Gary Kaufman
Last call for the Hall
Readers have their say about which players should make it to Cooperstown. Last of three parts.
Over the past two days I’ve talked about which position players and pitchers ought to make the Hall of Fame. Now it’s your turn.
The e-mails have been pouring in, and some major themes have emerged, aside from the usual major theme of questioning my intelligence, parentage and mental state.
One theme is that I’ve misjudged the criteria for induction into the Hall of Fame, that it’s easier than I think, and some of the guys I’m saying won’t make it actually will. This is not so much misjudgment as poor writing on my part: I didn’t make it clear that I haven’t been trying to predict who will make it; I’ve been talking about who I think should make it. The world according to me.
Another theme is oh please God no not designated hitters! Several readers wrote impassioned e-mails arguing against career DHs — Edgar Martinez, Frank Thomas and Jose Canseco were the ones mentioned Monday — ever being allowed to darken the door of Cooperstown.
While I’m no fan of the DH rule, it is a rule, and guys shouldn’t be punished for playing a legal position. Besides, I don’t buy the “all-around players only” argument. Let’s say Frank Thomas goes out and plays an indifferent first base for the next decade instead of being a DH. Would that keep him out of the Hall if he continues to put up monster numbers? No. So if mediocre defense wouldn’t keep a guy out, I don’t think no defense at all should.
I should take back one thing I wrote on Monday: In trying to make my admittedly eccentric argument that a guy should get in to the Hall for doing “a hell of a thing” — Roger Maris, Maury Wills — I mentioned that because of the consecutive-game streak I had no problem with the consistent but not dominant Cal Ripken Jr. getting in. As some of you pointed out, Ripken, a two-time MVP who consistently put up huge numbers for a shortstop, even before the current offensive inflation, was a dominant player in his prime. Streak or no, he’s in.
Some of you defended Robin Yount too. Well: I suppose. Will kids ever stare up in awe at Yount’s plaque? Maybe so. Not my kids though!
Otherwise, people seemed to more or less agree with my opinions to an alarming degree.
Anyway, here’s a list of players whom at least a few readers believe I left out of the last two columns, each with a comment by me. I know I said it’s your turn, but I get the last word because I’m the guy doing the typing. Get your own gig.
Craig Biggio: He’s a fine all-around player who moved from catcher to second base after four years in the majors, which is impressive. I think he’s just that next level down from Hall of Famer, but I wouldn’t be offended if he got in.
Will Clark: His first five full years in San Francisco were Cooperstown quality, but since then he has been just another pretty-good-hitting first baseman. Sweetest swing around, but not a Hall of Famer.
David Cone: Not enough really good years. No.
Andres Gallarraga: Lots of mediocre years in Montreal and St. Louis, and inflated stats from playing at Coors Field for five years. He doesn’t make it.
Mark Grace: I was surprised at how many people suggested him. Not nearly enough pop for a first baseman to be considered for Cooperstown. His career offensive numbers are distressingly similar to those of longtime utilityman Tony Phillips.
Jeff Kent: He’s hitting like second basemen just don’t hit, but he didn’t really come into his own until he was 29. If the three and a half great years he has had stretch into nine or 10, he’ll be an excellent candidate, but he’d have to keep this up till he was pushing 40.
John Smoltz: He had two spectacular seasons (1996 and ’98), but otherwise has been the kind of guy who’d typically go 15-12 while playing for the best team in baseball. A good, solid pitcher, but not a Hall of Famer.
Omar Vizquel: A very intriguing suggestion. The Ohioans who are campaigning for this slick-fielding Indians shortstop on the “if Ozzie Smith, why not Omar Vizquel?” ticket are on to something. Like Smith, a likely Hall of Famer when he becomes eligible, Vizquel doesn’t do much in the way of offense, but, like Smith, he’s the dominant fielder of his era at the toughest position. He needs to shine for a few more years, but if he does, I’d vote for him.
John Wetteland: I had kind of forgotten about him. A tough call, as relievers generally are. He hasn’t been very good the past two years, and one wonders whether at 33 that’s a permanent trend. On the other hand, before that he was excellent for seven years, which for a relief pitcher is about two lifetimes. I wouldn’t mind putting him in.
Searching for the real killers
O.J. Simpson smiles creepily on his comeback TV tour, hoping to win back our hearts -- and pin a little guilt on his NBC hosts.
I have $50.31 on me right now and I’m willing to put it up as a reward to find the “real killers” of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald Goldman.
O.J. Simpson went on the “Today” show Tuesday to hype his Internet appearance Thursday at AskOJ.com, where, for $9.95, he’ll answer any question from the public, as long as it’s not about his kids.
Simpson said he’s asked the sponsoring company to donate his profits to three charities. But “Today” host Katie Couric said those charities — including the Innocence Project (which uses DNA evidence to spring the wrongly convicted) and a summer camp for kids with cancer that Simpson helped found — were reluctant to accept the donations. That’s OK, Simpson shrugged, if they don’t want it, some charity will be happy to take it.
Continue Reading CloseHall of Fame hurlers
After Clemens and Maddux, which active pitchers are on their way to Cooperstown?
Monday we talked about which active position players were likely to make the Hall of Fame. Today we consider pitchers, who are a little tougher to judge. Especially relief pitchers.
Baseball showers honors on relief pitchers who rack up a lot of saves — a statistic that borders on the meaningless. How many times have you watched a “setup man” pitch out of a bases-loaded jam with a two-run lead in the eighth, only to have the “closer” come in and set down the side in the ninth to collect the save?
Continue Reading CloseWho’s going to Cooperstown?
Considering the definitelys, the probables and those intriguing maybes.
Carlton Fisk and Tony Perez were the recently retired players inducted into the Hall of Fame Sunday, which is as good a reason as any to consider which current players are headed to Cooperstown. (Note for you cub reporters: That’s what we call a news peg.)
Today we’ll consider position players. Baseball’s offensive explosion, which began in 1993 and really went nuts in 1998, may force the voters (baseball writers) to reconsider the “magic numbers” for inclusion. Traditionally, collect 3,000 hits, 400 home runs or 1,500 RBIs and, with a few exceptions, you’re in. Will that still be true when players who have spent most or all of their careers in the current rabbit-ball era start to become eligible?
Continue Reading CloseDropped like a chalupa
The Taco Bell Chihuahua talks about his sudden, shocking dismissal and considers his showbiz future.
The Taco Bell Chihuahua sits slumped over a picnic table at a Doggie Diner in this Los Angeles suburb with the misleadingly glamorous name. He’s wearing dark glasses and chain-smoking Dunhills.
“I fucking knew it, man,” he says, stubbing out a barely started cigarette on the tabletop and adding it to a rapidly growing collection under his seat. “Everything’s always ‘Cool, beautiful, man, we love your work,’ but I always knew deep down that I was just a dog to them.”
Continue Reading CloseShocking allegation
It seems that Don King may have acted improperly.
You’re just not going to believe this: Don King may be facing another investigation.
The New York Post is reporting that the state of New York will look into whether the electric-haired boxing promoter illegally lobbied Democratic assemblymen to vote against a gambling bill that would have blocked a new Indian-owned casino in the Catskills.
New York state law requires that those who do more than $2,000 worth of lobbying be registered with the state Lobbying Commission, which records show King was not. Several members of the Assembly told the Post they’d received calls from King urging them to vote against the bill, although Assemblyman Herman “Denny” Farrell of Manhattan, the head of the Ways and Means Committee, admitted, “I was very confused as to what side he was on.” If you’ve ever heard King speak, you know what he means.
Continue Reading ClosePage 1 of 6 in Gary Kaufman