Farhad Manjoo
Comcast agrees to lift BitTorrent block
Facing a threat of regulation, the ISP makes nice with a file-trading protocol.

It’s kind of like if Eliot Ness and Al Capone got together to open up a brew pub, or maybe if Eliot Spitzer and the Vice Squad collaborated on Emperors’ Club 2.0: Comcast and BitTorrent have agreed to put aside their differences and work together to manage network traffic over Comcast’s Internet lines.
Comcast and BitTorrent, you’ll recall, are bitter enemies. BitTorrent is a file-sharing method preferred by lovers of copyrighted movies, TV shows, music and games as well as by folks looking to move legitimate large files over the Internet. Consequently, BT consumes much space on network lines — and Comcast, the Associated Press reported last year, was dealing with this load by surreptitiously delaying or blocking peoples’ BitTorrent sessions.
Comcast’s actions sparked an outcry; consumer advocates and regulators rightly suggested that the company was violating principles of “network neutrality,” which hold that operators should treat all traffic on the network equally.
Perhaps as a result of that anger — and the possibility of regulation — Comcast now seems to have backed off.
The Wall Street Journal’s got details on the agreement between Comcast and BitTorrent, Inc., the private company that manages the open-source BitTorrent protocol: To keep its network running smoothly at peak times, Comcast will now slow down access for people consuming the most network bandwidth, and will no longer delay specific applications (such as BitTorrent).
This is a good move. It’s unfair to penalize everyone using a certain application because some users of that application eat up a lot of network space.
Imagine if Comcast decided to slow down Firefox for everyone because some of its users download far more Web pages than users of Internet Explorer. It’s crazy to imagine it — but the company’s BitTorrent block was really not much different.
The new network policy — which Comcast will try to roll out by the end of the year — fixes the problem at its source: It institutes an effective bandwidth cap on users, allowing every customer equal access to the network regardless of how they’re using their lines.
In other words the network is “neutral” with regard to your application choice, which is what consumer advocates have been calling for.
Good on you, Comcast, for coming around.
But the move does not obviate the need for regulation. Comcast only came around because it feared the government would step in; clearly, the government needs to step in to prevent others from doing the same.
In a statement, Markham Erickson, who heads the advocacy group the Open Internet Coalition, underscored this point:
Time and time again, when the telcos and cable companies engage in discriminatory behavior against certain types of speech and content — as we’ve seen with AT&T, Verizon, and most recently with Comcast — a familiar pattern emerges. First, a spotlight gets focused on the bad behavior. Then, when exposed, the companies state such action is within their power as network operators. After that, the FCC and Congress focus on these discriminatory acts, and finally, the companies do a U-turn and apologize. While it’s always a positive step when these companies admit the error of their ways, it’s a bad way to run the Internet.
[Flickr picture by dmuth.]
The thinking man’s action hero
Using paper clips, chewing gum, chocolate and down-home ingenuity, MacGyver always saved the day. Let's bring him back -- and give him a girl!
It isn’t necessary to explain how, in the pilot episode of “MacGyver,” our mulleted, Midwestern hero gets himself trapped inside a top-secret research bunker overflowing with sulfuric acid. Suffice it to say, he needs to find a way out, and probably soon (because government agents are fixing to fire a missile at the bunker to prevent the acid from spilling into a nearby aquifer). Plus, he has to save the people he has found inside (among them a gun-wielding climate scientist who wants destroy the bunker in an effort to set back research into an ozone-layer-ruining weapon of mass destruction). Fortunately, MacGyver has a few chocolate bars, a scrap of sodium metal, a cold capsule, a pair of binoculars and cigarettes.
Continue Reading CloseGoodbye to Machinist
Yo, I'm out.

Today much of the tech world is sad that the iPhone 3G’s launch is going so miserably. But I’m sad that it’s my last day at Salon.
I’ve accepted a job at Slate, where, starting next week, I’ll be writing a twice-weekly technology column. Machinist will go on a break for a week, after which a guest blogger will bring you the latest tech dish.
Continue Reading Close“True Enough” at Google, and in San Francisco
A YouTubey presentation of my book.
As I mentioned in the comments yesterday, I’m getting ready to depart this space; I’ll have a fuller explanation tomorrow, sometime before or after I get in line to buy the new iPhone.
In the meantime, I thought I’d add a note about one of the more fun events related to my book’s release — the opportunity I had, in May, to speak at Google’s headquarters in Mountain View.
Continue Reading CloseThe iPhone 3G reviews are in: It’s pretty good
But battery life suffers, and the GPS isn't as great as you hoped.
Walt Mossberg (WSJ), David Pogue (NYT) and Edward Baig (USA Today) have been using the new iPhone 3G for a couple of weeks now, and today they all dish on their experiences.
Continue Reading CloseScary! YouTube ordered to hand your viewing history to Viacom
But there's a silver lining to one of the most bone-headed legal decisions in recent times.
Update: This post has been updated with comments from Viacom.
In the fall of 1987, a freelance reporter named Michael Dolan learned that judge Robert Bork kept an account at Potomac Video, a D.C. rental shop. This was at the height of the contentious and ultimately failed Senate confirmation hearings for Bork’s nomination to the Supreme Court — so naturally, Dolan thought there was a story here, and he went to work on getting a peek at Bork’s video rental history.
Continue Reading ClosePage 1 of 143 in Farhad Manjoo
