Anita Chang

China group says U.S. uses Facebook to sow unrest

Perceiving threats to Communist authority, a government-backed think tank calls for scrutiny of social media

  • more
    • All Share Services

A Chinese government-backed think tank has accused the U.S. and other Western governments of using social networking sites like Facebook to spur political unrest and called for stepped-up scrutiny of the wildly popular sites.

As China’s online population — the world’s largest — surges past the 400 million mark, its Communist government is growing increasingly sensitive to any online threats to its authority. Although Beijing operates an extensive system of monitoring and censorship to block material deemed subversive, the Internet is still the most open and lively forum for discussion in a society where traditional media are controlled by the state.

Twitter, for instance, has emerged as a gathering place for dissidents and other politically minded Chinese wanting to voice their complaints and share information. Though the government routinely bans sites like Facebook, Twitter and YouTube, technologically savvy users can easily jump China’s “Great Firewall” with proxy servers or other alternatives.

According to a report released this week by the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, the sites also harbor an external threat. Social networking sites threaten state security because the U.S. and other Western countries are using them to foment instability, said the report, titled “Development of China’s New Media.”

“We must pay attention to the potential risks and threats to state security as the popularity of social networking sites continues to grow,” the report said. “We must immediately step up supervision of social networking sites.”

It cited unnamed U.S. officials as saying that social networking is an “invaluable tool” for overthrowing foreign governments. A comment by U.S. Defense Secretary Robert Gates that new communication technology is a “huge strategic asset” was also given as an example of the U.S. threat.

The report noted how Facebook and other social networking sites were used as tools of “political subversion” in the mass protests following the Iranian elections last year. They also played a role in the violence in China’s far-western region of Xinjiang last summer that left some 200 people dead, the report said, noting some online groups overseas had issued calls for independence for the traditionally Muslim area.

A spokesman for the U.S. Embassy in Beijing declined to comment on the specifics of the report because he had not seen it, but said the U.S. viewed freedom of expression as a “universal human right.”

“For us, it’s an issue of Internet freedom and we’re strongly committed to Internet freedom and oppose all forms of censorship,” spokesman Richard Buangan said.

Facebook, based in Palo Alto, California, did not immediately respond to an out-of-hours e-mail seeking comment.

Most of the overwhelmingly young Chinese Internet users go online just to chat, play games, listen to music and shop. Government-approved Chinese substitutes for banned sites are readily available: Kaixinwang and Renren instead of Facebook, for example.

But China remains so sensitive to potential threats posed by the Internet that it recently issued a directive banning its troops from having blogs or personal websites, as well as visiting Internet cafes or online dating sites. Military experts said the steps were necessary to avoid compromising security.

——

Associated Press researcher Xi Yue contributed to this report.

Loveless Chinese troops banned from online dating

Military expert says some soldiers were leaking military secrets when chatting on the Net

  • more
    • All Share Services

Loveless Chinese troops banned from online datingFILE - In this Oct. 10, 1995 file photo, a Chinese soldier tries out a desktop computer at a computer exhibition in Beijing. Rigid restrictions on Internet usage imposed this month on the 2.3-million strong Chinese armed services are sure to cramp the already lackluster social lives of the predominantly young, male force. Online dating was given the boot, along with blogs, personal websites and visits to Internet cafes. (AP Photo/Mike Fiala, File)(Credit: AP)

What will the lonely hearts of the People’s Liberation Army do now?

Rigid restrictions on Internet usage imposed this month on the 2.3 million-strong Chinese armed services are sure to cramp the already lackluster social lives of the predominantly young, male force. Online dating was given the boot, along with blogs, personal websites and visits to Internet cafes.

It may seem harsh and out of touch, particularly for troops posted in remote regions of China who have little contact with the civilian world. But military experts said restraints are necessary to avoid compromising security for a Chinese military that prizes secrecy.

“Some soldiers leaked military secrets when chatting online, for instance, giving away troop locations. Certainly a large amount of secrets were revealed this way and the regulation has just blocked the hole,” said Ni Lexiong, a military expert at Shanghai University of Political Science and Law.

Plus, Ni said, “matchmaking for soldiers can be conducted in more serious ways, such as through introductions from families, friends, or their work units.”

China is just the latest country to wrestle with the sticky issue of Internet freedoms for its military, trying to find a balance between the demands of Web-savvy troops, who as civilians were used to sharing personal details online, and the need to maintain security.

After years of back and forth, the U.S. Department of Defense now promotes use of social media by everyone from privates on the front line to generals at the Pentagon as a way of spreading its message. For example, Adm. Mike Mullen, chairman of the joint chiefs of staff, has 20,000 followers on Twitter.

Most other countries fall somewhere in between.

“Cyberspace has been a gray area. This is a tricky issue because it straddles both personal and professional space,” said Ho Shu Huang, an associate research fellow at the Institute of Defense and Strategic Studies at Singapore’s Nanyang Technological University.

“The military is a reflection of society and how it responds will be a result of that. So in more closed societies, it’s easier for the military to say, ‘Don’t do anything. Don’t talk online. That’s that,’” he said.

Countries such as Britain and Israel allow troops to post personal information online, as long as it does not compromise military operations. The open approach has not always worked for Israel.

The Israeli military scrapped a raid on a West Bank village earlier this year after a soldier revealed the time and location of the operation on his Facebook page. In 2008, a soldier attached to an elite Israeli intelligence unit was sentenced to 19 days in jail after uploading a photograph taken on his base to Facebook.

The Chinese Internet prohibitions are a brief part of lengthy internal affairs regulations issued by the Communist Party’s Central Military Affairs Commission.

“Seeking marriage partners, jobs or making friends through the public media is not permitted. Going online in local Internet cafes is not permitted,” the regulation states. “Opening websites, home pages, blogs and message forums on the Internet is not permitted.”

It was not clear if troops would be completely cut off from social networking sites. The regulations do not apply to civilians serving in military research and training academies.

It’s also not known how authorities in China plan to enforce the restrictions. The regulations, posted on the Ministry of National Defense’s website, did not say how troops would be punished for transgressions. Phones rang unanswered at the ministry’s information office and questions submitted by fax were not answered.

Yet the prohibitions seem out of step in a wired society with 400 million overwhelmingly young Internet users in a country hurtling toward prosperity and global power.

“(The policy) is regressive in its understanding of technology, regressive in generational attitudes and regressive in transparency and attitudes we have of leading powers in the 21st century,” said Peter Singer, director of the 21st Century Defense Initiative at the Brookings Institution.

Chinese social networking sites and instant messaging programs are wildly popular. Young Chinese office workers chat online with friends throughout the work day. Internet cafes in small towns are packed with youngsters playing games. Ni, the Chinese military affairs expert, said in the past soldiers had been allowed to visit Internet cafes in plainclothes and some had become addicted to the pastime.

The stipulation that troops cannot “make friends through the public media” is likely to be unpopular. In recent decades, rank-and-file soldiers often drawn from poorer rural families and until recent years paid miserably have found it hard to find spouses.

A blog apparently written by a paramilitary soldier which has not been updated since the new rules took effect on June 15 features a poem titled “We Are Still Single.”

The Internet has been a boon, with a proliferation of unregulated online dating sites targeting military men.

The Chinese military now plans to attack that problem the way it did decades ago, when it arranged socials between military units and civilian work outfits with heavily female work forces such as textile factories. A report on a military news website said the Xigaze Military District in central Tibet is working with the local government and women’s federation to help troops find partners.

Ho, the researcher in Singapore, said the restrictions are meant to prevent people from getting an inside look at the military. He said security lapses don’t usually involve highly classified information, but rather small details that intelligence agents can use to piece together a larger picture about an operation or a unit.

“Most intelligence is based on really, really mundane stuff. History is replete with examples: the color of the sand, the types of uniforms they’re wearing, the kinds of vehicles being deployed, the number of people and what they’re wearing, whether they have facial hair, stuff like that,” he said. “That’s what militaries are concerned about, people piecing bits and pieces together.”

——

Associated Press researcher Yu Bing contributed to this report.

——

Online:

Dating site for Chinese troops: http://8181.com.cn/

Paramilitary soldier’s blog: http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/articlelist–1562068555–0–1.html

Text of regulation: http://www.mod.gov.cn/policy/2010-06/07/content–4162971–5.htm

Adm. Mike Mullen on Twitter: http://twitter.com/THEJOINTSTAFF

(This version CORRECTS spelling of “compromising” in paragraph 3)

Continue Reading Close

China nixes Mr. Gay pageant

Police shut down the first-ever event just before it started

  • more
    • All Share Services

China will not send a delegate to the Worldwide Mr. Gay pageant next month, an organizer said Monday, after police blocked an event to choose a Chinese contestant.

Police shut down the first-ever Mr. Gay China pageant just before the event started Friday, but organizers had planned to privately select a candidate from the eight contestants. They have now reversed their decision, so no one from China will compete at the pageant in Oslo, Norway.

“This was a very carefully considered decision,” said Ben Zhang, a pageant organizer. “We just cannot send anyone, the organizers and competitors came to this decision together.”

Zhang declined to elaborate on the reasons for not sending a delegate.

Worldwide Mr. Gay Executive Producer Tore Aasheim told The Associated Press that he was “saddened and surprised that the Chinese authorities took such steps.”

“China once again shows that they don’t honor human rights,” he said.

Homosexuality remains a sensitive topic in China. Gays are frequently discriminated against and ostracized, and any Chinese national who competes at the Norway pageant would likely be the target of uncomfortable scrutiny, especially after police canceled Mr. Gay China.

Police cited a lack of permits for canceling the pageant at a swanky Beijing club. Chinese authorities frequently cite procedural reasons for closing down gatherings deemed politically sensitive.

The pageant would have featured a fashion show and a host in drag.

Aasheim said that the Mr. Gay China organizers told him that they decided not to participate in the worldwide competition in Oslo next month after Chinese officials threatened to strip any attendees of citizenship.

“If any of the participants travel to Oslo, they won’t be allowed to return to China,” Aasheim said. “They’d risk losing their citizenship, losing their right to go home. It’s a cruel thing to do.”

He added that Chinese officials had confiscated the Chinese organizers’ passports.

In response, Aasheim said his organization plans to stream the Worldwide Mr. Gay competition in February online and to grant access for free to any Chinese Web sites that want to host the live video feed.

——

Associated Press writer Ian MacDougall contributed to this report from Oslo.

Continue Reading Close