(Reuters/Jim Young/Yuri Gripas/photo montage by Salon)

It's time to rewrite the Constitution: Why our governments ability to decide war & peace is totally broken

When we go to war with ISIS, Congress does not declare it. When we try to make peace with Iran, Congress refuses


Marcy Wheeler
July 17, 2015 8:58PM (UTC)

It's time to rewrite Article 1 Section 8 of the Constitution, or at least the part that says "the Congress shall have power ... to declare war." Given Congress' recent behavior, it seems they'd prefer that clause to read, "the Congress shall have power to thwart peace, but the Executive can go to war any damn time he wants."

After all, while most members of Congress have proven completely disinterested in declaring a war on the Islamic State -- even though we've been at war against them for almost a year -- a large percentage Congress seems intent on squelching President Obama's  nuclear deal with Iran.

Advertisement:

Let's deal with that first part up front: It took Obama six months before he asked Congress for an "Authorization to Use Military Force" against ISIS. But it was framed such that both Democrats, trying to place real limits on the Executive, and Republicans, pushing for ground troops, had reason to oppose it. When Congress held hearings in March, some were unhappy with the Administration's admission that they had written the AUMF to preserve flexibility. Predictably, Congress refused to pass the AUMF in that form. Republicans asked the Administration to write a new draft -- but why would they? So in spite of ongoing efforts from a few in Congress -- who believe the Legislative Branch should fulfill the role enumerated in the Constitution to declare war -- to generate some enthusiasm for actually authorizing the war that has been going on for 11 months, it is just not happening.

So, for political and legislative reasons, Congress seems unlikely to ever actually authorize this war. But unless they defund it, that won't stop the Administration from doing what it wants in the name of fighting ISIS.

Meanwhile, even before the Administration and its allies finalized the deal with Iran to limit that country's nuclear development on Tuesday, Congress passed the Iran Review Act, which gives it a review period before the Administration can remove sanctions against Iran. Because of delays in the deal, that review period will be 60 days, which means it will extend into the August recess, which has been a volatile period in recent political fights.

The Administration built in means to undercut Congress there -- the UN will get a chance to review the deal before Congress, for example, which raises the likelihood the international community will have committed to remove its sanctions on Iran before Congress gets its say about U.S. sanctions. In addition, it's likely that enough Democrats will support the bill to sustain any presidential veto over an effort to kill the deal.

So it's unlikely those in Congress who want to quash this deal will succeed, they will insist on exercising the prerogative to weigh in they guaranteed with the Iran Review Act. That is their prerogative won through earlier legislation.

Still, consider the spectacle before us! Significant numbers of Congressmen want to prevent an agreement. the alternative to which may only be war. If you believe that the only alternative to the Iran deal is war then what these members of Congress are trying to do is literally thwart peace.

Advertisement:

But many of the same members of Congress are refusing to fulfill their duty enumerated by the Constitution: to declare war (and set some limits about the targets and geographic bounds of the war).

It's a really telling set of priorities.


Marcy Wheeler

Marcy Wheeler writes at EmptyWheel.net and is the author of "Anatomy of Deceit."

MORE FROM Marcy WheelerFOLLOW emptywheel

Related Topics ------------------------------------------

Foreign Policy Government Iran Isis The Constitution

BROWSE SALON.COM
COMPLETELY AD FREE,
FOR THE NEXT HOUR

Read Now, Pay Later - no upfront
registration for 1-Hour Access

Click Here
7-Day Access and Monthly
Subscriptions also available
No tracking or personal data collection
beyond name and email address

•••






Fearless journalism
in your inbox every day

Sign up for our free newsletter

• • •