Video Games
“Grand Theft Auto IV” is a dark urban masterpiece
With a fictional universe of astonishing cleverness and complexity, this is one of the smartest video games ever created.
Rockstar Games
“Grand Theft Auto IV” wears its reputation on its sleeve, most likely in an ambidextrous shoulder holster with a double-mag pouch. Fans of the series come to this latest game, which has already set sales records since its release last week, with high expectations: that its landscape will be lush and flexible, offering endless opportunities to wreak havoc over a tyrannized virtual populace — but also intricate and clever, stamped with in jokes, futuristic absurdities and wry references to pop culture and politics.
Detractors, too, keep a checklist handy for any new “GTA” release. In a game that aims to re-create the underside of urban life, there’ll be guns and crooks and prostitutes and sex and drugs and booze. The combination, under the thumbs of 14-year-olds and re-created in high-def right in your living room, has proved a recurrent boon to the nation’s concern industry.
What’s beautiful about “Grand Theft Auto IV” is how grandly it both fulfills and tweaks these expectations. This may be the darkest, most realistically violent game in the series, and if you go looking for sin — as many players do — you’ll find dozens of sequences that’ll provoke outrage on the late local news. “GTA IV” allows you to hire prostitutes and then murder them — need any more be said?
On the other hand, as several reviewers have pointed out, the graphical and narrative realism of “GTA IV” serves, unexpectedly, to diminish a player’s blood lust. The game’s story line is so absorbing that you aren’t really moved to murder random passersby. Its fictional universe is unendingly deep, far more complex than what came before — not to mention than much of what one finds on TV or at the movies.
This new dimension elevates “GTA” from mere entertainment into something that can credibly, if a little self-consciously, demand to be called art. The more you play “GTA IV,” the more real everything in it feels. And it won’t be long before you’re calling it the smartest video game ever created.
Folks cleverer than me — notably Steven Johnson — have convincingly expounded on the mind-expanding capacities of video games, but with previous versions of “Grand Theft Auto,” the argument has been a tough sell. When you tell people you’re playing a game that allows you to mow down virtual civilians — indeed, that such behavior constitutes the game’s defining thrill — they recoil. It sounds hollow, mindless, attractive only to sadists — on the order of rape porn, “Bumfights” or a Gordon Ramsay reality show.
“GTA IV,” like previous versions, sets you up as an outsider in the city, where you gain status and notoriety by embarking on a series of missions (murder, robbery, mayhem) for a variety of friends and associates. But unlike the other “GTAs,” this one gives each of your associates unique, fully fleshed personalities and characteristics.
The fellow you play, Niko Bellic, is an Eastern European immigrant scarred by unnamed strife in the motherland, and his actions hew to a moral code born of that conflict. Others have odder quirks: the wife of a gang leader who can’t stand the monster her husband has become. The ex-con who feels the press of suicide as he adjusts to life outside the can. The girlfriend who’s a clean freak, and who, during some off-screen activity that one presumes is sex (the controller vibrates knowingly), ecstatically compliments your conversational skills.
But it’s not only that the people you encounter are interesting — it’s also that there are so many of them! I was often struck, while immersed in “GTA IV,” at its resemblance to another fictional universe I love, David Simon’s in “The Wire.” The similarity is not narrative, but rather structural — understanding the game’s world depends on your learning and navigating a web of sometimes mysterious social connections.
As much as it is a driving and shooting game, then, “GTA” is also a puzzle game. The puzzle concerns social relationships: You’re working with and for several characters at once, and what you do for some of them affects how you get along with others. In a game known mainly for carjacking, it’s surprising how much time you’re asked to spend building and maintaining friendships and romantic liaisons — going on dates to bowling alleys and comedy clubs, hanging out with your pals at bars and pool halls, keeping up with a surfeit of text messages and e-mail (even deleting Nigerian spam).
Where “The Wire” tries to present the modern American city as it is, “GTA IV” gives us the city as it might become. The city here is called Liberty, a stylized riff on New York, but the name’s ironic: There’s no liberty in Liberty City. Officials pump up terrorism fears, crime is rampant, ethnic tensions are high, and everyone is rude.
It may be too much to say that “GTA” has a message, but it certainly has a vision: It’s the dystopian near-future, something like the world of “The Children of Men” (there are no kids here, either).
The vision is pushed by the media your character encounters — the radio stations, the TV networks, the astonishingly deep in-game Web (with parodies of Craigslist, Fox News, Match.com and other sites, which you access at Internet cafes called TW@).
As you pass through the city, you learn about the end of reading as a pastime, or the new market in selling babies over the Internet, or the extremely elevated terrorist threat — “Liberty City is now officially on Charcoal 8 Alert, more serious than the Red High 7 Risk Alert, but not as serious as the recently created Black Severe 9 Alert,” the game’s Fox News analogue, Weasel News, warns.
Crucially, your aim here, unlike in many games, is not to set right what’s wrong with this place. I haven’t finished the game — it could take weeks — but I get the sense that once Niko Bellic has achieved all he can in Liberty City, it will still be the pits.
Win or lose, the world goes on without you.
Farhad Manjoo is a Salon staff writer and the author of True Enough: Learning to Live in a Post-Fact Society. More Farhad Manjoo.
Holiday carols, eggnog — and video games
It's a new tradition -- generations around a game console. For 25 years, families have shared "The Legend of Zelda"
The legend goes like this: As a boy growing up in Japan, Shigeru Miyamoto was playing outside and discovered a cave. The cave haunted the child, who loved comics and dreamed of becoming an artist, but he was too afraid to go explore. Pained days followed, and the boy tried to summon the courage to see what was hidden. As we all do eventually, however, Miyamoto finally faced his fears. He went inside — and it helped change the way we all play.
Thirty years later, Miyamoto defined video games during a period of remarkable creativity. He gave games their first story in “Donkey Kong”: Ape kidnaps lady, climbs a building, mustachioed fella rushes to save her. It’s a classic boy-rescues-girl plot, but before “Kong,” games only had beginnings and endings in the sense that a challenge was completed or not. “Kong” had a story arc — and gave birth to games’ most enduring icon, Mario.
Continue Reading CloseInside the geeky, revolutionary world of “Minecraft”
Can a video game change the world? At the "Minecraft" convention in Las Vegas, crazily costumed obsessives say yes
(Credit: FLICKR USER NAME / CC BY 3.0) The revolution will be pixelated. It will be digital, yes, but also lo-fi and open-ended. And it’s underway right now in the virtual world of “Minecraft,” the deceptively simple online video game that has conquered the gaming world by stealth. Well, it was stealthy until one November weekend, when 5,000 die-hard fans converged on Las Vegas for Minecon and the celebration of “Minecraft’s” official launch.
“Launch” is a bit of a misnomer, as the game already has 16 million registered users in its beta form. The day before the announced launch, Mojang, the small Swedish company that created “Minecraft,” quietly released its new smartphone app — and within 24 hours it became the No. 1 selling app in the U.S. With an Xbox version of the game coming this spring, another 30 million Xbox Live subscribers will be jumping into the “Minecraft” Nether. The Minecraft Generation has officially begun.
Continue Reading CloseRob Spillman is co-editor of Tin House magazine. More Rob Spillman.
Court reaffirms: Sex much worse than violence
A high court ruling underlines the increasingly obvious problems we have with nudity but not gore -- and why
Sex is scarier, and more dangerous, than violence.
That was the cultural belief the Supreme Court reinforced on Monday when it rejected an attempt to ban the sale of violent video games to minors. Despite the frequent rhetorical link made by politicians and activists between sex and violence in the media, when it comes to First Amendment exemptions, sex stands entirely on its own. The majority ruling states clearly that federal obscenity law applies only to “depictions of ‘sexual conduct’” and not to scenes that are “shocking” for other reasons, like extreme violence. The Court ruled in the 1968 case of Ginsberg v. New York that states could ban the sale of sexual material to children, even if the content is not considered “obscene” for adults.
Continue Reading Close
Tracy Clark-Flory is a staff writer at Salon. Follow @tracyclarkflory on Twitter. More Tracy Clark-Flory.
Court: Calif. can’t ban violent video game sales
Supreme Court says governments do not have the power to "restrict the ideas to which children may be exposed"
The U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington, D.C. The Supreme Court on Monday refused to let California regulate the sale or rental of violent video games to children, saying governments do not have the power to “restrict the ideas to which children may be exposed” despite complaints about graphic violence.
On a 7-2 vote, the high court upheld a federal appeals court decision to throw out the state’s ban on the sale or rental of violent video games to minors. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Sacramento had ruled that the law violated minors’ rights under the First Amendment, and the high court agreed.
Continue Reading CloseShould I worry about my son’s gaming obsession?
I'm concerned he's wasting his college years in front of a screen -- but is it just a generational difference?
Not long ago I was trying to pry some news out of my reticent senior-in-college son without much success when I changed the subject to computer gaming. He’s been punching the keyboard ever since I got my first Apple II when he was 5, when electronic games were beyond Pong but not yet past Pac-Man, and I know it’s not something he’s outgrown. Still, he’s usually circumspect about his gaming life, knowing his mother and father consider it something between an addiction and a vice.
Continue Reading CloseLawrence Tabak is a writer currently looking for a home for his YA novel about a teen gaming prodigy who makes the leap to the South Korean professional circuit. More Lawrence Tabak.
Page 1 of 22 in Video Games