, in the July heat, we tethered balloons to the fence for Julian’s second birthday. Inside, twisted streamers crisscrossed the ceiling and the dining room table was pushed to one side of the room and covered in a paper table cloth. I can’t remember what was printed on it. I remember the tablecloths of other years, talismans of his changing passions: farm animals, pirates, the Beatles. Maybe I don’t remember this one because there were no pictures taken for his second birthday party. We left the moment it began.

We heard the first guest: It was his best friend, Coleman, with his parents. At last! Julian ran out to see them. As soon as he reached them and knew that the party was really going to be now, he turned and ran toward the house, a blur of blond. I turned away to reach for a bowl of chips to bring outside. Then I heard the wail, one of those screams that follows a too-long delay of breath after the thunk of a crash.

Then blood. Blood was pouring out of his mouth. I dropped the bowl and ran. Held him. Felt his blood soaking through my shirt. Brought him inside. Tried to calm him. Get a towel! I don’t know what happened! Calm him. He is arching his back. He wants me. He doesn’t want me. People are coming in. His grandfather, my father-in-law, laughs. It’s one of those tales we’ll tell, he’s already thinking. OUT! My mother shoos my father-in-law with a gentle arm behind his back. My own father, Julian’s other grandfather, slips up the carpeted stairs. There is nothing he can do.

We apply ice, and things begin to slow. His face is red from blood and tears and fear and rage. He is on my lap all this time, all these four minutes, maybe five. I can see: His tongue is still whole, but his lower teeth have gone all the way through his lower lip. His father, by nature so calm, raises his voice. Fucking shoes! He yanks the brand-new navy blue sandals from Julian’s feet.

And I’m thinking, is it bad enough? Is this swelling gash across his lip the break in his line, the empty section in his palm? And as soon as the thought comes to me, I know it isn’t. It’s going to be worse.

Over time, I allow Liu Yen’s prophesy to fade from my maternal consciousness. It recedes, and I relax, only to have it lurch forward with the unsuspected force of an earthquake.

Riding home from school when he is 5, Julian says, “Mom, I have a choosing question for you and you have to pick one.”

“OK. Shoot.”

“If you have the choice, if you could fly like a bird or swim like a fish under water for as long as you wanted, which would you choose? And you can’t say ‘either.’”

“Give me a minute,” I say. “OK. Flying.”

“Not me,” says Julian, “I’d choose swimming, because then I’d get rid of one of my deaths. I could never drown.”

A temblor of memory jolts me to readiness. It could happen anytime.

Only once did I tell friends, fellow mothers, about Liu Yen’s prophesy. They checked their own palms. Only one had a break in her life line. “Look at this,” she said, full of reassurance, “and here I am, still alive.” But what she was forgetting and I was remembering was the haunting story she’d once told us about how, while traveling in a foreign country, she was raped at knife point.

When he is 7, I hold a private vigil at circus school, sitting on an icy concrete bench, watching Julian’s body fly in a great arc on the trapeze that, like a sinking pendulum, slowly lowers him to the safety net. The pendulum weights time, and I hold my breath through every slow swing, every stretched second.

I keep meaning to ask Wendy how often they check the circus school’s trapeze, how recently they have inspected the condition of the lines, the riggings, the metal spools over which the lines slide as spotters pull, hold, and release. Watching Julian on the trapeze, I calculate the effect of one of the ropes jamming or splitting. It’s the remaining rope that would do the damage. It would send Julian in a 45-degree trajectory outside of the safety net. If one of the spotters is distracted by a voice calling, a fly on her neck, what happens to the rope? Is there a safety catch that would hold? When Julian lands, I exhale.

A few weeks after circus classes began, I get a phone call. “There has been an accident. We are closing the circus school until further notice — to check the equipment, make sure it’s safe.” Later I learn that an accident, through no fault of the school’s, caused a young woman’s death. I try not to think of the prophesy, but when I look at Julian I think: For now he is safe. There is more time.

For Julian’s friend Mila’s 7th birthday, she has a gypsy party. The girls are barefoot, all bangles and flowery skirts, with eye-shadow, rouge and lipstick calling attention to their innocence. Julian is a 7-year-old buccaneer in short black pants, one of my scarves wrapped around his waist, and his black felt pirate vest on top of one of my white blouses. A torn and faded blue bandana is tied across his forehead, blond spikes sneaking out.

After I drop him off, the fortune teller pulls up in a beat-up Datsun. I watch her wrangle herself and all her gear out the door of the car. She wears a colorful flouncy skirt, a white peasant’s blouse, and jewelry that sings with gold coins. She also wears sneakers and carries a boom box.

Mila’s parents tell me later how the children watched in silence as she turned the tarot cards. They were rapt as they listened to her describe who each child was and what might become of them.

“I am a knight!” Julian swoons when I pick him up. “I don’t remember his name, but he discovers important things. He’s also a leader,” he says, “I think.”

His bandana is turned around so that the knot is over one eyebrow, and his vest is half torn off his shoulder. He is breathless, running up the stairs and into our house.

“And see this?” he says, holding up his hand, palm to me. “I have a lifeline on my hand.”

I breathe.

“Here, give me your hand. I’ll show you yours,” he says, opening my hand, then without looking, turning his eyes to his own.

I wait.

“But see this?” he says. “Mine stops here, then it keeps going over there. That means I’m going to have an accident or something someday.”

Another breath.

Halfway through a box of raisins he looks up, into the space above his head and says to no one, “Maybe I’ll discover something really good. Maybe I’ll find some treasures.”

I haven’t seen Liu Yen since she left for school eight years ago. But the stone she threw is close enough now for me to see its pitted surface. There is a crack through its middle, and a shard has flown into Julian’s hands. He caught it without so much as a scratch, and I watch the rest of it spin through space, lighter now, flawed now, and within my reach.

Emotional insurance

Pictures of polliwogs, first baths and birthdays preserve my children in time, but I am always standing just out of the frame.

  • more
    • All Share Services

Two faces peer at me through 3-by-3-inch square windows. One is of Julian, my son, who is now almost 8; the other is of my daughter Sonja, 4. Their baby faces are positioned against a backdrop of heavy black paper, not yet anchored to the first pages of their photo albums. Over the coming weeks I will move forward, page by page, with an uncertainty of what I might discover about myself as a mother.

Flipping through stacks of pictures, I make two piles: Those to include in the albums and those to return to their envelopes. There are so many to choose from, so many I’ll have to leave out of these stories I’m about to tell. Yet the bigger challenge is accepting the difference between the stories in the photos and the stories in my memory. Again and again, I open an envelope and find one truth while remembering the same moments in time as a starkly different truth.

As I sift through the photos of Julian’s first years, I realize how random
the moments were when his father, John, and I were inspired to pick up a
camera. Even more unsettling is how random my choices are of what to
include in his album. Will a pattern emerge from the chaos? Will pages of parties, baths and beach trips form a kind of photographic fractal? Is it irrelevant which photos I choose? Maybe all I can hope for is that whichever pictures I paste onto these pages will tell one true story.

Halfway through my making of this album, we leave for Camp Mather, a family camp on the edge of Yosemite. It’s a jaw-dropping spot, deeply rooted among redwoods and blue jays and wild columbines. At night we listen to the crackling of dry pine needles as black bears tramp by, the sound of their breathing labored and close. In the morning we gather nets and buckets and head to the lake to catch polliwogs and minnows. I’m taking lots of pictures. But here, when I pick up the camera, I think of the albums. I do what I criticize others for: I let the recording take over the event. This, of course, has made an otherwise spontaneous task a painstaking, although engaging, act of internal and external documentation. Framing each shot, I’m aware of my choices: What I include for the sake
of content or line or color, and what I leave out.

While we were away, John took Julian, his friend Zak and Zak’s parents on a day trip. When they returned I asked John if he’d taken any good photos. While Sonja and I caught record numbers of polliwogs, scooped from the shady edges of the lake, I’d imagined Julian and Zak holding hands in mid-air, jumping into the river’s water. I’d imagined water rushing over ancient Yosemite stone, spectacular redwoods on either side, El Niño-fed wildflowers in meadows passed. “I brought the camera,” he said, and added with an accusing look, “but there wasn’t any film left.” So I’m left with my imaginings.

If I take a photo of, say, Sonja holding her first-caught polliwog in the palm of her small hand, does the image of that moment in my mind dissolve? In taking the picture, am I free to let it go, knowing I’ll soon have a 4-by-6 in my own palm? If so, when I see the 4-by-6 in its gleaming Fuji blues and greens, mat or glossy, it could become the only memory of the scene, the token for all the moments around the second the shutter blinked. When I first glimpse the photo, I may remember that Sonja had a new friend named Laura standing next to her, out of the frame. But ‘out of the frame” means that next year, maybe, and in 10 years, for sure, I won’t remember Laura. Then again, without the photo, 10 years from now I probably wouldn’t remember the polliwog twisting in Sonja’s cupped palm.

Something keeps me from savoring the sweetness of this photo. I know I’m making these albums for my children so they can see how abundant their lives already have been, and later, so that they can delight in their evolution, note how that tilted smile or hand-on-hip posture has been with them since forever. But I’m also making these albums for myself. When I turn the pages of the completed albums, I expect to find that the images have melded into a kind of flip-book, and that I will be left with either the elegant package of a mother’s job well done or the record of a job subtly but irrevocably botched.

I have fallen short, even done wrong, too many times. How has this happened? I try to piece together the parts — memories of regretted
moments, harsh words — in hopes of constructing a whole. There are the many moments of patience lost, the inability to deal with the child who won’t drink her glass of milk or put his shoes on. There are the many hours of lost sleep that cause me to say things I wish I hadn’t. It all sounds so trivial! Yet those outbursts of impatience accumulate. Add to them the many hours of not having time to read, not being able to enjoy uninterrupted conversations with anyone. As these fleeting moments of dissatisfaction with my role as a mother rise to the surface, they conceal depths of love. I’m sure my children can see the resentment on my face and hear the weariness in my voice. I fear these moments will define their memories of childhood.

Back from Camp Mather, I sit at my desk, licking photo corners and arranging pictures. I hold a picture from 1991. Julian, 1 year old, is pounding the keys of a keyboard with great flourish at my parents’ house. This is not something he spent much time doing, nor has he expressed any interest since in learning to play the piano, yet I devote an entire two pages of the album to this activity. I do the same for a bath. I hesitate, wondering whether I should let something like a bath take up so much room. Then it occurs to me that every bath, every meal, every cry, every nap taken together, took up so much room.

I pull envelopes marked “summer, ’98″ from a box. These recent photos are
perhaps the most surprising because the time between having taken them and seeing them again is short, yet in these photos I see Julian and Sonja as I never have before. When I look at them in person, I don’t see how they’ve grown — but put a layer of celluloid between us, and I see. I notice how thin Julian is and how long his limbs. Sonja’s neck has sprouted; her belly is not so round. In these photos, I see more than Julian and Sonja: I see a second-grader, dreaming of slamming a home run at Candlestick Park; I see a girl whose drawings of cats at long last are recognized by others as cats.

The camera lends another perspective, separate from my own. A couple of men I know, both fathers of young girls, are professional photographers. Often I have seen them shoot without looking through the camera. Mark, wanting a shot of Sonja and his daughter Molly hiding under the bed, crawls on the floor, stretches his camera-holding hand under the bed, looks up at the ceiling and clicks. Jason, wanting a shot of the aftermath of a 1-year-old’s birthday party — babies among wrapping paper, torn and strewn everywhere — reaches up above it all with his camera and clicks. They trust this other lens, which can reveal a surprise and spontaneity that a parent framing a moment cannot.

I know that if I leave the photo album I just completed in a drawer or closet, one day I will open it and discover stories I’d completely forgotten. I will turn the pages and be surprised by the faces that look up at me. Last week, I found an envelope full of photos I must not have looked at much before tucking them away. There were of me and Julian spending a day in Boston’s public garden. In one of the photos, we are strolling down Newbury Street when Julian stops, mesmerized by a sprinkler spraying water over a small patch of grass, a tended corner of urban garden. He stretches his starfish hands across the spray and laughs at the water. This is something I would have never remembered.

It troubles me that I — family photographer — am absent from most of the pages. “This is not the truth!” I want to tell them. I realize I want proof of my attendance, the light reflected off my hands cradling a downy head, captured on paper. But I also desire consolation. I can’t feel Julian’s sleepy infant face burrowing into my chest anymore. I can’t feel Sonja rubbing my long hair over her face like a blanket. Soon, I won’t be able to drop to one knee open-armed and watch her back up, then run full speed into me. Soon, I won’t sing to Julian at bedtime. Years from now my memory may retrieve these moments, or it may not. These albums are a kind of emotional insurance.

In years to come, I imagine going through these albums with Julian and
Sonja on either side of me. From first baths to birthdays, they recognize little until we get to albums of later years. When they’re all grown up and showing these photos to a new friend, they will no longer know whether they remember the event or the photo or the story I’ve told. The three will have become one.

Perhaps more than the stories themselves, what my children will remember
is sitting by my side, listening. There will probably be no photo of that, no 4-by-6 to remind them of how they leaned into my shoulders. Yet these images are only props. What I hope to give them is the knowledge — the thorough sense, the kind that can’t be forgotten, the kind that resides in flesh, bones and blood — that they were loved. And evidence of my having accomplished that is something I’ll probably never find in a photograph.

Continue Reading Close