Bill McKibben
George Harrison and the Concert for Bangladesh
He knew what he should do and he went out and did it. The result was the first, and perhaps the greatest, concert-for-a-cause ever staged.
In Dhaka, the sprawling capital of Bangladesh, a small museum on a quiet side road commemorates the country’s war of liberation — a war that, though now dimly remembered, stands among the greatest genocides of the 20th century.
The museum houses a numbing collection of tragic artifacts from that 1971 conflict — shirts and sandals of some of the nearly 3 million Bengalis the Pakistani government managed to kill in their convulsive yearlong campaign to retain control over the eastern portion of their country. Maps of mass graves were left behind by the Pakistanis, who then as now enjoyed the patronage of America, in this case because Henry Kissinger thought they were geopolitically significant. Oh, and hanging on the wall of the museum is an LP jacket, and inside it the record of a fundraising concert in Madison Square Garden.
George Harrison organized the Concert for Bangladesh — the first, and perhaps the greatest, concert-for-a-cause that rock ‘n’ rollers ever staged. “Rock reaching its manhood,” Rolling Stone said in its review. “Under the leadership of George Harrison, a group of rock musicians recognized, in a deliberate, self-conscious, and professional way, that they have responsibilities — and went about dealing with them seriously.”
In a sense, the concert for Bangladesh begins with “Norwegian Wood,” where Harrison first experimented with the sounds of the sitar. He went on to India to see Ravi Shankar, the master of the instrument (currently on his own farewell tour). “I felt that his enthusiasm was so real, and I wanted to give as much as I could express,” said Shankar in a 1997 interview on VH1. Beatlemania intervened — people recognized Harrison in Bombay and eventually he had to flee.
But the men stayed friends, and in 1971 Shankar, who had relatives in East Bengal, told Harrison he was trying to put together a benefit show “and maybe raise $20,000, $25,000, $30,000, and send it,” Shankar told VH1. “George saw how unhappy I was, and he said, ‘That’s nothing, let’s do something big.’ And immediately he, like magic, phoned up, fixed Madison Square Garden and all his friends, Eric Clapton, Bob Dylan, and it was magic really. And he wrote that song also,’ Bangladesh.’ So overnight that name became known all over the world, you know.”
It’s hard now, 30 years later, to imagine rock stars as real honest-to-God consciences of anything. We’re used to a certain smug self-satisfaction behind almost every gesture — and used to the mediocre music that usually accompanies feed-the-world extravaganzas. But George Harrison clearly didn’t need to buff his image by raising money for Bangladesh. And this was not precisely a safe cause: America was sending both money and arms to the Pakistanis. Harrison told VH1 that he’d been inspired by John Lennon — “I think one of the things that I developed, just by being in the Beatles, was being bold. And I think John had a lot to do with that, you know, cause John Lennon, if he felt something strongly, he just did it. I picked up a lot of that by being a friend of John’s.”
The concert, Harrison added, ran on “pure adrenaline,” without a full rehearsal. Who needs to rehearse, however, when you have George to sing “Here Comes the Sun,” “My Sweet Lord” and “Something”; Ringo to sing “It Don’t Come Easy;” and Dylan to add “Just Like a Woman.” And everyone, all together, on the title track:
My friend came to me
With sadness in his eyes,
He told me that he wanted help
Before his country died.
Although I couldn’t feel the pain
I knew I’d have to try
Now I’m asking all of you
To help us save some lives
Here we remember the Concert for Bangladesh as the birth of a new kind of political-artistic-philanthropic circus, one of those cases where the first example was also probably the best. There are moments now when one wishes that it had never occurred to singers that they should also preach.
But 1971 was not one of those moments. Not here, where in the midst of a dozen other crises the atrocities in Bangladesh were passing largely unnoticed. And certainly not in Bangladesh, where desperate people screwed by the imperatives of Cold War politics suddenly found themselves being heard by the world. “You can’t imagine what a ray of light that was when we found out,” said the museum’s director.
That small museum in Dhaka is one of the most moving places I know on earth. It is haunted by the usual ghosts — the millions of Muslims raped and killed by rampaging Pakistani troops, armed and funded by the grotesqueries of Cold War politics. And haunted now too by a shaggy-haired British musician who knew what he should do and went out and did it.
Global warming hits home
After a year of freakish and destructive weather, Americans are finally waking up to the dangers of climate change
Houses were severely damaged after Hurricane Irene came through Bethel, Vt. on August 28, 2011 (Credit: U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service - Northeast Region / CC BY 2.0) The Williams River was so languid and lovely last Saturday morning that it was almost impossible to imagine the violence with which it must have been running on August 28, 2011. And yet the evidence was all around: sand piled high on its banks, trees still scattered as if by a giant’s fist, and most obvious of all, a utilitarian temporary bridge where for 140 years a graceful covered bridge had spanned the water.
The YouTube video of that bridge crashing into the raging river was Vermont’s iconic image from its worst disaster in memory, the record flooding that followed Hurricane Irene’s rampage through the state in August 2011. It claimed dozens of lives, as it cut more than a billion-dollar swath of destruction across the eastern United States.
Continue Reading CloseThe rules that should govern energy subsidies
Taxpayer dollars shouldn't be propping wealthy fossil-fuel companies whose products we want less of
In this March 19, 2012, photo, a motorist pumps gas at a Mount Lebanon, Pa., mini-mart (Credit: AP Photo/Gene J. Puskar) Along with “fivedollaragallongas,” the energy watchword for the next few months is: “subsidies.” Last week, for instance, New Jersey Senator Robert Menendez proposed ending some of the billions of dollars in handouts enjoyed by the fossil-fuel industry with a “Repeal Big Oil Tax Subsidies Act.” It was, in truth, nothing to write home about — a curiously skimpy bill that only targeted oil companies, and just the five richest of them at that. Left out were coal and natural gas, and you won’t be surprised to learn that even then it didn’t pass.
Continue Reading CloseClimate change denial’s new offensive
Global warming is wreaking devastation, but Big Oil won't give up profits without a planet-destroying fight
A crew member from the Nevada Department of Forestry works to control the Washoe Drive fire in Washoe City, Nev. on January 19, 2012 (Credit: Reuters/James Glover II) If we could see the world with a particularly illuminating set of spectacles, one of its most prominent features at the moment would be a giant carbon bubble, whose bursting someday will make the housing bubble of 2007 look like a lark. As yet — as we shall see — it’s unfortunately largely invisible to us.
In compensation, though, we have some truly beautiful images made possible by new technology. Last month, for instance, NASA updated the most iconic photograph in our civilization’s gallery: “Blue Marble,” originally taken from Apollo 17 in 1972. The spectacular new high-def image shows a picture of the Americas on January 4th, a good day for snapping photos because there weren’t many clouds.
Continue Reading CloseThe political power of being naive
Cynicism makes us complacent. 2011's successful protests show how hope can change the system
A demonstrator holds up his sign as he marches to City Hall plaza in Oakland, Calif. November 14, 2011 (Credit: REUTERS/Kimberly White) My resolution for 2012 is to be naive — dangerously naive.
I’m aware that the usual recipe for political effectiveness is just the opposite: to be cynical, calculating, an insider. But if you think, as I do, that we need deep change in this country, then cynicism is a sucker’s bet. Try as hard as you can, you’re never going to be as cynical as the corporations and the harem of politicians they pay for. It’s like trying to outchant a Buddhist monastery.
Here’s my case in point, one of a thousand stories people working for social change could tell: All last fall, most of the environmental movement, including 350.org, the group I helped found, waged a fight against the planned Keystone XL pipeline that would bring some of the dirtiest energy on the planet from Canada through the U.S. to the Gulf Coast. We waged our struggle against building it out in the open, presenting scientific argument, holding demonstrations and attending hearings. We sent 1,253 people to jail in the largest civil disobedience action in a generation. Meanwhile, more than half a million Americans offered public comments against the pipeline, the most on any energy project in the nation’s history.
Continue Reading CloseHas global warming become a campaign issue?
Why blocking the Keystone pipeline could help Obama and denying climate change will hurt Romney
President Barack Obama and Mitt Romney (Credit: AP) Conventional wisdom has it that the next election will be fought exclusively on the topic of jobs. But President Obama’s announcement last week that he would postpone a decision on the Keystone XL pipeline until after the 2012 election, which may effectively kill the project, makes it clear that other issues will weigh in — and that, oddly enough, one of them might even be climate change.
Continue Reading ClosePage 1 of 4 in Bill McKibben