Hillary Frey

Bad boy blues

In a fantastical finale, Ryan gets back in touch with his inner thug. Is it enough to save "The O.C."?

  • more
    • All Share Services

Bad boy blues

Last week, after a colleague caught a few minutes of “The O.C.,” she was compelled to ask me a simple, yet poignant, question: “Do you watch ‘The O.C.’ because you think it’s really good? Or are you just addicted?” It was clear from her tone of voice that her opinion of Fox’s Thursday night teen drama, based on only a few minutes of viewing, was not high. I fumbled, uttering something about how good the first season was, about how the tawdry soapiness she’d glimpsed wasn’t what the show was about. In other words, I dodged the question. I had once loved “The O.C.” so much that I felt I had to cover for it — sort of like when a friend points out what an asshole your ex was, you feel compelled to make excuses for him, even though you know it’s the truth. The real answer was just too sad to admit: At that point, I was only watching “The O.C.” because I had promised to write about the season finale.

I was addicted, to use my colleague’s word, to the first season of “The O.C.” I watched it in sequence on DVD, and actually woke up early in the morning more than once to sneak in an episode before work. A teen show without a taste of the supernatural (i.e., an awesome lead character who slayed demons) hadn’t worked such a spell on me since the first season of “Dawson’s Creek.” The premise is simple: The wealthy, perfect Cohen family of Orange County — coolish dad Sandy (Peter Gallagher), waspy mom Kirsten (Kelly Rowan) and their adorably awkward son Seth (Adam Brody) — have their world rocked when dad comes home one day from his work as a public defender with a surprise in the form of — a new son! Ryan Atwood (Ben McKenzie), a troubled kid from the wrong side of the tracks and one of Sandy’s clients, provides a missing piece for each member of the Cohen clan: a second (and blond!) child Kirsten never had, a chance for Sandy to do good in the most hands-on way, and, most important, the super-cool older brother Seth always wished for.

Ryan’s bumpy adjustment to life in the O.C. provided a solid central narrative for most of the first season to revolve around and stretch out from. His anger, a full flame kindled by a rotten childhood, fueled the show. Had anyone in Orange County ever wanted to kick so much ass? A mere cross-eyed look at Ryan would mean a fight — with punches and grunts and swift kicks. He fought for Seth, for his girlfriend, Marissa (the pretty but tragically bad Mischa Barton), or just for the hell of it. He seethed, he brooded, he sulked in his black hoodie. Ryan was a character of few words, but he possessed an interior life we believed was deep, dark and, needless to say, attractive. He was “The O.C.’s” James Dean, with muscles and tank tops and, instead of a motorcycle, keys to the Cohen’s SUV.

Seth was, and remains, the show’s brightest star; he’s the boy whose quirky intellect, terrific wit, swell taste in music, Le Tigre shirts and mensch-ness make him an oddity in the O.C., but a dreamboat to all us girls of Brooklyn. (Plus, those curls! Those cheekbones!) But Ryan, he makes “The O.C. ” Without him, the show would be merely a slightly torqued “90210,” focused on the trials of poor little rich girls and the geeky boy who loves them. That’s why it was so awful to watch Ryan this season. He was emasculated — not by Marissa, but by the writers. He got nice. His flame blew out. He dated a pretty, normal girl, did his homework and didn’t run off to Chino to steal cars. During the finale, just as he’s about to go beat the hell out of his brother (more on that in a minute) he says to Seth, “All year I’ve tried to be a different person. I can’t do that anymore.”

At that moment, I thought: So that’s what happened? It turns out that being a different person — in this case a good, perhaps less erratic person — also means being really boring. The one thrilling moment last night came just before Ryan uttered that line to Seth: He really looked mad. Like he was coming back to life. Like, maybe, he’d been waiting for the chance to return to his natural state for the last 23 episodes, but something had been keeping him down. It looked like he was thinking: This is my moment for revenge — not on my brother, but on “The O.C. ”

And some revenge it turned out to be! But let me back up for a minute; this is, after all, supposed to be a report on the finale. Aside from the sidebar that Marissa’s sweet, but oft-misguided dad Jimmy (Tate Donovan) appears to be returning next season to reunite (surely temporarily) with his ex-wife Julie (played by the fantastic Melinda Clarke), there were two main story lines to follow: one involving Seth’s parents, who got a lot of airtime for troubles of their own these last few months, and the other involving Ryan and his no-good ex-con brother, Trey (Logan Marshall-Green).

Let’s get Kirsten out of the way first. Basically, she’s an alcoholic. In episodes previous, she’d gotten tipsy from “her Chardonnay,” but for the last few weeks she’d been hitting the hard stuff, hardcore. One night she was drinking and driving and was in a car accident with a semi; a few short weeks later she was wandering through her father’s funeral reception with an entire bottle of vodka in her hand. (“Jesus,” Sandy said. “Couldn’t you at least use a glass?”) All of this led her husband to stage an intervention and have her committed to a detox farm somewhere, no doubt, in California wine country. All we really know is that the place is beautiful, and the sheets have a very high thread count.

With the teenagers, things were far more dramatic. Marissa finally confessed to her best friend Summer (the ever-shrinking Rachel Bilson) that Trey had attacked her a few weeks before when Ryan (who is currently her boyfriend, again) and Seth (who dates Summer) were in Florida visiting Seth’s grandma. Summer told Seth, who told Ryan, who brooded, and then broiled. His parting words to Seth were, “Trey and I are going to settle this once and for all.” And then he was out the door.

The attack in question was an awful almost-rape that left Marissa with a tremendously bruised upper-chest and a terrible fear of intimacy. Ryan had every right to be angry; this was one instance where a foe really, really deserved the beating he was about to receive. Of course, Ryan’s revenge couldn’t play out as planned. Through a network of speed dials, Marissa was dispatched to the scene as Summer and Seth made their way there. When Marissa walked in the door, she saw that Trey had the upper hand in the fight, and that Ryan was going to die (Trey was choking him) if she didn’t do something. What’s a 98-pounder to do? She yelled a little and then, fortunately, noticed the gun lying on the floor, left over from a drug deal Trey had done earlier in the day. Of course! Marissa picked it up and shot Trey through the back, just as the rest of the gang walked through the door to Trey’s apartment. End of season. Cue up the indie rock.

Trey was truly a piece of shit, but as a character, I had to feel a little sorry for him. He had a lot on his shoulders, even before he took a bullet through them. During the first season, he’d been nothing more than an auto thief, doing time in Chino for stealing a few cars. Upon his release — and once he’d been swept up into the wide, waiting arms of the Cohens — he also became a drug dealer, a rapist, and a man so violent he would kill his own brother. None of this fits together; the writers needed a bad guy, so they put everything on him. Poor Trey was little more than a plot device! (He wasn’t alone: Earlier this season, in perhaps the most unbelievable pairing ever, Olivia Wilde played a lesbian named Alex who had a short relationship with Marissa. Marissa — a very straight, inexperienced young woman suddenly turned Sapphic goddess. Right. OK. Poor Alex; worse than a plot device, she was a ratings booster, promising lesbian action with the Keds spokesmodel.)

In “The O.C.’s” first season, even when plotlines were contrived — how do these 17-year-olds get into nightclubs, anyway? — they were at least spawned from the real messiness of life: the anxiety of adolescence, the thrill of young love, the insecurity of even the prettiest and most popular. The only big soap opera moment came at the end of the season when Ryan’s ex-girlfriend from Chino, whom he’d briefly reconciled with during a break from Marissa, discovered she was pregnant. But that cheesy, lazy twist pales in comparison to what happened last night and many others on this season of “The O.C. ”

Sadly, the way the second season wrapped, it seems like we might be in for more of the same. Will Marissa go on trial? More important, will Mischa Barton, who up to this point has only really expressed coyness and upset, have to learn how to act so that she can express something like guilt? It’s true, and good, that Ryan has his vital anger back. But it’s going to take a lot more than that to save “The O.C. ”

Read the rest of our Finale Recaps.

“Mimi” generation

Those weaned on Mariah Carey should feel emancipated by her return to form -- and her escape from Whitney's sad fate.

  • more
    • All Share Services

Before I moved to New York City in 1997 and gave up my car, I was one of those people who cherished commercial radio. My high school years were spent chauffeuring friends around in my Chevy Blazer, compulsively changing the dial between Baltimore’s pop station B104 and Washington’s unmatched alternative channel, 99.1 WHFS. In college, even as DJs were formatted out of existence, I tuned in to the Albany rock channels in that same trusty truck whenever our campus station got too earnest or obscure (which was often). I was always a sucker for the hits — my last year with the radio left me indelibly marked by the Wallflowers’ “One Headlight” and Third Eye Blind’s “Semi-Charmed Life” — even as I mail-ordered records from Teenbeat, Simple Machines and other tiny labels. To my friends I was a walking contradiction, a devotee to manufactured pop and indie rock in equal measure. And, to quote Whitney Houston, they didn’t even know about my greatest love of all: Mariah Carey.

I haven’t stayed in great touch with Mariah — like I said, I pretty much stopped listening to commercial radio eight years ago — but the memory of her from the early ’90s has haunted the entire decade that has made up my 20s. As a teenager I spent countless afternoons after school, alone in my parents’ living room, belting out “Vision of Love” as the video played on VH1. (As a little, little girl riding in the “way-back” of my parents’ station wagon, I dreamt of being discovered by a radio executive because I knew every word to every song in the top 10 of Casey Kasem’s weekly top 40. As a 16-year-old with a decent voice, I subconsciously believed that hollering along to “Vision of Love” was going to get me somewhere — if not a record contract, then a boyfriend enchanted by my somewhat agile voice.) “Someday,” Mariah’s incredibly upbeat revenge hit that played on B104 at least once every hour of my junior year of high school, summed up my teenage angst and anger better than any Cure song could. And “Love Takes Time” — has any breakup ballad ever put it better?

Around then, my true loves were probably Jane’s Addiction, New Order and the Beastie Boys’ “Check Your Head.” But Mariah, she got to me. “But the catsuit!” exclaims a friend, recalling her outfit in the “Vision of Love” video. OK, sure. But compared with other manufactured divas of that era, Mariah was the real deal. She wrote her own songs! She could really, really sing!

For most of the late ’90s, I watched from afar as Mariah coasted along, putting out more and more ballads and, eventually, a collection of greatest hits. Her outfits got worse and worse but, I must admit, I loved seeing her defiantly busting out of her clothes all the time on billboards around downtown. (Mariah is no Kate Moss.) However, when she suffered a very public breakdown in 2001, following her disastrous screen debut in “Glitter” and the tanking of the film’s ’80s-throwback soundtrack, I quickly snapped to, and rushed back to her side.

The press (and most of the public, it seemed) didn’t have much sympathy for Mariah. I understood why. The year before, she had signed a record-setting $80 million, five-year contract with Virgin records. (The deal was later dissolved.) She had been the bestselling female performer of the 1990s, with 13 No.1 singles and more weeks spent at the top of the Hot 100 singles chart than any other artist in history. She was famous and beautiful; she was, obviously, rich; she dated Yankees shortstop cutie Derek Jeter. It was easy to think that 2001 had brought Mariah’s day of reckoning: a 10-year run was enough; it was her turn to crash and burn and fade. Months later, when she finally spoke about the breakdown, she attributed her bizarre behavior — performing an impromptu striptease on MTV, writing rambling, suicidal messages on her Web site — to exhaustion. But it was fair to wonder, as many people did: Can someone as wealthy and successful as Mariah Carey really be more exhausted than your average fan?

I caught Mariah on “Oprah” doing damage control post-breakdown, around the time that her rebound record “Charmbracelet” came out. I was with Oprah: I felt sorry for the girl. On the show, she was surprisingly articulate and credible; when she described shuttling back and forth between L.A. and New York while making “Glitter” — and suffering from insomnia to boot — her breakdown seemed inevitable. Poor Mariah, I thought, spending all those nights in the studio and on red-eye flights. As she sang her inspirational hymn “Through the Rain,” and explained that it was all about her personal struggle to keep going, to survive, I teared up a little. She’s just a hard-working woman with a dream, I thought. She gives so much money to the Fresh Air Fund that they named an entire campsite after her. She doesn’t have a husband and spends most of her time with her mom. Why do people so love to hate her?

“Charmbracelet,” unfortunately, was a throwaway — a record rushed into production with the hopes that it would erase “Glitter” and the breakdown from minds of her fans. It bombed (though not quite as badly as “Glitter”) and, in its wake, things continued to look grim for Mariah’s future. So news earlier this year of a second comeback, one saddled with the improbable title “The Emancipation of Mimi” (after a nickname used by those closest to Mariah), was greeted with a groan by many, including me. A few weeks ago, when “Mimi” was hitting the stores, I held my breath and said a little prayer for Mariah, expecting the worst. And when the record debuted at No. 1, I quickly exhaled. The songstress of redemption and healing had done it. As she hopefully sang a few years ago, she “made it through the rain.” Mariah was back on top.

“Mimi” had a very strong first week of sales, moving 404,000 copies, and it’s currently sitting at No. 2 (behind the Boss) as it approaches its first million sold. The critics, by and large, are liking it (and I am, too). The first single, “It’s Like That,” didn’t get too far up the charts, maybe because the song is a fun but bland hip-hop throwaway that could have been sung by anyone. Indeed, Mariah’s voice here, and on a few other tracks, is barely recognizable as her own. The second single, a slow jam called “We Belong Together” that cuts a bit closer to the classic Mariah mold, is faring better, hanging in at No. 7 on the Billboard Hot 100 singles chart.

“Mimi” makes it clear that Mariah’s voice is not what it used to be. The record holds a few signature Mariah flourishes, but mostly the diva is subdued here, playing it safe by avoiding the highest of her five octaves and staying within a tighter vocal range. It’s a little mean to say, but I honestly cringe at the thought of the woman on “Mimi” attempting the feats Mariah pulled off on songs like her 1992 MTV Unplugged cover of the Jackson 5′s “I’ll be There,” or the triumphant pop love song “Emotions.” As she ages, perhaps this is the formula for success. At 35, less of Mariah is actually more. It’s a sad fact of aging, but I’m very grateful she and her smart producers (including Jermaine Dupri and the Neptunes) recognized it.

I’m impressed. Just a year ago it looked as though Mariah was destined to be the next Whitney Houston. Remember her? Mariah’s soul sister, with her ex-star husband and her drug problems? Thanks to the tabloids and 10 o’clock news, an entire generation knows Whitney as a supposed crack addict instead of the girl in the tank dress singing into the telephone “How will I know if he really loves me?” or the poised young woman who covered millions with goose bumps when she covered Dolly Parton’s “I Will Always Love You” for her movie “The Bodyguard,” which seemed destined to make her a major movie star. Although she’s got an active contract with Arista and put out a full-length record in the late ’90s — one that garnered modest critical and commercial success — it seems unlikely that she’ll ever reclaim her former glory. Should she even try? The public is unforgiving; to most of us, Whitney Houston seems like a lost cause.

Mariah, on the other hand, appears to have been found, yet again. Scoff as you like at the title of her new record, but Mimi has indeed been emancipated. And I, for one, am delighted.

Continue Reading Close

“Wasted Beauty” by Eric Bogosian

No one makes good decisions in this novel that follows the lives of a restless, but well-meaning, middle-aged doctor and a confused, drug-abusing fashion model.

  • more
    • All Share Services

This new book from novelist/playwright/actor Eric Bogosian covers territory that some might prefer to avoid in their pleasure reading: drug abuse, adultery, mental illness and, perhaps most difficult to handle, professional modeling. Though Bogosian treats it all with a light touch, and designs his characters with incredible empathy, this is the stuff of ugly American living. No one in this book makes good decisions; no one is clean.

However, if your tastes are anything like my own — meaning, you find the films of Todd Solondz riveting, books like Tom Perrotta’s “Little Children” and A.M. Homes’ “Music for Torching” infinitely pleasurable, and plays like David Rabe’s “HurlyBurly” not only challenging but funny — “Wasted Beauty” might be right up your alley. It’s hard to explain why relatively unremarkable depravity can be so alluring — heroin addiction and cheating and sexual perversion are not new things to hang a plot on — but for some of us, it never gets old.

“Wasted Beauty” primarily concerns a young woman named Reba, who lives with her brother, Billy, on an upstate New York farm. On weekends, the two of them come to the city to sell apples at the farmer’s market in Union Square. Billy dreams of making apple farming his living, while Reba tries to figure out how to make something, anything, of herself. They’ve lost both of their parents to illness and are stuck with bills and an overdue mortgage; Billy, additionally, is saddled with a crush on his 19-year-old sister that fills him with hatred toward her, not to mention deep self-loathing.

Eventually, Reba finds a way off the farm: modeling. She is discovered in a McDonald’s, rechristened Rena, and sent off to shoots and parties all over New York. (This, inevitably, leads to her on- and off-again heroin use.) Billy becomes a drifter on a search for his sister, whose every magazine photo makes him lust after her more and more. He winds up broke and homeless, and, after a nasty street fight, institutionalized.

Rick, Billy’s E.R. doctor, is the other main character in “Wasted Beauty.” His story is woven through with Rena’s even before their inevitable meeting. He is in midlife, married with two kids, dreaming of cheating and leaving but never really doing either. He pops Viagra and beats off to porn. He spies on his neighbors having rote sex. Like Rena, he is neither bad nor good. He is human, and confused, and wanting not much more than to figure out how to be happy without hurting too many other people.

Indeed, for all the stretched circumstances and dark corners, the themes in “Wasted Beauty” are familiar: How do you grow and try new things, but avoid excess? How do you love others and preserve yourself? How do you deal with desire responsibly? What does it mean to love? Bogosian tells his characters’ stories through alternating second and third person, giving voice to the thoughts of Rena and Rick and Billy, and then stepping back to describe their encounters from the outside. He laces together changing voices and thoughts with great agility, never confusing his reader or leaving her behind.

But Bogosian’s greatest skill lies in his ability to keep the story moving, to keep the interior monologues interesting and enlightening, to keep things edgy, while also keeping them real. It’s not that these are people you necessarily know — we’re dealing with an E.R. doctor, a model and a mental patient here — but they are recognizable. It’s a compelling tension that makes reading “Wasted Beauty” both tremendously fun and poignant. There’s no gimmickry here, just storytelling.

Yet, there’s also a happy ending. It comes off as a little overly hopeful, but after all Bogosian’s characters have been through by the end of “Wasted Beauty,” it’s as much a gift to his readers as it is to Rena and Rick.

Our next pick: An exciting first novel turns Akron, Ohio, into a surprising fantasyland

Continue Reading Close

Death shows for cuties

Why can't indie bands stay on the soundtrack -- and off the stage -- of trendy TV teen shows?

  • more
    • All Share Services

Death shows for cuties

Death Cab for Cutie’s performance Thursday night on Fox’s teen drama “The OC”should have been a dream date for my television and me. I’m a devotee of the band and an “OC” loyalist; I relish any opportunity for an uninterrupted one-on-one with my old Magnavox. But the event was more like a setup with a friend’s friend than an intimate evening with the one I love. I’ll be honest: For the short time Death Cab graced the stage of the Bait Shop, I was holding my breath, waiting for frontman Ben Gibbard to call out to the stiff, overstyled, underage crowd, “Good night, OC!” so the show could resume its regular, tumultuous, completely contrived course.

I suspected this might happen. My expectations for the show were low. Like blind dates, setups like this one have never panned out particularly well. Watching bands I love play to indifferent audiences of slim, styled Abercrombie-wearing TV teens plunges me into despair. Inevitably, the bands look old and, often, fat; the sets are brightly lit and unconvincing; the sound is, if not completely dubbed in, terrible. Last year, I made my news junkie friend Laura turn off a White House press conference on Iraq to watch the Shins perform on “Gilmore Girls” — what a mistake! When Aimee Mann made a forced, awkward appearance on “Buffy the Vampire Slayer” a few years ago, she was shown walking offstage muttering, “I hate playing vampire towns” — a memorably bad line in a memorably well-written show. Modest Mouse — a band that’s been around for 12 years and started out with tiny K Records — on teen prime time? Don’t ask.

I don’t blame the musicians for the lack of chemistry. They’re there to serve as backdrop for an unfurling plot rather than connect with their fans. Most of the time the music isn’t even live. With Death Cab, their three songs were clearly dubbed in; the sound of “Title and Registration” as it faded in and out to allow for Summer and Marisa’s bantering, was pristine, right down to its very un-live synthetic beats. I admire that “OC” creator Josh Schwartz (whose tastes in music have been passed on to lead character Seth Cohen) and his music supervisor Alexandra Patsavas are bringing the music they love into their hit shows; they’ve helped fuel the recent revival of indie rock. Seth’s well-known adoration of Death Cab is, I suspect, in no small part responsible for the fact that the band signed a major-label deal last year. But these performances can’t be doing much of anything for these bands that the various “OC” and WB soundtracks haven’t done already. Watching a bunch of guys pushing 30 perform in front of a crowd of kids who look like they’d rather be at the mall, or checking out “The Amityville Horror,” would only seem to raise doubt about their mass appeal — not strengthen it.

Around the time the Shins performed on “Gilmore Girls” last year, I had just seen the band play two sold-out nights in a row at Irving Plaza here in New York. (I know, dorky, especially for a gal who’s pushing 30 herself.) Those crowds — mostly college-age girls and their messy-haired boyfriends — danced and sang along like they were at a Beatles show in 1964. “So Says I,” the first single from their second record “Chutes Too Narrow,” came off like a club hit; the girls shook their bobbed hair and twisted to the floor while the boys engaged in some seriously earnest head-nodding. It was thrilling, especially since the Shins aren’t exactly the Beatles. Meaning: Their lead singer is a small, thin-haired sweetheart with little stage presence; their keyboard player (and default frontman) is a chubby goofball; the other two band members are not particularly charismatic. In other words, teen idols The Shins are not.

When it’s live, who cares? The music is what matters; the too-loud sound connects you to the band. It’s what transforms Shins singer/songwriter/genius James Mercer from a modest every-boy to the most beautiful man you have ever seen hold a guitar. But on TV, in these unconvincing clubs that mysteriously allow teenagers, these great bands look flat and lame; instead of rock gods, they devolve into throwaway garage bands begging for prom gigs. On “Gilmore Girls,” Mercer looked so paranoid and out of context, and the crowd (with the noted exception of Rory) appeared so mismatched, you’d have thought the Shins were a last minute fill-in for N’SYNC. Last night on “The OC,” Ben Gibbard was the only one of the Death Cab quartet to get any real face time, and that which he did was terrible. During “Sound of Settling” he looked absolutely spastic, there were so many jump cuts. And the lovable Gibbard — who, like Mercer, doesn’t have the looks your average female fan would dream up to go with his agile and warming voice — was shot from the side, so that the only sense you got of him was a blur of black, Clark Kent-style glasses and a mole on his cheek.

But it’s good marketing, right? All the kids watching “The OC” spend money on CDs and legal downloads after seeing the band on the show? But what was so wrong with keeping the music to the soundtrack, in the background? I’d rather associate a song with a kiss between Seth and Summer, or a fight between Ryan and some water polo player, than a limp hangout scene in the Bait Shop. On the stage, there’s no drama. A band is nothing more than a prop, a song is never loud enough, the very cute guitar player is never visible. The setup takes all the joy out of a live performance, and all the excitement out of a truly dramatic moment. It’s a waste.

And I’d rather keep my dates predictable. If “The OC” and its WB cousins keep trying to set me and my television up for some kind of crazy minage-a-quatre, I might have to break up with someone. And I’m pretty sure it isn’t going to be the band.

Continue Reading Close

Exile gone mainstream

With her fourth album, titled simply "Liz Phair," the erstwhile queen of nasty indie rock grows up (sort of) and plays radio-friendly pop (mostly). She says that's always where she was headed.

  • more
    • All Share Services

Exile gone mainstream

For 10 years, critics and members of the indie rock faithful have been waiting for Liz Phair to make an album that sounds like, well, Liz Phair. That is, the old Liz Phair — the one whose screwy guitar chords, lo-fi sound and fuck-you (or, rather, fuck-me) lyrics made her 1993 debut “Exile in Guyville” a veritable alt-rock blockbuster that sold more than 200,000 copies.

With 1994′s follow-up “Whip-Smart” and 1998′s “Whitechocolatespaceegg,” Phair left behind the four-track, the dirty talk and the exhausted take on relationships that made “Guyville” so powerful, in favor of a slicker, more conventional pop sound both musically and lyrically. Where “Guyville” had Phair angrily declaring, “I wanna be mesmerizing too!” over hand claps and guitars, “Whitechocolatespaceegg” had her feeling “the sun on my back” and smelling “the earth in my skin” over a backing band — keyboards and all. With the release of this month’s “Liz Phair” — reaching stores on June 24 — she’s gone even further. Upbeat and scrubbed almost clean, “Liz Phair” is actually radio friendly — so much so that you might be inclined to pass it on to your Christina-loving teenage sister rather than file it between Pavement and Polvo in your own record collection.

But don’t. At least not just yet. “Liz Phair,” produced in part by the Matrix (i.e., the folks who’ve brought us Avril Lavigne), may sound at first like a disc for the sub-17 set, but there are traces of the girl who made “Guyville” all over it. Phair’s been taking a pre-release beating for this record, and not just from my boyfriend but also, and probably more important, from actual rock critics. In Spin, Chuck Klosterman gave the new record a B-minus and put it this way: “[On 'Guyville,'] Phair deconstructed relationships with an insight that didn’t seem mortal. Now she plays videogames with some slacker dude.” But “Rock Me,” Phair’s song about hanging out with the cute kid and his Xbox, isn’t that simple. Shouldn’t she get some points for subversion? Admit it: An empowered, 36-year-old, divorced single mom who picks up a guy nine years younger and uses him for sex kinda rocks.

Speaking with Phair by phone on the eve of the scaled-down Field Day Festival (originally planned for eastern Long Island, the festival was moved at virtually the last minute to Giants Stadium in East Rutherford, N.J.), I ask what she makes of people who continue to lament that she hasn’t made another album like “Guyville.”

“I don’t know what to say,” says Phair, with a trace of irritation. “I’m really happy that I made ‘Exile in Guyville’ — I love that record. But I don’t know that it’s possible for me to go back and make a ‘Guyville.’ That was really a product of me being 20 and having nothing else to do but sit around and get stoned and play guitar all day long.” After her annoyance subsides, she adds, ” I think people who choose to keep one thing that they do and just circle it again and again — that’s valid. That’s great, but that’s just not the kind of person I am.”

Besides, she notes, “I like big sounds.”

Although “big sounds” came through on “Whip-Smart” (think of “Supernova”) and “Whitechocolatespaceegg” (the title track, or “Polyester Bride”), this remark still comes as a bit of a surprise. It’s been easy to assume all along that Phair’s steady drift toward the mainstream came from an impulse outside herself — from some corporate pressure to capitalize on the success of “Guyville” by producing songs that are attractive to millions rather than thousands. In fact, Phair explains, each of her subsequent records has come closer to the way that she wants her music to sound.

“I used to feel afraid of being in a room with ‘real musicians,’” she confesses. “I didn’t feel like I had a voice enough to say what I wanted or to get to a place where the song felt like what I wanted. As I’ve been working, I’ve become more comfortable in those environments — and they’re less lo-fi and more hi-fi. I feel comfortable experimenting.” It’s hard to believe, but the same woman who redefined bedroom politics with songs like “Guyville’s” “Flower” (“every time I see your face/ I get all wet between my legs”) and “Whip-Smart’s” “Chopsticks” (“he said he liked to do it backwards/ I said that’s just fine with me/ that way we can fuck and watch TV”) was actually afraid of calling the shots in the studio.

Phair’s present self-possession was hard-won. Her marriage, subsequent divorce and newfound single-mom status, she says, have all made her tougher: “Going through what I went through was really difficult, and coming out on the other end OK made me feel pretty powerful as a person,” says Phair, now 36. And the same experiences that differentiate the old Liz Phair from the new have also defined “Liz Phair.” Where “Guyville’s” appeal resided in its universality — whoever you were, there seemed to be a song on that record that described your feelings about relationships — the new record’s strength lies in its intimacy. That the record is self-titled is no coincidence: These songs are Liz Phair.

Take, for example, “Red Light Fever,” a track about a relationship that stalls because the guy won’t commit. “That was about a really intense relationship that I had right after my marriage. I thought we were going to get married,” Phair says. “It was very messy but very passionate. I watched him being really self-destructive and really torn — he couldn’t decide which way to go. He couldn’t move ahead with me in his life and he couldn’t just stay where he was. I couldn’t help him.”

Then there’s “Friend of Mine,” a slower, sorrowful description of post-breakup exhaustion. (“I don’t have the heart to try/ one more false start in life/ It’s been so hard to get it right.”) When I ask Phair about it, she says ruefully, “That was also about the relationship after the divorce.” “Little Digger,” about Phair’s six-and-a-half-year-old son, “is me imagining,” she says. “It’s me giving him a voice. The hardest thing about divorcing was that he had no say in the things that were happening to him. What I do will affect this person forever. It’s his life, and that’s what this song is about.”

Still, for all the emotion underpinning what are, for the most part, upbeat pop anthems, Phair insists that everything is going pretty well. “I have a million things to do. I don’t have this uninterrupted freedom and I can’t get stoned all the time anymore,” she says, “but I’m really more enjoying my day-to-day moments. I’m really in them as opposed to standing outside myself going, ‘What if you do that? What will happen then?’ I think I’m much happier.”

It shows. Songs like “Why Can’t I?” and “Favorite” are positively ecstatic — to the point that they practically sound as though they’re by someone else. In a more familiar vein, there’s “H.W.C.,” a chipper paean to “hot white cum” — the “fountain of youth” and “the meaning of life,” in Phair’s formulation.

Still, just as “Divorce Song” from “Guyville” perfectly described the common early-adulthood experience of corrupting a friendship with sex — “It’s harder to be friends than lovers/ and you shouldn’t try to mix the two/ ‘Cause if you do it and you’re still unhappy/ Then you know that the problem is you” — so a handful of Phair’s new tracks capture the tensions in more mature relationships nearly as well. We shouldn’t write Phair off because she became a well-adjusted adult. We should congratulate her instead.

Continue Reading Close

Shakira’s pop

I don't like Pepsi, and I never liked the yodeling Colombian Britney clone. Then I saw the TV ad.

  • more
    • All Share Services

Shakira's pop

Count me among the music snobs who have willfully ignored the writhing, grinding singer known as Shakira since she yodeled her way to America in 2001 with her first English-language CD, “Laundry Service.” I wondered how the Colombian hottie — the third point on that Christina-Britney axis-of evil girl music — could hold anything for me, a child of rock ‘n’ roll. How could that tan tummy, those bleached-blond locks and ample, um, vocal chords, be worth more than a salacious spread in Rolling Stone? I looked the other way at the gym when her videos played on the TV above my elliptical trainer. I sniffed at the idea of her doing an “Unplugged” CD. I snorted in disbelief when I heard that Gabriel García Márquez calls himself a fan.

Then I saw the Pepsi commercial.

If you watch the WB, UPN, Fox or any station that airs prime-time teen dramas, you’ve probably seen it, too. The spot goes like this: It’s late at night. A geeky clerk is closing down the minimart after a long day of hawking chips and beef jerky, mopping the floor, when he sees her: Shakira — or at least a life-size cardboard cutout of her, propped up at the end of an aisle as part of a Pepsi promotion. Our geek looks around and, seeing he’s completely alone, drops his mop to embrace the inhumanely rigid image of the petite singer.

The music starts; it’s “Objection (Tango),” the first cut from “Laundry Service.” His sheer desire turns cardboard Shakira into the real thing, all flesh and hair. They tango. He’s in heaven. And of course, she drinks Pepsi.

I have never had an ad work such magic on me. But the effect wasn’t the intended one; I’ve always been a Coke drinker, and always will be. The Pepsi spot did make me want to possess Shakira, on CD. Immediately.

First, the music. “Objection (Tango)” — a slow-building tango updated with electric guitars and bass laid overtop more traditional accordion and piano — is irresistible. [Download the song here.] Its opening bars lodged in my head like the best bits of certain “guilty pleasure” radio hits: parts of Sublime’s “Santaria,” Third Eye Blind’s “Semi-Charmed Life” and Train’s “Drops of Jupiter” all come to mind, keeping me up at night, providing a personal, slightly aggravating soundtrack to my everyday life. The staccato beat demands dramatic movement — preferably erotic dancing.

Add to this Shakira herself, and you have something way more potent than Pepsi. When the camera stares down the short grocery aisle to find live Shakira striking a pose worthy of Elvis, I was had. And when she gets body to body with the clerk and smiles in the most mischievous way, it’s clear she’s in on the joke. Who cares about the fucking Pepsi? These 30 seconds are owned by Shakira. This ad stands in marked difference to the overt way Pepsi usually peddles its cola through pop music. Last year we had the all-American pop-tart Britney singing the branded words “Joy of Pepsi.” Beyoncé Knowles has just done a minute-long spot in which she performs a highly produced and dramatic version of “The March of Carmen,” with the lyrics rewritten to tell the story of a guy named Zeke who wants a — guess what? — Pepsi. [You can view it here. ] While you couldn’t miss the point with Britney or Beyoncé, the Shakira spot simply doesn’t work as a vehicle for selling soda. What it does do, and remarkably well, is plant that little seed of a perfect pop song, along with an unforgettable image or two, in heads across America.

“Laundry Service” doesn’t quench my thirst for Shakira like the ad does — that pose, that sway, that smile! But I like it so far. There’s a song with overtones of the Cure, and another one that genuinely rocks. Still, I have yet to get past song No. 6. Around then I start to think back to the Pepsi dance, to crave that beat and accordion sound, and I tap the “back” button until it returns to No. 1. And then Shakira comes alive all over again.

Continue Reading Close

Page 9 of 9 in Hillary Frey