Movies
“The Lady and the Duke”
The pictures are more alive than the story -- or the actors -- in Eric Rohmer's arty snoozer.
When the painted backdrops in a movie are more alive than its characters, you know you’re in trouble. Eric Rohmer’s “The Lady and the Duke” is based on the diaries of Grace Elliott, an Englishwoman who lived in Paris during the French Revolution and who had been the mistress first of the Prince of Wales (who became King George IV) and later the Duke of Orléans, the cousin of the ill-fated Louis XVI. Rohmer spreads the authenticity delicately, layer by layer, but the movie still ends up feeling stiff and stale. It’s a stately history lesson that moves along at an escargot’s creep, and a treatise on the nature of love and honor that’s so static it makes the fruity wallpaper of Grace’s tastefully furnished home look exciting by comparison.
“The Lady and the Duke” is a painterly movie, and that’s both good and bad. Instead of trying to re-create late 18th-century Paris (and its outskirts) with elaborate sets, Rohmer uses rich painted backdrops that consciously mimic classic styles of French painting. They’re so evocatively rendered that they’ll look familiar even if you think you wouldn’t know a Claude Lorraine landscape if it bonked you on the head; they’re sure to conjure long-buried memories from art history classes you thought you slept through. In fact, the most delightful thing about “The Lady and the Duke” is the way Rohmer revels in the artificiality of those backdrops. He daubs bits of movement onto them — birds winging across a bright blue sky, or the waves on a river shimmering with sunlight. The effect, in concert with the actors moving in the foreground, is something like viewing an animated 3-D scene through a stereopticon, although it was achieved using sophisticated digital technology. It’s enchanting.
What a drag that the story is such a dud. Lucy Russell plays Grace Elliott, an English aristocrat who has decamped to France and adopted it as her homeland. She remains close friends with her former beau, the Duke of Orléans (Jean-Claude Dreyfus), and the two maintain an easy familiarity. When he comes to call on her, she invites him into her private chambers to chat while she finishes dressing; propriety isn’t an issue with either of them.
As the atrocities of the Revolution escalate around her, Grace is forced to plumb new depths of courage and resourcefulness. She briefly harbors a fugitive in her house, risking her own life. Later, as heads roll, she continues to maintain her aura of aristocratic virtue. (You see, the rich are better than you and me.) The duke, meanwhile, wobbles and loses his footing in this frightening new world. Charming and cultured, but also clearly open to sensuality and pleasure, he recognizes that the world must change: He just isn’t sure of the best way to bring those changes about. Much to Grace’s horror, he ends up voting to sign the death warrant for his own cousin, a move that doesn’t, in the end, save even his own skin.
Their relationship — the easy kind of friendship that former love affairs sometimes, if we’re lucky, segue into — is the movie’s chief underpinning, and it’s a potentially interesting one. But “The Lady and the Duke” is laden with so much expository dialogue (“What times we are living in! Those enlightenment philosophers should open their eyes”) that it’s a bit like being trapped inside a badly written history book.
And if the character of Grace is supposed to be a model of ever-increasing resilience and fortitude, why is she always bursting into tears whenever something bad happens? At some point, you’d think she’d catch on that a revolution is no picnic. Instead, we see lots and lots of dignified, womanly crying, followed by Grace’s dabbing at her tears with a hankie and straightening her torso inside her brocaded bodices. That’s the movie’s idea of character development. Russell might have rescued the role by bringing some grit and liveliness to it, but she doesn’t seem to have it in her; she’s best when she’s bantering with Dreyfus, who has a jowly sexiness about him, but even then, she never lets us forget how noble and admirable her character is supposed to be.
“The Lady and the Duke” isn’t boring in the same way Rohmer’s most recent pictures, set in the modern day, like 1998′s “Autumn Tale,” have been. There are no insufferable people socializing irritably around their outdoor dining tables. Nor are there many (or any, for that matter) nubile young babes whose pouty lips are intended to substitute for a story line. But it’s dull in a very tasteful way, with none of the reverberating tenderness and sometimes surly vigor that characterize Rohmer’s best work, things like “Summer” and “The Aviator’s Wife.”
But oh, those backdrops! Rohmer seems to have poured more feeling into them than he did into his characters, whether he meant to or not. Softly colored but vivid, they transport us not necessarily to another time, but to a place outside time where things of exquisite beauty — paintings, music, buildings, landscapes — can move us to a state of breathlessness. Rohmer stops time, in the good way, with those backdrops. Too bad that the rest of the time, he drags the minutes around like a dead weight.
Stephanie Zacharek is a senior writer for Salon Arts & Entertainment. More Stephanie Zacharek.
Pick of the week: Haunting, gorgeous “Oslo, August 31st”
Pick of the week: "Oslo, August 31st" is a wrenching voyage of discovery in Norway's suddenly trendy capital
“Oslo, August 31st” is, as the title suggests, an evocation of one day in the Norwegian capital, as experienced by a troubled young man who’s facing the end of summer and the end of his youth. It’s a marvelously constructed personal journey, both wrenching and bittersweet, whose emotional ripple effects stay with you for days and weeks afterward. While much of international art cinema can seem overly talky or conceptually alien to American viewers, this second feature film from Norwegian director Joachim Trier is a dynamic, even breathtaking visual experience without much dialogue or any philosophical heavy lifting, following the bony, handsome, exceedingly vulnerable Anders (Anders Danielsen Lie) through coffee shops, nightclubs and bodies of water, en route to an ambiguous final destination.
Continue Reading Close“Moonrise Kingdom”: Wes Anderson’s mid-’60s love story
Bruce Willis and Ed Norton are at their best in the rapturous summer fantasy "Moonrise Kingdom"
Tilda Swinton, Bruce Willis and Edward Norton in "Moonrise Kingdom" All the details of Wes Anderson’s rapturous and hilarious mid-1960s New England summer romance “Moonrise Kingdom,” taken one at a time, are plausible. Indeed they are more than plausible; they’re perfect, from the fitted uniforms and yellow canvas tents of the troop of “Khaki Scouts” headed by cigarette-smoking Edward Norton to the achingly picturesque island home where the brood of children belonging to Bill Murray and Frances McDormand sit around listening to the Leonard Bernstein recording of “A Young Person’s Guide to the Orchestra.” (I’m not going to bother questioning whether that record existed in 1965; some production intern probably spent half a day tracking down its history.)
Continue Reading CloseMovie assailant punches a kid, becomes a folk hero
A 10-year-old gets punched in the face for being too noisy at "Titanic" -- and the Internet applauds the beating
(Credit: iStockphoto/IBushuev) It’s a general rule of thumb that a grown man doesn’t get a lot of support for knocking out a 10-year-old child’s teeth. But Yong Hyun Kim has won himself a few fans lately for doing just that.
Back on April 11, the 21-year-old Washington state man settled in with his girlfriend to enjoy “Titanic” in 3D — right in front of a boy known only in police documents as KJJ. What ensued led to a night in jail and a charge of second-degree assault.
Continue Reading Close
Mary Elizabeth Williams is a staff writer for Salon and the author of "Gimme Shelter: My Three Years Searching for the American Dream." Follow her on Twitter: @embeedub. More Mary Elizabeth Williams.
“The Intouchables”: Racial comedy, French style
"The Intouchables" is the biggest foreign-language film of all time. Some critics say it's also racist
A still from "The Intouchables" Here’s a startling news item: “The Intouchables,” a lively if largely predictable Parisian comedy about a wealthy quadriplegic and his ne’er-do-well immigrant caretaker, has become the biggest international success in the history of French cinema. Indeed, according to some sources — and these things are notoriously difficult to measure on a global and historical scale — “The Intouchables” is now the biggest non-Anglophone film of all time, with a worldwide gross approaching $300 million.
Continue Reading CloseMale grooming: The movie
From beard contests to ball cream, Morgan Spurlock's "Mansome" goofs through modern-day male narcissism
Jack Passion in "Mansome" American men are bewildered about their place in the cosmos, or so we have been told repeatedly over the last 20 years. They don’t know whether to thread their eyebrows or wield a welding torch, and end up trying to do both at once (which is inadvisable). As comedian Adam Carolla laments in a scene from Morgan Spurlock’s documentary “Mansome,” the old-time certainties of gender identity have melted away: Women are flying fighter jets and men work at the hair salon; there are no longer “chick jobs and guy jobs.”
Continue Reading ClosePage 1 of 708 in Movies