John Bowe

Americans talk about love: How we chose an open marriage

"Early in our relationship, Cate said, 'If you ever see anybody else, I'll kill you.'" An oral history of polyamory

  • more
    • All Share Services

Americans talk about love: How we chose an open marriage

Nick: The first thing you have to know is that early on in our relationship, Cate actually said, “If you ever see anybody else, I’ll kill you.”

Cate: Oh, yes, I was completely conventional. I’d never heard of polyamory. I certainly would not have believed that it was possible to love more than one person.

Nick: When I met Cate, we’d each been married and divorced. I was 48, she was 42.

Cate: We had sex every single night we were together. For something like five years.

Nick: Yeah, but we weren’t together every night.

Cate: [Laughs] My kids lived with me four days a week, and Nick lived with his full time, and we traveled a lot, so we never had the chance to devolve into a domestic routine.

Nick: I mean, we were in love –

Cate: [Fake sobs] You said “were”! [Laughs]

Nick: We met each other in January. In April, we did Ecstasy together for the first time. We began to do it every few months. It always resulted in this very significant affirmation of how much we loved each other. It did all the good things Ecstasy is supposed to do. About seven years into our relationship, we started fantasizing about various sexual possibilities. You know, just for fun. Cate wanting to see me with a guy –

Cate: I mean, we were naked, in bed, so it was not a totally abstract conversation on our part.

Nick: This went on probably two or three times, and at a certain point I said to Cate, you know, we don’t have to just fantasize about this stuff. We can actually do it.

Cate: I smacked him! [Laughs]

Nick: My best friend from high school, he’s sort of a closet homo, and he’s always wanted to do sexual stuff with me. So we were out at his house one day, getting stoned, and Paul was delighted, you know, by the prospect of sucking each other off in front of Cate.

Cate: I was not interested in participating. Paul’s quite beautiful physically, but he’s way too annoying. But it was fun because it was different. I’m generally up for anything different as long as, you know, no puppies or minors are being hurt. [Laughs] I’m glad we experienced it.

Nick: There was something unfun about it for me. I’m not particularly attracted to guys. But I was doing it primarily for Cate’s delectation.

The next day, we had dinner with Cate’s best friend, Elizabeth, and got stoned. And Elizabeth and I were totally clear that the three of us could be fucking. Then and there. And when we left, I said to Cate, “You know, we could have gone to bed with Elizabeth just now.” And she said, “Really?”

Cate: I was oblivious as usual.

Nick: I set it up. We went to Vegas and rented a room.

Cate: Because where else do you go to be sinful? [Laughs] I just figured that life was short. I really trusted Elizabeth and I really trusted Nick.

Nick: Cate had a justification, which I have always found incredibly romantic. Which is that she wanted somebody to reminisce with at my funeral about what a great fuck I was.

Cate: I imagined all your lovers gathered around the casket going, “Daaaamn!” [Laughs]

I thought it was exciting because it was transgressive. I had never been in bed with a girl before. And it’s a turn-on for a lot of couples to watch their partner have sex. It was sexy to see Nick in bed with someone.

Nick: And what Cate said, which I find interesting, is that on one hand, it was one of the most terrifying things she’d ever seen, but on the other hand, it was one of the most exciting things she’d ever seen.

Cate: Yep, that’s true.

Nick: And what happened next was that Elizabeth and I really wanted to be together again. Cate agreed to another meeting. And it was pretty disastrous. It turned out that neither of us was sufficiently bi. Threesomes weren’t going to work out for us.

Cate: I didn’t want to be in bed with them. I didn’t know how to be. I’m just not sufficiently bisexual, and unfortunately, that’s not going to change. I remember being acutely aware that we had opened Pandora’s box. We’d unlocked the genie from the bottle. Because what happened was that then Nick got involved with Elizabeth. Emotionally. So we decided we would have sex with other people. Separately. Separate relationships.

Nick: Cate was unbelievably brave about it.

Cate: Well, the reason I went along with it was simply that it seemed interesting. It seemed worth it to me to push my psychological limits, to just work through it. I wanted to get to a better self, because I knew — I hope that doesn’t sound preachy — but I just feel like if you can be generous in that way, it’s better.

Nick: Cate, I’m just … I’m a boy, you know. It’s not unusual when a boy wants to do this sort of thing. What’s unusual was Cate, like nobody I’ve ever seen, decided at some point that this was a good idea. And she sort of never looked back.

Cate: But it was hard. It was complicated. I was so jealous. Oh, my God. Nick would be with Elizabeth and I wouldn’t be able to sleep. She lived in California and he was there a lot on business, so they would spend the night together. They spent a weekend in Paris and it almost killed me.

Nick and Elizabeth, to their credit, would always offer to stop. And I knew that if I had asked, they would have. Once he was with Elizabeth and they called and said I was really present in their thoughts. And I knew that was true. But I remember really struggling with it. I remember explaining to Nick: “You have my permission 100 percent. But I can’t promise that I’ll be happy.”

Nick: I remember we had a very interesting conversation that I’ve never forgotten. We were walking around in Montreal and discussing how in your average relationship, at some point, somebody strays. And then you spend an unbelievable amount of energy either breaking up or salvaging things.

Cate and I realized that we would rather figure out a way to have a rich, sexual, romantic life with expanded boundaries than to constantly be trying to repair a relationship that was falling apart because somebody’s got the hots for somebody.

Cate: It just seemed like a more interesting way to live, to have an infinitely greater sense of sexual possibility, to have the possibility of romantic love with more than one person. I mean, it’s rare in life to really fall in love, but –

Nick: I mean, there’s love and there’s love and there’s love and there’s love.

Cate: But just that there’s that possibility, if you’re having drinks with someone, or, say, see someone standing on the subway, for example, and you know even just in the abstract that you could have sex with them and that it wouldn’t send the entire apple cart crashing, there is a sense of possibility that is lovely to live with — even if you never, ever exercise it.

Nick: We started out with quite a few rules, and we ended up with three: no sneaking around; safe sex; and we each have veto power. If one of us says no, that’s it.

Cate: Anyone who comes into our life has to understand that our primary commitment to each other is the foundation for whatever takes place with anyone else. And that’s not up for grabs: I’m not leaving Nick.

Nick: Still, I like to say this is not a game for amateurs, you know? This is a high-risk game. Because we’re definitely talking about more than just being simply in lust. Really, if you’re going to live a polyamorous life, you have to accept the fact that your partner might fall in love with somebody else.

Cate: When one of us has a crush on someone new, the other one can’t replicate that. They cannot compete with the newness, and the new relationship energy takes over.

Nick: Somebody said to me, “Jealousy obviously isn’t a problem for you and Cate.” I said, “Don’t be ridiculous. If we weren’t jealous, we wouldn’t care about each other.” It’s that we handle it differently than the average couple.

To make this work, we have to appreciate each other all of the time.

Cate: You cannot take each other for granted.

Nick: Being poly, if you’re going to make it work, you’ve got to work twice as hard on your relationship. To the extent that Cate can go out and fall in love with somebody, I have to work pretty hard to earn her respect and her love. It becomes very important to express our love for each other. When I get on an airplane, I always text Cate — part of it is habit and part of it is I need Cate to know I love her.

Cate: I think the impression that people have of these things is that the guy is the sexual adventurer, and he somehow talks his girlfriend into this and she goes along to keep him happy. That was not the case.

Nick: No. I’m very jealous of Cate’s love affairs.

Cate: Wait, whoa, whoa. I have one. One love affair. With Daniel. And I did have this intense thing — this –

Nick: It isn’t over yet, and it counts.

Cate: Yeah, it totally counts, but you fell “in love” with Christine, or at least you were; you certainly fell “in love” with Sara; you were “in love” with Elizabeth. You’re not exactly sitting on the shore here.

Nick: I don’t think I was ever in love with Elizabeth.

Cate: [Rolls eyes and makes a face]

Nick: [Laughs] We had a very dark period, which came about when Cate first deeply fell in love with someone else. It was just the classic case where, you know, the boys tend to be the ones that say to the girls, “This is going to be great! Let’s do it, let’s do it, let’s do it.”

And when the girl finally decides, “Okay, this non-monogamy thing is fantastic. Let’s do it,” that’s when the boy tends to freak out: “Wait! Wait! It was okay when I was sleeping around, but if you’re going to do it, and especially if you’re actually going to start falling for someone, this is way too nerve-racking for me.”

Cate had been so brave going through the pain of me and Elizabeth, when it became my turn to go through some pain, because Cate had really fallen for someone, the last thing I was going to do was pull the plug on it. But I didn’t have all of the resources necessary to go with the flow. It was problematic.

Cate: But Nick also went through open-heart surgery. And — can I discuss the chemical aspect, Nick?

Nick: Yes.

Cate: Okay, this is about seven years into our relationship. Nick was fifty-five. He had open-heart surgery. And I was in a relationship with Daniel, who was thirty years younger than Nick. Nick was self-medicating with cocaine for part of that time.

Nick: We call it the Dark Period. I had to go through what Cate went through when I was with Elizabeth. But listen, part of it is that Daniel is thirty years younger than I am. It had nothing to do with mortality issues. It has to do with vitality issues.

Cate: What’s the difference?

Nick: I wasn’t worried about dying.

Cate: Liar! “I’m only having open-heart surgery — but who thinks about dying?” [Laughs]

Nick: The big problem with the Daniel period — it drove me crazy that I couldn’t excite Cate the way that Daniel could. To know that we couldn’t have that new relationship energy, as Cate calls it, that fresh excitement of somebody new, that I wasn’t able to provide that for Cate, and conversely, that she wasn’t able to provide that for me –

Cate: I think Nick was having a life crisis.

Nick: No. The point is that I was afraid you’d want to leave me for him. And by now, we’ve each had a half a dozen relationships that have been of any significance. Some of them have gone on for five or six years. But for me, none of them could replace Cate. If Cate fell off the face of the earth, it’s unlikely that I would have sought any of them to be my girlfriend.

Cate: That’s a relief.

Nick: I mean, I had a deep, deep crush on Sara. You always pointed out that my eyes just glazed over at the thought of her, that she turned me to jelly. But Sara’s fucking crazy. I mean, I would never in a million years want to be with Sara.

Cate: But when it happened with that woman Christine whom you saw very briefly, every fiber of my body went WHOOP! ZHOOP! ZHOOP! I mean, it wasn’t a matter of personal animus –

Nick: She was a really good person.

Cate: But I was just terrified of her, terrified — as I have never been before or since — that I would lose Nick. Not because of her, but this was during the Dark Period, and we were not on solid ground. If you want to have a non-monogamous relationship like we have, you have to be able to communicate, and we weren’t communicating well.

Nick: It was a complicated moment. Cate was several months into this very serious, deep love affair with Daniel, and I met this woman who I think would never have tried to take me away from Cate.

Cate: I was not worried about her being the evil player in this at all; I was worried about Nick falling in love with her.

Nick: I was falling in love with her. And I think the really interesting thing that I’ve never understood how to parse is that Cate has fallen deeply in love with people without ever thinking about leaving me, whereas I have found it difficult to fall in love with people, precisely because of that fear.

Cate: That’s because I’m good at boundaries and rules and you are not.

Nick: That’s probably a good answer.

Cate: Anyway, there’s terror in any direction. It was a good example of the judicious use of veto power.

Nick: Whereas with Colleen, with whom you invoked the veto at the beginning, it was because you don’t trust her.

Cate: [Hisses] [Stage whisper] She’s a viperrrrrrr. [Laughs]

There were a million — not a million, but many — painful challenges. Enormous, terrifying. But if you have relationships that have real emotional depth to them, which is what we aspire to, then it is never safe. You’re terrified about losing the person. It’s high risk.

But if we weren’t polyamorous, who knows what would have happened?

Nick: I can’t imagine that I could have stayed in a relationship for this long monogamously.

Cate: It seems like giving each other permission to have these other adventures is definitely the reason we’re so happy.

I would say that I love Nick for nine million reasons. Most of which have to do with the same conventional reasons that cause other people to love each other. I love him for how he takes care of me, and how smart he is, and how principled he is and blah-di-blah-di-blah.

And the fact that he allows me this happiness that I have been able to find with other people is a tremendous and trust-filled gift. I suspect that he feels this way even more so, in that he is more of a browser. I’m not implying that Nick is some big rottweiler and I have to say, “No, down boy.” He’s actually not a total horn dog –

Nick: I’m not.

Cate: But his default is “yes.” I mean, that’s the essence of what I love about him. His catholic taste is enormously appealing. Nick is the most interesting person I’ve ever known.

Nick: Oh, darling, that’s so sweet.

Cate: I’m always saying this, but it’s what Virginia Woolf said about Leonard Woolf: that when he entered the room she never knew what he was going to say. And I never know what Nick is going to be thinking or reading or wondering about, and it’s intoxicating. 

Dory, 66

"If someone had told me that we would ever get back together, I would have laughed. Because it wasn't just a separation. We really did sever the ties."

  • more
    • All Share Services

Dory, 66

It worked for a really long time. We laughed a lot. He was a really funny guy. He still is. And I admired his — he was a very hard worker. Our first years of marriage, it felt like we were real compatible, and we had fun together. We had a lot of friends, went to lots of parties. We didn’t have children until after we had been married for four or five years, and so we traveled and did fun things together.

But there were some pretty really big events a few years before we split up. We moved out to Montana due to my husband’s job in about 1983. And then we moved back three and a half years later. We came back to the Twin Cities. My husband was starting a new business. I was not seeing the great stress that he had during that time, and I wasn’t in sympathy with that, I guess.

I was just kind of plugging along being a mom and being probably not the best wife in the world. I didn’t take care of myself as much as I should have the early years of our marriage. I got just so into the children, and I was just so focused on them and doing all the things that I was supposed to for them, that I didn’t do enough things like going to exercise class or just even going out and having fun with my girlfriends. I just way felt like I had to be the mom and be everything for everybody in that family. He wasn’t very helpful because he had stresses. Over a few years’ time, things were sort of deteriorating. It just sort of crept up on us. We just weren’t communicating.

There was one separation for a few months where my husband moved out. I can see myself and I can see him in the kitchen. I can’t remember really what led up to it. We must have been in some kind of discussion, but all I remember was we were both standing in the kitchen. He said he was leaving, something about that he was leaving. And I said, “Oh?” And I said, “When?”

He told me later he was shocked. I probably was feeling some relief.

That lasted a few months, and then he was back, and then it was maybe a year and a half later he started a relationship with someone and announced that he was leaving again. By then I didn’t know that he had another friend, but I knew I didn’t really care, because things were not that good.

We were divorced a few months afterwards, and it was then that I realized this was such a huge thing. I spent about a year sort of wallowing. I was devastated and really down on myself. It wasn’t that I missed him or was sorry that he was gone, but I was born and raised Catholic, and for that marriage to have failed was just a huge thing for me. A failure of the dreams that you have when you’re young, that this marriage that you got into was going to last forever.

In those first couple of years, so many things came up, things I didn’t give him credit for. Things that would happen around the house, and I’d go “Oh my God. What am I gonna do here?” Things that, you know, he was always there to take care of them. A lot of financial things. And different things that came up with the kids. I had a suspicion that my son was probably smoking marijuana, and what I did is I took these little weedy things that I found in his bedroom in a plastic bag up to the police station to ask if that’s what it was. The guy said, “You and your husband need to have a talk with this kid.” I guess Tom ended up talking to him. So that kind of stuff, everyday stuff of being a parent. I did miss that.

That same year a brother of mine died, and he was my favorite. He was an older brother and died suddenly, and I just felt, “Oh — there’s a lot goin’ on for me here. All my advisors are leaving me.” Because he was another one I could go to and ask questions.

But then I started learning to do things. Especially a lot of financial things that I had never bothered to — I had no idea about our family’s finances, and that was my fault because he had always encouraged me to be more interested. So I learned more about that. I was pretty independent.

We were divorced for five years. During those five years I think I thrived. I did my job. I did a lot of studying and got a higher position. I was a nurse in the oncology system at United Hospital in St. Paul, but I got into a supervisory position. I was very content with doing the things I was doing for myself — as far as my job went, as far as maintaining relationships with my children, who were by then off on their own.

I don’t think that I ever would have started a relationship with someone else. I had a couple guys that asked a couple times to go out to coffee, go out for a drink or something, but I just wasn’t interested in that. There are some religious values that I have of my Catholic upbringing, and unless I had a marriage annulled I would not have gotten married again to someone else. Or probably even have gotten into a relationship.

If someone had told me that we would ever get back together, I would have laughed. Because it wasn’t just a separation. We really did sever the ties. Except that we did have to communicate about the children.

While he was seeing this woman, we would get together for a couple of hours on Christmas. He came to my brother’s funeral. But there was nothing except he was there because it was his duty and I was tolerating his being there. We weren’t unfriendly, but we weren’t in any kind of relationship at that time.

Our first granddaughter was born about October of 1995. And there’s something that happens when [laughs] you become a grandparent. It feels like your heart is just sliced wide open — or for me anyway. I wasn’t aware of what was going on at the time, but there was so much love for this child that I was opened up to be able to receive again.

It’s probably similar to when you are first in love with a girl and you wake up every morning and everything is wonderful — that kind of thing. It does open you to other relationships ,and you’re a more optimistic and open person at that time, whereas when you’re getting ready to divorce and things are falling apart in your life, you’re more closed.

Looking back, that was the time when we began corresponding a little more. And then it was shortly after that I heard that he was no longer with this woman.

I can’t pick out a minute. It just evolved over a year’s time. We started visiting the grandchild together. And from there, once in a while we’d do stuff together — go to a concert or something. It seemed really natural. Then one day my daughter said to me, “Mom, are you and Dad dating?” And all of a sudden it occurred to me. “I guess we are.” [Laughs.]

I remember the first time we kissed again after all this time. It was at his home and I was dropping him off after we had gone somewhere. It felt like I was a young teenager having my first kiss. We weren’t staying over at each other’s houses or anything like that at that time. I remember going home and thinking, “Well, this is kind of silly that I’m feeling like a young kid again.”

And then another time, maybe a couple of weeks after that, when we were departing after a nice evening, I had driven and took him back to his house, and we were just having another little kiss goodnight — he said, “Dory, next time bring your toothbrush.” And I’m going “Oh my God.” Here I am, a grown woman, and I’m feeling pretty much like a young kid.

I think he wanted it a little more than I did, to get back together. I think he was lonely. I had learned to accept myself. I could have been happy just going on the way I had the last five years. It didn’t feel like I needed another person at that time. But, you know, we kept on; we had fun together.

We had talked about getting married again, but I still wasn’t sure if that’s what I wanted. We decided we’d wait until after our daughter’s wedding because we didn’t want take away from her enjoyment. I guess we waited another six months.

Our second wedding, we had a mutual friend who’s a judge in Pine City, Minn., and we got dressed up — not in wedding clothes. He wore a suit, and I wore a bright red dress, and we had corsages. We went up to the courthouse and his friend married us. Our kids didn’t come. We didn’t invite them. And then we went and had lunch with our judge friend and went out for dinner, and that was it.

So we got married December 26, 1966. We divorced in, I think it was, 1991, and we remarried in 1996. We celebrate our anniversary on the day that we were first married.

I guess I don’t look back and have any regrets about anything that we did. We weren’t the first people this had happened to. And more and more I hear about other people getting back together.

I think we’re in a really nice place in our lives now. We’re ready to help each other through whatever might come in the next years. We’re both getting a little older — any day there could be a health issue that could diminish one of us or devastate one of us.

It just — we grew back into a relationship that I’m pretty satisfied with now. And I think he is. That feeling of failure is gone now. And I think we both admitted to ourselves — probably not as much to each other — all the ways that each of us needed to change to make it work again.

We’re just so much more tolerant of each other. We’ve gone through a lot together and we’re older, and I think that getting older makes you see that there’s so much more to the world and to love and to life than what you see when you’re young.

It taught me there’s so much more to love. Accepting everything about the other person even though, in any relationship, everybody doesn’t love everything about that person, and if they say they do, I don’t think that they’re being honest.

In my everyday living with the guy, you realize you just have to let some of this stuff go. Little things — they seem like fairly childish to me.

We have our lake cabin on Lake Superior near Schroeder, Minn., like 78 miles northeast of Duluth. We actually spend seven or eight months of the year here. And then we have a condo down in the Twin Cities, in St. Paul.

OK, I’m looking out the window and I have some beautiful flowers and pots out here and stuff, and my husband. For about two or three weeks, he’s been running around the yard, buttoning things up for winter. You know, putting away hoses, putting covers on different parts of the house for winter so things don’t get in there. And it’s October. I’m going, “But we still have five weeks before winter. Do we really have to worry about this?” And he says, “Oh no, I’m not gonna be doing this in the middle of the winter.” And I pretty much need to close my eyes to it now.

Or: My husband has taken up cooking the last couple of years. I’m really thrilled about it now, but he’s rearranged the whole kitchen. The first day I came in and couldn’t find anything. I just was going ballistic. This happened a couple years ago. And now I just think, “OK! He cooks! Let it go and just keep looking for the stuff that you need.” So that’s a couple examples.

I guess that before, I was more controlling than I ever wanted to admit. I think I probably wanted things my way or no way a lot of the time. There was probably a lot of me overreacting, and him withdrawing. At the time you don’t think you’re overreacting at all. And he didn’t think he was withdrawing at all. But that’s what you learn after a lot of years of looking back.

When we were starting over, it felt like we didn’t have any real attachment to each other except we had been married so many years before — like 25 years. We were both free. I felt I was a different person and I had learned new things. And surely he had, too. I guess we had learned to be kind to each other again, or good to each other. To be more careful to listen to the other person and not reacting. Listening. I guess that’s a huge thing.

Continue Reading Close

Rebecca, 47

Most of our conversations were conducted between the Mexican busboy. Hector couldn't speak English, so he would talk to the busboy in Portuguese, and the busboy would speak to me in English. And then we arranged to go on a date.

  • more
    • All Share Services

Rebecca, 47

I was, I suppose — I don’t remember — 36, 37 maybe. About 10 years ago. I was working in a little English restaurant. I worked 18 shifts per week, so I spent most of my time there. And it was mostly South American guys in the kitchen, American customers, businessmen, mainly, and English waitresses like me.

The man I was with at the time wanted children. He was an Italian count. I knew I wanted children. But it really stressed me to think of having them with him because he was always like, lying in a hammock, having a cigarette. He was very charming, but he was, you know — I had three jobs, and he had no jobs. And I always thought to myself, if I have a child with him, he’s going to be the child.

And then we had this new busboy. I remember seeing him one day when he was leaving. I was talking to my friend Carol, and I said, “Cool! Who’s that?” and she said, “It’s the new busboy.” He was Brazilian. He didn’t speak a word of English. He was picked up at the airport by another Brazilian guy, and the next day, he started working in our restaurant. He didn’t know anything. He had a family in Brazil. Kind of left his wife, really. They kind of split up. He had gone straight from her to working here and sending money back — that was the aim.

And we worked together for a long time. He had a really nice aura. Full of kindness, and he was hard-working. I suppose I really fancied him. The first time I saw him, I said to Carol, “I want to have his children.” [Laughs.] But I meant it. I had this feeling, “That’s the man I’m going to have children with.” I wanted to have children with someone I fancied and really liked, and I was in a relationship with someone that I didn’t really have a sexual sort of connection with.

He was two years younger than me. We would talk. He would ask me, “Can I have Coke, please?” and I’d say, “Who do you think you are that you can ask for drinks? Get back to work, you dog.” [Laughs.] He’d go really red. And I’d say, “I’m kidding. I’m joking.”

Most of our conversations were conducted between the Mexican busboy. Hector couldn’t speak English, so he would talk to the busboy in Portuguese, which is somewhat similar to Spanish, and the busboy would speak to me in English. Or he’d write me little notes in broken English. And then we arranged to go on a date. We met at the Telephone Bar in the East Village. He was all dressed up for it. He brought flowers.

I remember saying to him, “Do you want some wine?” And he didn’t understand that. I was like “Vino! Vino!” He had this little dictionary, and he took it out and I remember thinking, “How can he not understand ‘vino’? My God! He’s good-looking, but he’s an idiot!” And then we had sex and everything, and — I really did like him a lot!

And then I went back to France to visit my mom, and so it kind of stopped. I still had the boyfriend. But it was all right, because I’d found out that whenever he went back to Italy, to Rome, he would have little flings. So I thought, “OK. I understand now.” I understood why it hadn’t been right between us. And when I came back from France, Hector and I had another date. Next thing, we were sort of going out. We didn’t tell anybody. They caught us kissing in the corner, and then it all kind of came out.

When I said I wanted to have children, he gave me this little lecture about money and drinking and responsibility and not having money and how having children is a big responsibility. I ended up getting pregnant the next month. We wouldn’t have bothered to get married, but we needed to for him to get legal, to get his papers. So I had to get my citizenship, because I’d never bothered with that yet. Then we got married after my daughter was born — Dominique. We got married twice actually. He found out he hadn’t gotten divorced properly in Brazil, so we had to get that annulled, and then we got married again.

My brothers laugh at me. Because the count, just before I left him, he’d always be talking about his big estate. The big estate that he was going to get. Which he did. So my brothers always joke, “Ah yes, she left a distinguished Italian count for an illegal alien … who doesn’t speak English and is retarded.” [Laughs.] But now they really like him.

I love him. But I sometimes hate him. We fight a lot. Sometimes it’s money, because I spend more. I’m really bad with money. And he’s more organized. He’s a plumber’s helper. The money’s pretty bad, and he works long hours. We don’t have enough money to live — so sometimes it’s that. Sometimes we argue about me going out with other guys. I have a lot of male friends. They were friends I met before him. And it’s like, this very Latin thing — who you can see and can’t see. He wouldn’t speak to me for a few days. He was doing that for a while.

Oh, and we argue sometimes because he says I don’t let him finish what he’s saying. I finish his sentences with not the right ending. We argue like that, for lack of communication. On the phone, I don’t know what the hell he’s talking about. He doesn’t speak English properly. I don’t speak Portuguese. So sometimes he says something, and I say, “I don’t understand you!” [Screams.] In the office the other week, I found a plumber’s job for him on Craigslist. And I called him and told him, and he said, “What? What does you mean?” And I said, “I’m fucking helping you!” It drives me to distraction.

I think it’s a lot to do with not having a formal education. He doesn’t read … he didn’t even go to school. He went back to school a bit when he was about 18 or 19. I mean, he’s intelligent. But he was working when he was 8. He has made an effort. But — he’s crap at it. I thought he’d learn — and he didn’t! [Laughs.] But I’m not great at it either.

A friend of mine says you have to have three things in common: intellectual compatibility, emotional and sexual [compatibility]. So um, we don’t have intellectual. But that’s the thing: I have friends who have very intellectual relationships. That’s really important to them. So sometimes I think, “Am I missing out on all that?” Like, the best-friend kind of thing? But that’s the choice I made.

A lot of people don’t have much sex because of their lifestyles, but they’re still into each other. But a lot of people who have been in a relationship for quite a while — they don’t really talk about those intellectual things anymore. You talk to people about how did you meet, and they describe the thing, and they’re having this memory, and it’s so clear that the memory has to keep them going. They argue a lot. The way they speak about their partners, the way they speak to each other, the way they — everything. It turns my stomach … it’s so awful.

I’ll give you an example. I had a friend that I thought had a really wonderful relationship. She’d been with her partner for 10 years. They were both very intellectually in tune and very successful in the media and everything. They discussed everything, and they really seemed like close, close friends. And then she met another guy and she just fell in love with him. And of course, you know, problems had been happening, but nothing they ever talked about, or even they were problems that other people wouldn’t think were necessarily problems.

And she fell completely in love with this other guy who was completely the opposite of her partner. She broke off her relationship and her children and everything for this other relationship. When I thought back, there’s so many times when there was a kind of contempt. It came out just a little bit. He wasn’t very good at doing practical things. And I think a light bulb or something had gone off, or maybe it wasn’t a light bulb, it was something a bit more demanding, like maybe the fuse or something, and he was slightly unsure of what to do. And she said, “Just put that in there,” and she starts looking at him with absolute contempt and hatred.

I think being physically tied to somebody makes you maybe kinder than that. I think if you have a good sex life with somebody, there’s a fundamental respect for that person. There’s a boundary that you can’t cross, in terms of behavior between you. I think — when your lover becomes your best friend — you tell everything to him, and you share everything, and you work together, and you do everything together, maybe in the end, it becomes boring. Like, you can no longer smell the person, and it affects the sex. And ultimately, if you don’t have that physical connection, you will leave, or you’ll have an affair, or you’ll find someone else, because that’s what really you’re hungry for. I think sex is the only intuitive thing that you do. It’s not verbal. I think it demands a certain amount of mystery or independence to keep it good.

I have a lot of friends, who, when they’re talking about sex with their partner, they go, “Oh, I can’t bear it.” They pretend to be asleep. You know, this isn’t just one of my friends, it’s most friends, like 97 percent. They say that they have sex maybe every month or two months. And I’m thinking, “Why have I ended up different from my friends?” And I think it’s because we can relate sexually.

A lot of people I know that don’t have sex — it’s because they can’t be bothered. Since you can’t be bothered it means that you’re not too interested in the other person. And what differentiates that between a friendship? I’ve been in that relationship myself, where we haven’t really wanted to have sex. I’ve gone through all that. It’s a horrible place to be.

When kids come along, the relationship isn’t “I love you. Oh my God, I love you, I love your mind.” It’s all about the kids and about work and the division of work. It becomes incredibly un-sensuous. I know this because I’m around our kids all the time. We have three of them now. But we’ve managed to keep things sensual. To a fault. [Laughs.] It’s lovely. It’s still good.

It’s better even. But our relationship’s gotten better as well. I am connected with him. I look forward to having sex and I look forward to seeing him and kissing him and those things, you know. I like the way he smells and lots of things like that. Kind of simple things. That man-woman stuff has lingered since the day we first met, really. He’s very strong about who he is. He always wants sex every night, so it’s just sexy, you know? It just feels natural: Have sex and then sleep. It connects you to something. To life, you know, to something important.

But it’s more than just being turned on by hot, foreign dark guys. [Laughs.] It’s a certain emotional sensibility he has. His emotional instincts are right — about people, about things. He’s much quieter than I am. He’s quite shy. And more. I notice this so much in New York: So many people never consider other people, how they have to struggle to get by. They pass them on the street, lying down on the ground, and they never stop and consider what it’s like, what it means, that they don’t have proper food or a place to stay. These people go around all the time saying, “Oh, I deserve this, or I deserve that.” Hector’s of the other kind. He’s had a hard life. He understands people. He stops and gives money to people. It’s a goodness. He has a goodness in him.

I followed my instincts. I’ve never regretted that. I thought, I can never stay with someone who I don’t have that intimate connection with, that chemistry. It wasn’t like, Oh, I want to have good sex with someone and then marry them. I’m not that naive here. With Hector, it’s the feeling of his being independent, capable and hardworking, the very opposite from my last boyfriend. And the thought of having someone who could look after you — it’s kind of an instinctive thing. Someone who’s responsible — to me it’s a turn-on.

I’m one of those people who things always happened to. I never chose a career. And with this relationship, I wanted it. I created it. It doesn’t matter if it was a good idea or a stupid idea. I wanted to live with this person, have a baby with this person. I’d never dreamed it would last this long. But I hope I grow old with him. Why not let it happen? I thought, “What’s the worst?” The worst is that we don’t stay together.

Continue Reading Close

Shawn, 31

"I met my ex-wife, Jackie, when she was 12 years old and I was 17. We kind of had this little thing."

  • more
    • All Share Services

Shawn, 31

I’m Shawn Whitworth. I’m 31. I was born in Orlando, Fla. My name was S-H-O-N-E to start out with, because my family was so country, that’s what they put on my birth certificate. Let’s see. My dad was in the military when I was born and my mother didn’t bother to tell him that she was pregnant so he didn’t know until after I was born. I saw him a couple of times between the ages of 3 and 5. But we moved to L.A., and I never saw him again.

I had a stepfather. He wasn’t like the most loving father, but he did provide for us and, you know, I love him. I call him Dad. But, like, my first stepdad was really abusive. I was burned and slapped and punched and beat. He smoked weed with me and drank and I was only like 2 or 3 years old. I can remember actually being burnt with a bottle — he lit it, so it was like, black and then stuck it around my nipple. And it just seared into me. My mother was an alcoholic and she didn’t really fight. But she got at him by being really stubborn. There was a lot of friction, a lot of argumentation. It was very dramatic.

Like, once I went fishing with my mother and a guy came down to the river where we were and she started talking to him and they ended up drinking some beers together. And this is a small town where everybody knows everybody, and like, he had his hand on her leg the whole time and she’d been married to my stepdad for like 15 years at the time. They did it right there in front of me. And then a couple of days later, the guy pulls up in our driveway, and I’m standing outside, and I’m like, “Oh shit.” I walk up to the car very calmly and he’s like, “Is your mom here?” I’m like, “That’s my dad over there. I think it’s best that you leave.” So he backs out of the driveway and my dad comes over and he goes, “Who was that?” I’m like, “He got the wrong address.” That’s tough to do when you’re 12. So my mother pretty much ruined me as far as trust goes with women. I don’t think that — I think I could trust a woman. It’s just not like something that I would immediately do.

Being raised in Tennessee from around 7 to 14, they have a lot of mixed ideas there, a lot of backwoods, backward ways. I remember my grandmother slicing her wrists. I saw the blood trails. When I was like 6 or 7, this kid named Kevin molested me. I didn’t like it. He was like, “Don’t tell anybody.” I was like, “Well, fine. I’m not gonna tell anybody.” He was like 13. And when I was 4, I had two girls in my neighborhood that used to fool around with me. They were sisters. They were 7 or 8. They’d be like, “Do this to me. Do that to me.” I basically went down on them and I mean they definitely didn’t have hair down there, anything like that.

I pulled a gun on my brother when I was 11 years old. It was a 410 shotgun, single shot. I pointed it at him because they were being rambunctious and I was like, “You’re gonna calm down, you’re gonna listen to me.” So I got sent to a mental hospital. And then the day I got back from the mental hospital, my mother was in jail for DUI.

When I was like 13,14, 15 — my mother would be out drinking and driving almost every night. I would sit and wait by the window or outside on the porch waiting for my mother. Like a dog waiting for its master to come home. I didn’t know what to expect. Was my mother dead? Was she in jail again?

I met my ex-wife, Jackie, when she was 12 years old and I was 17. We kind of had this little thing. We did drugs together, smoked weed, basically. I really didn’t get involved too much in the heavier drugs. But she made it known that she liked me and I was like, “You’re 12.” At that point in my life, I had girls flocking all over me so it was more like, we’ll be friends.

And we were friends. She was really mature. I think it’s because maybe that she was molested when she was a kid and it made her grow up really fast. She never told me who it was. She was afraid I might do something about it.

I never tried anything with her. Like maybe I kissed her a couple of times or something, but I never tried to get down her pants ’cause she was so young — I think she was like 13 or 14 around that time. And she told me she had been molested, but she hadn’t been raped, so she was a virgin. And basically she told me that she was ready for me to take her virginity. At the time, she stayed with her sister in Georgia. And she called me and was like, “Hey, we want to meet you in Chattanooga.” She’s like, “I’m ready.” And I was like, “Oh my God, man. I don’t know what to do.” But I wanted to see her. I took my brother with me, and I told her, you know, “You don’t have to do this if you’re not ready.” She was like, “This is what I want.” I’m like, “OK.” So later on that night I took her virginity.

And then immediately the next day I felt bad about it. And also, her sister, Carrie, was older. I thought she was more my type. I just kind of stayed away from Jackie. Which made her feel really bad, like basically, you know, he doesn’t have feelings for me anymore and he took my virginity. But you have to remember I lived in a different state. I called her from time to time, but like, I wasn’t pursuing her for that.

So, a few months went by and I went to visit her in Florida and when I was going there, my car broke down, and her parents had the great idea to have her sister [in Georgia] pick me up. So she met me halfway, took me back home to her place and was like, “Yeah, I’m tired. I’ll take you home tomorrow.” And then another day went by and she’s like, “Oh, I’m tired. I’ll take you home tomorrow.” And every day she did something else to try and lure my attention. And every day it got more and more difficult and I was trying — not that I had any commitment with Jackie, I just didn’t want her feelings to be hurt. I knew it was probably the wrong thing to do. So a week goes by and like Carrie’s coming out of the shower in her robe and she’s like, “Do you want a massage?” And with the hot oil and all this and I’m like, “Oh my God. I can’t control myself.” So I broke down and ended up spending about a month there. And then finally, I was like, “Look, I can’t do this.”

So I made her take me back home. And then Jackie comes to Georgia to stay with her sister and — things are really fuzzy. All I know is that I went back to Georgia and Carrie didn’t want to tell Jackie I was sleeping with her because she thought her sister would hate her. Which she did when she found out. But when Jackie got there she wanted to sleep with me too, so I was at a loss what to do. I ended up sleeping with both of them at different times of the day. While one was at work I would do it with one and while the other was at work — it was a very confusing, exhausting time for me, and they both were subconsciously aware of the fact, though I don’t think they admitted it to themselves at that time.

Then Jackie started hanging around with all her friends doing heroin and coke and roofies and all these different drugs. She was fooling around with this kid that was 15, and she ended up getting pregnant. She told me about it, and she was like, you know I don’t believe in abortion. And she was going to have the baby. Well, I felt guilty. Because I’m the one who took her virginity. I fucked around with her sister. I felt like she had done this stuff to find a way to try to get me off of her mind or to forget the situation. And I basically didn’t really have any relationship-type interest, but we were still friends, and I felt guilty. I was like, “Well, this kid is gonna need a father.” I felt like, you know, I had to marry her and get her away from these people.

So, when I was 21 and she was 16, we got married. I mean, I loved her, but I didn’t love her like “in love,” you know, like a fairy tale love story. Basically, before we got married, I had sex with another woman, because I felt like once I got married I wasn’t gonna do that stuff.

I adopted her kid by the other guy, Robbie. It wasn’t a legal adoption. It was basically like a mental adoption. But I mean from — immediately we had problems. Her father was abusive toward her mother and shattered her knee in a domestic argument. That’s her memories as a kid. She blocked a lot of them out but they were still with her constantly, and every time I would raise my voice, it would scare the hell out of her. And I’m a very passionate person. I tended at that time to get in people’s faces. So, she would leave me. I trusted her, but in the back of my mind, because I cheated on her before we got married, I always had it in the back of my mind that she’s gonna try to get me back. Like I really thought she was gonna try to really hurt me, so, you know. I was really jealous and really afraid, and every now and then when she was pissed off she would tell me some shit, like, just to enrage. And this went on in Florida — you know, every time the police are called somebody’s got to go to jail. So one time she went to jail, and three times I went to jail.

But she loved me. I mean, she still puts it this way today, she “worshipped the ground I walked on.” And I didn’t appreciate that at all. I was very self-centered, very selfish, you know, was like, “OK, I’m gonna go to work, you stay here with the kids, you cook, you clean, and like, the money that I make is my money.” At the time I had not a great job, you know. I was a nurse’s assistant. I was working 16-hour shifts five days a week so I was bringing home $1,500 every couple of weeks, which isn’t great. It was horrible. When I look back and think what a ridiculous person I was — I mean it was so bad that she’d be like, “Can you buy me a water?” And I’d be like, “I’m not buying water. What’s wrong with you?” When she would cry I would be like, “Shut up. Be strong.” I would basically run her in the ground for crying. Because I never cried as a kid, really. I remember being slapped so hard that my ears rang — and I didn’t cry. And like, when my grandma died I didn’t cry.

We stayed married for four years. However, we only lived together in that time maybe a year. Three or four months after we got married, Jackie got pregnant with Bethany. And then after that came Jason and Amber.

After we were divorced I moved back to Tennessee and we still maintained contact. Jackie was always the type of person — she wasn’t real promiscuous. Like, we had sex even after we were divorced — I mean forever. But I was living in Tennessee with my brother in a duplex. And my stepdad’s father had died, and my stepdad gave us each four grand. So I’m talking to Jackie and I’m like, “I’m gonna come down and see you. Can we stay at your place?” We wanted to go have a good time with the money. You know. “Can you hook my brother up with Andrea?” She had a friend living with her named Andrea. I’ve known Andrea since she was like 12 years old. And now she’s like 20 or something like that so. I talked to Andrea and Andrea said, “Sure.” OK. So we get there. Everything works out. My brother gets with Andrea. I get with Jackie.

And then Jackie and I get in a dispute, so I have to leave. The money was running low by the time the dispute happened. So I went to a dock and tried to get on a shrimp boat ’cause I heard you don’t need any sort of documentation whatsoever, it’s under the table, you just jump on the boat and go long days, whatever. So I’m on the boat, and my brother’s been at Jackie’s for, I guess, three weeks, something like that, and I’m like, “Yo, don’t you think it’s time you go back home?” And he’s like, “Yeah. I just need some money.” I’m like, “Well, get a job.” So three weeks turns into three years and Andrea has moved out and, you know, I get to Key West, and then my captain was on heroin, and I couldn’t take it, and a friend offered me a place in New York, so I moved to New York.

And I’m like constantly — every time I’m talking to my kids and Jackie, I’m like, “Yo, he’s gotta leave. This isn’t right.” My kids are there, you know. It doesn’t seem right. And a year after I’m here in New York, they’re like, “We’re together.” So I completely freak out. I think I had a nervous breakdown, and I talk to my brother and I’m like, “Look, man, if you had sex with her that’s OK. I can forgive you. Just please, just move out.” And he’s like, “No, we’re together.” And at that point I start screaming like a mad man. I’m like, “I’ll fucking kill you!” Like, “Don’t even turn your back for a minute if you see a shadow out of the corner of your eye it’s gonna be me, I’m coming to kill you. You better believe it. You’re dead. You’re dead.”

The thing is that he’s my brother and that coming from a trailer trash background that’s the last thing I felt my kids needed is to have some sort of shit like that go on in their life to affirm to them that they are redneck trailer trash hillbilly fucking hicks and that that’s all they’re ever gonna be. You know? And now he’s not their uncle anymore, he’s Trevor. They’re married now and they have a kid of their own so now, my kids’ sister is also their cousin. And it pisses me off. They didn’t have any kids at the time and I felt like they should have walked away from it.

I don’t talk to him. When he answers the phone, I say, “Where’s my kid?” And that’s the most I’ve talked to him in two years. But … there’s a joke I didn’t get for a long time, but now I get it. This guy who’s in prison for 10 years comes home and he knocks on the trailer door and his wife answers the door. She invites him inside and he looks over and there’s a guy sleepin’ on the couch. And he says, “Who the fuck is this guy sleepin’ on my couch?” She says, “That’s the man that’s been payin’ the bills for the last 10 years.” And the guy says, “Well shit. Give him a blanket! He looks kinda cold.” My brother’s paying the bills, you know. He takes care of my kids. He gets ‘em private tutors if they want. I’m like, “Well, shit!” That man is doing better than I could’ve done. I think they’re really in love and I’m happy for ‘em. My kids are happy and I don’t pry too much. I was mad before, but now I’m more contented with the situation.

You know, I felt bad when I left. She begged me not to go. And I’m like, I can’t be here. I can’t live like this. I can’t. And my youngest son was like a month old and my — I couldn’t conceive of the responsibilities that I was taking on at the time. After I was married I didn’t know what my responsibilities were. I really lacked in them, and I was really selfish and it was to my own detriment and now it’s to my children’s detriment as well because their father’s not there to be with them.

If you were to see me 10 years ago you wouldn’t believe I was the same person. I had a mullet. For like, five years. When I was a kid you probably couldn’t understand me when I spoke. I was like — I’ll spell it out for you. I’d say “An-kur.” For “I don’t care.” That’s what I used to say to my teachers in school. I was such a disgruntled kid.

When I first moved to New York I had not the slightest idea of what prosperity was. This was only five years ago. In Tennessee, it was always just a hundred junked cars parked on the property, you know, the front porch falling in, everybody living in trailers, nobody wanting to do better for themselves. It was like knowledge was evil and the more you learned or the more diverse you are, they think you’re a pussy, or you’re — I don’t wanna say liberal, because they don’t use that word. Like “nigger-lover.”

So in New York, I saw people that not only had jobs, but they were in school at the same time and they still had a social life … they juggled. That to me was so awe-inspiring. How do people do this? And I sort of had this moment of epiphany, like, to try to be a better person. I think that there was just some ingrained desire to be a better person. You know, I want to learn. And the fact that I’m uneducated is balanced by the fact that I’m smart, witty, and I search for knowledge. I’m self-centered, but I’m loving and I’m caring and I’m helpful. I’ve learned a lot of restraint. I think just a person gets older — you kind of calm down a little and you start to learn that this type of behavior is unacceptable. And that nobody is going to be comfortable until you learn to deal with your anger a little better.

I don’t think I’ve ever been in love or trusted a woman — except Jackie. I learned more from her than I’ve ever learned from any other woman in my life. And also, she dealt with more than any woman could ever be expected to deal with. And when I look back I know at the time she truly loved me, and I took complete advantage of that.

If I met her today and she was the same person she used to be, and I was the person that I am now, I think things would be a lot different. I think, yeah, I could love her, that I would be lucky. I don’t think that I’ll ever find that kind of love again. I think I really screwed up. I don’t ever expect to experience that again.

I admire her and respect her because my children are in safe hands. And I’m so lucky that she is the person that she is. You know, she dropped out of school in the 7th grade, but she doesn’t drink, she doesn’t do drugs. My children are safe. They go to school, do their homework, she’s there for them — emotionally, physically. She loves them. She doesn’t talk bad about me. I mean she could say a million bad things about me and totally ruin my children’s thoughts about me, but she doesn’t do that. As far as I know.

I just recently met someone. She initiated the whole girlfriend-boyfriend type thing and I found it rather odd. She’s 17 — which is legal in the state of New York. I was waiting for lineup for my stripper job. I do go-go at a gay bar. I went outside for a smoke break and she was outside, and I said “Hi” to her and she ended up giving me her number and I called her up. This was like a month ago.

I’m really skeptical. You know, the age factor. The fact that she has a lot of guy friends that she’s possibly had relations with in the past. I don’t want to talk too much about this relationship.

My views on love are conflicted in my head so much that I may be an old man before I figure it out. I think that some form of companionship and “love” in quotations is necessary for human beings. Maybe not every single human being, but for most human beings, having a companion and someone that you love definitely helps heal the hurt, the stress of life, even if sometimes it makes life more stressful. But love is very elusive and if there were a precise definition I would like to know it.

I’m sure that I’ve felt something like love plenty of times in my life. I know it exists because I love my children. But have I loved anyone unconditionally? I mean even with my children, there’s conditions. I think that maybe things are what you perceive them to be. That if you think that you love, then you love. I would like to choose to believe that I have loved or that I can and am capable of love. I’m almost sure that it exists. But if it slapped me in the face, I couldn’t tell you what it was.

Continue Reading Close

Paul Pesce, 83

I turned to her and said, "Could I take you to your home?" She looks at me and -- with a pause -- she says, "If you got a quarter you can go anywhere you want."

  • more
    • All Share Services

Paul Pesce, 83

I was born in Brooklyn. My mother died when I was about 9 years old. My father tried to take care of us. What he did was he moved us in with a family. My brother and I. And he went to work and he paid them for room and board to take care of us. But then he would come home and say, “Did you drink your milk?” and I would say, “What milk?” He’d say, “I gave money to the people to give you milk.” And besides the money business, other things happened. But we won’t talk about those.

Anyway, he had to put us in the orphanage. After we got out, there was a war on, so I went and I joined the Navy. When I got out, the whole world had changed for me, because they were paying for education. What I did was, I went to pharmacy school in the day, I went to high school at night to finish up my high school diploma, I worked as an X-ray technician, I had an internship, which I was doing at Walgreen’s in New York. And going home one Sunday night, I go down on the subway and something happened that has never happened before — ask any New Yorker, they’ll agree with me — there was nobody, I mean no single person on the subway platform.

It was maybe 10:30, 11 o’clock. The train comes, and again, nobody is on the train. Except for a woman sitting at the head of one of the cars. So being a young New York boy I get on the train, I walk the length of the train to where she’s sitting, I sit down right next to her, pull out a book, and start reading. And I peruse the page, or a half-page, I turned to her and I said, “Excuse me, does this train go to Brooklyn?” She looks me in the eye and she points across the other side of the car and, of course, there’s a big sign: “To Brooklyn.” I said, “Oh! Thank you! Goodbye.”

Get back to the book. Couple minutes later I turned to her and said, “Could I take you to your home?” She looks at me and she says — with a pause — she says, “If you got a quarter you can go anywhere you want.” Which was what the subway cost at that time. And she got off at the next station, and I got off with her and followed her.

She’s standing here watching me tell this story again.

Now, I can’t say why I was doing this. It was just instinct. And if the train had been crowded that day, I wouldn’t have seen her, or if I had, I don’t think I’d do what I did. I can show you pictures of her back then. She was very good-looking. I’ve got pictures of her. But I really have to say that it was just instinct. We went from one train to another, from the New York train to the New Jersey train, and then at one of the stations, she changes to a two-tiered bus. She goes up to the top, and I sit down next to her, pull out my book, I’m reading it, and I turn to her and I say, “Excuse me, can I buy you a drink?” She looks at me and she says — with a pause again — “I don’t drink.” I said, “Oh no, no. I meant coffee. Can I buy you a drink of coffee?” Pause. She says, “OK.”

OK, great. So we go down, have a cup of coffee, and when we were leaving the coffee shop I said to her, “Can I walk you to your home?” She says, “I’d rather walk by myself.” I said, “Oh. All right. Would you give me your phone number?” Pause. “OK.” Pulls out a paper and pen, writes down a number. And I go home. And her name is Eleanor, by the way.

Monday morning I call right away. And Eleanor comes to the phone and I said to her, “Can I take you out tonight?” And she responds, “No.” “How about tomorrow night?” And she responds, “OK.”

So she gives me her address and phone number, and I pick her up, take her to New York, and take her to see a play. And as we’re exiting from the play I turned to her and I said, “Will you marry me?” She looks at me — pause — and she says, “OK.”

Now you gotta realize that the time that we spent together did not really include much communication. Having coffee was not the most intimate relationship. Through the play we hadn’t talked to each other. I was standing next to a stranger and so was she. And as we’re walking out, “Will you marry me?” “Yes.”

Now she’s left the room, but at this point, when she’s listening, she usually says, “And what’s the name of the play?” And this was 55 years ago. I always answer, “I don’t know. I don’t remember.” Which I don’t.

I really don’t know why I asked her. I just liked her. Before I met her, I was just doing the thing that comes naturally to a young man. As far as I was concerned I’d be dead before I was 35. Shot by a jealous husband. I wasn’t thinking about marriage. It just came out. I think it was just instinct.

To me, love is a chemical reaction that takes place, or a psychic reaction. I just felt like she was nice. And that she was beautiful. And that she paused and she contemplated anything she said to me. But like I say, it was just instinct. Like the bugs and the animals. What kind of courtship do they need? We had a 15-minute courtship!

After she said yes, she said to me, “Don’t tell my mother we just met. Tell her we knew each other in grammar school.” And that’s what we told her mother. And her mother acquiesced. Her mother started making plans for her wedding, but her stepfather kept making excuses for slowing things down in his broken English. He was selling a car — a Chrysler New Yorker — and her mother loaned me $500 to buy the car. I took driving lessons. But I didn’t know anything about how to drive. I had to ask a cop once how to turn on the lights.

I wanted to get licensed in Florida, because I had been stationed in Jacksonville, and I figured that as a pharmacist I might someday want to go to another state. And I said to Eleanor, “I’m gonna go to Florida to take the state boards, and then when I get back, we can get married.” She says, “No, you won’t.” I said, “No? What are you talkin’ about?” She said, “I’m going with you.” Her mother agreed. She said, “Go ahead. That’s the best thing. Elope.”

So one night we throw a couple clothes in the car, get in the car and we begin to drive from Jersey down to Florida. And as we come to the Pulaski Highway, which goes from Jersey, I drive directly into the median. On each side, one wheel on each side of the median. So I turned to her and I said, “You watch the gauges. And I’ll watch the road.” So, backed off, we took off again, and she watched the gauges and I watched the road and we drove through the night.

We went over to Tallahassee so I could take the state boards. And then we went to a justice of the peace and got married. And I told her, “Look, as long as we’re here, why don’t we go down to Miami before we go back to New Jersey?” And she says, “OK.” So we’re driving into Miami and I’m reading a newspaper and it says, “Pharmacists wanted. A hundred dollars a week.” A hundred dollars a week! Goddamn! They’re paying me only $75 a week in New York. So I go to the address of the drug store and I said, with the newspaper in my hand, “You, uh, hiring pharmacists?” He says, “Yeah.” He flips out his pharmacy jacket, puts it on my shoulder, and says to me, “I’ll see you tomorrow. I haven’t had a day off in six weeks.”

I went outside, and I said to Eleanor, “Find us an apartment. We’re staying.” I started working. She found a little house in Little River that we rented, and I worked two shifts every day for about a year without a day off.

One day one of the accountants comes over to me and he says to me, “Hey, Paul, what are you doing working for somebody else? Why don’t you get a pharmacy or a drugstore yourself?” So I told Eleanor. And this is the way my whole life has been with Eleanor: I get an idea, I tell her, and goddamn if it doesn’t happen. ‘Cause she makes it happen.

We found this little drugstore way on the outskirts of Miami. And we worked in the drugstore for about five years. Now, because we were, you know, on the outskirts of Miami, we also put in a post office, a Western Union, American Express money orders, we collected bills for Florida Power and Light, Gas Company, we put in a beauty shop. We had a fountain, with hamburgers, soup, sandwiches and the fountain itself. We had a freezer that we sold milk out of and we sold bread, cake, cigarettes, of course — and Kotex. We bought Kotex at a certain price and sold it at the wholesale price, which would bring people in.

And all of these were my ideas, but she was the one executed them. She was an accountant for Singer Sewing Machine before I met her. So she was good with money. And the marriage was always fine. Fine. Fine. I mean, we’re too busy to fight. We were running the business. She’s doing most of the running. All I’m doing is working as a pharmacist. But she’s taking care of the business, taking care of hiring the help.

I had promised myself when I was in high school that I was gonna retire by the time I was 35. So we were very frugal and we saved money and we had enough to retire. Which we did when I was 39. I started taking acting lessons. My doctor friends all said to me “What the hell are you doing?” So I went to medical school.

I became a physician. A family doctor. We sold the drugstore to a friend of mine. And Eleanor took care of the business part. She was the boss of the office. And by that time we owned the building, and a strip center.

After trying for eight or nine years to have a baby, we finally did — Paul Pesce Jr. We gave him the nickname PJ, which he still uses to this day. And then we had Chris, and then Vicky. I worked in the office, and Eleanor worked in the office and took care of the kids. And we never fought. I’m — hey, I’m not gonna fight. Well, I can’t say that — one time we did have an argument and I left. That was a while back. In my youth. I stayed with a girlfriend. She’s not in the room now so I can say that. I stayed away about two days. When I came back she got so mad at me she hit me. She punched me. In the chest. And I slapped her in the face. And I think PJ remembers that. I think he was about 10 or 12 at the time. That was the only time we really got into a fight. I mean we’ve had discussions and arguments about certain things but not too much — we seem to think more or less on the same plane. I think one of the key ingredients of our marriage is that we agree on so many things. We don’t — we’re willing to give in to the other. I think I was probably pushier than her about getting my way — probably by a huge margin. But, well, even if it’s not equal it’s still satisfying.

 

Day to day, it’s always been in my mind, how lucky I am. We weren’t shy with each other, we were very affectionate. Lovey dovey. If I got upset, she calmed me down. Out of the 56 years we’ve been married, I’ve only been away from her for two weeks.

I think it has something to do with my generation. Because I think the natural thing for my generation is you stay with it. I don’t know anybody of our friends that got divorced. Even if the wife knows the guy is foolin’ around. She may not accept it that gracefully but she accepts it. And the guys, if they were doing something like that, I mean nobody flaunted it.

Anyway. Now she’s got Alzheimer’s. Which is heartbreaking for me. She’s had it I’d say about four or five years now. I don’t think she realized it when it was happening, and neither did I. It was her friend who said to me, “Hey, Paul, what’s goin’ on with Eleanor?” She would keep repeating the question — the same question — after you gave her an answer. I started realizing it. And when I spoke to the doctors about it, they agreed.

Mostly she doesn’t communicate. She just sits and stares. Occasionally I’ll get a giggle out of her. She’s pretty well aware of her condition. Which is terrible, you know. If she didn’t know it wouldn’t be so bad.

You’re looking at a guy who delivered babies in the Cancun jungle, who scuba dived in the Bay of Mexico and the Great Barrier Reef in Australia, who climbed the Alps, the Andes. We’ve been to China, Japan, Italy, France, England, Brooklyn. I was just lookin’ at a picture of us when we were in China and we were dressed in Chinese costumes — as Chinese warriors. We’ve been all over the planet because I mention it and she makes it happen. If I thought that we oughta own property, all of a sudden we had shopping centers. Or that we should be going to the beach — even if I didn’t say it, even if I just thought about it — we were going to the beach. She’s handled millions of dollars. She was so brilliant. She took care of me all of my life. All our lives. From that one meeting in the subway.

And now we walk around the house. There’s a law in Florida that says if there is a school that’s receiving money from the government and there are any empty seats in the classroom they should give them to the senior citizens free of charge. So what I’m tryin’ to do is find classes that have movies. She seems to enjoy watching them. Tomorrow, I’ve got to take her bowling in the morning with a group of women who have Alzheimer’s. And that’s what we do. And it’s just heartbreaking. So in case I sound a little confused, or a little off, you’ll know why.

I consider myself one of the luckiest people on the planet. I’ve gone through wars, depressions. Never been hungry. But this is horrible. I’m 79. I’m sorry — I’m not 79. I’m supposed to say I’m 39. I’m 83. And … All my friends are leaving. And now this. It’s horrible.

We have a doctor’s appointment now at about 11:30 and she’s been standing around here with a purse on her shoulder, which she’s gonna lose, waiting to go to the doctor’s. Which is over an hour now that she’s been walking around with that purse on her. Doesn’t say anything but you know she’s waiting to go to the doctor’s or somewhere, she doesn’t know for sure where it is. If she knows where it is she’ll forget it in 10 minutes.

She’ll last longer than me. Even with the Alzheimer’s. Eventually her brain will forget to tell her heart to beat, and she’ll die. But she’ll outlast me. Because women last longer than men.

I’m not sure that the Bible is anything real about heaven. I think that there is something or somebody, something that has created us. I think of it as a guy who made, like, a little miniature railroad track with a town and a train. And he watches what’s happening as it runs. If there’s such a thing as an afterlife, I hope I can spend it with her.

 

Continue Reading Close