Robert Spillman

The Conversations at Curlow Creek

Robert Spillman reviews "The Conversations at Curlow Creek" by David Malouf.

  • more
    • All Share Services

Call it the Merchant/Ivory syndrome: “My, what beautiful wallpaper!” Malouf, whose last novel, “Remembering Babylon,” was short-listed for the Booker Prize, spreads thick his beautiful, evocative prose in “The Conversations at Curlow Creek,” but the swatches hang together in a slightly mismatched and irritating pattern, never cohering into a whole.

The plot, as Malouf sets it up, is interesting: Two Irishman — one a career soldier, the other a rebel peasant — spend the night in a hut in the outback of Australia in 1827, the officer present to oversee the dawn hanging of the peasant. The peasant had wanted a priest, and he’s ready to pour his heart out; the soldier wants to go home to claim the girl of his dreams.

The majority of the book, however, is given over to a backstory that would’ve made Dickens proud. Every last detail of the soldier’s upbringing amidst the Irish gentry is recounted. We learn of the tragic death of his opera-singer parents, his adoption by eccentric landowners, his love for the wealthy, smart and reckless neighbor girl, as well as his having to raise his adopted parents’ son. There is an inevitable triangle between the soldier, the girl and the son, a three way psychological tug of war for affection. The soldier is all order. The neighbor girl is all fire. The young boy is all rebellion. The soldier traipses around the world to exorcise his demons and to find the inner spark that will win the girl. In New South Wales he learns that the boy he raised has become a rebel leader. By the time he gets to Curlow Creek the only survivor of the young man’s band is a lone peasant to be hung in the morning.

Unfortunately, little is exchanged between these characters. Instead there are many poetic passages about rivers, trees and horses. The central theme — the inner conflict of chaos and order — is merely glimpsed in a few compelling passages. With this kind of book, you forget why you are reading it and find it easy to put aside when your eyes glaze over as you stare at the pretty words.

ECHOES OF AUTOBIOGRAPHY

Naguib Mahfouz, Doubleday, 144 pages

  • more
    • All Share Services

Naguib Mahfouz, the 85-year-old Egyptian Nobel Prize-winner best known for his Cairo Trilogy, packs a lifetime of wisdom and reverence into this slim new book. This is not a dry, academic “I was born here, studied there” recounting, but a series of half-page meditations which capture the essence of a writer deeply tuned in to the spirituality of the everyday.

Fellow Nobel Laureate Nadine Gordimer writes in her introduction that “For Mahfouz life is a search in which one must find one’s own sign-posts.” Throughout his remembrances, anecdotes, allegorical and mystical tales, Mahfouz concludes that rapture is found in being constantly open to the world, and that the most perfect moment in one’s life may well be in “the fleeting look of contentment under the date palm” which is “the secret of life and its light.” The entries are filled with a constant struggle between polarized ways of living: between the need for order and the freedom of anarchy, between the pureness of abstinence and the humanity of sensuality, between the urge to examine everything and the contentment of letting life flow. The latter part of the book is taken up with the musings of a mythical Sheikh abd-Rabbih al-Ta’ih, a mystical figure who dwells in a desert cave that he refers to as a “tavern” because friends gathered there get drunk on the joy of communing with like-minded spirits. The Sheikh acts as a medium for Mahfouz to distill his Sufi-infused philosophy, a vision of acceptance, tolerance and a constant striving for the spiritual.

“The nearest man comes to his Lord is when he is exercising his freedom correctly,” the Sheikh tells his followers. As the end of the book approaches, the entries get smaller and the pronouncements more precise, until they finally take on a Confucian simplicity. “As you love, so will you be,” reads one entry called “The Secret.” With “Echoes of an Autobiography,” Mahfouz has produced a fascinating and thought-provoking meditation on memory, love, spirituality and the eventuality of death. As the Sheikh says of Mahfouz, “O God, bestow upon him a good conclusion, which is love.”

Continue Reading Close

The Book of Yaak

Robert Spillman reviews Rick Bass's book of essays entitled "The Book of Yaak".

  • more
    • All Share Services

The Yaak Valley, one of the most remote places in the United States, is nestled in the northwest corner of Montana bordering Idaho and Canada, where the Rockies meet the Pacific Northwest. It’s a wilderness filled with incredible biodiversity — trees, rare orchids, wildflowers, grizzlies, wolves, coyotes, elk, moose and caribou. Bass, a geologist turned naturalist and short story writer, is one of only a hundred people who call the Yaak home. In this, his tenth book, Bass takes the reader on long walks through what can only be described as a spiritual place. With detail-rich prose, he relates the delicate rhythms that the valley’s fauna, fish, wildlife — as well as various human recluses — go through over the course of brutal winters, short, spectacular springs and picturesque summers and falls.

In these interconnected essays Bass shows how the Yaak forms a vital link to other near and far wild areas, one absolutely necessary for the survival of the migratory animals he has tracked over the years. Then he introduces us to the land-rapists. Pushed out of the Pacific Northwest, multi-national lumber conglomerates have recently become hellbent on clear-cutting the old growth in this unique but tourist-unfriendly valley, a place not deemed worthy of governmental protection. Bass describes how the United States Forest Service uses tax dollars to build roads into pristine forests so that logging companies can denude whole hillsides, then send the logs out of state, and frequently out of the country. Local communities are given a short-term economic boost, but then are saddled with long-term ecological disaster.

While this book is a cry for help, it is also a meditation, one often worthy of Thoreau. Bass, having moved to the wilderness to pursue a solitary life of art, wonders what happens when the last wild areas are destroyed, whether one can live and create without the “grace and magic” that exist only in wild ecosystems. He worries that when a society destroys all that is mysterious, it dooms itself. “We need wilderness to protect us from ourselves,” Bass warns in this passionate love letter to one of our last pristine lands, a paradise deserving of a country’s respect and protection.

Continue Reading Close

The Woman and the Ape

Robert Spillman reviews the novel "The Woman and the Ape" by Peter Hoeg.

  • more
    • All Share Services

Peter Hoeg, the Danish author of the surprise international bestseller, “Smilla’s Sense of Snow,” has concocted a new book that’s as awkward as its own half-breed protagonist. “The Woman and the Ape” centers on a captured ape of an unknown species — a missing link that’s nefariously smuggled to London to be the centerpiece of an expanded zoo and animal research center.

Hoeg has tried to write what might best be termed a feminist/animal-liberationist/futurist/social-disaster thriller, and the result is half bird and half rhino — an ungainly monster that never gets off the ground. The Woman, a pampered, upper-crusty Dane named Madelene, is the wife of zookeeper Adam, and she’s the only one who can save The Ape from grisly testing and permanent imprisonment. After they run off together, The Ape quickly learns English, and (naturally) one thing leads to another — and we are faced with some truly absurd cross-species pollination. This happens in a paradisaical animal preserve in Northern England, a place of Darwinian simplicity where the humans have left the animals to fend for themselves within the confines of the forest.

Madelene and The Ape leave the garden only when they realize that Adam will most likely kidnap other Apes. Hoeg deftly shows Madelene’s entrapment by her social and marital status, and he parallels this with the societal imprisonment of The Ape and all other animals. Unfortunately, Hoeg gets tangled up in his own ambitions — he rambles on and on about the fate of the animals and mankind, and the threadbare plot can barely hold up all of the saccharinely earnest sermonizing. Hoeg’s intentions are obviously genuinely charitable (he is donating all proceeds of this book to a self-started fund that helps Third World women and children). But from such a talented writer this is a surprisingly flat, disorganized and sadly unconvincing novel.

Continue Reading Close

INDIAN KILLER
By Sherman Alexie, Grove/Atlantic, 352 pages.

  • more
    • All Share Services

Sherman Alexie is a Spokane/Coeur d’Alene Indian who’s received much deserved praise for his wry, taut, short story collection “The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven,” and for his blackly funny first novel “Reservation Blues.” With the ambitious and provocative “Indian Killer,” however, Alexie has arrived as one of the most potent new voices in American fiction. This multi-faceted tale is set in Seattle, a melting pot of Indians and whites, and the home of John Smith — a tall, full-blooded Indian of an unknown tribe, raised by his loving white adoptive parents. A construction worker on “the last skyscraper in Seattle,” John is a loner who hears voices, mainly that of his mentor, a Jesuit Indian who walked into the desert never to be seen again.

John feels neither Indian nor white, and he longs to lash out both at his own insensibility and in retribution for the entire history of Indian/white confrontation, “as if the world could be changed with a single gesture.” He decides that this single gesture should be the random killing of a white man. After committing the bloody murder, John isn’t satisfied and thinks that he needs to commit a much more brutal crime to capture the attention of white America. Some liberals and Indians are (uneasily) thrilled by this belated revenge, and everyone has an opinion about who is really behind the gruesome acts. John’s violent and seemingly untraceable path crosses with a variety of well-sketched minor characters: an Indian student activist; a well-meaning white anthropologist who teaches Native American lit; a white ex-cop mystery writer who claims to be Indian and thus feels entitled to speak for all Indians; an angry young white man whose brother has been killed and who seeks revenge against all Indians; an angry young Indian whose white father beat him and who now lashes out against all white men; and a right-wing talk radio host who spreads fear of Indians after a white man is found scalped. Alexie neatly weaves them into a mesmerizing thriller packed with a righteous indignation reminiscent of James Baldwin at his best. This is a passionate, beautifully constructed and compelling novel by an extremely gifted writer.

Continue Reading Close

INDIAN KILLER
By Sherman Alexie, Grove/Atlantic, 352 pages.

  • more
    • All Share Services

Sherman Alexie is a Spokane/Coeur d’Alene Indian who’s received much deserved praise for his wry, taut, short story collection “The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven,” and for his blackly funny first novel “Reservation Blues.” With the ambitious and provocative “Indian Killer,” however, Alexie has arrived as one of the most potent new voices in American fiction. This multi-faceted tale is set in Seattle, a melting pot of Indians and whites, and the home of John Smith — a tall, full-blooded Indian of an unknown tribe, raised by his loving white adoptive parents. A construction worker on “the last skyscraper in Seattle,” John is a loner who hears voices, mainly that of his mentor, a Jesuit Indian who walked into the desert never to be seen again.

John feels neither Indian nor white, and he longs to lash out both at his own insensibility and in retribution for the entire history of Indian/white confrontation, “as if the world could be changed with a single gesture.” He decides that this single gesture should be the random killing of a white man. After committing the bloody murder, John isn’t satisfied and thinks that he needs to commit a much more brutal crime to capture the attention of white America. Some liberals and Indians are (uneasily) thrilled by this belated revenge, and everyone has an opinion about who is really behind the gruesome acts. John’s violent and seemingly untraceable path crosses with a variety of well-sketched minor characters: an Indian student activist; a well-meaning white anthropologist who teaches Native American lit; a white ex-cop mystery writer who claims to be Indian and thus feels entitled to speak for all Indians; an angry young white man whose brother has been killed and who seeks revenge against all Indians; an angry young Indian whose white father beat him and who now lashes out against all white men; and a right-wing talk radio host who spreads fear of Indians after a white man is found scalped. Alexie neatly weaves them into a mesmerizing thriller packed with a righteous indignation reminiscent of James Baldwin at his best. This is a passionate, beautifully constructed and compelling novel by an extremely gifted writer.

Continue Reading Close

Page 1 of 2 in Robert Spillman