This Week in Crazy
This week in crazy: Bob Woodward
Is it possible that the world's most successful political reporter actually does not understand politics?
Bob Woodward, one of two Washington Post reporters who broke the Watergate scandal open in the 1970's, leaves his home in Washington, June 1, 2005. On May 31, Woodward and fellow reporter Carl Bernstein confirmed that former FBI official W. Mark Felt was "Deep Throat," the legendary source that leaked Watergate scandal secrets to the Washington Post and helped bring down President Richard Nixon. REUTERS/Jason Reed JIR/SV(Credit: © Reuters Photographer / Reuters) On Tuesday, Bob Woodward did one of those things that makes the entire stupid cable news ecosystem go nuts for 24 hours: He claimed, based on supposed inside info, that something plainly ludicrous was probably going to happen. CNN’s John King (USA) started it, of course. He held up Woodward’s book, then repeated some of that idle Beltway “gossip” that is usually just made up by pundits wishing to speculate. “You know the talk in town, a lotta people think if the president looks a little weak going into 2012, he’ll have to do a switch there, and run with Hillary Clinton as his running mate.”
Now, first of all, “a lotta people” do not actually “think” that will happen. It’s something pundits like Mark Halperin fantasize about. But wishful thinking is not the same as an actual reasonable prediction of future events.
So, King asks Bob Woodward, America’s most famous journalist — the man who speaks to everyone worth speaking to in the corridors of power, who just finished what he always refers to as “hundreds of hours” of interviews with everyone at the White House from the president on down — did he hear anything about a shocking and unprecedented Clinton-Biden switch?
“It’s on the table,” Woodward said.
Wow! Except, as the Atlantic’s Marc Ambinder succinctly tweeted: “No, it’s not.”
Does the world’s most successful political reporter actually not understand politics? That’s what Ambinder went on to argue in a piece that was also an amusing parody of Woodward’s omniscient third-person prose:
“I can’t believe Woodward would say something like that,” Ambinder told his editor, Bob Cohn, over coffee in Cohn’s Watergate office the next day. “It suggests that he knows next to nothing about the president’s actual relationship with his vice president and secretary of state … or that he has done no reporting on the question at all. Which is absurd, because Woodward is a reporter’s reporter.”
Then again, Ambinder thought privately, one of the senior policymakers who played a starring role in Woodward’s latest book had characterized its conclusions as “60 percent right, 40 percent completely wrong.” And that was from a policymaker who came across favorably in the book.
Woodward is notorious for giving favorable coverage in his books to the people who talk to him the most (and for worshiping certain members of the military, especially when they’re engaged in policy battles with civilian leadership). But does the guy actually believe what his odious sources tell him in his lovely Georgetown home? Does he buy their lies? Does the guy who took down Nixon think political operatives are trustworthy?
Here’s a big red flag: His source on the Biden-Clinton switch was apparently pollster grifter Mark Penn. Penn is a professional liar and nearly every political decision he made while attempting to steer Hillary Clinton’s 2008 presidential campaign was epically, historically stupid.
So Woodward was just repeating half-baked speculative nonsense from professional (and inept) Clinton-booster Mark Penn as if it was something serious people in the White House were considering.
Faced with unequivocal denials from the White House, Woodward “clarified.”
In response to the White House’s pushback against his idea that Hillary Rodham Clinton and Joseph R. Biden Jr. might exchange places, Bob Woodward said this afternoon that the idea of a Biden-Clinton swap is “on the table” in the sense that “any legitimate vote-getting strategy is always on the table in politics.”
That’s a great bit of weaselly backtracking from a reporter supposedly charged with keeping politicians honest.
Believing that a sitting president would seriously consider replacing his running mate for reasons not involving some horrific scandal belies a truly weird understanding of history and politics for a man who’s been covering Washington since the only time in the post-WWII era when a vice-president actually was replaced on a national ticket.
Although, should we expect a serious understanding of politics from a man who admitted on Friday that he allows a child to vote for him?
Alex Pareene writes about politics for Salon and is the author of "The Rude Guide to Mitt." Email him at apareene@salon.com and follow him on Twitter @pareene More Alex Pareene.
Westboro Baptist Church announces Tucson pickets
In a total non-shocker, pastor of the "God hates fags" church posts a video praising Saturday's shootings
Fred Phelps It’s only Monday, but a front-runner for This Week in Crazy has already emerged. Fred Phelps, founding father of the whacko Westboro Baptist Church, posted a YouTube vid thanking God for the “violent shooter, one of your heroes in Tucson.”
He’s referring of course to Jared Lee Loughner and his murderous spree in Arizona over the weekend. Phelps wants you to know that “God sent the shooter“ and that his devout/brainwashed followers, true to form, will picket the funerals of the six victims who died, including the service for 9-year-old Christina Green.
Sorry for making your blood boil so early in the week, but below is Phelp’s taped message to the nation:
Michelle Fitzsimmons is an editorial fellow at Salon.com. More Michelle Fitzsimmons.
Year in Crazy: The Top 10
Slide show: Will Glenn Beck reign supreme again? Could John McCain finally win? We ranked our favorite offenders
Jenny McCarthy, Glenn Beck and Sen. John McCain We often say it’s been a crazy year, but this time: We have proof. For 12 months now, Salon has turned a spotlight on the nutty, the certifiable, the gobsmackingly cockeyed in news and culture with our “This Week in Crazy” feature, which came to you every Saturday thanks to the superb duo of Alex Pareene and Mary Elizabeth Williams. The series began in 2009 with a year-end story crowning Glenn Beck the king of cracked. Now, as we wind down a year that has included one midterm election, several heated debates over gay civil rights and a million tears shed on cable news, we count down the people who truly hit out of the park. People, we present your Class of Crazy 2010. – Sarah Hepola
This week in crazy: Gen. James Amos
His reason for opposing the repeal of "don't ask don't tell"? Gay people will cause Marines to lose their legs
Gen. James Amos Gen. James Amos, commandant of the Marine Corps, opposes the repeal of “don’t ask, don’t tell,” the military’s long-standing ban on openly gay service members. On the whole, the Marines are less receptive to the idea of lifting the ban than most other branches of the armed forces, so his opposition makes a certain kind of sense. But he can’t really come up with any good reasons to oppose lifting the ban. His most recent justification for discrimination: Gay people will cause Marines to lose their legs! No, seriously:
Continue Reading Close
Alex Pareene writes about politics for Salon and is the author of "The Rude Guide to Mitt." Email him at apareene@salon.com and follow him on Twitter @pareene More Alex Pareene.
This week in crazy: Naomi Wolf
The feminist who weathered her own storm over sexual misconduct lashes out against Julian Assange's rape accusers
Ever since publishing “The Beauty Myth” nearly 20 years ago, Naomi Wolf has built a reputation as a challenging, tough and thought-provoking feminist writer. Now, she’s also bananas.
It’s not that the rush to arrest WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange on “one count of unlawful coercion, two counts of sexual molestation and one count of rape” wasn’t mighty questionable. After all, it’s pretty funny how often individuals accused of sex offenses gallivant around the globe with relative impunity — until they start publishing classified documents. And since the allegations first arose back in August, there have been several conflicting accounts, massive mishandlings and plenty of speculation over whether this is a case of abuse or just of a man who doesn’t like to wear condoms.
Continue Reading Close
Mary Elizabeth Williams is a staff writer for Salon and the author of "Gimme Shelter: My Three Years Searching for the American Dream." Follow her on Twitter: @embeedub. More Mary Elizabeth Williams.
This week in crazy: John McCain
The old maverick invents the weirdest reason yet to oppose the repeal of "don't ask, don't tell"
John McCain John McCain has finally, inexorably stumbled upon the weirdest and most transparently troll-ish reason yet to oppose the repeal of the military’s ban on gay and lesbian service members: The economy sucks.
That’s it. The Senate can’t address a fundamental inequity, because the markets are down.
Continue Reading Close“I will not agree to have this bill go forward, and neither will, I believe, 41 of my colleagues, either, because our economy is in the tank,” said Sen. John McCain of Arizona, the ranking Republican on the Armed Services Committee and the leading opponent of an immediate repeal.
Alex Pareene writes about politics for Salon and is the author of "The Rude Guide to Mitt." Email him at apareene@salon.com and follow him on Twitter @pareene More Alex Pareene.
Page 1 of 9 in This Week in Crazy