Philip Weiss
The Clementi family’s compassion
Instead of the predictable thanks or celebration, a hopeful message
Joseph Clementi, left, comforts his wife Jane Clementi, after the couple opened up a symposium on use and misuse of social media at Rutgers University, Nov. 14, 2011, in Piscataway, N.J. (Credit: AP) I’m on a misanthropic kick. I think that people are selfish and mean. I believe the truth of the Colonel Sherburn chapter in Huck Finn, that humanity is vicious and cowardly and easily swayed. And our religions are outmoded and encode the worst impulses in tribal society.
Well, below is the statement made yesterday by Joe Clementi, father of the late Tyler Clementi, after the conviction of his son’s former roommate Dharun Ravi in the hate-crime spying case at Rutgers that caused his son to commit suicide in 2010.
The statement on behalf of the Clementi family contains no thanks to the jury, no celebration of the conviction. In its crucial paragraphs, you will see that Joe Clementi steps outside his family’s pain and puts himself in the shoes of other young Dharun Ravis who will see other gay people, and hate them:
Just a word about personal responsibility.
To our college, high school and even middle-school youngsters, I would say this: You’re going to meet a lot of people in your lifetime. Some of these people you may not like. But just because you don’t like them, does not mean you have to work against them. When you see somebody doing something wrong, tell them, “That’s not right. Stop it.”
You can make the world a better place. The change you want to see in the world begins with you.
I sense that the Clementis want to forgive Dharun Ravi, and they seek some statement/action from him that will allow them to do so.
Also in this statement is the Clementis’ own dedication to a purpose. Like the Corrie family that built a foundation out of the loss of their daughter in a politically-charged crime nine years ago– for which there has been no accountability from the Israeli government or the American government– the Clementis are taking this evidence of the worst of humanity and trying to change social mores for the internet age:
We have come to understand that the criminal law is only one way of addressing these problems and that there are other ways that are better, particularly when it comes to changing the values and behavior of young people in [the] important areas of respect, privacy, responsibility in a digital world.
As you know, our lives have taken a new turn, and we’re on a mission to address these issues in an affirmative way through the Tyler Clementi Foundation, which we have set up in memory of our son. We hope that the media attention will not fade and that positive efforts on these important issues will be acknowledged.
I’m focused on the worst of humanity these days. But there sure are some exceptions.
How 9/11 saved my life
It forced me out of the ghetto of high-end journalism and into the movement to change Jewish life
(This article first appeared in Mondoweiss.)
Later I learned that one of the planes had gone right over me. I wonder if I noticed it at the time. I was working outside that day in the Hudson Valley. I was already disaffected enough from mainstream journalism that I worked now and then as a laborer for a friend. We were putting sheathing on a house. When the announcer on the radio said a second plane had hit and started playing weird music, we went inside and turned on the TV. “I’ll go fight them,” I said to Dave.
Continue Reading CloseWhy is America so afraid?
The Egyptian revolution threatens an American-imposed order of Arabophobia and false choices
This originally appeared at MondoWeiss
I’m as thrilled as anyone by what I see in the Cairo streets, but when I turn on American television I see only grim faces. Robert Gibbs looked frightened during his delayed press briefing yesterday afternoon; he didn’t know what to say. Obama’s comments last night were equivocal and opaque: I’m with Mubarak, for now. This is his 9/11 — the day Arabs blindsided a president.
Continue Reading CloseThe road to Jerusalem runs through Tunis and Cairo
America didn't see democracy coming to the Arab world because it didn't want to see it
Hamas supporters attend a protest in Jabalya refugee camp in the northern Gaza Strip January 28, 2011, in the wake of documents released by Al Jazeera showing Palestinian officials offering big concessions in negotiations during past rounds of peace talks with Israel. The Palestinian officials have accused Qatar, the Gulf emirate where Al Jazeera is based, of standing behind a "smear campaign" designed to undermine Abbas. Qatar has ties to Hamas, the Islamist group which seized the Gaza Strip from Abbas's Authority in 2007. REUTERS/Mohammed Salem (GAZA - Tags: POLITICS CIVIL UNREST)(Credit: Reuters) This originally appeared at Mondoweiss
The neoconservatives told us that the road to Jerusalem lay through Baghdad. They meant that invading Iraq and installing a democracy there would lead to peace in Israel and Palestine. The way they imagined that peace was a neocolonial landgrab: a greater Israel with portions of the West Bank amalgamated by Jordan. Still, that is what they believed– that creating democracy in Iraq would lead to a peace in Palestine.
Continue Reading CloseTo walk in Palestinian shoes is to experience actual persecution
The Palestinian experience is not the experience of animals or terrorists. It is a human experience
This piece originally appeared at Mondoweiss:
Two thoughts on the meaning of the Israeli violence.
There is, of course, a big effort in the Western press now to make the flotilla members into violent people, provocateurs, engaged by cool Israeli commandos. I must tell you my one actual experience of this dynamic.
In January, I attended a demonstration against the occupation in the West Bank village of al-Masara. I wrote about it here: “An English politician watches Israeli soldiers lose control at a peaceful demonstration and vows to bear witness.”
Continue Reading CloseAmerican mandate in Palestine is coming to an end, and about time
For 62 years, the U.S. government has signed off on every action Israel has taken, no matter how destructive
Hamas security officers patrol on Gaza's seaport, Tuesday, June 1, 2010. Palestinians in Gaza declared a general strike and a day of wrath following Israel's deadly naval raid on an aid flotilla bound for the blockaded Gaza Strip on Monday. (AP Photo/Hatem Moussa)(Credit: AP) This was originally published at Mondoweiss:
My wife, who pays very little attention to these issues, said this morning, “I think we should all get on boats and go over there.” She looks on Israel/Palestine as complicated, but this one’s easy. “People should keep going and going and going.” Do you know about the underlying conditions? I tested her. “Gaza.”
I have to believe that her human response to the besieged and humiliated people of Gaza is widely-shared today, around the world. And this is a challenge above all to American governance.
Continue Reading ClosePage 1 of 2 in Philip Weiss